| Title | : | The New Space Opera |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | 0060846755 |
| ISBN-10 | : | 9780060846756 |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Paperback |
| Number of Pages | : | 528 |
| Publication | : | First published June 1, 2007 |
| Awards | : | Locus Award Best Anthology (2008), Ditmar Award Best Collection (2008) |
Contents
1 • Introduction (The New Space Opera) • (2007) • essay by Gardner Dozois and Jonathan Strahan
6 • Saving Tiamaat • (2007) • shortstory by Gwyneth Jones
24 • Verthandi's Ring • (2007) • shortstory by Ian McDonald
39 • Hatch • [The Great Ship Universe] • (2007) • shortstory by Robert Reed
66 • Winning Peace • (2007) • novelette by Paul J. McAuley
88 • Glory • (2007) • novelette by Greg Egan
112 • Maelstrom • (2007) • novelette by Kage Baker
143 • Blessed by an Angel • (2007) • shortstory by Peter F. Hamilton
158 • Who's Afraid of Wolf 359? • shortstory by Ken MacLeod
170 • The Valley of the Gardens • (2007) • novelette by Tony Daniel
202 • Dividing the Sustain • (2007) • novelette by James Patrick Kelly
234 • Minla's Flowers • [Merlin [4] • 2] • (2007) • novella by Alastair Reynolds
291 • Splinters of Glass • (2007) • novelette by Mary Rosenblum
316 • Remembrance • (2007) • shortstory by Stephen Baxter
334 • The Emperor and the Maula • (2007) • novelette by Robert Silverberg
379 • The Worm Turns • (2007) • shortstory by Gregory Benford
401 • Send Them Flowers • (2007) • novelette by Walter Jon Williams
436 • Art of War • shortstory by Nancy Kress
454 • Muse of Fire • (2007) • novella by Dan Simmons
The New Space Opera Reviews
-
Rating System:
5 Excellent
4 Very Good
3 Good
2 Fair
1 Poor
0 Awful
“Saving Tiamaat” by Gwyneth Jones - 2
“Verthandi’s Ring” by Ian McDonald - 2
“Hatch” by Robert Reed - 4
“Winning Peace” by Paul J. McAuley - 3
“Glory” by Greg Egan - 3
“Maelstorm” by Kage Baker - 5
“Blessed by an Angel” by Peter F. Hamilton - 5
“Who’s Afraid of Wolf 359?” by Ken Macleod - 4
“The Valley of the Gardens” by Tony Daniel - 5
“Dividing the Sustain” by James Patrick Kelly - 4
“Minla’s Flowers” by Alastair Reynolds - 5
“Splinters of Glass” by Mary Rosenblum - 5
“Remembrance” by Stephen Baxter - 4
“The Emperor and the Maula” by Robert Silverberg - 4
“The Worm Turns” by Greg Benford - 4
“Send Them Flowers” by Walter Jon Williams - 4
“Art of War” by Nancy Kress - 4
“Muse of Fire” by Dan Simmons - 5
The first two stories, “Saving Tiamaat” and “Verthandi’s Ring”, left me cold. I really didn’t connect with them, though the former ended well. The latter was so far in the future with vast time scales and god like technology that it seemed like I was reading mythology. After going 0 for 2, I was afraid that I might’ve made a mistake in picking up this book.
But the third story, “Hatch” by Robert Reed, got me. The story is the latest in a series of tales which take place on an alien constructed, Jupiter-sized starship circumnavigating the galaxy. Humans, and many other aliens, are just along for the ride.
“Winning Peace” and “Glory” were solid stories. The former dealt with a post-interstellar war treasure hunt while the latter concerned an archaeological dig on an alien world in the midst of a cold war threatening to turn hot.
Things took a turn for the better after that.
“Maelstorm” is about the amusing misadventures of a production company on Mars performing a retro form of entertainment known as “plays.”
There’s nothing amusing about the diabolical exploits of the titular character in “Blessed by an Angel.” It brought the promise of immortality, but the price was one’s soul. And “no” really wasn’t an answer it wanted to hear.
“Who’s Afraid of Wolf 359?” takes the clever play on words and runs with it.
“The Valley of the Gardens”, one of a few stories in which humanity gets its ass handed to it, skillfully pits bio-engineered humans versus an extra-universal lifeform that achieved sentience when the universe only contained subatomic particles.
“Dividing the Sustain” is another amusing tale in which humans re-engineer themselves with strange physical characteristics to avoid becoming stale.
“Minla’s Flowers” shows that no matter how hard you try to save a world from destruction, you inevitably wind up destroying it. Good intentions and roads to brimstone destinations and all that. This was my first Alastair Reynolds story. I'm now on my third book.
