| Title | : | Lightspeed Magazine: Queers Destroy Science Fiction! |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | - |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Audible Audio |
| Number of Pages | : | - |
| Publication | : | First published May 10, 2015 |
| Awards | : | Nebula Award Best Short Story for "Madeleine" (2016), Locus Award Best Short Story for "Madeleine" (2016) |
This special issue features original science fiction short stories from John Chu, Kate M. Galey, Bonnie Jo Stufflebeam, Chaz Brenchley, Felicia Davin, Rose Lemberg, Jessica Yang, K. M. Szpara, Amal El-Mohtar, Tim Susman, and Susan Jane Bigelow. Plus, it includes original flash fiction from E. Saxey, Charles Payseur, Claudine Griggs, Stephen Cox, Eliza Gauger, Erica L. Satifka, Gabrielle Friesen, Gabby Reed, Shannon Peavey, Sarah Pinsker, Bogi Takács, and JY Yang, as well as reprints by RJ Edwards, AMJ Hudson, Raven Kaldera, Rand B. Lee, and Geoff Ryman.
Lightspeed Magazine: Queers Destroy Science Fiction! Reviews
-
I definitely liked this anthology better than
Queers Destroy Fantasy!. It felt more diverse and fleshed out.
My notes as I read:
~ Amal El-Mohtar's book reviews were passionate and compassionate: a winning mixture. They almost won me over to try Elizabeth Bear's Karen Memory. (Almost, because, well, I'm not adding anything to my
To-read list before I bring it down to 90- entries. Ah, wish me luck.)
~ Cedar Rae Duke's essay "Not Android, Not Alien, Not Accident: Asexual and Agender in Science Fiction" addresses an issue that I'm very interested in. Given that in the debate about sexuality, I glide, not so much along the "female ~ male" or "hetero ~ homo" axes, but along the "gender-pronounced ~ gender-free" one, any exploration of characters (and people) for whom sexuality isn't a leading factor fascinates me. I suppose this also explains the overall non-sexual feel of my own writing ... and why some readers get frustrated with it.
~ There're many kinds of pettiness that people can inflict on one another. In my recent dealings with a querulous subset of Bulgarian fandom, I've experienced my share of them, but Michael Damien Thomas's essay "Queers Digging and Destroying" introduced me to excesses beating anything I could imagine. My heart goes out to him and his family and indeed anyone who gets such a treatment, for such reasons. Our squabbles are sheer silliness compared to that horror. May we all grow out of it sooner.
~ Although the main idea of Felicia Davin's "The Tip of the Tongue" was familiar, the tone was warm and gentle. And the story featured
the best kissing scene I've read in ages.
Gentle and warm. :)
~ Jessica Yang's "Plant Children" is what I'd call a "mood piece," a story that may go nowhere but makes you relish the ride. (Much like my own "Festive" tale in the
Heroes and Villains cycle. Like--you know--life. ;)
It was gentle too. And funny. And it tugged at my heart, the way all subdued, unspoken emotion does.
~ Amal El-Mohtar's "Madeleine" was the third story to boost my faith in the strength of the human spirit and warm me up. (Although "calm me down" is perhaps more appropriate, given the state I was in before I began reading it.)
And its Author Spotlight contains a lovely summary of the need for anyone to "destroy" any genre:You also participated in Women Destroy Science Fiction!. For you, what does it mean to destroy science fiction?
It means grinding into a fine powder the conviction that I’m not smart or educated enough to write hard SF. It means obliterating the fear that men I respect will roll their eyes at my attempts. It means facing up to the fact that men who would do that don’t deserve my respect, and that indeed men for whom I care deeply rooted for and supported me throughout the process. It means standing up, shoulder to shoulder, with women and queer people and people of colour against the fiction that things are fine as they are, that nothing needs to be changed or addressed, that our voices are sufficiently loud at a whisper.
~ Susan Jane Bigelow's "Die, Sophie, Die"--about a game critic getting harassed on the Internet after poking fun at sexism in a video game--struck me hard because I've just found out about
Gamergate. (And I didn't know that Zoe Quinn, of
Depression Quest, was one of the targets.) I ... don't know what to say. So I'll revert to what I said earlier:
May we all grow out of this sooner.
~ Shannon Peavey's "Nothing Goes to Waste" is funny and sad and strange and familiar ... it has all the elements that make a flash piece memorable.
~ Bogi Takács's "Increasing Police Visibility" demonstrates another way to write memorable flash fiction: focusing on an idea that will set us thinking.
So, what will be the percentage of false positives at airport terrorist checks?
~ Another important reminder in Sigrid Ellis's essay:There’s no such thing as a queer story. That’s stereotyping, that’s profiling, that’s marginalization.
Except, of course, that all sorts of stories are queer.
To be queer is to defy easy definition. Which is also what science fiction does. It defies what is known, what is safe. Science fiction extrapolates and explores. It pushes the edges of the known. Science fiction takes us to live in other people’s bodies, in minds and hearts alien to our own.
There is no possible way that queers can destroy science fiction. Science fiction is already, has always been, queer.
~ Raven Kaldera's "CyberFruit Swamp" was the naughtiest, most over-the-top under-the-table experience of the lot. I cringed and grinned, often simultaneously, throughout the ride. :)
~ Among the essays, there's not a single one I disliked. Even if they weren't literary masterpieces, their honesty always touched me. The one that touched me the most is Jerome Steuart's "When We're Not There, We're Not Here," not only with its raw sincerity, but also with the reminder that we're not just "this" or "that": we can be a little of "this" now, a bit more of "that" later--and many others in between.
