Lucky Alan: And Other Stories by Jonathan Lethem

Lucky Alan: And Other Stories Reviews

• 
  Ellie

  
  Lucky Alan: And Other Stories is a collection of short stories by author
  Jonathan Lethem. If you are a fan of his (and if you've read him at all, I think you must be!) then this is an experience you won't want to miss.
  
  Every story is terrific (unusual in a story collection). Although I am primarily a novel reader, I also love short stories. A well-crafted short story can create a complete world and is an absorbing experience that can be grasped at a single sitting. These short stories deliver that and more.
  
  One of my favorites, "The Dreaming Jaw, The Salivating Ear" is told by the builder of a blog located precariously on a cliff by the ocean in which The Formal and Justiny are engaged in a seemingly life and death battle. Although what kind of life either of these two creatures (?) have is anyone's guess. The story is like a koan which I could neither grasp nor abandon. I especially loved as it teetered near the edge of reason and began seguing into Bob Dylan songs and Yeats' poetry.
  
  The last story, "Pending Vegan" (a state I have to admit to sharing) is a more realistic tale of a man on his own cliff edge-that of sanity, perhaps to be pushed to the edge by a trip with his wife and children to SeaWorld. The story has one of my favorite sentences of the book, "Civilizing children was pretty much all about inducing cognitive dissonance." He presents an excellent defense of this statement!
  
  Speaking of sentences, another story (aptly titled "The King of Sentences") demonstrates the dangers of literary fandom taken too far. The story manages to be both hilarious and terrifying.
  
  The title story is another realistic one (as realistic as Lethem gets-his stories are all tinged with a dreamlike quality). "Lucky Alan" is actually a story within a story-an aspiring actor becomes friends with an avant-garde director, Sigismmund Bondy who in the course of administering a questionnaire created by Max Frisch (also a favorite author of mine) launches into an accounting of a "friendship" with the epoonymous Alan. "Lucky Alan" of course turns out to be something...well, I'll avoid spoilers and just say that the friendship is outstanding primarily for viciousness, rivalry, and bitterness. And yet it still manages to be funny.
  
  
  Lucky Alan: And Other Stories is filled with anxiety and humor. It is written (as always with Lethem) exquisitely.
  
  I was lucky enough to win this book from Goodreads First Reads giveaway. The review written is an honest reflection of my opinions about the work.
  
  I recommend this work very highly.
• 
  Jenny (Reading Envy)

  I got an advanced reader copy from Edelweiss, with the understanding that I would provide an honest review.
  
  I wasn't sure how I'd like Lethem in short story form, despite loving his novels (although I'm a bit behind, I don't think I've read the last two.) I really enjoyed these! He plays with the words to a greater extent than I remember him doing in the longer novels, and it's almost tangible, like he's behind the pages cackling, waiting for the reader to say, "I see what you did there."
  
  Favorite stories:
  The King of Sentences (absolute favorite)
  The Porn Critic
  The Empty Room
  Pending Vegan
  
  A few of the stories are a bit more experimental and not my favorite, but I wonder if they will come with illustrations. They could easily, but reading a review copy, it's hard to know.
  
  Here are a few bits that delighted me, with the caveat that they may change in the final version:
  
  "Blondy didn't play by the Manhattan-neighbor rules. He was provocative, voluble, grabby."
  - from "Lucky Alan"
  
  "We worked in bookstores, the only thing to do... Clea and I were custodians of a treasury of sentences much bigger on the inside than the outside. Though we mostly handled the books only by their covers.. we communed deeply with them, felt certain that only we deserved to abide with them. Any minute we'd read them all cover to cover, it was surely bound to happen. Meanwhile, every customer robbed us a little."
  - from "The King of Sentences"
• 
  Mattia Ravasi

  Somewhere in Jonathan Lethem's house there's clearly a drawerful of Aztec shrooms he only taps into when he decides to write short stories, and some of that stuff expired years ago.
  
  That said, even at its most toxic his short fiction manages to convey through language some of its intoxicating euphoria, as if the ink they used at Vintage contained a percentage of acid from the deepest nineteen-sixties. Read too much of this stuff and you'll start speaking in tongues.
  