“Splinters of Glass” is an excellent tale of intrigue and love beneath the ice on Europa.
“Remembrance” is another Earth’s ass gets brutally kicked story. The problem is, no one remembers it. Well, one guy does.
“The Emperor and the Maula” is a bit gentler in its ass kicking of Earth. Humor salves the wound though. In order to save our world, a woman seeks an audience with the Emperor. But as Earth is considered barbaric, barbarians are to be executed upon setting foot upon the capitol world.
Corporations will always be up to shenanigans. Hostile takeovers for competitors will go on, whether the prize is greater telecom market share or wormholes. In “The Worm Turns” a plucky woman is sent out to traverse a wormhole before someone else can snatch away the rights to it.
“Send Them Flowers” lets us know that the laws of physics may change from one to universe to the next but love triangles are still messy.
History shows us that you can learn a lot about a culture by studying its art. In “Art of War” the same holds true for aliens, but whoever heard of soldiers as artists?
“Muse of Fire” ends the book on a spectacular note. A Shakespearean production company is tasked with performing various works of the Great Bard for humanity’s alien overlords. The performance of the work will determine whether our species lives or dies.
All in all, this is a great collection of stories that will please most sci-fi fans. Hard sci-fi purists are the only group that I don’t see enjoying this anthology. I’ll have to pick up volume two and see what great tales Messrs Dozois and Strahan have gathered for us to read. -
"The New Space Opera" is a somewhat deceptively titled but otherwise very good collection of short stories by what the editors refer to as "new space opera" authors. I put "somewhat deceptively" because, in my opinion, most of the stories don't really qualify as space opera. Space opera is a sub-genre of SF, consisting of over-the-top, galaxy-wide adventure stories, often with larger than life heroes, usually containing lots of space ships, dealing with a numbers of planets or galaxies or even universes. It's adventure, romance and violence. Galaxy-wide intrigues. Multiple societies on multiple planets. Aliens, if at all possible, should be included --- ideally many different kinds of them. Also, space opera doesn't pay too much attention to science - as a matter of fact, I'd go as far as saying that it doesn't count as space opera if it doesn't have some form of faster-than-light or hyper-speed or phase space or whatever else the author comes up with that allows ships to shoot from galaxy to galaxy in a few hours or days.
So anyway. The stories in this collection all range from good to excellent. There are really no clunkers in there (although strangely enough, the very first story - by Gwyneth Jones - comes closest). The odd thing is that many of the stories just aren't space opera. One of them is set entirely under the ice on one of Jupiter's moons. While it's a thrilling story, it's really not space opera. Others are confined to a single city. Kage Baker's story, loosely connected to the "Empress of Mars" novella (and I just figured out this is actually connected to her Company series) deals with someone setting up a theater company on a Martian colony. It's great, but it's just not space opera.
Of course, the short story as a format by definition doesn't lend itself to the epic narrative form you'd expect for space opera, but if you're willing to concede that some of these stories offer slices of a larger epic, a snapshot of a longer story, then they could work as space opera. In fact, some of the stories are presented as part of an author's established SF universe. E.g. Peter F. Hamilton's story appears to be set somewhere between "Judas Unchained" and "The Dreaming Void" (and explains some of the new concepts that popped up in the 1500 year gap between those 2 novels). Other stories are part of a series of short stories that tell a larger story.
There are some great stories in this collection. The final story, "Muse of Fire" by Dan Simmons, is simply excellent. "Minla's Flowers" by Alistair Reynolds is also great (and reminded me of "Tuf Voyaging" by George RR Martin). I'd recommend this anthology to anyone who is looking for new authors to try, and to people interested in the genre. However, if you're new to space opera, you're probably better off trying something by Iain M. Banks (who is missing from this collection, unfortunately) or Peter F. Hamilton. -
Review for GLORY by Greg Egan
An ingot of metallic hydrogen gleamed in the starlight, a narrow cylinder half a meter long with a mass of about a kilogram.
A very abstract beginning. I skimmed past most of that science-tech babble, I confess. I liked the story that followed the info dump.
However...
“There’s more to life than mathematics,” Joan said. “But not much more.”
Math was always one of my best subjects at school, but still... too much! Math Fiction? Mathematical SF?
It was ok, nice idea of a vaguely Star Trekky set-up without the Prime Directive and more cloning and uploading of consciousness. Plus that hard SF thing with the needle that I skimmed... Did I miss the big reveal, aka Brig Crunch? It probably just flew right over my head.
Glory by Greg Egan can be read for free here:
https://outofthiseos.typepad.com/blog... -
Nothing terribly impressive in this collection.
