彼女が公爵邸に行った理由 3 (Why Raeliana Ended Up at the Duke's Mansion, Vol. 3) by Whale

彼女が公爵邸に行った理由 3 (Why Raeliana Ended Up at the Duke's Mansion, Vol. 3) Reviews

• 
  Tamara

  S3- FINISHED @ ch. 121
  S4-Coming soon (Probably June?)
  
  I've already missed my babies ┗( T﹏T )┛
  
  This season was great because we've finally met Beatrice the bitch, Raeliana came clean to Noah, Rae and Noah both confessed to each other and the main plot finally started ticking. My boy Noah is definitely the best male lead!!
  
  Ok Theory time. I think the Beatrice is not from another world, she is the original Raeliana ヾ(☆▽☆) Why? Because she said that she wanted to change her 'fate' and we had a flashback scene about original Raelina. I think the original Raeliana noticed Francis was trying to kill her and decided to use black magic to place her soul in Beatrice to take over her body. But what I dont understand is what exactly happened to original Beatrice? Where did her soul go after Raeliana's soul go into her body? Who was the shadow person who pushed our Raeliana?
  
  So many questions. Cant wait for S4!! (〜￣△￣)〜
• 
  Kelly⁷

  *SCREAMING* THE MOMENTS BETWEEN NOAH AND RAELIANA ARE EVERYTHING TO ME.
• 
  Rebecca

  Noah, my dear, at this point you're only fooling yourself.
  
  More pertinently, I think we really have to start wondering about Beatrice. If she wasn't where she was supposed to be when Eunha originally became Raeliana, that would seem to imply that she may never have been the "good heroine" the book made her out to be. Who's to say that she wasn't somehow behind original Raeliana's death and used her to get Noah for herself? That one shot of her in this volume may just be hinting at it.
• 
  Laura Grace

  4.5 stars
  
  I forgot how much I love this series because once I started reading, I was already laughing and very much enjoying myself because these two are one of my favorite "fake" couples!
  
  But, ha! Who is to say it's fake anymore with the developments in this one? 😏😏😏
  
  Also, can I just take a moment to say I LOVE seeing the bookkeeper again?! I didn't think Raeliana would go back to that one bookstore, but that whole conversation was GOLD and definitely one of my favorite scenes in this volume!
  
  I think the only thing that was NOT my favorite was the High Priest. Ugghhh! He is such a prideful and stuck-up man and his kid-like appearance made it even worse! LOL! Though I will say…that glow-up was quite the glow-up. 👌
  
  And not just his physical features, but Noah's brother! *jaw drops* I was NOT expecting him to look like that! Granted, I'm alllll here for Noah, so no worries there!
  
  Though I was surprised by how many new faces we see, including him and the High Priest! I am curious how some of them are going to play a role in this story moving forward because while almost all of them SEEM good guys, we know from the beginning how sly Noah can be and if these people are in his inner circle (Not sure all of them are though?), then Raeliana definitely needs to be on guard!
  
  Speaking of, she is such a wonderful character! Her expressions make me laugh more than once and some of the "soft" moments definitely had me squealing! While I felt bad for her in regards to what she was hoping would happen due to her knowledge of the novel, this volume had some mystery sprinkled throughout as a result of things not unfolding the same way. This of course leaves me a little on edge about the danger that could lie ahead. It was however a nice twist I didn't expect!
  
  Another fantastic volume even if the whole torch ceremony (well leading up to it) was not my favorite. VERY excited for the next volume, especially with how this one ended!! 🥰🥰🥰
• 
  Michelle

  These two are so freaking cute. I can’t wait to see what happens when Noah’s brother tries to intervene.
• 
  Umaiya ❄️Ramblings of a Scattered Mind❄️

  
  LOVE. LOVE. LOVE!!!
  