Yay, we contain multitudes. ;)
~ While I hated the dystopian, concentration-camp premise of Geoff Ryman's "O Happy Day!", I appreciated the exploration of two rare subjects. One: that you can go to extremes no matter which side of the wall you're standing on. Two: that a prison guard is just as imprisoned by the box as any prisoners inside; that you need to communicate across the walls in order to give boxes a chance to blow open.
~ I was similarly torn about Rand B. Lee's "The Sound of His Wings": the paranoid nature of its eternal conflict repelled me, but the characters and the writing ... my, the writing. -
Of this issue, I have only read, so far,
Madeleine by Amal El-Mohtar. Rating is just for that story (which is really hard to rate, but going with gut feeling, very good but not her best writing).
I love Amal El-Mohtar's short stories (and ocasionally poems if they come my way), the prose is beautiful, the sensitivity. This is another very good story of hers, in the aftermath of testing a new alzheimer's medication, which has been causing memory flashbacks a woman starts seeing somebody new, that she never met. Beautiful bits about grief, a theme of philosophy (and its consolations) also.
But, the ending is a bit soft, maybe a bit predictable and almost different in tone from the beginning of the story. As usual, this is just my feelings about it. -
Overall impression: a couple of mis-matches among the audio performers and the story they were performing sometimes left for an odd disconnect twice, but overall I did find the collection really, really strong. I also found it really, really dark, grim, and at times so depressing I walked away from it to listen to other things for a while. That's not to say it's not great (it is), just that my mood in winter couldn't sustain more and more of these stories where the "victory" (if there was one) was so often with an admixture of loss/settling-for-less/holding-on-to-scraps. I loved seeing all this queerness, but after listening to it, I really, really want there to be another collection: Queers Destroy Solarpunk or something.
I'll be reviewing some of the stories as part of my ongoing
"Sunday Shorts" series on my blog, so if you'd like to see thoughts on any particular story, that's where they'll be showing up throughout the year (that link will take you to these stories in particular). -
"She wonders at how change comes in like a thief in the night, dismantling our sense of self one bolt and screw at a time until all that’s left of the person we think we are is a broken door hanging off a rusty hinge, waiting for us to walk through."
I can't help but nod at how true this statement is. Dealing with change is something we constantly battle with, all the while being perplexed each and every time. We never learn, do we?
The narrative of story alternates between two different styles just as the topic of the story dapples in two different versions of memories - One version that projects the memories from the past in all its vividness and other, the kind that erodes with each wave that washes ashore. How will a woman deal with both of these.
The setting of the story is well chosen - a woman who signs up for a Alzheimer's clinical trial as a coping mechanism to deal with the death of her Alzheimer's afflicted mother. The drugs from the trial drop her into a cauldron of her childhood memories, giving her a chance to relive the best moments. She looks for triggers to open doors to her memories, to dive into hallucinations projected by her past. But somewhere in her memories, she meets a person, she has never met in her life before. A companion that she longs for in such desolate times. While her counsellor is convinced that she has imagined a non-existant person to deal with her loneliness, even as the line between her projected hallucinations and reality start blurring, Madeliene wants nothing more than being lost in the bliss of camaraderie and love, possibly.
Though I could easily guess who this person might be, this is a story worth reading for the evocative picture that the writer paints. The following paragraph on grief reveals the kind of potential this writer has and I would gladly read more stories by the writer.
Grief, thinks Madeleine now, is an invasion that climbs inside you and makes you grow a wool blanket from your skin, itchy and insulating, heavy and grey. It wraps and wraps and wraps around, putting layers of scratchy heat between you and the world, until no one wants to approach for fear of the prickle, and people stop asking how you are doing in the blanket, which is a relief, because all you want is to be hidden, out of sight. You can’t think of a time when you won’t be wrapped in the blanket, when you’ll be ready to face the people outside it — but one day, perhaps, you push through. And even though you’ve struggled against the belief that you’re a worthless colony of contagion that must be shunned at all costs, it still comes as a shock, when you emerge, that there’s no one left waiting for you.
Worse still is the shock that you haven’t emerged at all.
Rating : 4.5/5
Note : Read this as part of BB's Flash Readathon, August. -
4.5 stars, not quite as amazing as Lightspeed's Women Destroy Science Fiction, but only by a hair. Some of my favorites of the original fiction: John Chu's "Influence Isolated, Make Peace" and Amal El-Mohtar's "Madeleine." From the Flash Fiction: "Rubbing is Racing" by Charles Payseur, "Helping Hand" by Claudine Griggs, and Sarah Pinsker's "In the Dawns Between Hours."
-
Good, short read. I came across this while scrouging for some short story to pass time.
Better classified as under psychological genre than science fiction. -
Read the original review at
SF Bluestocking
Last year, Lightspeed invited
women to
destroy
SF; this year
the LGBTQ+ community gets their turn. It's glorious, and it kicked off this month with a massive
special issue of Lightspeed.
At over 500 pages (according to my epub of it), Queers Destroy Science Fiction! is a weighty piece of work, and it's clear that it's been conceived and crafted with deep caring and exquisite attention to its purpose. Most importantly, a real (and successful!) effort was made to be inclusive of the entire
QUILTBAG acronym, and the more than two dozen personal essays included in the issue are must-read content for this reason. If you're not queer, they offer a great variety of different perspectives to learn from; if you are queer, there's a multitude of stories to identify with. Either way, if you have a soul something here will speak to you.