  Some of the most successful stories in here ("The King of Sentences," "The Porn Critic") are understandable and immersive in spite of a constant feeling of something major being off - just as in the best of Lethem's long fiction, namely Chronic City.
  
  Speaking of syntactical royalty, there are a couple of truly framable lines in here. "The Dreaming Jaw" describes a blog as "an inner-made-outer vanishing point, a place where feeling ventures out to make a meeting with language and finds itself savaged."
  Also, a line in the inexplicably telegraphic "Traveler Home" - "Unfathomable mysteries of science best ignored" - had me in hysterics for reason likely connected with that psychedelic ink.
  
• 
  Lemar

  It's getting harder to bury the thought that we are at a crisis point in relation to the environment. The protagonist of the story, with a classic Lethem name of Espethet, is a family man. This role thrusts him somewhat unwillingly into the position having to explain to the next generation what is really happening to the environment and what is he doing about it. The problem is that he is aware of the facts, that animals are raised in horrific mass production facilities and that the demand for beef and meat proteins worldwide is not sustainable, and this knowledge gnaws at him. He is having trouble executing the doublethink, can't unremember that the solution requires drastic action. Hey it's depressing and it requires a tremendous amount of personal discipline. Espeseth has decided what he needs to do for his peace of mind, and to set an example for his kids. But, like me, he has not taken the step, he remains a Pending Vegan.
  Lethem taps easily into the psyche of a family man living a 'life of quiet desperation'. His characters have been mainly lone wolves, great ones!, but this a rich departure. The story crackles with energy: the twins, his enigmatic wife, his shrink, I want to know more!
• 
  Silea

  The general rule of thumb is that short stories have to end with a punchline. Something fundamental must occur in the last few sentences, something that makes the whole story suddenly make sense, or challenges the fundamental assumptions the reader had when they started, or changes the reader. Something needs to _happen_ at the end to make the story, short though it was, worthwhile.
  
  And, well, that just doesn't happen in this book. Some of the stories have a small revelation near the end, but nothing that made me pause in the slightest. Most, however, just kinda petered out. Stuff happens to people, and then the story ends. The End.
  
  I was, not once in these pages, moved. I wasn't challenged, i wasn't enlightened. I wasn't even really engaged. These stories are like overhearing a conversation on the train: it's surely vitally relevant to those who participate, but as an eavesdropper, at best you get a discrete snicker or eye-roll out of it, but you forget about it by the time you've stepped onto the platform.
• 
  Larry H

  I'd rate this 2.5 stars.
  
  Full disclosure: I received an advance copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an unbiased review.
  
  For someone who once unequivocally refused to read short stories because I convinced myself that rather than invest myself in characters and plots that end quickly, my time was better spent reading full-length novels (such foolishness), I've more than made up for lost time over the last few years. And as any fan of the short story knows, the richness of characterization and storytelling can actually be intensified in shorter form.
  
  While I tend to read many different types of genres, I usually like my short stories to be reasonably straightforward. I don't necessarily need realism or linear structure, but I don't like to have to struggle to wonder what a story means, or what an author is trying to say. (Yeah, I'm opinionated that way.)
  
  This quirk of mine may be one of the reasons that a number of the stories in Jonathan Lethem's new collection Lucky Alan: And Other Stories didn't quite click for me. I think Lethem is a terrific writer, and I've read several of his books, but again, I've tended to enjoy those which hewed to a more traditional narrative better than those which were a little dreamier or more surreal.
  
  The characters in these stories are quirky, and the situations they find themselves in are often tremendously unique. Some of those I really enjoyed included "The Porn Critic," in which a young man tries to overcome the perceptions people have about him because of his job; "The Empty Room," which dealt with the craziness that results when a somewhat dysfunctional family moves to a house much larger than they know what to do with; "Procedure in Plain Air," in which a man unwittingly becomes a player in a situation he doesn't quite understand; the title story, which chronicles the narrator's friendship with a quirky, formerly legendary film director, and the dynamics of that man's relationship with a neighbor; and my favorite, "Pending Vegan," in which a man on the verge of a nervous breakdown has the bad idea to take his wife and young daughters on a trip to Sea World.
  
