| Title | : | Superman/Batman, Vol. 1: Public Enemies |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | 1401202209 |
| ISBN-10 | : | 9781401202200 |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Paperback |
| Number of Pages | : | 160 |
| Publication | : | First published January 1, 2004 |
Collects Superman/Batman #1-6.
Superman/Batman, Vol. 1: Public Enemies Reviews
-
Where is the rivalry?
Sure these guys may have already settled their debts and have learnt to work together, but where is the competition? Where is Batman’s naturally morose attitude? Where is his desire to show that you don’t need super powers to kick ass?
This just didn’t get the relationship of the two right, and moreover it pointed out the most painstakingly obvious details such as “I hate it when he does that.” I mean we don’t really near to be explicitly told this. The art can carry it through. I shall read no further. -
An asteroid from the planet Krypton is in a collision course with Earth..
The president of the United States, Lex Luthor, blames Superman for this. Batman tags along to help Sups clear his name. Thus, the two become public enemies!
For starters, the first half was pretty solid, however, the second half, I just did not care for.
The story is fine, it's just that it would have been better if Jeph Loeb had not wrote it.
More often than not, his dialogue comes off as stiffy to me, the kind of dialogue that you would find in comics from between the '60s/70s. There's nothing wrong with that per se, I'm not the right target for that, unfortunately.
It saddens me, that aside from a few stuff that he did most of his work does not appeal to me.
4/10 -
Reread: 26/06/2022
This was so good omg again. Rereading it again was great like Seeing how Metallo comes in and the duo team up and a simple case becomes so complex and then the coming of President Luthor and declaring a bounty on Superman and the duo teaming to fight these threats and the way they knock down all those villains was just golden and epic! Plus how they stop their friends was just epic and then the scene vs Luthor first their family and then them and Cap Atom getting such a good moment here and then Luthor <3!
What a re-read it was loved it, the art was excellent and makes you love this all the more. Great characterization of both these characters and excellent narrative beats!
__________________________________________________________________
This is one of the greatest team up stories ever!
It starts off with Superman fighting Metallo and then Batman gets involved and there is some mystery involved with the death of his parents and how the former could be involved in it and a meteorite ..from Krypton is falling to Earth and with Luthor being the POTUS he says its Superman's plan to destroy Earth and so every Meta human is after him and its upto the worlds finest to stop these villains and stop Luthor and this insane schemes and they face off against former Heroes and their friends and ally with new Toyman to stop it and the things they find are shocking and the revelations with Luthor are even more shocking!
I like how simple the concept was yet it feels so epic and the inclusion of a certain new god and mysteries compiling on top of each others is intriguing. The art was really good and it reads really well with the writing. Great story from Jeph again! -
Simple yet charming, this is a great team up adventure between DC's big two. There's something so intrinsically entertaining about the pair's dynamic, especially the way in which they parallel each other whilst still being extremely different. The character work is wonderful, but it's a little let down by the rather uninspired story-telling. With moments of greatness in an overall good experience, it's a must try for fans.
-
This is literally like a McDonald's value meal for the eyes. I consumed something, yes, but it's not lasting and I don't feel sated. Sigh.
-
Lex puts out a warrant for Supes, a bunch of villains/heroes turn up to help/capture him, it's not heavy on plot as it focuses on Batman and Superman waxing poetic about each other. I'm not sure about the artwork some of it works and then at times it looks like a shitty knock off Bruce Timm.
After reading some reviews i was expecting some over the top bromance, proclamations of love, life saving endearing moments, y'know a lil something something.
But nah son, you all lied.
It's probably a bit too cutesy for me, i need more drama from my guys and at least 70% more brooding from Batsy. Also there's a line about Alfred in this that really annoyed me and i don't get it, i don't think Bruce would only think of Alfred as just the 'help' like come on without Alfred, Bruce would be 100% done. Annnnnd i've read a bunch of Loeb's work and this is the only one where it didn't feel like his writing like i had to double check he wrote this, usually my emotions have been kicked in the teeth or there's a plot twist this doesn't have either, and i know he isnt glued to Sale's side but i missed his art.