The fiction included is well chosen, which is characteristic of the publication in general, and there is a good mix of work included. My favorites, in no particular order except the one I read them in:
"Trickier With Each Translation" by Bonnie Jo Stufflebeam - a bit of a time traveling super hero love story
"The Tip of the Tongue" by Felicia Davin - a story about reading and government control that has given me a new nightmare
"Plant Children" by Jessica Yang - a sensitively written romance about plants and family
"Nothing is Pixels Here" by K.M. Szpara - a story about hard choices
"Two by Two" by Tim Susman - a story about the end of the world and how we might face it and who we will face it with
"Melioration" by E. Saxey - about the power of words
"Helping Hand" by Claudine Griggs - an astronaut survival story
"Bucket LIst Found in the Locker of Maddie Price, Age 14, Written Two Weeks Before the Great Uplifting of All Mankind" by Erica L. Satifka - exactly what the title says, but sad and beautiful (I love the conceit of telling a story through a found piece of ephemera.)
"A Brief History of Whaling with Remarks Upon Ancient Practices" by Gabby Reed - exactly what the title says, but also sad and beautiful
"In the Dawns Between Hours" by Sarah Pinsker - about why or why not and when to use a time machine if you can
"Letter From an Artist to a Thousand Future Versions of Her Wife" by JY Yang - another story that is exactly what the title says, but also sad and beautiful (If you can't tell, sad and beautiful are two of my favorite attributes in short fiction, and I'm also a sucker for clinically descriptive titles.)
"CyberFruit Swamp" by Raven Kaldera - definitely the most graphically sexual story in the collection (and be sure to read the author spotlight on Raven Kaldera)
"The Sound of His Wings" by Rand B. Lee
and "O Happy Day!" by Geoff Ryman - Both of these stories deal with obvious Nazi metaphors and totalitarian futures, but with vastly different approaches and two very different ways of integrating queerness into the narrative.
In nonfiction, aside from the truly wonderful personal essays, there's also a nice piece on Robert A. Heinlein's influence and an excellent
interview with David Gerrold. This, however, leads to my only real complaint about the issue, which is that the David Gerrold interview is extremely poorly formatted. I thought it might just be the epub version of the magazine, but it appears that the online version of the interview is similarly difficult to read because with no quotation marks, italics, or block quoting it's hard to tell what parts of it are David Gerrold's statements and what parts are Mark Oshiro's commentary.
At just $3.99, Queers Destroy Science Fiction! is a great value, and I highly recommend
purchasing it.
Queers Destroy Horror!, a special issue of Nightmare will be out in October, followed by a
Queers Destroy Fantasy! issue of Fantasy Magazine in December. And in 2016, Lightspeed will be doing POC Destroy Science Fiction! with guest editor Nalo Hopkinson. -
I've just stumbled upon this collection of LGBT+ stories and I can't wait to dive into them all. It's 500+ pages too, like YAAAAS. But also, I do *not* have time for these wonderful distractions. THERE ARE SO MANY THINGS I WANT TO READ AND THE LIST IS ONLY GROWING GOOD GRIEF. (This is like the best problem to have, really, but still, the ever-growing TBR is ridic)
read in this collection so far:
Bucket List Found in the Locker of Maddie Price, Age 14, Written Two Weeks Before the Great Uplifting of All Mankind by Erica L. Satifka. This short was brief but hard hitting all the same. Available
here. -
I'm kind of disappointed in this anthology actually, there were only two stories that stood out to me, and I skipped through a few others because I just couldn't get into them.
The two stories I really liked were:
- (Influenced Isolated, Make Peace) by John Chu; and
- Trickier With Each Translation by Bonnie Jo Stufflebeam.
Both were very early in the anthology, so maybe they raised my expectations and I'm being unfair on the rest? I don't know.
The collection of essays were all worth a read. -
Simply perfect to listen to, and proof that representation does not have to be a challenge
-
Time to make some notes about this one, so I can let my mother borrow it!
Original Shorts Section
pg. 69 "We let a man name himself after his children, after a country not relevant to any of them, not true to any story of their lives. We assert that names are changeable, assignable at whim, and then we attach unalterable value to them."
pg. 273 "The Tip of The Tongue" by Felicia Davin, reminds me of
Fahrenheit 451
pg. 86 Felicia Davin bisexual Western MA scifi writer (TBC?)
pg. 87 "How to Remember to Forget to Remember the Old War." by
Rose Lemberg" brilliant, checkout more of her work
pg. 95 "Plant Children" by
Jessica Yang (POC author), creepy good, some lovely prose passages
pg. 103 "The yam leaves ever hardy, continued to live on. If yam leaves were people Qiyan though, they would be boisterous uncles who wore suspenders over stained undershirts. and spat fat globs of phlegm on the side of the road."
pg. 105 "Nothing is Pixels Here" by K.M. Sparza (
http://www.lightspeedmagazine.com/fic...), interesting use of Virtual Reality, exploration of trans issues
pg. 115 author bio for K.M. Sparza, local to Baltimore, Masters in Theological Studies from Harvard
pg. 116 "Madeline" by
Amal El-Mohtar, memory, therapy, loss, allusions to
Proust
pg. 116 artist
Orion Zangara
pg. 130 author bio
pg. 131 "Two By Two" by Tim Sussman, queers, some kind of apochlypse?, alt history, family the CSA (Confederate States of America)
pg. 145 author bio
pg. 157
Susan Jane Bigelow trans women author, local to Northern CT (TBC), libertarian?