  If you're a fan of stories that don't quite follow the traditional path, this is definitely a collection you should pick up. Lethem is a tremendously talented storyteller, with a voice all his own.
• 
  Doubleday Books

  This is an amazing collection of short stories from a literary master. Whether the story is realistic, rooted in mysticism, or found somewhere in between, each one is unique and thought provoking. Jonathan Lethem has a way of making every story he tells stick with you long after you’ve finished turning the pages.
• 
  Andrew

  An eclectic and wildly uneven short story collection from the author of
  Motherless Brooklyn and
  The Fortress of Solitude.
  
  My favorite stories are "The King of Sentences," a very funny (self-)parody of literary preciousness, the brutal
  Shirley Jackson-esque "Procedure in Plain Air," and "Pending Vegan," a story of everyday guilt and discomfort that I related to very strongly.
  
  The rest of the stories are a mix of quirky, charming New York City character sketches ("Lucky Alan," "The Porn Critic") and truly insufferable prose experiments and one-joke narratives that drag like a 10 minute SNL sketch (basically everything else). I found The Fortress of Solitude to be equal parts dazzling and irritating; that same ratio basically applies for me here. Maybe it applies to everything Lethem writes.
• 
  Chaitra

  I started this immediately after I read Mark Dunn's rich in letters fable Ella Minnow Pea. I also have a habit of reading short stories in alphabetical order. This meant starting the book with The Dreaming Jaw, the Salivating Ear. It felt, in the initial stages of the story, eerily, like I never left Nollop - the crusty seaside "blog" was written in similar overly formal, archaic and arch fashion as Ella. It changed once the story progressed, but I was hooked. There was an added advantage - this was the weakest of the nine stories comprising the book. They don't always fit a format or a style or even a genre, but I found merit in all of them. Particular shout out to The King of Sentences, a story of two stalker-y bookish nerds who decide to worship a particularly reclusive author. It made me laugh out loud. In all, this collection is a huge step up from Dissident Gardens, which I loathed with a vengeance.
• 
  Nicole D.

  I have only ever loved one short story collection, and it was Salinger's Nine Stories. Usually with short story collections, just when you get interested in a story it ends, and then you have to start over and get interested in the next. Also, I generally find the stories hit and miss. With this collection, I couldn't wait to see what Lethem would do next! With the exception of Lucky Alan, which I thought was weak, every story was better than the last.
  
  There were some very creative ideas, tons of social commentary, funny lines, and some flat out great lines: "What right did my parents have to do anything but stand stock-still for my barely attentive scorn?" - Can you feel the contempt?
  
  Short story fan or not, Lethem fans are in for a treat.
• 
  The Reading Raccoon

  Listened to on audio for the Popsugar Reading Challenge Prompt “book written by a local author”.
  
  This was probably too Smarty Pants for my tiny raccoon brain. I’m used to more action and less contemplation. Like nothing happened. People just walked around and mused. I’m not even interested in my own musings well alone someone else’s.
• 
  Marc Nash

  Master craftsman at work. Lovely turn of phrases and extended metaphors. Of the 9 stories only 1 I really didn't get on with and another so-so, but loved "Pending Vegan" and "The Porn Critic".
• 
  Dave

  There's nothing to recommend this, the 3rd straight Lethem book I've given 2-stars.
  
  - The title story is the best of the lot, with a couple of film enthusiasts criss-crossing paths, as you learn a bit about their home life
  
  - The King of Sentences is odd, but readable, as a couple stalk a writer to a cheap motel in a small town
  
  - The Porn Critic is paint by numbers NYC fiction - characters talk, go to someone's apartment, discuss records and jobs, and then may or may not get it on
  
  - The Back Pages and the Dreaming Jaw are 1-star stories
  
  - The Empty Room is a halfway decent family tale centered around, well, an empty room
  
  I have one more Lethem on my shelf, but that will conclude my time with him. The Fortress of Solitude is top shelf, but that's all I can recommend of the six books I've read.
• 
  Jake LaCaze

  I wanted to like this collection. Jonathan Lethem is a contemporary of some of my favorite authors, so I’d hoped I could add him to my list of go-to writers.
  
