| Title | : | Born Behind Bars |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | 0593112474 |
| ISBN-10 | : | 9780593112472 |
| Format Type | : | Hardcover |
| Number of Pages | : | 272 |
| Publication | : | First published September 7, 2021 |
Kabir has been in jail since the day he was born, because his mom is serving time for a crime she didn't commit. He's never met his dad, so the only family he's got are their cellmates, and the only place he feels the least bit free is in the classroom, where his kind teacher regales him with stories of the wonders of the outside world.
Then one day a new warden arrives and announces Kabir is too old to stay. He gets handed over to a long-lost uncle who unfortunately turns out to be a fraud, and intends to sell Kabir. So Kabir does the only thing he can--run away as fast as his legs will take him. How does a boy with nowhere to go and no connections make his way?
Fortunately, he befriends Rani, another street kid, and she takes him under her wing. But plotting their next move is hard--and fraught with danger--in a world that cares little for homeless, low caste children. This is not the world Kabir dreamed of--but he's discovered he's not the type to give up. Kabir is ready to show the world that he--and his mother--deserve a place in it.
Born Behind Bars Reviews
-
Love this story so much!
If you want to read a really good middle grade book about survival and acceptance, get this one!
Chapters are short. Characters are good. The plot is okay but I feel things are a bit too convenient for the child main characters.
Also, I want to know more about the mother, the grandparents and Rani as well.
But yes, a book full of positivity and hope. -
Kabir does not know a world outside the Chennai, India prison he was born in. His Amma was falsely accused of theft by her employers before he was born. The prison administration suddenly realizes he has aged out and must be released. An uncle comes forward to claim Kabir, but are they really related? Drastic steps have to be taken when it looks like he will be exchanging one prison for another. Will he be able to find his real family? How can he get his Amma released? What happened to his appa? As with
The Bridge Home, we see children fending for themselves on the street. There are also scenes that depict the conflicts between those who are Hindu and those who are Muslim as well as the significance of the regional languages. This is a heartwarming read and filled with hope. The narrative is structured with short chapters and paragraphs making it a quick read that satisfies the soul. -
Wonderful and heartwarming story about Kabir, a young boy who has only known life in jail because his mom was wrongfully imprisoned before he was born. At a certain age he is forced to leave prison and has to survive on his own in the world. He meets Rani, a young Roma girl, who takes him under her wing and together they look for Kabir's family. I loved learning a bit about the caste system, the justice (or lack of it) system in India, the tension between Muslims and Hindus, the water crisis and so many other areas of life in India. I would recommend this on audio.
-
March 12, 2021: "following a boy who is released onto the streets of Chennai, India to fend for himself after spending his whole life in jail with his innocent mother" This is going to be heart-wrenching, I can already feel it.
-
Another middle grade masterpiece from Padma Venkatraman! Sweet, lovable main characters you will forever root for against a corrupt caste system. CW for incarceration, child trafficking, castes, racism, xenophobia (Hindu vs. Muslim) and parental death.
-
First of all... the cover of this book is gorgeous. Probably one of my favorite Middle Grade covers of all time! When this book 1st started, I wasn't feeling it as much as I expected that I would. Kabir was born in jail to a mother who was imprisoned for stealing (even though it wasn't a crime she actually committed). The parts in jail were not my favorite, but as soon as Kabir left the prison and found his new friend, Rani, I LOVED it. She was the best character!
-
Kabir has been in jail since the day he was born, his mother serving time for a crime she didn't commit. What will he do when he's unexpectedly released to the streets of Chennai, India once he's nine years old?
-
When she was pregnant with him, Kabir Khan's mother was accused of a crime she did not commit and put into a Chennai jail where he was born. He has lived there since that day, in a cell with several other women besides his mother. Small for his age, no one paid much attention to Kabir until the new warden decides that at age 9, he is old enough to be released. Before he goes, his teacher at the prison school tries her best to prepare him for the outside world, as do his cellmates.