Flash Fiction Section
pg. 167
http://www.nerds-feather.com/
pg. 168 "Helping Hand" by Claudia Griggs , interesting space opera esque.
pg. 172 bio, Writing Center Director at Rhode Island College and writes on transsexuals (TBC)
pg. 173 "The Lamb Chop" by Stephen Cox, interesting alien, transgressive love between 2 queer dudes since once is alien and one is not (aliens control earth?)
pg. 177 bio
pg. 178 "Mama" by Eliza Gauger, beautiful prose, strange flash fiction
pg. 180 "Bucket List..." by Erica L. Satifka, concept bucket list before the singularity, bi women with gender queer spouse
pg. 189 author bio of Gabby Reed, didn't particularly like their story in the anthology but nevertheless seems intriguing, queer, bisexual Filpin@-American writer, poetry, story in
Beyond: the Queer Sci-Fi & Fantasy Comic Anthology (which I really must read)
pg. 194 "In the Dawn Between Hours." by
Sarah Pinsker. sweet romantic time travel story with lesbians!
pg. 197 author bio, lives in Baltimore
pg. 198 "Increasing Police Viability." by
Bogi Takács, interesting take on security apparatus,
pg. 201"Bayes Theorem" (
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayes%2...)
pg. 201 author bio, poetry writer
Reprint Fiction
pg. 215 blog
Queer Book Club
pg. 215 podcast
HARK! A Holiday Music Podcast
pg. 215 webcomic
Riot Nrdd
pg. 216 "Red Run" by AMJ Hudson, life switching
pg. 227 author bio, track down her piece "Motherland."
pg. 228 "CyberFruit Swamp" by Raven Kaldera, (I know him), interesting but a bit dated, color chain to identify what you are and are looking for (pg. 229), trans terminology
pg. 240 author bio. Raven could be on a queer scifi and fantasy panel at TBC!
pg. 241 "The Sound of His Wings" by
Rand B. Lee
pg. 242 "the sike and the simp," pg. 253 more terminology
powers, mutants and non mutants (like Xmen or Heroes), themes of identity, originally published 1982
pg. 263 Author bio
pg. 264 "O Happy Day." by
Geoff Ryman lesbian separatism, men killed except gay men who are used to kill the other men, concentration camps, surveillance, interesting from a history of genre specific, but stupid reductive gender existentialism. still moving in places.
pg. 292 author bio
Excerpt of...
Skin Folk (I wanted to like this more than I did)
pg. 300 bio
Author Spotlights
pg. 314
Bitter Waters and
Being Small by
Chaz Brenchley
pg. 317
Rose Lemberg talks about her concern in her writing with what happens when water is over, also the impact of trauma
pg. 319 mentions
Sciegentasy
pg. 320 mentions story "Grandmother-nai Leylit's Cloth of Winds." in magazine
Beneath Ceaseless Skies and "The Book of How to Live" in
Start a Revolution
and finally "Geometries of Belonging" (also in
Beneath Ceaseless Skies)
pg. 327 Be on the look out for Docile, "a science romance set in a near future Baltimore City." by
K.M. Szpara
pg.329 Find and read "The Green Room" by
Amal El-Mohtar
pg. 331 T.V. show to try"Blakes 7" and the accompanying podcast (
https://downandsafe.wordpress.com/).
pg. 342 book recs by
R.J. Edwards
Nevada
A Safe Girl to Love
pg. 344 books recs by AMJ Hudson
Everything Begins and Ends at the Kentucky Club
pg. 349 author spotlight by
Rand B. Lee mentions
East Wind Community
pg. 351 look out for Centaur Station
pg. 351 Reviewer to watch out for their own work (Arley Song)
Artist Gallery
Orion Zangara (pg. 357)
Isabel Collier (pg 357)
Steen (pg. 357)
pg. 362 Afrofuturism in
Aailyah music video "We Need a Revolution
pg. 364 agapeic romance
Book Reviews, June 2015: Friendship, Chosen Family and Queer Communities by Amal El Mohtar
pg. 365
Archivist Wasp, YA without a love triangle! primary relationships friendships
pg. 366-367
Karen Memory, diversity not forced or unusual,
Mary Robinette Kowal's principle of "subtract homogeneity for the sake of realism"
Other Nonfiction
pp. 370-377 Interview with
David Gerrold,
The Martian Child: A Novel About a
Single Father Adopting a Son, also his nonfiction essay take down of
Orson Scott Card's homophobia (
http://joemygod.blogspot.com/2013/07/...) and on Hugos
I still need to read
The Man Who Folded Himself!
"That's how I feel about human beings. We're all different, we're all interesting, and we're all monsters too, each of us in own way. I've had the 'privileged of meeting of lots of people, weird, beautiful, sane, crazy, damaged, recovering, sad, ambitious, foolish --- and even a couple of sociopaths as well. And that stuff rubs off. (I have no idea what part of me rubs off onto other people."
LGBT people as monsters
influential books on him
City of Night,
The Front Runner,
Venus Plus X
His experience with Star Trek TNG and Star Trek New voyages
Moonstar Odyssey
The Martian Child: A Novel About a Single Father Adopting a Son
Interview by
Mark Oshiro
pg. 378 book mentioned
The Stars Change
pg. 382 Jennifer Cross, black queer feminist nerd
Outside the Box and
Writing Ourselves Whole
pg. 383 "Not Android, Not Alien, Not Accident: Asexual and Agender in Science Fiction" by Cedar Rae Duke
pg. 386 Star Trek TNG episode "The Outcast" commentary on
pg. 388 bio
pg. 389 "Diversity in the Ghetto: The Marginalization of Modern Activism in Traditional Fandom" by Pablo Miguel Alberto Vasquez
pg. 391 bio
pg. 393 "Queers in a Strange Land." by Amber Neko Meador
essay on
Robert A. Heinlein
pg. 397 bio, film
"Night of the Living Catgirl",
Other Selves: A Journey of Gender, Fiction, Discovery, and Hope
Personal Essays
pg. 408
Sandra Odell's essay mentions
Hiromi Goto
Charlie J. Andrews, and
Nisi Shawl among others
pg. 413
An Owomoyela asexual author
pg. 415 Mark Oshiro (see above) mentions
The Left Hand of Darkness which I totally still need to read
pg. 417 "Science Fiction Has Always Been Queer by
Sigrid Ellis
pg. 418 bio,
Queers Dig Time Lords
pg. 419 "Halfway in the Pool" by James L. Sutter
bisexual representation
pg. 422 "All That Glitters" by Jill Seidenstein
pg. 424 bio, twitter @outseide
pg. 428
Jerome Stuart, Be on the look out for his novel "One Nation Under Gods." website on religion in science fiction (
https://tesseracts18.com/)
pg. 429
The Fall of the Kings, answer for "when did you first recognize yourself in a science fiction or fantasy novel?"