  But I never felt pulled into the stories. Every story felt nonsensical, leaving me to ask what was the point, why was I reading it, and what was I bothering. This collection feels like the epitome of style over substance, which isn’t by default a bad thing, except that the style composed of big words purely for the point of literary masturbation isn’t at all appealing.
  
  After five stories spanning ninety pages, I decided this book simply wasn’t for me.
• 
  Daryl

  I like Lethem's work generally and had positive feelings about this one after reading the first few stories, but it slumped here and there. "Traveler Home" was my favorite, and "Pending Vegan" was good too. "The King of Sentences" was funny and clever but not really capital-G Good. "Their Back Pages" fell really flat for me. "The Dreaming Jaw, The Salivating Ear" was baffling and frustrating initially but ok in the end (but still not one I much loved). I liked the title story well enough, and "Procedure in Plain Air" was ok. That leaves "The Porn Critic" and "The Empty Room," about which I mostly felt very meh.
• 
  Anthony Schorr

  Some were good, some just pretentious, some just not as good
• 
  Allen Adams

  
  http://www.themaineedge.com/buzz/keep...
  
  Jonathan Lethem has long been gleefully subverting the tropes of genre fiction and using them to amplify the impact of his own writing. His expert folding of the weird into the everyday makes his work a reading experience like no other.
  
  His latest story collection is “Lucky Alan: And Other Stories” – an assemblage that duly captures the anarchic spirit of Lethem’s work. While these nine stories aren’t perfect, their imperfections are a very real part of the book’s overarching success. The variation from piece to piece comes not in terms of quality – excellence is definitely the watchword - but rather in terms of style, voice and/or choice. There’s a wonderful disparity – these tales are tied together despite often presenting themselves in wildly different ways.
  
  Though in truth, this book’s most difficult-to-forgive flaw is a simple one: its brevity.
  
  The book’s titular opening story is fairly conventional relative to most of the book’s other offerings. It explores the sorts of non-relationship relationships that sometimes spring from the rocky soil of urban proximity, as well as the fleeting nature of those acquaintanceships. But then you’ve also got something like “Traveler Home,” a tale related by way of an almost stream-of-consciousness inner dialogue by a man whose inadvertent discovery of something in the woods might well lead him down the path to even stranger knowledge. It’s a challenging form of storytelling that plays out with clean precision.
  
  There’s “Procedure in Plain Air,” a story about an aimless Brooklyn man who finds himself recruited to hold an umbrella over a hole in the street in order to protect the hole’s current denizen from the elements. It plays like a postmodern riff on Kafka, infused with a playfulness that belies the unspoken darkness lurking beneath the surface.
  
  Perhaps my favorite of the bunch is “Their Back Pages,” a surreal exploration of forgotten comics characters stranded on a deserted island following a plane crash. It’s a fascinating deconstruction of the inner lives being lived beyond the panels of the newspaper or comic book. The rapidly shifting points of view and radically different voices of each player result in a hilariously funny pastiche that should by all rights descend into cacophony, yet somehow never does.
  
  There’s an art to assembling a good short story collection. Not only does each piece have to stand alone and self-contained, but the work taken as a whole should have something to hold it together. That binding element need not be overt – it can be thematic or aesthetic or stylistic – but the very best collections must have it. This one does.
  
  Lethem’s considerable intelligence is always front and center in his work; “Lucky Alan” is no exception. But it’s his ability to wield that intelligence in the name of emotional connection that makes him so accessibly transcendent. Brilliantly twisted turns of phrase are scattered throughout, lyrical constructions that elicit humor and pathos – sometimes simultaneously. The marriage between head and heart – that’s the foundation upon which Lethem builds his elaborate, engaging worlds.
  
  There’s a quality to Lethem’s work that can be a bit difficult to articulate – call it soul. Even in the freewheeling breadth of this collection, the weird and wild differences from story to story, that sense of soul is inherent to each piece. Whether he’s mining magic from the mundane or whisking us away to the freaky fringes, that feeling of possibility – that soul – is always front and center.
  