On the day of his release, Kabir is picked up by a man who says he is his uncle. But it doesn't take long for him to realize that the man is not a relative and that he plans to sell Kabir. Using his wits, Kabir manages to escape and in the process he meets Rani, a Kurava (Roma) girl a few years older than him and living on the streets with her pet parrot.
Rani take Kabir under her wing, teaching him how to survive on the streets, educating him on India's caste system that makes low caste people like them invisible to others. Together, they manage to earn money for food - Rani tells fortunes and Kabir sings. Kabir knows all about his father and how much his dad loved his mother, but his father never told his parents about his wife before he left for Dubai because she is Hindu and Kabir's father's family are Muslim. Now, Kabir is determined to go to Bengaluru to find his grandparents.
A stroke of good luck and Kabir's strong sense of honesty enables him to get enough money to buy train tickets to Bengaluru for him and Rani. Sadly, they face caste discrimination buying the tickets and riding the train, but also kindness of strangers helping them. In Bengaluru, they find the mosque that the Khan family worships at and follow a man to his business thinking he might be a relative of Kabir's. But when fighting over water breaks out, Rani manages to help the man save his business. In return, he posts their pictures on social media and luck is once again on Kabir's side. His grandparents see the post and manage to find him and Rani. Soon, Kabir finally has new, clean clothes, enough to eat, a room of his own and he even makes another friend who teaches him how to play cricket. Rani, who hates being confined indoors, is introduced to a woman who runs a school that allows her to live in a tent of her own with her parrot, and get an education. The woman also knows lawyers who may be able to get Kabir's mother released so that they can be reunited.
Born Behind Bars is told in chapters that consist of short paragraphs and that are narrated entirely from Kabir's open, honest, observant perspective. Though his eyes, readers learn what jail is like for the women and children who are incarcerated there, and also what life on the streets is like for so many children in India. Kabir's story is a nice mix of good and bad things happening to both him and Rani as Venkatraman explores themes of poverty, tolerance and intolerance of religious and caste differences, justice and injustice, loss and revelation. I also think it may be surprising for young American readers to realize that children can find themselves alone in the world on the streets of India and that it isn't just a thing of the past.
But is Kabir's luck too good to be true? I wondered that as I read the book and perhaps the story focused on the upshot of his good luck rather than the alternatives. Think what could have been if his fraudulent uncle has managed to sell this plucky, hopeful boy into what would have amounted to slavery.
I have always enjoyed reading Padma Venkatraman's novels set in India and this is no exception. The writing is beautiful, the story is poignant, and Kabir is a character you won't soon forget. He is honest, with an engaging sense of humor regarding his circumstances (I loved his private nicknames for the women with whom he shared his jail cell) and the challenges he faces on a daily basis. It is, in short, an enlightening, compelling novel.
This book is recommended for readers age 9+
This book was an eARC gratefully received from NetGalley.com -
Padma Venkatraman’s BORN BEHIND BARS is the story of Kabir Khan, a boy in India who was born in prison. When he reaches an age in which children are no longer allowed to remain in prison with their mothers, he is transferred to a so-called relative, a False Uncle, from whom he escapes. Using his own wit, he finds friends (e.g., Rani) and other relatives, all the while learning to acculturate to a ‘free’ society.
This book highlights the issues that many children around the world—including the United States—face after being born to imprisoned mothers. However, it also forces readers to learn about inequalities in all countries. While many people are familiar with the caste system in India and call it abhorrent, those same inequalities found within the caste system (including violence, discrimination, and unfair imprisonment) can also be found within the US and how people for centuries have viewed and identified “race.”
Venkatraman did a fantastic job of structuring this story and was careful to show readers that there is a lot of diversity in how Indians view otherness. One of the ways that she did this was by naming her MC after ‘Saint Kabir’, a 15th century poet and mystic, whom both Hindus and Muslims revere. The author explained how Kabir (the saint) tried to bring both groups together as one while at the same time decrying the caste system.