It's definitely one for Lex fans he kinda steals this show in this and Batman and Superman are kinda meh. I'd still say pick it up just don't expect a lot and if you do want a good Batman and Superman bromance then pick up Snyder's unchained instead. -
I love Loeb's Superman/Batman! If you haven't checked these out, you are seriously missing out on the fun.
-
An okay read! So this my first time reading the comic for this story, their was an animated film of this story, that I have watched over ten times! Unfortunately overall, I think I like the animated film better... My major issue with this story is just how confusing a lot of it is, I don't wanna spoil, but so much stuff happens in this one book that its crazy; I can see why the animated film they had to simplify the story a lot, but this one time, it was for the right reasons! So basically the story is that a giant Kryptonite meteor is headed for earth, this is during that period in the comics when Luthor was President, and Luthor blames Superman for the meteor(In the most stupidest way possible, more on that later). Usually I like Luthor, he is by far my favourite Superman Villain, but this and Batman v Superman, are the two times where I didn't like him; they do explain later why he is acting so weird, but for me it was too late. Also my other gripe is the reason Luthor gives for blaming Superman, for the meteor, its like really stupid(That's something I'm glad they changed in the movie), and the fact that most of the heroes eat it up, and just believe whatever Lex says, really stupid. Positive's I love how the book constantly contrasts Batman and Superman, from the awesome opening to end, its written and done really well! But overall guys, I'm disappointed, I wanted to love this story, but overall, I'd rather watch the movie then read this again!
-
You can find my review on our blog by clicking
here.
The world’s oldest question: Superman or Batman? Now, what if it isn’t always a “or”? The two titans haven’t always been either side of the fence. Although their sense of justice and their means vary grandly thanks to differences in their childhoods, there are various similarities that bring these two together more often than not. Legendary Jeph Loeb brings forth one of the many popular series that stars the “World’s Finest” duo as they tackle the danger that lies within their reach. With Gods roaming Gotham and Metropolis, it is only fair to find non-believers among the crowd. Superman/Batman (Volume 1): Public Enemies reunites the two biggest members of the Justice League in a story of survival. President Lex Luthor announces that an imminent meteorite made out of nothing other than the famous and scrumptious Kryptonite is heading straight towards Earth. Jumping on the opportunity, Luthor convinces the world that Superman is at fault and conveys a “Wanted Dead or Live” order on Superman, with an extra 1 billion dollars on his forehead. With a special secret team in the palm of his hands, known villains appear from the shadows to take up for grabs the great Superman and his partner, Batman.
Dark, gritty, cynic, and filled with death, it wasn’t. Simply put, this first volume to the series was simple, action-packed and passionate on several level. The first issues gets both titans to meet again over mysterious circumstances and lead them into a confrontation with a villain who might hold pertinent information for Batman’s past. Until we get a blast from the past with the arrival of Future Superman, things start to become urgent and chaotic. The alert of an imminent treat as well as disclosure on a potential mistake lead Superman and Batman to quickly hatch up a plan to seize the danger. Until the President comes forth to the media and puts the whole weight of the danger on Superman’s back. Accused for the giant chunk of Kryptonite coursing its way through the galaxy to Earth, Superman and Batman team up to take down Lex Luthor and find a solution to the problem in the sky. It is only from this part on that we’re gifted with a dose of DC Universe and its almighty collection of superheroes and villains. Page after page, we’re treated with a nifty collection of fights between Superman and Batman against the world.
I’m quite thankful that this turned out a lot better than The Dark Knight Strikes Again, because that sequel was one atrocious pile of poo. With Ed McGuinness’ artwork, this first volume captures a more bubbly and cartoonish illustration. Although it does exhibit a finely drawn artwork, it felt a lot closer to an animated TV show put on paper. It isn’t a bad thing, but it does take away any attempt to make it anything close to sinister. The artwork does however put forth a more colorful palette and gives all the characters a more vibrant and popping presence. After all, with the countless number of appearances, especially the inclusion of both Superman and Batman’s “families”, the artwork was a great complement. While we’re still on this subject, I’d even say that the whole experience was so overwhelming, but still remained satisfying. Seeing the beloved heroes of DC unite in one volume and figure out their different allegiances was probably the highlight of this volume.