  “Lucky Alan: And Other Stories” is a sweeping collection that brings together many of the disparate skills and influences that make Jonathan Lethem one of his generation’s preeminent storytellers. No story is like any other, but they are indisputably brothers in arms.
• 
  Wayne McCoy

  'Lucky Alan' by Jonathan Lethem is a collection of nine short stories. I've read a few books by Lethem and this collection is a winner.
  
  His style ranges from realistic to a sort of magical realism. A man weaning himself off anti-depressants takes his family to Sea World. Another man writes critiques of porn, then feels awkward bringing guest over to his house with it's piles of video tapes. A family buys a house and leaves one room empty, but why? A group of back page cartoon characters find themselves marooned on a desert island. A couple go looking for an author famous for his sentences.
  
  There isn't a bad story in this short collection. The strange can inhabit our lives at any time, and Lethem seems to understand this. Even better, he can articulate it with the most amazing prose.
  
  I was given a review copy of this ebook by Doubleday Books and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you for allowing me to review this great ebook.
• 
  Chris

  This feels like a collection mandated by the publisher. At least one of these stories--written as a series of blog posts descending the number line, is six years old, and it hasn't aged all that well. Lethem is hit or miss both here and in general with his formal experiments, but I appreciate that he finds new forms to play with.
  
  Still, the best story here is his least experimental and most realistic, the story of a father recently off his anti-depressants taking his family to Sea World, seeing only the unseemly and seedy. It would be worth it if only for this lovable sentence: "Irving Renker was a Jewish New Yorker who'd crawled out of his archetype like a lobster from its shell, still conforming to that shell's remorseless shape but wandering around fresh, tender, and amazed."
• 
  David Piwinski

  Giving this 4 stars might be slightly generous - there are indeed a couple of really fantastic stories in this collection, but there are also several that didn't do a whole lot for me. Still, the ones I liked really hit home with me - I liked "The Dreaming Jaw, The Salivating Ear" so much that I immediately read it again. "Procedure in Plain Air" and "The King of Sentences" were also favorites.
  
  Lethem's short fiction is often really weird, but that's what I love about it. Definitely recommended to fans of his, maybe not so much if you are unfamiliar with his stuff.
• 
  Alan

  Of course with this title, I had to read it! Seeing him read a story at my local book store was icing on the cake. I'm a fan of Jonathan Lethem's novels, but his short stories are excellent. He never wastes a word. His stories move seamlessly between realistic (sort of) and surrealistic (definitely) but always leave with more questions than answers which is a sign of a story that will stick with me for a long time. Looking forward to reading his next novel (which had a short story excerpt in the New Yorker!).
• 
  Daniel Kukwa

  The first story had me hooked...but it was all downhill from there. This is more of a collection of stories yelling "look how witty, experimental, and existential I am", as opposed to a series of stories that make me want to delve further into the book. I'm sure this might hit some reader's sweet spot...but it totally sail past my own.
• 
  Rambling Reader

  I'm confused by this collection of stories. really shocked at the quality.
• 
  NamLitFollows

  This short story collection is a mixed-bag. Yes the sentences are dazzling. But this time the stories left me feeling awfully cold, distant and oddly unmemorable.
• 
  Colin

  Bejeweled underwhelm
• 
  Tony

  Lethem's always been a bit of a boom or bust writer for me -- the books of his I've liked, I've loved, and those that don't work for me, really don't work for me. It's been a long time since I've read any of his short stories, so I figured I'd give this collection of nine stories a shot. Five originally ran in The New Yorker, and the others all ran in similar publications, such as The Paris Review, Harper's, etc.  For me, short stories can succeed in any number ways -- they can be flashy and dexterous with language, they can contain a single unique image, they can deliver an unexpected insight, they can bring forth a truly memorable character or situation, there are lots of ways that they can delight and compel. The nine stories here do none of that. They are flat, limp, exercises that washed over me and left nothing behind at all. In a month (or maybe a week) I will recollect exactly nothing about any of them.
  