pg. 432 "All Your Fic Are Belong to Us." Wonderfully snarky essay
pg. 434 bio, novella "The Lady Who Plucked Red Flowers Beneath the Queen's Window."
pg. 435 "Go Bisexual Space Rangers, Go! by
Cecilia Tan (TBC)
homosexuality in
John Varley
group marriages in
Diane Duane
pg. 438 "Drama Kid" by Cecil Baldwin
pg. 439, bio, narrator of
"Welcome to Nightvale"
pg. 442 "Confessions of a Queer Curator" by
Lynne M. Thomas
Smithie!
librarian (
http://libguides.niu.edu/sciencefiction)
recommends
Swordspoint,
Stratford Man series
pg. 444 bio,
SQUEECAST
pg. 445 "Where Now Must I Go To Make A Home" by
Hal DuncanHal Duncan
escapism v. rescuism
"A little escapism's no bad thing but what I've found in SF is something better dubbed rescuism, I think. Utopias, dystopias and heterotopias exploring the capacities of cultures for glorious deviance from the normative."
pg. 448 "Destruction is What Creation Needs." by
Sunny Moraine
"Science fiction for me has always been about the erosion of constraints. it's always been about flexibility, transformation. It's always been about building, but also about movement within and outside of that building. It's always been about constructing something and then smashing it apart to see what happens. It's been about questioning everything. Changing everything, if it's possible to do so."
pg. 448 bio, live just outside D.C. (TBC),
Line and Orbit,
A Brief History of the Future: collected essays,
Website
pg. 448
Sam Miller novelette
We Are the Cloud
writer of color
Lisa Bolekaja "work through shit just 2 feel comfortable putting sentences on paper. Some days 1 sentence is a a miracle."
pg. 448 bio
pg. 452
Lisa Morton recommends
Starfarers
pg. 454 bio, lives in D.C. (TBC)
pg. 457
Alyssa Wong,
Website
pg. 461 must read
Joanna Russ
pg. 462
Everett Maroon, trans,
The Unintentional Time Traveler
pg. 466
Minions of the Moon
Christopher Barzak
pg. 468 "A World of Queer Imagination" by
Bonnie Jo Stufflebeam
talks about Willow on Buffy
and
"Inventory" by Carmen Maria Marchado
pg. 469 bio of essay writer
pg. 474 "Queers Digging and Destroying" by
Michael Damien Thomas
probably my favorite of the bunch of personal essays. biphobia within hetero and queer communities
pg. 476 author bio
Special Issue Staff bios (pg. 495)
Seanan McGuire aka
Mira Grant
Steve Berman
Sigrid Ellis
Mark Oshiro
Wendy N. Wagner
Cecil Baldwin
Arley Sorg (linked elsewhere in review)
Sandra Odell (linked elsewhere in review)
Jill Seidenstein (linked elsewhere in review)
Rahul Kanakia -
From the perspective of Americans fighting for and/or trying to assert LGBTQ rights, this is an important work. It ticks all the correct PC boxes in terms of interviews, artworks, essays etc. Even in terms of selection of authors it choses those who declare their sexual preferences as various sub-categories of 'Queer'.
But what about the quality of fiction— which matters to us, the lesser mortal readers?
It's hard to find a duller book.
Except Sarah Pinsker's "In the Dawns between Hours", Claudine Grigg's "Helping Hand" (made famous by 'Love, Death and Robots'), and RJ Edwards' "Black Holes", I couldn't find anything memorable here. It's a sad testament and proof in support of the accusation against speculative fiction in West that political correctness is being prioritised at the expense of story-telling.
Not recommended, unless your sole aim is to support the LGBTQ movement. -
Lightspeed is a very well-known science fiction and fantasy magazine. Even in science fiction, supposedly the genre of limitless possibility, where everyone is invited to the adventure, minorities are often underrepresented. Last year Lightspeed started the "destroy science fiction" series, a yearly program focusing on underrepresented minorities to give them a voice, and to see what they have to offer and to contribute to the genre. In 2014 they focused on sci-fi and women. This year (2015) they focused on queer authors and themes. Next year they will focus on people of color. While sci-fi is considered by many the more open of the literary genres, heterosexual, heteroromantic, and cisgendered are considered the default, to the extent that everything else is "deviation," and must be eyed with suspicion. But all science fiction is real science fiction. Science fiction is vast, and incredible fascinating in all its facets. It is inclusive. Science fiction is about people, and queer people, no matter how they identify [Gay, lesbian, bisexual, demisexual, asexual, pansexual, intersex, transgender, genderfluid, genderqueer.. anyone who fits within the QUILTBAG], are a big part of that. They always have been. They are just sometimes harder to see. So, in the interests of visibility and breaking stuff, Queers Destroy Science Fiction! will show you just how wide the spectrum of sexuality and gender identity can really be. This special all-queer issue features original science fiction short stories from many award winning authors includin John Chu, Kate M. Galey, Bonnie Jo Stufflebeam, Chaz Brenchley, Felicia Davin, Rose Lemberg, Jessica Yang, K.M. Szpara, Amal El-Mohtar, Tim Susman, and Susan Jane Bigelow. The issue also include an interesting assortment of author and artist spotlights, interviews, nonfiction features, plus more than twenty personal essays from writers about their experiences being queer reading and writing science fiction.