This novel is beautifully written and would be an excellent teaching tool for both parents and school teachers. -
Born Behind Bars | Padma Venkatraman | 03Jan2022
-------------------------
One-Sentence Review
Simplistic and short yet subtle and structured.
---------------------------
Published/Pages : 07Sep2021 | 272 pages
Location: Chennai (Tamil Nadu), Bengaluru (Karnataka)
Genre: Realistic Fiction, Middle Grade
TW: homelessness, child labor, hints of child traffiking, religious xenophobia
Characters: Kabir Khan, Rani, Amma, Grandma Knife, Mouse Girl, Malli, Aunty Cloud, Bedi Ma'am, Jai (Parrot)
-------------------------------
Rating Analysis
Premise: 8/10
Introduction: 8/10
Number of Characters: 7/10
Character Development: 8/10
Backup History for the Story: 8/10
Fiction Quality: 7/10
Pace of the Story: 8/10
Dramatic Effect: 7/10
Climax: 7/10
Impact it Made: 7/10
TOTAL: 75/100 (7.5 Stars = 3.75 Stars ~ ★★★★)
--------------------------------
Review
"Beyond the bars, framed by the high, square window, slides a small patch of sky. For months, it's been as gray as the faded paint flaking off the walls, but today it's blue and gold. Bright as a happy song. My thoughts, always eager to escape, shoot out and try to picture the whole sky--even the whole huge world. But my imagination has many missing pieces, like the jigsaw puzzle in the schoolroom. All I've learned here in nine years from my mother and my teachers is not enough to fill the gaps."
Padma Venkatraman could have been a surgeon, if she choose to! The way she manages to skillfully dissect the human emotional existence and then manage to sew it back with threads of social reality with the nimblest of fingers, all while keeping the patient (aka the characters) alive and well, is a measure of excellence. Not to mention that these characters are almost always children - those with a throbbing will to survive.
This story, according to the epilogue, is actually thematically inspired by a real life tale of a boy born in the prison where his mother was wrongly imprisoned and then how he gets out and faces the world at the tender age of 9 or 10. But, mind you, Ms. Venkatraman manages to take this germ of a thought and craft a tale full of heart, hope, and humility.
Having read Ms. Venkatraman's
The Bridge Home and being bowled by its beautifully sketched characters, I certainly went into this expecting to have my heart-strings pulled - and I wasn't disappointed. Kabir and Rani are the very embodiment of resilience that kids can have, especially those who are thrown into a life of hardships which many times even the grown-ups find tricky to manage. The author successfully manages to create these characters without making them pitiful or desperate given their situation, but in turn gives them the agency to tread this treacherous path while maintaining their innocence. There are moments of mirth and nuggets of novelty that these kids experience as they experience life on these streets. But nowhere does the author romanticize their reality. We are always kept aware of their stark reality and how dangerous things can be at any given moment.
This book tries to talk about a lot of things. Incarcerated parents, mothers especially, who give birth in the prison and somehow manage to raise their kids in those confines. The life of these kids who really don't know the world outside the prison cell. The transition that these kids have to do from being thrown into that real world at tender ages without any guidance or support, being separated from their mothers who really were their sole source of support all their life. Street kids and their need to survive on a day-to-day basis, where they are constantly at a threat by animals and humans alike (the later probably the worst one), and how they somehow manage to find a way to make their ends meet. On top of that, we have religious turmoil since Kabir is half Hindu, half Muslim and sociological challenges that are faced by people living in Tamil Nadu and Karnataka over the sharing of water, the two states featured in this story.
These are questions that need deeper discussions and assessments - this book does not try to solve them. But somewhere I thought it got a little too muddled with all these things and resolutions for Kabir's story came through a little too simplistically. We are never really pushed to the edge of the dangers of his life through all his and how he would have survived in those situations. I would have appreciated a little more depth to Kabir's reality, even at the expense of some of the aforementioned issues (which is not to say that they are not important!), because that would have shown a more vulnerable side to Kabir's truth.