  The first and last stories ("Lucky Alan" and "Pending Vegan") are perhaps the ones most grounded in the real world, the first revolving around a New York theater director and the last about a father's struggles with a family trip to Sea World. The middle seven range include absurdist farces "The Porn Critic" (about the manager of sex shop whose apartment is overwhelmed with the VHS tapes he is forced to review) and "The King of Sentences" (about a couple obsessed with meeting the once-famous writer they revere). There are slightly more absurdist stories that function as critique: "The Empty Room" and "Procedure in Plain Air." There are two that experiment in form: "Their Back Pages” (a script about a group of comic-book characters stranded on a desert island) and “The Dreaming Jaw, The Salivating Ear” (completely incomprehensible to me, I have no idea what it's meant to be doing). And lastly, "Traveller Home", a gothic fable involving an outsider, seven sisters, wolves, and a baby in the snow.
  
  There is the occasional nice turn of phrase here and there, but unless you are either a Lethem completist, or really into short fiction about unhappy middle-aged white guys, there's no reason to pick this up -- even as short as it is.
• 
  Stephen

  I picked this book up at a yard sale somewhere, probably Washington, DC, or Brooklyn. I doubt anyone in my tiny town has read any of Lethem's short stories. His novels sure, but these kind of left my hanging in the wind. I did not read them consecutively but over several months, which is what I often to do with short story collections. I have a friend who only reads short story collections of current writers because he is generally disappointed with the novels they write and by focusing on a shorty story collection thinks he understands the writer. Well, if I had read this collection before a novel, I never would have read a novel of the authors and I have read several and enjoyed them all. I really did and that is why I thought to myself when I picked it up, "I WILL LIKE THIS." At times I felt I was reading "Naked Lunch" by Burroughs. It made absolutely no sense. I did understand the depravity of what Burroughs was doing, but Lethem? The author writes in an interesting time-warp in the spaces between all kinds of literary genres: realism and absurdism, modernism and postmodernism, magical realism and surrealism, satire and a particular brand of dark-humor based on the general culture of the United States. Some of the stories were good, the first on and the last one, for sure, and maybe one or two in between. I might try one more collection if I see one somewhere, but more of his novels, he is prolific, definitely.
• 
  Bobby Keniston

  This collection is for Lethem fans, and I have been one since "Gun, With Occasional Music."
  
  In his third collection of stories, Lethem delivers compact, precise, and often delightfully bizarre tales, embracing influences like Philip K. Dick, Kafka, and the entire Theatre of the Absurd (with a few nods to his beloved comic books, as well).
  
  I don't wish to go into too much detail--- as I said, these stories are tight and compact, and the slim yet meaty volume can easily be consumed in a day. No room for spoilers, here.
  
  Still, of the nine stories, here are my favorites:
  
  "The King of Sentences," about a couple who work at a bookstore and are obsessed with sentences, and one particular writer who they force a very strange encounter with,
  
  "Traveler Home," told mostly in percussive, short sentences, that involves wolves and a foundling,
  
  and "Pending Vegan", about a man just recently off his medication trying to avoid a breakdown during a trip to Sea World with his wife and twin daughters.
  
  If you are already a fan of Lethem, I don't doubt that you will devour this collection. If you are new to him, I might suggest you check out a few of his more accessible novels (the aforementioned "Gun, With Occasional Music," or "Motherless Brooklyn") before diving into "Lucky Alan and Other Stories." But who knows? I could be completely wrong.
  
  I give this collection a B+.
  
  Thanks for checking out my thoughts on "Lucky Alan and Other Stories." Happy reading!
• 
  Sandie

  In this anthology, the reader gets a look into the mind of Jonathan Lethem. There are nine stories. The first is the title story and is about a theatre director living in Manhattan and a financial investor. The two meet on the street as they live in the same neighborhood and strike up a friendship. The director is older but the other man is young and seems wealthy. After a visit abroad, he returns with an Asian wife who then becomes pregnant. The man dies soon after his child is born and the director comes to question their friendship.
  Some of the stories are obscure and others are very relatable. My personal favorite was the last story which is titled Pending Vegan. It is about a family man taking his wife and two daughters to Sea World, unfortunately after deciding to take himself off an antidepressant.
  
  Jonathan Lethem is considered one of our better novelists. He was a MacArthur Fellow and has won the National Book Critics Circle Award for Fiction. Some of his better known novels include Dissident Gardens, Motherless Brooklyn, The Fortress Of Solitude, The Feral Detective and A Gambler's Anatomy. This book is recommended for literary fiction readers.