A very interesting read, looking forward reading the next "destroy" issue. -
originally posted at:
http://thebookplank.blogspot.com/2015...
A while back I read the short story Pockets from Amal El-Mohtar which was a very cool story and I have been keeping my eye out for another story to appear from her and this month in the special issue of Queers Destroy Science Fiction! from Lightspeed Magazine wherein another one of her stories appeared: Madeleine.
I read the store once and didn't really know what to make of it (feelings wise). I read it again and just reading the first few sentences I understood the hidden beauty of the story. In the recent short fiction review I read more lighthearted stories, with Madeleine Amal El-Mohtar delves deeply into an emotional front.
The story focuses on Madeleine who lost her mother to the disease of Alzheimer. SInce Alzheimer has a degree of running in the family, Madeleine has chosen to sign up for an experimental drug procedure. SInce the medication is experimental, some side effects are still unknown. Madeleine starts to experience strong flashback of her mother and sees another girl in them. A girl similar in her age to which she bonds. Her doctor however claims that these flashback are no side effects and that it would be better for Madeleine if she would be examined at the hospital. But as the flashbacks become more frequent, it becomes clear to Madeleine that the women is real. And that this women means much more to Madeleine than she had even dared to think.
With Madeleine Amal El-Mohtar has produced a very strong and provocative story, that will make you view things different. What I have been able to read of Amal El-Mothar's short fiction, shows to it is diverse, tackles a wide range of subject. It's a treat to read.
You can read the story for free here -
there's something about the intersection between sci fi & lgbt anthologies that never lands properly. there's something wrong with the politics of it, the feel-good "we're all the same kind of q/eer" mentality that does a disservice to the complexity & variety of the lgbt community. invariably i find myself always wanting these sorts of anthologies to be very good and i end up disappointed because i have found that they never are as a whole, though some of the stories stand out. i don't have this problem with others sorts of anthologies. perhaps the problem is the lack of specificity. the dark matter anthology (black science fiction authors) was amazing, knocked me off my feet. it was specific though: black writers, not an amorphous category of "PoC". i don't know. i think there is something lacking in the current conversation of lgbt identity/politics/rights/whatever that is affecting how we collect anthologies of lgbt writing, but this is a problem i have with the lgbt community at large--how we talk about ourselves internally and how we present ourselves to the rest of the world externally. how we've decided to learn the lessons of the past few decades. i don't know, i don't know. maybe i need to check out lesbian anthologies instead (or bi anthologies, or gay anthologies, or trans women anthologies, or trans men anthologies, or nonbinary anthologies ... you see what i mean. specificity, in fact, serves a purpose: reinforces identity and corporeality). i'll keep thinking on this.
-
A while back I ran across a Kickstarter campaign to record and distribute a bunch of stories as an audiobook, and the name of the collection was to be Queers Destroy Science Fiction! How could I not sign on?
My reward, once the campaign was successful, was a download of the collection, which I just finished listening to. What a treat. Not every story is a gem, of course (never has there been an anthology that was genius from start to finish), but there are only one or two true clunkers. Most are extremely well-done and have fascinating takes on what it is to be queer (in all the many ways one can be queer) in a futuristic or alternate universe.
Perhaps the most alluring part of this collection is that, for the most part, the queerness of the characters is taken as a given and the story unspools without any specific reference to the effect of their sexual or gender orientation. This impulse leads, I believe, to a sense of inclusiveness that can inform our societal acceptance of those who do not fit our narrow definitions of "normal". On the other hand, there are several stories that do directly address the political, social and sexual norms that dominate our society. It is a satisfying and well-balanced mix.
Overall, this is a highly recommended collection. No matter what your personal orientation, I think you will find this a delightful read. -
SO. FREAKING. GOOD. From the short fiction to the flash fiction to the reprints to the nonfiction to the essays, this is an exceptionally-well-curated collection that is worth every penny and every minute you spend on it.
You can get all of the "___ Destroy" collections (or preorder unreleased ones) at
http://www.destroysf.com/
Once my reading queue shrinks a little bit, I'll definitely be picking all of the other collections up. -
A grieving Madeleine volunteers for a clinical trial. But the drug has side effects - flashbacks at odd times, increasingly vivid and increasingly to unfamilar times. It is here that she meets Zeinab and finds companionship. But Zeinab claims it is Madeleine who is her imaginary friend rather than vice versa. SPOILER ALERT - at the end one is left wondering whether the two trial volunteers are experiencing reality together or not
-
I can't recommend it enough. A great balance of SF exploring LGBT+ themes and issues, and cracking stories with characters who "just happen to be" queer. A great collection for any fans of genre fiction.
-
I finally read the personal essays from the back of this special issue, which means I finished it! I've been reading this on and off ever since it was published, so I've forgotten a lot of the stories. I did prefer the Queers Destroy Fantasy! special issue, though (surprising no one).