  I NEED MOREEEEEE!!!!!!
• 
  torpidowl

  1)
  Season 1: ★★★★★
  2)
  Season 2: ★★★★.5
  3)
  Season 3: ★★★★.25
  
  
  4.25 stars
  
  
  season 3: chapters 88 - 120
  
  
  NON-SPOILERY THOUGHTS
  
  annnd we have yet another great season! this author is seriously a genius. since there isn't much i can say without spoiling everything, i recommend reading
  my review of the first season for reasons why you should read this masterpiece ;)
  
  
  SPOILERY THOUGHTS
  
  Sir Adam can be my sugar baby - literally! (cue the awkward laughter...)
  
  in this season, we were introduced to more facets of Raeliana's character, which i liked but also found... frustrating. okay, hear me out: her worries about Noah and Beatrice's potential attraction drove me off the ROOF. like, why couldn't you see it, girl?! this man is crazy about you. i swear, if Raeli had kept on pushing him away, i would've jumped into my screen and snatched him away from her.
  
  regardless, i'm glad the author knocked something inside her head, even if her epiphany of "enjoying the present" was extremely abrupt after having ONE conversation with her "dad." speaking of abrupt, i expected that her confessing she was from another world would make Noah question his reality or something, but it was strange how he accepted it without feeling any conflict, which didn't make sense logically. this manhwa actually does a very good job in terms of logic, so these two abrupt events, as you can imagine, are kind of disappointing.
  
  i remember how i've always wanted Noah's character to have more depth, but i guess he'll forever be just another bland love interest. sigh, another character with great potential wasted. i also wish that he had more screen time (Justin can get it with Vivian Shamal), and that his interactions with Raeli had more depth instead of always the classic rescuing-the-damsel trope whenever they see each other. i'm pretty tired of that, honestly. usually i don't mind this particular trope, but it happened way too many times to my liking. so Raeli, please stop getting into situations where you always need protecting - you and i both know you can shoot everyone dead, and i like that.
  
  i expected that Beatrice would turn out to be a bitch. why does the original main character almost always have to have a hidden side? despite this, i still have many questions about her backstory and motives. i can't wait to uncover what they truly are.
  
  i appreciated Raeli's guilt and inner turmoil every time she saw her family (this doesn't happen in many isekai manhwa, so a huge bonus point for the author), and i really liked the side characters. humor was another major bonus point since the author ALWAYS pulls it off so well in every single situation. the salamander royal beast, Raeli's apprehension of drooling on Noah's lap, and the subtle emotions and reactions from all the characters were so hilarious!
  
  i'm a tiny bit disappointed with this season because of the potential the author displayed in previous seasons, which made my expectations yay high. but negatives aside, i really did like these chapters and do not regret reading them - otherwise, i wouldn't have given this season 4.25 stars. it was a masterpiece if we ignore these minor discrepancies (...that bothered me a lot, but i'll forgive them because i like the characters so much).
  
  overall, not as well-written as the previous seasons, but definitely very solid compared to some other manhwa. onto the next season!
• 
  Hisgirl85

  4 stars. I don't know if this is a manhwa or isekai story structure thing, but after the first volume or so, the story kind of drags a bit or slows down to build-up plot threads from the beginning while aslo adding new ones. There is little explaining but random showing of something happening in the background and at this point that is most of the story with maybe one casual reminder of the main character's overall goal (staying alive) and a few mentions of something related to it (finding Beatrice--the original novel's female main character). Maybe it works better as a serial, but all together and seeing the trickle forward with random side quests and focus (eating gruel) made it drag a bit more for me. I still like this one more than others when it started to drag, but without the pretty art and tie-in from the first two volumes this would not hold up beyond an "explore some of the world episodes." It felt filler. At this point, I don't really care about who is trying (poorly with all the failed attempts) to kill the character(s). Just shit or get off the pot. I don't care who they are as the mention of them brings out the fun exploratory story, and they seem rather incompetent. The tension is not rising anymore after two volumes of death lurking around every corner. Multiple storylines are being juggled and not well enough to sit in this single volume cohesively. I like the story, the world, the art, and the characters. I like long series...but I'm getting whiplash from exploding jewels to buying jewels to no mention of jewels beyond a vague not discussed quest (maybe) to Beatrice is here, but this guy who met her doesn't know the fmc, which we find out after they've been chatting for a bit so the raised tension felt tired once his lack of awareness was revealed. It's the equivalent of a jump scare without payoff and feels like cheap storytelling. I hope there is some payoff for volume 4, or this will be a series I borrow instead of buy.
  