But there is a lot to love here, a lot to root for. Kabir's life, his connections to people inside and outside the prison, and how he learns to adapt is nothing short of heart-warming. One wants to hug him for his innocence, and applaud him for his resilience. And we get someone of the best supporting characters in Rani, Grandma Knife, Bedi Ma'am, and best of all, Jai, the parrot!
Ms. Venkatraman is a driving force in Middle Grade literature and I hope these stories create the necessary conversation and hopefully solutions, because these characters exist in the world today. These stories do not exist in a phantasmagorical bubble but are happening as we speak. Hopefully, every child get to experience their patch of sky not through their tiny sky square of their confinement, but through the vastness of their flight.
Reaction Section
-
First sentence: Beyond the bars, framed by the high, square window, slides a small patch of sky. For months, it's been as gray as the faded paint flaking off the walls, but today it's blue and gold. Bright as a happy song. My thoughts, always eager to escape, shoot out and try to picture the whole sky--even the whole huge world. But my imagination has many missing pieces, like the jigsaw puzzle in the schoolroom. All I've learned here in nine years from my mother and my teachers is not enough to fill the gaps.
Premise/plot: Padma Venkatraman's newest middle grade novel opens in a prison (in Chennai, India). Kabir, our young hero, has spent his whole life--all nine years--in prison with his Amma (mom). He's friends with the other cellmates, his 'aunties,' and he loves, loves, loves his teacher. But though he's physically small for his age, he is past the age--technically speaking--of when he'd be allowed to stay with his mom in prison. So he's being released--without his mom--into the world. He's upset, anxious, and a tiny bit excited. What is the WORLD like? And where does he belong in it?
He looks at the world with WONDER and hope. He's heard stories, tales, even legends...but he's never lived "in the real world."
Born Behind the Bars mainly chronicles his time OUTSIDE bars. Readers join Kabir on his quest to find his paternal side of the family. (His mom was Hindu; his dad was Muslim). Can he find his dad? or his dad's family? Will he be welcomed into the family? Is there ANY way for him to 'save' his mom?
My thoughts: I would not want to read this story in the hands of any other author. But Venkatraman manages to tell this heavy story with hope and wonder. It's not that she scrubs out or erases the injustice and cruelty. It's that she's given Kabir the ability to see the world--in all its shades and colors--with hope. Yet at least to me Kabir does not come across as irritatingly naive like David Copperfield or Pinocchio.
I read this book in one sitting. I loved the short chapters. I breezed my way through this book with all the feels. -
4.5⭐
This is a must-read middle-grade novel that sheds light on important social issues as such poverty, racism, homelessness, India's caste system and inhumane conditions in prison.
The story is told through the POV of 9-year-old Kabir, whose journey I really enjoyed following. I also loved all the characters.
A fast-paced, illuminating and wonderful read. We need more books like this one. Highly recommended! -
Where to begin? This stories is one of the most heart-felt, rollercoaster of a book that I've ever read. The whole storyline is amazing! The characters, events and emotions all mix together perfectly. I absolutely adore the friendship between of Kabir and Rani! Along with the small comedic relationship with Jay. Thank you for writing this Padma Venkatraman, Princess of Emotions. 💜📚👸
-
Just as with The Bridge Home, I was immediately drawn in by the characters, voice and situation. The scenes in the prison are heart-wrenching but never overwhelming (except maybe when Amma and Kadir say goodbye--that was almost too sad to bear). Plucky, wise-beyond-her-years Rani and her cursing parrot Jay are wonderful, and readers will be rooting for this trio all the way. With short chapters and lots of white space (which I found a little puzzling), the book moves swiftly, and Kadir's courage and love find their due reward. The happy ending came a little too easily for me, but then this is a book that evokes fables and song, so maybe that makes it all of a piece. Venkatraman has given children another window onto a harsh reality too many of their peers must face.
-
A heartwarming story about a young boy born in jail
-
I enjoyed this book. It didn't end like I thought it would and I'm happy about it. I would gladly put this in the hands of my students to show them there are people out there who are willing to help even if it seems hopeless.