Hey man, how is it “passionate on several level”? Well, friend, listen here. Although it might have been unintentional, Jeph Loeb’s writing for this volume depicted more bromance than necessary. Aside from the sexual jokes toward a certain character (Yes. You. Power Girl.), Superman and Batman’s relationship is probably the most exuberant part. To highlight this, I’ll definitely point at the narration. Original and clever overall, it however also added an extra layer of acute admiration for each other (Superman and Batman). Throughout the volume, both Batman and Superman narrate the story with background descriptions on themselves and comparisons to their fellow partner. As they continuously alternate bubbles, each pair are fairly similar and showcases the similarities between the two heroes, despite their differences. But these very similarities also show admiration and a level of bromance that slightly spills over the threshold. Even if the narration is overlooked, some scenes between these two Gods illustrates the love nonetheless. However, I did enjoy how laid-back Batman seemed, and giggle a little bit at his inability to panic and rush. While on the other hand, Superman’s recklessness and simpleton manner held some comedic value.
Superman/Batman (Volume 1): Public Enemies is still a fun and adrenaline pumped volume. It’s never a bad thing to have the two blockbuster superheroes share the same panel and wreck havoc against shared enemies. Another part I actually enjoyed are the allusions done to chess. The idea behind the metaphors was fun and invigorating. It showed tactic, strategy and chemistry. I do have to say that I’m a sucker for anything related to chess. I see a lot of things like a game of chess. And now I see Batman in the mist of it? Win. Even if the volume as a whole was quite hectic and simple plot-wise, it remained a fun and creative path taken by Jeph Loeb. If you ask me, Jeph Loeb knows his chess pieces and doesn’t hesitate in making good use of them. Although there are plenty of other series that are far superior to this Superman/Batman series, this still remains one of the many long series that has attracted attention and brings two of our favorite heroes together.
Yours truly,
Lashaan
Lashaan & Trang | Bloggers and Book Reviewers
Official blog:
http://bookidote.wordpress.com
_____________________________
I thought it would be a good idea to check out one of the many series where Superman and Batman are under the same spotlight before Batman v Superman comes out. It's one thing to see them team up instead of fighting each other, but to see them go beyond bromance? Wish it didn't go overboard. The artwork felt so bubbly; like it was made to have a animated adaptation in the future (which it does!). The story is fairly simple, but the first volume contains a HUGE chunk of DCU. I wonder if it has as many as The Dark Knight Strikes Again... One thing's for sure, this was by far better than Frank Millers attempt to put every hero in one book.
The story is fun nonetheless...if you can overlook all the flaws that jump in your face! ;)
P.S. A full review will before BvS comes out in theaters!
Yours truly,
Lashaan
Lashaan & Trang | Bloggers and Book Reviewers
Official blog:
http://bookidote.wordpress.com -
Kali pertama seumur hidup aku membaca komik adiwira barat. Di hari krismas pulak tu.
Aku tak adalah apa2 jangkaan tinggi pasal komik ni sebab minda aku dah lama dipengaruhi oleh manga jepun dan komik tempatan. Jadi aku rasa komik ni biasa2 sahaja jalan ceritanya. Kau sudah boleh agak agak apa yang akan terjadi, pelbagai adiwira dan adijahat yang muncul dalam komik ni dan aku gembira sebab aku kenal hampir kesemuanya (sebab dah layan hampir kesemua filem adiwira DC kot). Rasanya rakyat malaysia lebih cenderung menonton filem dari membaca komik adiwira, sebab tu penerbitannya cuma sempat 3 buah je.