  That said. I read it immediately but felt disappointment and frustration growing with each chapter as it continued to not fulfill the promises made or even make steps toward them. Instead, we got fluff with "warnings."
• 
  Autumn

  4 stars
  
  After building the world and story, finally, the main character of the story is introduced. Her name is Beatrice but everyone likes to call her 'Beabitch' because we don't want no homewrecker!
• 
  Olga

  Появление другой злодейки и мутные намеки на то, как героиня оказалась в текущем положении.
• 
  monica

  Okay wow the intensity of these chapters seriously had me on the edge of my seat. The sewers? The fire? Noah still pining for Raeliana despite being destined for someone else? 10/10.
• 
  Angela

  "one's love and one's fate are up to them and them alone."
  
  reading this series with two of my kids. and i have zero regrets.
• 
  Andrea

  Season 3: (chapters 88-121)
  
  It looks like the changes of Raeliana staying in this world are finally catching up to the story. With her new friendships and influences affecting events will things still turn out alright for this couple in the end?
  
  Also in the next season hopefully we will get answers to what the heck Beatrice end goal is.
• 
  Hanya Mostafa

  RTC
• 
  Miss Amelie

  Saat menyelesaikan season dua, aku berharap season tiga memberikan cerita yang lebih menarik. Mengingat betapa banyaknya pembaca yang menggemari manhwa ini, ekspektasiku menjadi sangat tinggi ketika membaca chapter 88. Dari chapter tersebut hingga chapter 90-an, aku masih merasa agak bosan dengan jalan ceritanya. Tapi kemudian aku berubah pikiran setelah membaca chapter 102. Karena dari chapter inilah kita mulai mendekati konflik utamanya.
  
  Raeliana perlahan menyadari bahwa alurnya sudah menyimpang terlalu jauh. Melihatnya diliputi keraguan seperti itu, aku sempat mengira Raeliana akan berusaha memperbaikinya dengan cara apapun. Tapi ternyata aku salah. Raeliana sadar bahwa Beatrice yang dia temui saat ini sangatlah berbeda dengan versi novel aslinya. Alih-alih diam menyaksikan Beatrice menyentuh Noah dengan mesra, Raeliana bergegas memotong pembicaraan mereka. Sikap Raeliana dalam menangani situasi tersebut membuatku semakin menyukainya.
  
  Selain Raeliana, aku juga suka dengan karakter Noah. Kepribadiannya sangat cocok dengan Raeliana. Hanya saja, aku tidak menyangka Noah akan memilih sikap seperti itu ketika Raeliana melakukan pengakuan. Aku pikir Noah akan merasa aneh saat mengetahui hal sebesar itu. Tampaknya Noah benar-benar sudah jatuh cinta sepenuhnya pada Raeliana sehingga dia tidak peduli dengan hal-hal seperti itu.
  
  Season tiga yang dipenuhi momen-momen manis serta menegangkan ini ditutup dengan sebuah pertanyaan besar:
  
  “Apa yang dimaksud Beatrice dengan mengubah takdir?”
  
  Berdasarkan pengakuan Raeliana, judul pada novel yang dia baca adalah ‘Beatrice’. Itu artinya, seluruh peristiwa dalam novel tersebut berpusat pada Beatrice. Tapi kenapa Beatrice justru ingin mengubahnya? Mungkinkah alur novel berubah karena keinginan Beatrice tersebut?
  
• 
  maria cecília

  Palavra que resume essa temporada: desespero. Que agonia ter que ficar lendo os capítulos pra saber o que a Beatrice e a Vivian estavam planejando contra a Raeliana, e só nos 3 últimos capítulos que deu pra esclarecer algumas coisas. Depois dessa parte da história, a Raeliana aceitou mais seus sentimentos pelo Noah, mas continua sendo muito receosa por causa da premissa do livro. Porém, acho que agora por ter contado ao Noah toda a verdade, talvez tenha percebido que ele realmente a ama (tanto que ele até disse 'eu te amo' pela primeira vez, antes mesmo dela).
  
  Gostei da resolução de alguns plots e desenvolvimento de outros personagens, agora só quero que tenha paz, mas sei que vai ter muito desespero pela frente. Também fiquei contente com a Raeliana sendo uma protagonista forte e inteligente, e sempre que pode, mesmo com medo, faz alguma coisa para ajudar os outros e mudar o rumo da história.
• 
  Anindita

  Season 3 chapters 81-121 completed!
  