I had already read the two standouts - "Minla's Flowers" (Alastair Reynolds) and "Muse of Fire" (Dan Simmons). Of the remaining, the best is Tony Daniel's "The Valley of the Gardens" and the absolute worst is Robert Silverberg's "The Emperor and the Maula," a retelling of The Arabian Nights.
My dissatisfaction with many of these stories is philosophical more than literary. There's a tendency in the New Space Opera and other hard-SF novels toward a coldness and inhumanity that rubs me the wrong way. -
A superb anthology courtesy of Messrs. Gardner Dozois and Jonathan Strahan. Definitely worth a second reading. Highly recommended. Mr. Dan Simmons's "Muse of Fire" is unforgettable.
-
Very good collection.
The term "new space opera" -- like other trendy genre labels of recent decades such as "cyberpunk" and "slipstream" -- seems all too vaguely defined. In this case perhaps it's little more than a marketing tag, or to be more generous, "what the editors think is cool this year." That's a quibble, I suppose, since it still resulted in a nice anthology, even if a number of the stories really didn't fit the editors' own description of "new space opera."
The only two stories I really didn't care for were those by Kage Baker and Robert Silverberg. I tried starting the Baker story twice and bounced off it both times, which surprised me since I always found her Company stories pretty readable. The Silverberg story felt like a work from the 50s where the aliens are just thinly-disguised non-Anglo ethnic stereotypes -- think those Chinese-sounding trade reps in the Star Wars movies for sad comparison. I can't imagine the editors would have considered publishing this if it hadn't been by a sf eminence grise like Silverberg.
On the other hand, I particularly liked Ian McDonald's "Vertandhi's Ring" (which takes place in a vivid post-human far future), Robert Reed's "Hatch" (set in a niche of the Marrow milieu), Paul McAuley's "Winning Peace," Greg Egan's "Glory," James Patrick Kelly's "Dividing the Sustain," Alastair Reynolds' "Minla's Flowers" (though the direction the plot took was fairly inevitable), Gregory Benford's "The Worm Turns" (felt like a first run at a future novel), Nancy Kress' "Art of War" (maybe was a little long for the central idea), and Dan Simmons' "Muse of Fire." The Kelly and Simmons stories were particularly original and vivid; Simmons's novella in particular had a haunting, gothic feel to it that shouldn't surprise anyone who read the Hyperion novels. -
Greg Egan is the hardest SF writter of all times and in this short novel is not less,he introduce advanced quantum physics comcepts as quantum Zeno effect and as ever extrapolates the most advanced physics known ,but rigurously and beliavly to astounding limits.
This narration, with a very fitted title , is about the possible evolution of advanced civilizations as Seekers is to say,that once reached material confort is aimed , witout go out its planet, to pure mathematics,music,art,literature and so on,or as Spreaders that search a way to stars and his efforts are aimed to pure and applied physics,applied mathematics,tecnology,engineering,esplotation of resources and conquering space.
In the novel this dicothomy is presented between the ancient civilization of the Niah and the new of Noudah. -
Stronger of the two. Go-to review is David's, below:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Standout for me, from memory:
“Who’s Afraid of Wolf 359?” by Ken Macleod. One of his "fast burn" stories, clever & fun. Online at
http://clarkesworldmagazine.com/macle...
I should reread it. OK, I did, in 2016, so not just yet. Shorts are good for rereading, because I forget then so fast.... -
I read a lot of short fiction in the SF and Fantasy genre, but I rarely read an entire anthology from cover-to-cover. This is one of those where my effort was rewarded; every story is worth checking out.
-
GR Personal Rating System:
★★★★★ 5 Stars ~ LOVED
★★★★☆ 4 Stars ~ ENJOYED
★★★☆☆ 3 Stars ~ LIKED
★★☆☆☆ 2 Stars ~ MEH
★☆☆☆☆ 1 Star ~ NOPE
Anthologies are such a mixed bag. 2.6 Star average.
This 24-hour audiobook collection was a beast to get through. I found a couple of authors I'd like to follow further, and a ton of authors that I'm turned off from. What is it with so many male authors using their stories as a license to write these masturbatory vignettes? It popped up so often enough that it's worth mentioning in relation to the entire compilation.
★★☆☆☆ SAVING TIAMAAT by Gwyneth Jones
The writing made a lot more sense once I switched from audio to text. A big part of that was that the narrator didn't seem to click with the material. Then again, I don't think I did either. It was a neat idea. Space cannibals and reality rewiring assassins should be awesome. But... Meh.
★☆☆☆☆ VERTHANDI’S RING by Ian McDonald
Okay, I like weird, challenging sci-fi: surreal, post-human, virtual reality matrices etc. Anything by Ted Chiang. Stories like The Quantum Thief, Annihilation, This Is How You Lose the Time War are exquisite and satisfying. I suspect the author was attempting to show off how weird they could be.