Apa yang aku kurang suka ialah terlalu banyak cakap/dialog melankolik, aksi pun 1-2 panel sahaja apabila bertemu adijahat, maklumlah banyak karakter yang muncul, kalau lawan sampai 10 mukasurat mahu tebal gila buku ni. Lagi satu faktor kekuatan Superman yang kita sedia tahu bahawa dia ni kuat gila nak mampus dan kelemahannya hanyalah Kryptonite, terlalu baik dan Lois Lane. Tak logik pun ada bila Batman bertarung, kita tahu yang Batman ni manusia biasa tapi selamba je menang dengan adijahat dan adiwira yang bukan manusia. Ikut logik akal, Batman hanyalah tikus bersayap (ayat salah satu adijahat dalam ni yang memang kelakar!)
p/s: Batman hanyalah tikus bersayap. -
Honestly, this is my second favorite Batman/Superman story.
It does such a great job showing why Bruce and Clark share a bond to begin with. Loeb did a great job with Bruce and Clark's narratives being parallels of each other. You see them reading each other's minds throughout the entire case, being on the same page, thinking almost exclusively about each other throughout the entire arc. Bruce is constantly worried about Clark's safety and going so far as to say he'd be okay with whatever punishment Clark doled out to Luthor because of what Luthor had done to Clark. Clark worries about Bruce constantly and expresses a secret wish that Bruce would stop being Batman, despite all the good he's done, because Clark worries that it will one day get Bruce killed.
They understand each other so completely and have such a storied past. It's wonderful to see and I really enjoy reading a story where their bond leads to them saving the day - not just fighting each other.
The only detriment for me was that I forgot how poorly the women were used - in the three or so pages they were present. Didn't appreciate Power Girl being told her usefulness in this plot was to distract a 13 year old with her boobs (hey, thanks) or the random kiss between Luthor and Waller that resulted in an incredibly OOC response from her. Again, in some cases, better to not feature women at all if this is how they're going to be used. -
Jeph Loeb...just this name is enough to motivate me into reading this series, and Mr. Loeb really doesn't disappoint. Plus the artwork is also good.
PS: and President Lex Luther isn't such a bad idea after we saw what is going on in the real-life USA! -
A fun team up. Watching Superman and Batman working together is always fun as they work so different yet they work so well as a team. And with Lex being the main threat here, and using Superman's origin as a way to make him the "bad guy" is really a cool idea. I also really dig the art, slick and works well for this style of storytelling.
I will say having so many other superheroes in here kind of took away from Superman and Batman team up. I didn't need Hawkman, Power Girl, Shazam and so on. Also it does drag on a bit, I think this would have worked better as a 4 part, MAYBE 5 part story.
Oh and also Jeph Loeb has a few too many sexist style dialogue remarks that feel off at times.
Saying that still a fun team up and a 3 out of 5. -
I am so loving that I committed to reading more graphic novels in 2014 because books like this are so much fun! I'm actually a Marvel guy and have never read much in the DC universe but this book was a blast.
Asteroid heading toward earth. President Lex Luthor offers a bounty on Superman (blames the asteroid on him) and an all out battle royal ensues. It's pretty much everyone against Superman & Batman - Soloman Grundy, Hawkman, Green Lantern, Power Girl (yea), Mister Freeze, Captain Cold, Mongul, Lady Shiva, Nightshade, Grodd and about 20 more that I didn't recognize. Reminded me of the job of reading Marvel's Secret Wars back in the 80's.
The story is much deeper than I'm giving it credit for but what I enjoyed was the fun
AND
The fact that it was self contained (if you follow my reviews you'll know about my aggravation lately with books that can't seem to exist outside of a series).
Yes it could be better - there is still that cheesy DC universe to contend with but recommended nonetheless. A good way to spend a Sunday afternoon. -
A Quickie Review
When it comes to superheroes, the old saying is true: You can't beat the classics. Superman and Batman are two of the standby comic book stars, and this volume of comics is entertaining despite both its age and its old-school cast of characters. It's not exactly perfect--there's some profanity, a little blood, and one heroine wears a buxom outfit--but, for what it is, it's quite fun.
Score: 4/5 -
This was alright, the art was a bit too cartoony for my liking at first but I got used to it eventually. Story-wise things were a bit cluttered, but I do love Batman and Superman's friendship/partnership and their banter so I might continue reading, but we'll see.
