Title | : | Plate Tectonics: An Insiders History of the Modern Theory of the Earth |
Author | : | |
Rating | : | |
ISBN | : | 0813341329 |
ISBN-10 | : | 9780813341323 |
Language | : | English |
Format Type | : | Paperback |
Number of Pages | : | 448 |
Publication | : | First published December 26, 2001 |
Plate Tectonics: An Insiders History of the Modern Theory of the Earth Reviews
-
This important scientific revolution seems to suffer from shallow treatment by educational media designed for he public. It's mind-boggling. Your parents lived through this scientific revolution. You If have ever been heard someone intimate that the jigsaw puzzle fit between South America and Africa was somehow a smoking gun to accepting continental drift, read this book. If you have ever been taught that Plate Tectonics needed a physical mechanism to explain it, read this book. The essays in this book describe the actual conflicts behind Plate Tectonics that you will not found written in any way, as eloquently or even as objectively factually similar, in any other Geology text. You will never get to meet Lavoisier's or even Einstein's colleagues, but many of the writers in this collection are still alive and kicking. This is a really fantastic record of History of Science. written for this generation to understand.
-
There is quite a few interesting things with this book, even if I didnt love it myself.
First: it will be a very important document for the history of geology, as it is written by quite a few people directly involved with the plate tectonic (revolution/paradigm shift/evolution/fact creation?).
Second: It also shows that great scientific writing and understanding is not the same as great science writing. Its an art and a skill to write well about a history of a subject, and not all people can do that. It is one of the reasons why it is tought as a subject. Some of these authors could not write god scientific history and had no idea about how it is done. Some where pretty good at it.
For me, I did not have enough modern geology knowledge to fully understand this book. I could probably have googeld me to a lot of stuff if I could be arsed, but a book like this should also try to better explain things like this. See the second point above. If you have had a basic course in geology I think this will be much easier to understand.
All in all: a great book for someone that gonna write the history of geology in the 20th century. But I rather wait for that book. -
A bunch of historical essays by the people that were at the forefront of the plate tectonics "revolution", talking about what happened. A few of them were geared for someone who either has more knowledge than me or better retention of what was written earlier, but I followed most of it and the description of academic culture in the late 50s and 60s was interesting.
-
As heard on the Nature Backchat podcast:
http://www.nature.com/nature/podcast/...