-
Heartrending and life affirming!
-
I loved the character development in this moving story. I found it to be engaging and kept me coming back to read more. I feel like middle grade students could benefit from reading this novel, as it deals with topics I am sure they aren't familiar with. This book left a lasting impression on me.
-
I'm not a big audiobook listener generally but in an effort to get through a lot of books for end-of-the-year listmaking I put aside my podcasts and listened to 3 audiobooks in the last week, and of those 3 I think for me, I liked
Barakah Beats more as an audiobook than I would have in print, I think I liked
Rez Dogs less as an audio than I would have in print, and I think this one was maybe neutral.
I think the tone of this is just right in conveying what an absolutely shitty hand in life Kadir has been dealt here without being way too depressing but also without sugarcoating it. It's a compelling story that I think could be a great window for a lot of kids (American and elsewhere) into some issues they might not have learned about. Fans of "survival" stories (I put it in quotes bc it's not like, Hatchet, but somehow those kind of vibes) I think will enjoy this. It's fast paced and wraps up neatly in a way that's maybe a littttttle implausible but not wildly unrealistic IMO, and mostly you're just like, thank god this kid finally got a break. -
Born Behind Bars is a heartfelt story of what life can be like for untouchables in India. Although I knew the caste system was officially abolished in 1950, I was unaware that it is still going strong today. The events in this story seem to unbelievable to be true but yet they are.
Learning about India's "justice" system and the prejudice toward the poor and undesirables such as the Romani people and India's lowest caste was eye opening. I only picked this up because one of this year's Middle Grade March's book prompts was to read a book set in Asia. I am glad I read this book because it expanded my worldview.
My only criticism of this book is that everything wrapped up a little too neatly in a bow to be considered believable. Kabir seemed to have so many obstacles that seemed impossible to overcome. The resolution of the story was too abrupt and that's why I'm taking off a star in my rating. -
A thoughtful book about a tough situation. Kabir’s mother was wrongly accused of theft and sent to prison in India. She had secretly married a Muslim man and was carrying his child, who was born in jail. Kabir doesn’t know any other life until he’s suddenly thrust into the outside world, alone, because of his age—nine—too old to stay in jail with his mother. Venkatraman sensitively portrays Kabir’s shock and confusion and provides him with a friend who has also been rejected and ignored. Her name is Rani. She is Roma. She lives in a tree, with her parrot, Jay, and works the streets fortune telling during the day. Together, Rani and Kabir are determined to find Kabir’s father. So much to learn about the caste system, incarceration, loneliness, religious intolerance as well as kindness, determination and family devotion. Really a beautiful book. One of Utah’s Beehive Book Award Nominees for 2022-23.
-
Thanks to Edelweiss for the digital review copy of this book.
I wasn't quite sure what to expect when I started reading, but I'll be honest that the cover drew me in right away and piqued my interest! Reading the author's note at the end made this story that much more powerful as well. Love hearing about the inspiration for books.
This is a story about exactly as the title says, a boy who was born behind bars, but who is then forced to leave because of his age. I don't want to reveal too much of the story, but it's about his search for family and to get his mother released from prison. And it's about him figuring out who is is and how to survive in a world he doesn't know outside the prison.
I love some of the other characters in the story as well both in jail and out! Rani is someone he meets outside after being released and their story together is difficult, but lovely as they try to find trust and build a friendship. Grandma Knife is wonderful as well and I really enjoyed how her character came through again towards the end of the story.
I also appreciated that this wasn't a story with a "perfect" ending and that there are still places that we can imagine the story going. I think this could also be a great connector for some kids to more stories and research as well.
"Fear is a lock, and courage is a key we hold in our hands."
*Highly Recommend!!! Preorder!!! -
One of my favorite authors, I’ve read everything Padma Venkatraman has written for middle schoolers and young adults. Again I’ve read a book that I’m excited to share with my students and teachers. With characters that read genuine and situations gleaned from headlines, Venkatraman’s books implore empathy from the audience.