-
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Issue 61, June 2015
FROM THE EDITORS
The Queers Destroy Science Fiction! Manifesto
ORIGINAL SHORT FICTION
edited by Seanan McGuire
勢孤取和 (Influence Isolated, Make Peace) - John Chu - 4 stars
Emergency Repair - Kate M. Galey - 5 stars
Trickier With Each Translation - Bonnie Jo Stufflebeam - 5 stars
The Astrakhan, the Homburg, and the Red Red Coal - Chaz Brenchley - 3 stars
The Tip of the Tongue - Felicia Davin - 4 stars
How to Remember to Forget to Remember the Old War - Rose Lemberg - 5 stars
Plant Children - Jessica Yang - 4 stars
Nothing is Pixels Here - K.M. Szpara - 5 stars
Madeleine - Amal El-Mohtar - 4 stars
Two By Two - Tim Susman
Die, Sophie, Die - Susan Jane Bigelow
ORIGINAL FLASH FICTION
edited by Sigrid Ellis
Melioration - E. Saxey
Rubbing is Racing - Charles Payseur
Helping Hand - Claudine Griggs
The Lamb Chops - Stephen Cox
Mama - Eliza Gauger
Bucket List Found in the Locker of Maddie Price, Age 14, Written Two Weeks Before the Great Uplifting of All Mankind - Erica L. Satifka
Deep/Dark Space - Gabrielle Friesen
A Brief History of Whaling with Remarks Upon Ancient Practices - Gabby Reed
Nothing Goes to Waste - Shannon Peavey
In the Dawns Between Hours - Sarah Pinsker
Increasing Police Visibility - Bogi Takács
Letter From an Artist to a Thousand Future Versions of Her Wife - JY Yang
REPRINT FICTION
selected by Steve Berman
Black Holes - RJ Edwards
Red Run - AMJ Hudson
CyberFruit Swamp - Raven Kaldera
The Sound of His Wings - Rand B. Lee
O Happy Day! - Geoff Ryman
EXCERPT
Presented by Open Road Media
Skin Folk - Nalo Hopkinson
AUTHOR SPOTLIGHTS
edited by Sandra Odell
John Chu, Kate M. Galey, Bonnie Jo Stufflebeam, Chaz Brenchley, Felicia Davin, Rose Lemberg, Jessica Yang, K.M. Szpara, Amal El-Mohtar, Tim Susman, Susan Jane Bigelow, RJ Edwards, AMJ Hudson, Raven Kaldera, Rand B. Lee, Geoff Ryman
NONFICTION
edited by Mark Oshiro
Artists Gallery
C. Bedford, Odera Igbokwe, Orion Zangara, Isabel Collier, Paige Braddock, Steen, Elizabeth Leggett
Artists Spotlight
Elizabeth Leggett
Book Reviews, June 2015: Friendship, Chosen Family, and Queer Communities
Amal El-Mohtar
Interview: David Gerrold - Mark Oshiro
We’ve Made It To . . . Magrathea? - Jennifer Cross
Not Android, Not Alien, Not Accident - Cedar Rae Duke
Diversity in a Ghetto - Pablo Miguel Alberto Vazquez
Queers in a Strange Land - Amber Neko Meador
PERSONAL ESSAYS
edited by Wendy N. Wagner
Science Fiction Failed Me - Cory Skerry
So Say We All - Emma Osborne
1984 in 1980 - Lee Thomas
Speak Up, Speak Out - Sandra Odell
How Queer Narratives Beat the False-Consensus Effect, Reminded Me that
Diversity Existed, Exploited Human Psychology, Inspired Sex Positivity,
And Helped Me Stop Worrying (But Not to Love the Bomb) - An Owomoyela
Spark - Mark Oshiro
Science Fiction Has Always Been Queer - Sigrid Ellis
Halfway in the Pool - James L. Sutter
All That Glitters - Jill Seidenstein
When We’re Not There, We’re Not Here - Jerome Stueart
A Gay Boy Gets His Genre On - Anthony Cardno
All Your Fic Are Belong to Us - Rachel Swirsky
Go Bisexual Space Rangers, Go! - Cecilia Tan
Drama Kid - Cecil Baldwin
Rewriting Our Default Settings - Elizabeth Leggett
Confessions of a Queer Curator - Lynne M. Thomas
Where Now Must I Go to Make a Home? - Hal Duncan
Destruction is What Creation Needs - Sunny Moraine
Shiva and Octavia - Sam J. Miller
Creative Destruction - Lisa Nohealani Morton
Here’s How It Goes - Alyssa Wong
Acceptance - Arley Sorg
The Books That Read Me - Everett Maroon
The Desperate Task: Making the Invisible Visible - Christopher Barzak
A World of Queer Imagination - Bonnie Jo Stufflebeam
The First Rule I Learned about Writing Queer Characters in Science Fiction - Haralambi Markov
Queers Digging and Destroying - Michael Damian Thomas -
Fiction
Influence Isolated, Make Peace by John Chu: 2.75/5
Emergency Repair by Kate M. Galey: 4/5
Trickier With Each Translation by Bonnie Jo Stufflebaum: 4.25/5
The Astrakhan, the Homburg, and the Red Red Coal by Chaz Brenchley: 1/5
The Tip of the Tongue by Felicia Davin: 4.5/5
How to Remember to Forget to Remember the Old War by Rose Lemberg: 3.5/5
Plant Children by Jessica Yang: 4.75/5
Nothing is Pixels Here by K. M. Szpara: 4.25/5
Madeleine by Amal El-Mohtar: 5/5
Two by Two by Tim Susman: 5/5
Die, Sophie, Die by Susan Jane Bigelow: 2/5
Black Holes by RJ Edwards: 3/5
Red Run by AMJ Hudson: 3.5/5
CyberFruit Swamp by Raven Kaldera: 3/5
The Sound of His Wings by Rand B. Lee: 5/5
O Happy Day! by Geoff Ryman: 1/5
Flash Fiction
Melioration by E. Saxey: 1/5
Rubbing is Racing by Charles Payseur: 2/5
Helping Hand by Claudine Griggs: 3/5
The Lamb Chops by Stephen Cox: 2.75/5
Mama by Eliza Gauger: 3/5
Bucket List Found in the Locker of Maddie Price, Age 14, Written Two Weeks Before the Great Uplifting of All Mankind by Erica L. Satifka: 5/5
A Brief History of Whaling with Remarks Upon Ancient Practices by Gabby Reed: 4/5
Nothing Goes to Waste by Shannon Peavey: 3/5
In the Dawns Between Hours by Sarah Pinsker: 5/5
Increasing Police Visibility by Bogi Takács: 3/5
Letter From an Artist to a Thousand Future Versions of Her Wife by JY Yang: 5/5
Non-fiction and Personal Essays
Too many and too much repeated discourse to give a rating to all of them, but the most memorable and affirming to me personally were Diversity in a Ghetto: The Marginalization of Modern Activism in Traditional Fandom by Pablo Miguel Alberto Vazquez, Science Fiction Failed Me by Cory Skerry, 1984 in 1980 by Lee Thomas, Spark by Mark Oshiro, All That Glitters by Jill Seidenstein, When We're Not There, We're Not Here by Jerome Stueart, Here's How It Goes by Alyssa Wong, and The First Rule I Learned About Writing Queer Characters in Science Fiction by Haralambi Markov.
