Title | : | महिषासुर एक जननायक |
Author | : | |
Rating | : | |
ISBN | : | 9387441008 |
ISBN-10 | : | 9789387441002 |
Language | : | Hindi |
Format Type | : | Paperback |
Number of Pages | : | - |
महिषासुर एक जननायक Reviews
-
The contributors don't seem to be exploring an academic pursuit. Rather, they seem angry to the extent that they have lost the power of reason.
The book is at best in mode of abusive propaganda. With the alleged researchers, some amount of credible research would have not done any harm. Would it? -
Not surprising to those who are aware of top historians DD kosambi, D.N Jha or even Suvira Jaiswal Wendy Doniger. One gripe I have with not the book per se but this whole subaltern studies, cultural exploration & pride.. is it's rejection of any notion or struggle for socialism. Will a proportional presentation proposition solve anything. One can argue that at least that is marginally better but is it..it lulls people into thinking that that is the end all be all of all struggles where clearly it isn't.
One needs a framework to ascertain what view stands up to scrutiny as no matter how bottom up one wishes to be in their approach, one cannot seriously claim that every view is as good as every other view.
Aspiring to be equal partners in an oppressive socio-économic system cannot be a sane goal. That struggle cannot be fractured away & banished in place of just a cultural struggle no matter how justified that cultural struggle maybe.
No cultural struggle can be 'successful' without at least a simultaneous struggle for socialism. -
Best