In “Born Behind Bars” the author explores incarceration, poverty, Muslim-Hindu relations, tolerance, family, and loss as well as other issues. A quick and compelling read. -
Kabir has spent his life in India behind bars, due to a crime that his mom was accused of committing. When he ages out of the system that has kept him in the prison with his mother, he is sent away to live on his own, with no known family or resources. He meets up with Rani, another child who is living on her own, and they work together to find his family and to get her an education.
Early digital review copy received by Edelweiss. -
In my delight in finishing the story and wanting my son to read it because he loved
The Bridge Home when it was read in his class a few years ago, I had posted a quick review on Instagram and never dropped my review to my favorite place in the world, Goodreads.
This one is beautiful and not in the "broccoli" kind of way in which kids *should* read this title because it's good for them but it's really more for the adults, this one is TRULY a magic-less magical story of a kid, Kabir, persevering after a being born into a life that was less than ideal. A mother who was wrongfully convicted of stealing at a home she worked at was put behind bars and thus, her baby went with her. Kabir was born and raised behind bars. But at nine, he can no longer stay and is quickly "shown the door." Yet it'll be a struggle because his father stopped writing to his mother years ago and he has no where to start looking and the first connection with a supposed Uncle, ends up leading to a minor crisis before he runs in to Rani, a girl living on the street with her pet bird. Quickly endeared to one another, she shows him the ropes and he learns them quickly.
Without giving the closing third of the book away, it is heartwarming in the way Venkatraman has shown she can do over and over again. Kabir and Rani's friendship is one thing, but the developed adult relationships as the story progresses is equally empathetic and understanding of the life in Chennai, India, but also what could be possible. My son is halfway through it now and I know it's one of the books he'll want to own once it's published. -
Astonished by how much I loved this harrowing, hopeful book, the audiobook of which is narrated beautifully by author Padma Venkatraman. I was thinking that the bleak setting and abject poverty would make this a slog to get through, but 9 year old Kabir's spirit, pluck, hopefulness, and kind heart buoy the reader through the most terrifying circumstances. I suppose it might be criticized for an unrealistically happy ending, but if ever I rooted for happiness for two absolutely worthy child characters, I rooted even moreso for Kabir and his fierce, loyal, skittish friend Rani. In a world with so much injustice, sadness, and despair, I am so grateful for this book.
Recommended highly for upper elementary and middle school library collections. Can't wait to share this with my own 4th grade son; I know he will love it. -
Kabir's mother has been languishing in jail for 9 years, thanks to loop holes in the justice system in India, awaiting trial. Kabir was born soon after she was imprisoned and has spent his whole life in jail with her. When a new administration takes over, he is sent away. Never having lived outside, it is a rough adjustment. Luckily he finds help along the way as a looks for the rest of his family and a way to free his mother.
Pair this one with
All Rise for the Honorable Perry T. Cook for another story of a child raised in prison.
Recommended for grades 4 & up. -
I can see why it’s a beehive book award nominee! At first I found the happy way things work out throughout the book— and there’s a lot of happy and lucky moments—took away from the severity of this issue of abandoned children and caste discrimination in India and may be undercutting the author’s message but then I realized the author wanted to highlight the good going on in as well. She didn’t want to just wallow in the despair of homeless children but honor the people who do their all to help them and the children who survive on hope and ingenuity. She didn’t want to reduce India to a single story. We see good and bad people in all kinds of places and I loved getting a hopeful happy ending even if it may be a bit unrealistic. It is an elementary age read after all. A great, fast read.
-
Many years ago I read The House Without Windows (Hashimi), it wasn't until that time that I had any awareness of prisons in other countries detaining the children of women inmates within their confines [Afghanistan in that book, India in this one]. The title of this MG book alone sucked me in and I feel ashamed to say I enjoyed it because of the horrific subject matter but it really was good. There is no shying away of the hardships and injustices in this world and exposure to these lenses in middle grade literature is as relevant as ever.