  This was such an eye-opening season... The truth of the world is starting to unravel and I'm not sure how I'm gonna be able to take it. Noah is starting to open up to a new side of Raeliana and the same goes for her as well. I'm also so so glad that the mystery behind Beatrice is starting to build up tension in the manga now also.
  
  Things are changing in this world and fast. Events that were not meant to happen yet are arriving faster and Beatrice is making her move into the main story now at this point. I'm not sure why things are happening the way they are but I can not wait till this all boils over.. for better or worse I'm looking forward to the new season as well as dreading how it will unfold.
• 
  Cara

  This was a wonderful story. I adored the characters, at least the likable ones. The bad ones were very easy to dislike, but I even felt bad for Vivian. Never thought that would have happened.
  
  Raelianna isn't Raelianna. She's been reborn into Raelianna's body after she was pushed off a building and woke up inside of her favorite book. In order to survive, she approached the formidable Duke to get out of a marriage that would have taken her life. After that, everything was off the rails, at least in terms of how the book was supposed to go.
  
  I'm glad that I started it when it was completed because I couldn't stop reading because I needed to know what happened next! Definitely recommend.
• 
  Cami L. González

  Me di cuenta que ya había leído hasta el final de esta temporada recién. En fin, me encanta esta historia y es terrible tener que esperar por actualizaciones porque necesito saber qué va a pasar. Es todo lo divertida y cute que yo pido en una historia del estilo.
  
  Raeliana es una gran protagonista, me gusta que sea inteligente y sepa jugar bien sus cartas para poder salir adelante. Breatice me asusta, porque también es inteligente y es claro que va a por todas para recuperar lo suyo (según sus propias palabras).
• 
  Amethyst

  
  LOVE this season!! Noah confessed, Rae confessed back and told Noah about her situation; I don't think there's many shojo isekai/reincarnation stories that explores about the souls transferring and how that can affects the body?? Also, to let the male love interest know about it??
  
• 
  Jerawan Meesangnilverakul

  Awwww. How cute this couple is!
  Things get more complicated when Beatrice finally appears!
  
  What are her motives towards Raeliana? Why does she hate her so much?
  All this hasn't been revealed yet. And that makes me excited.
  
  BTW, they have confessed and become a lovey dovey. Their chemistry is on point, guys.
  I can't wait for the next season to come out.
• 
  Yuna

  3.5*
  Probably my least favorite volume so far, mainly because it's kind of slow and felt more like a setup volume than driving more plot. I don't particularly enjoy the priest character, but bless poor Wade--boy is just trying to do his job.
  
  And finally, our couple has a kiss! The feels are catching!
• 
  Tina Sy

  It's so sweet how much Noah cares for her. She knows he is supposed to fall for the main character Beatrice but she can't help falling for him. Her life is still in constant danger. She meets fun powerful characters who will support and aide her in time of crisis.
• 
  Abi

  This was such a fun read! The characters, art, plot, humor, and romance made for an entertaining, masterfully executed story. I really enjoyed it, would recommend it, and have reread it once already. 4.5 stars!
• 
  Isabella

  I like the characters. The art is pretty. It's fun to read. But... it's taken three seasons to finally get to the main plot. (Or maybe I'm too dense and didn't pick up on it sooner.) Like I said, I'm enjoying it though and I'm looking forward to see how it all wraps up.
  
  
• 
  Princess Allie

  I still love this series, BUT this one was slow. We get introduced to new characters and their interactions slow the book down causing less time between Raeliana and Noah. I also would like to see more action from Raeliana, like her gun talent.
• 
  Devan Hornsby

  I don't think I can wait until July for the next volume....this story is so very good. I need to find a light novel like this so I can revel in this type of story. This is definitely one of my favorite webnovels published into paperback!
• 
  Alaine Murray

  I loved this volume of Why Raelianna ended up at the dukes mansion. Enter Heika Demint , high priest and Raeli’s new grandpa lol. This volume is so funny 😆 . Several other characters are introduced adding to the intrigue. And the romance is heating up. I got to the end and wanted more.