-
É uma história ok, tem seus altos e baixos. O plot do Luthor ser presidente e querer acabar com o Superman é padrão do antagonismo dos 2, entretanto, o que se destaca no decorrer da história é a exploração do relacionamento do Batman com o Superman, ambos se ajudando e tomando suas decisões conhecendo um ao outro, tendo como base de sua amizade a confiança e o complemento na figura do que o herói representa.
Contudo, os elementos que arquitetaram todo o plano do Luthor como a equipe de heróis que ele comanda, a questão do asteroide, a origem da tecnologia e o elemento do começo da trama que instiga o Batman e sua identidade secreta de Bruce Wayne relacionado a morte de seus pais, deixaram a desejar. -
Superb. Surely the very best iteration of the World's Finest Team we will see in our lifetimes.
-
I really wanted to like this one, but it was bad, painfully bad. It had a moment or two of hope and it held my interest, but ultimately I was left hugely disappointed. First off, this is by far the most homoerotic comic I have ever read. The relationship between Batman and Superman surpassed the “Odd Couple” and dabbled into the very strange territory of secret love affair. I’m sure this was not the intention of the author but the constant secret admiration and worship of one another is uncomfortable and odd at best.
Second the writing is just awful, clunky and forced. The whole purpose of a graphic novel is to see more than tell, but the author was constantly stating the obvious…. I hate when Batman does that, it makes me angry, I am so mad! The constant switching between the internal monologue of ‘B’ and ‘S’ (yes they actually refer to one another with these nicknames) is distracting, annoying, and unnecessary. We get it. We can understand the differences and similarities between the two without you hitting us over the head with it.
Thirdly, the interpretation of some of the characters, especially the women is terrible. Lois Lane looks like a tranny and Power Girl is supposed to be one of the sexist superheroes out there and she looks like a cross dresser who ate Power Girl.
Finally, the plot seems very poorly constructed with quite a few plot holes and the most absurd resolution I have ever seen Lex Luthor convinces the public and most shockingly members of the JLA that Superman needs to be taken out due to his ties to Krypton, um what about the several other ‘Super’ characters?? Supergirl? Superboy? The fricken dog Krypto! Not to mention that this story has the absolute worst treatment of time travel that I have ever seen!
What a huge disappointment. Read it if you must, but don’t expect much. -
Si el guion estuviera a la altura del dibujo, la historia sería otra. Pero como por más bonito que dibuje McGuiness el dibujo de Loeb sigue siendo de lo más pavote e inverosímil, me veo forzado a promediar para abajo.
Marco la edición española por aproximación, ya que lo tengo en los números sueltos de SD. Lástima que jamás conseguí el #5 :( -
I was not aware of and had not followed any of the run up to this so it took a while to get into it. It was a nicely told tale and the art was very good overall. There are always moments where it dips but there was real spectacle here lovingly drawn.
I liked some of the twists, I enjoyed the narrative style and the way the 2 perspectives formed a type voice over to the action and the story
So overall it was a good read, fun while it lasted. You cannot really ask more than that from a book. Its nice when you read something that feels weighty or edgy but if you are going to read a lot then you still should appreciate the fun light reads that while away your time in a world of gentle smiles. This was one of those. -
Lex's proof to the American people that Superman is to blame is baseless. Subplots were shaky. Overall, I feel the Public Enemies movie got it better. Still, a good book.
-
Not bad but really not my thing....
-
Review originally published Imprint (Volume 29, Issue 33) [
http://imprint.uwaterloo.ca/index.php...]
Superman and Batman have always stood on separate ends of the "superhero" spectrum.
The Kryptonian poster-boy of truth and justice has never seen eye to eye with Gotham City’s night prowler, having sparred on more than occasion for the very same reason.
This comic collection from writer Jeph Loeb sees them fighting side by side, bending the spectrum to show that at the core, the two crime fighters are really one and the same, with differing histories that define who they are.
Using a tag-like narration style between the man of steel and the dark knight, Loeb guides us from the Smallville days when the two first meet, to the adventure that ensues in the book.