Average rating: 3.45/5, rounded up to a 3.5/5. -
I thought this was more uneven than other installations in the Destroy issues but there was some great stories and the cumulative effect of reading so many queer stories in a row is not to be underestimated. Some of my favorites:
Influence Isolated, Make Peace, John Chu
Trickier with Each Translation, Bonnie Jo Stufflebeam
Tip of the Tongue, Felicia Davin (I really really liked this one)
Plant Children, Jessica Yang
Two by Tow, Tim Susman
In the Dawn Between Hours, Sarah Pinsker
Red Run, by AMJ Hudson disturbed me.
I question the inclusion of Geoff Ryman's O Happy Day! (not because of the rape, though I find rape hard to read) but because it seemed more like a privileged white man's fantasy-fear of what women would do if they ruled the world, with the added problem of using the only person of color, a man, stand in for the traditional treatment given to women: a vessel who is raped as a catalyst for the main (white) character's story, pain and action. The story was powerful and upsetting on many levels but it seems to me it should have been left in 1985 where it came from. -
This was an incredible anthology. There were very few stories that I didn't particularly like - and only one that I clearly disliked. The rest of the stories were really well-written!
While reading many of them, I would reach the end of the story wishing there were more stories (or even books!) based on the same universe, because there was incredible world-building.
The most important element of the anthology, I believe, were the believable, realistic and relatable characters. I was genuinely interested in what would happen to them.
The non-fiction pieces at the end were great too, though they all had the same subject matter (so maybe don't try to read them in one sitting).
This is a short review, because it would take me forever to start mentioning all of my favourite stories and characters, or even just how much reading this anthology meant to me. During times when I would feel disconnected from everyone around me because of my identity, reading a part of this anthology always helped me feel better. I feel grateful that I came across Queers Destroy Science Fiction. -
Very solid collection! I am not a huge fan of short fiction (at all; i need the depth and breadth of a novel to really sink into), but as collections of short fiction go, this collection is extremely well-selected, and the vast majority of the stories are extremely good. and, rarest of rare beasts, there is not one single coming-out story among them! for which i would like to lavish the editor with exceptional praise. FINALLY we are seeing more strong queer (non-alien) characters in fiction, where the fiction is not necessarily *about* their queerness.
The personal essays at the end of the collection blow that a bit (too many of them are on the same theme, of the lack of queer characters in fiction, which any queer reader has already lived through abundantly, yawn) but the pieces that deal with the power of representation in terms of potential (rather than lamentation at the lack thereof) are strong. -
I heard that Queers Destroy Science Fiction was super controversial, really good, really transgressive. As usual, the rumor mill was wrong. Not that this is bad, and I don't actually read a lot of contemporary short scifi so my comparisons might be off, but I found this collection surprisingly... "bland" is the best word. Little domestic problems that were not particularly science-fictiony, or particularly GLTBQ. The only new story that really stuck with me was one of the flash fictions, "Bucket List", by Erica L. Satifka.
I think the most pressing argument for this collection as average is that by far the best stories, the ones with the most edge and attitude and good ideas and writing, were the oldest; Raven Kaldera's "CyberFruit Swamp" from 1996 and Geoff Ryman's "O Happy Day!" -
This is a great collection of stories, ideally suited to audiobook in my view. I immersed myself in the worlds created here. Pretty much all the stories were good, and some were excellent. I found it difficult to work out who wrote what because there was no list with the audiobook, which is a real shame as it makes it hard to follow up the particularly interesting stories to read something else by the writers. Ir to be specific about recommendations here. If I ever find a full list, I may edit this to add my faves.
The narration was also very good. I recognised a couple of readers from other SF stuff I had listened to, which helped transport me to other universes or worlds, or simply other ways of being. -
A quiet, nostalgic story about a woman wracked with grief. She decides to participate in an experimental drug trial after her mother dies, but she begins to experience strange, powerful flashbacks to her past. They are perfect recreations of her memories until another woman appears. Who is she? Is talking to her such a good idea? As Madeline's life spirals out of control, it seems like her imaginary friend is the only thing keeping her tethered. But what if the friend was actually real? It's a lovely story, focusing on an interesting friendship turned romantic partnership and the power of connection.
And officially my 366th short story of the year! WOO! -
To paraphrase the premise of the story as described by the author on
Writing Excuses:
A woman has participated in a clinical trial for an Alzheimer's drug. Now she's experiencing flashbacks to memories that are basically hallucinations, and it feels like time travel as a consequence. A lot of the story involves experiencing extremely vivid memories and observing them.
Interesting premise, and a fine story that does it justice. -
An excellent anthology in which is quite visible the effort that was put in making it as inclusive as possible.
There are happy stories and sad stories, angry stories and thoughtful ones, stories filled with hope and hopeless, but in all of them, the characters are brilliant and what shines at their heart.
Really worthy of your time.
The narrators vary in their effectivity, but they are en general very good.