Lex Luthor, president of the United States, accuses Superman of crimes against humanity when his crack team of scientists discovers a giant ball of Kryptonite headed on a collision course with Earth. To sweeten the deal, Luthor throws on a $1 billion bounty for capturing the Kryptonian fugitive.
The absurdity of the accusation drives Superman to fight his way to the White House to clear his name; with much ass-kicking along the way, as both heroes and villains drive to cash in on the bounty.
The bond the book creates between Supes and Bats as they fight off wave after wave of super beings is the same as one would find in blood brothers. You’ll find yourself squealing with joy as you notice the parallels between the thoughts of the two.
Ed McGuiness’ stellar artwork goes tit for tat with the narration adding on short gasps of excitement to your already aroused self. The intricate details imbedded within McGuiness’ work, especially the many full-page illustrations such as the spread of Supes and Bats striking a pose on pages four and five, cannot be done justice with words alone and must only be enjoyed first-hand.
Although the book breaks into some gushy, "ain’t that cute" type moments, but it does so in a very rough and tumble type way. You get the usual discussion of post-9/11 themes and other age-old adages such as groupthink in the government, but those too work on an integral level with the story.
There’s much to be expected from the man who brought us the explosive classic called "Commando" back in the ’80s, and more recently enthralled us with TV series like Smallville and Heroes.
It’s safe to say that he gets the job done. When you can successfully illustrate, both through words and drawing, what it’s like to piss off the world’s most powerful being, you deserve a damn medal.
Grab some Kleenex and paper towels before reading this, because watching Superman laying down the fists with his future self and then brandishing a shotgun is enough to make even those with the strongest wills wet themselves. Trust me, I did. -
Just wrapped up "Superman | Batman: Public Enemeies
I gave it 3 stars, it certainly had it's moments, but a lot of it was crap.
*SPOILERS*
Basically Superman and Batman team up (as the bestest of best friends) to take on President Lex Luthor who has amassed a team of Supers to take the Man of Steel down all while a continental sized hunk of Kryptonite hurtles towards earth (really fast!) threatening to destroy the world. It's really a Superman story, Batman is important to the plot mostly as a love interest. Their thoughts are in sink, they finish each others sentences, and they're little worry wort's over how the other is doing. Gag me, I prefer when Supes and Bats spare with each other (whether being portrayed as friends or enemies). They might have had more success in their early skirmishes if they weren't so busy staring into each others eyes.
Now that I got that out of my system, I'd like to say it was actually pretty good. A lot of cool stuff happens, a wide range of characters take part. Explosions, plenty of fights, giant robot rocket ships, turmoil as heroes struggle to make the right choice. It is ladened with all of that. But it is not without it's crap (as I mentioned earlier).
Some of the things I had a problem with: Lex Luthor turns the world, and superman's friends against him. We are supposed to believe that would happen. Lex apparently has "irrefutable evidence" that Superman is the reason the Krypton Asteroid is coming to Earth and everyone takes him at his word? and without seeing this so called evidence. Well, not all of them, but thinking any of them would take that bait is a little far fetched.
Another thing, I know this is a Comic Book, and I need to suspend reality for the sake of the story, but the Superman Vs. Future Superman scene. Isn't their a scientific principle, or at least a science fiction principal, that dictates that two objects cannot occupy the same space in time? OK, that may be a little bit of a harsh criticism, the real problem I had with that scenario is that Superman has come from the future. He has already lived that day, even dwelled on it for a while. Loeb makes it clear that superman knows there is kryptonite in the bat cave vault. Wouldn't he also be keenly aware that there is another piece of kryptonite floating around the batcave that day. Especially since it almost killed him (the first time around). And the kryptonite was fired out of a shotgun. Wouldn't Mister Faster Than a Speeding Bullet be able to dodge that?
Maybe I'm being to hard on the book, but that annoyed me. Other then that it was pretty good. I did like it, but wanted to get some of those issues off my chest. It is a worthwhile read even though it seems at times that Bats and Supes may abandoned the fight to head to the Fortress of Solitude to snuggle.
http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/57... -
Muy entretenido, misión cumplida del cómic.
-
Superman/Batman, Vol. 1: Public Enemies, Superman/Batman, Vol. 2: Supergirl, Superman/Batman, Vol. 3: Absolute Power, Superman/Batman, Vol. 4: Vengeance.
Прочитал довольно знаменитый ран Джефа Лоэба, у которого я люблю его работы про Бэтмена. В этот раз он взялся за один из самых популярных бромансов в комиксах, за дуэт Бэтмена и Супермена.
Целых 25 выпусков чистого, концентрированного веселья с участием огромного количества персонажей и классных событий. По атмосфере всё немного напоминает первых "Мстителей" Уидона 2012 года. Максимально развлекательный продукт, с огромным количеством юмора, экшена, фансервиса и прочих подмигиваний для фанатов. При этом, не смотря на легкость и веселье, присутствует и некоторое количество серьёзного и драматичного, поэтому читается на ура.
Лучшей историей в ране был сюжет о прибытии Супергёрл, очень уж там душевно всё было, когда историю изрядно начали разбавлять семейными ценностями, не забывая про драму и чувства. Самым слабым сегментом были заигрывания с перемещениями во времени и в разных альтернативных вселенных, очень уж там понесло Лоэба, который начал давить абсурдными событиями и откровенно безумными сюжетными ходами, слишком всё было сумбурно и странно.
Что было хорошо на протяжении всех 25 выпусков – так это работа с культовыми персонажами и постоянная возможность наблюдать за тем, как Брюс Уэйн и Кларк Кент смотрят на мир. Великолепно показано взаимодействие и взаимоотношения Человека из стали и Тёмного рыцаря. То же самое и с диалогами и монологами, живыми и интересными. Весьма живым вышел и рисунок, яркий и красочный, может и выглядящий мультяшным, зато этим он малость напоминает старые мультсериалы про Бэтмена, Супермена и Лигу Справедливости.
В итоге ран оказался отличным развлекательным чтивом, которое просто было очень весело читать, постоянно встречая классных персонажей, которых давно уже полюбил, да проникаться атмосферой прекрасного выдуманного мира DC. -
Well, let’s start with the art because that’s my biggest complaint. I felt like I was seven again. I hated this style. Perhaps it’s because I didn’t grow up in the 70’s. I was a 90’s kid. Almost everything from the 90’s was dark and gritty. That’s the way I like my comics. Dark, gritty, edgy, and clean, not cartoon-ish. If I wanted cartoons, goddamnit, I could have picked up the next Naruto.
Next, to the story. Oh my God, it was only slightly better. My biggest complaint was all the fighting. I know it’s a comic, but come on! This entire plot was just Supes and Bats going around and kicking some ass. I would find that highly entertaining at some point if it had some plot.
But it didn’t. At all. Ever. As a DC fan, I am disappointed.
Alas…
But on the upside (!) we got to see some awesome stuff with some rather witty quotes.
Alfred with a shot gun? Priceless.
Luthor: Under the Homeland Security Act, I could—
Huntress: Bleed all over the carpet.
Humorous.
Nightwing!Dick, oh how I have missed you!
Creepy ass old Superman is made of win.
FINAL RATING
1 out of 5 -
I wasn't sure I was going to like this because I'm usually let down by team up editions, (although I do like when either one shows up in the others' adventures) but this was a great book. The inner monologue is told by both Superman and Batman, and traces back to the first time they crossed paths (as children in Kansas apparently). The monologue does a great job of showing how very similar they are in so many ways, but since they don't talk as openly as some, they don't know just how similar they are. Obviously there are the big differences, but each in their monologues explain why they understand how valuable the different POVs are. On top of that, the story itself is great, and brings them up against a whole bunch of antagonists, ranging from Metallo to Mongul to Solomon Grundy, to Captain Atom, Green Lantern (John Stewart) and President Lex Luthor. A well written book which I didn't expect it to be, and another feather in the cap of Jeph Loeb. Well worth a read if you're a fan of either Batman, Superman or Loeb.