This one was creative and colorful, but the most exceptional part was The Reveal. Not enough for me.
★★★☆☆ HATCH by Robert Reed
The writing was good, the world was incredibly interesting although difficult to visualize. The humans/post humans/aliens were interesting too. But at the end I don't think I "got" it. Maybe I just needed more than a short story.
★★★☆☆ WINNING PEACE by Paul J. McAuley
I can't find my notes, but obviously I kind of liked it because I gave it 2.5 Stars.
★★★★★ GLORY by Greg Egan
Artifacts left by a previous civilization that survived for millions of years before mysteriously going extinct.. this leads to existential questions about what motivates a culture. There is a contrast between the ideas of The Hunters and The Seekers...
This was fantastic! It begins with a very complex and daring idea, I had to really concentrate to visualize this molecular needle probe that was crafted. My brain quivered a little bit under the weight of the ideas, but it was really cool. I always love a Sci-Fi story involving archaeologists or anthropologists and a good old mysterious artifact. The philosophical contrast between The Hunters and The Seekers motivations were incredibly appealing, and much more palatable than the dystopian galactic psychology of the Three Body Problem. To top it off, the ending was really satisfying too. I definitely want to read more by this author.
★★★★☆ MAELSTORM by Kage Baker
An embarrassingly rich eccentric on Mars wants to bring culture in the form of The Edgar Allan Poe Theater.
This was so lighthearted and fun, the perfect antidote to dark, serious, high stakes Sci-fi. And the narrator was great with all his melodramatic accents and voices.
★★☆☆☆ BLESSED BY AN ANGEL by Peter F. Hamilton
The debate between old fashioned humans and the higher synthetic mechanical organization.. and the lengths they go to to preserve and promote their culture.
This was a fairly straightforward story with a little bit of twist at the end. There were a couple interesting ideas, but there was also an uncomfortably explicit section which was strange and unnecessary. I expected better from this author.
★★☆☆☆ WHO’S AFRAID OF WOLF 359? by Ken Macleod
A narrator with unreliable memories goes to a doomed planet..
A couple really neat ideas, especially their method of travel. But I really must have been missing something, perhaps some cultural references that I'm ignorant of. This was nominated for the Hugo so clearly there is some depth here that missed me.
★★★★☆ THE VALLEY OF THE GARDENS by Tony Daniel
A wall divides a verdant land from a desert wild and corrupted with mad sentient nanotech left over from a previous war... And a love story.
There were so many ideas in this that I loved! The setting, the technology, the history was fantastic. There was one scene that was really off-putting, a sex scene obviously written by a man that crossed over into gross - and didn't even fit with the rest of the story. It kept it from being a five-star for me.
★★★☆☆ DIVIDING THE SUSTAIN by James Patrick Kelly
A courier traveling to a colony planet under false pretenses, decides to become biologically gay in order to become closer to the woman he has fallen madly in love with. And then it gets weirder from there.
A truly bizarre love story. I absolutely adored that the science in this culture had advanced to the point that people could freely alter their genetic code in order to modify their bodies and behaviors. At the same time, that comes up hard against cherished ideas about our essential identity. I was totally disconcerted that the story starts off with a man proclaiming that he decided to become homosexual. I think that could be downright offensive to some people, and it gave me a lot to think about. I got to give the author credit for going bold.
★★★★☆ MINLA’S FLOWERS by Alastair Reynolds
A traveler tries his best to help a doomed planet...
This was really well written, with clear grief and frustration at the inevitability of how people vie for power, even when there are more important things to be done. This story also reminded me of some of the ideas and themes in The Three Body Problem, on a much smaller scale, and with a more effective emotional impact.
SPLINTERS OF GLASS by Mary Rosenblum
★★★★☆ A man on the run with stolen biotech, and the woman who had been looking for him for 10 years.
What a wonderful world of ice and so-called mosses that are quite a lot like mycelium, the planet has a type of sentence. The setting was so vividly pretty it reminded me of my favorite video game landscapes. The relationship was pretty sweet too.
REMEMBRANCE by Stephen Baxter
★★☆☆☆ An invasion of our planet by an alien aquatic life form.
An interesting depiction of colonization and escalation of aggression. In this case, humans fought back against the subjugation by poisoning the water; the aliens fought back by freezing the entire planet hardcore for a year, which led to deep psychological trauma of the population, which led to the aliens doing a memory wipe... Then at the end there was some kind of time-traveling enemy? This was really strange; I listened to it twice and still wasn't clear on that ending.
THE EMPEROR AND THE MAULA by Robert Silverberg
★★☆☆☆ A sci-fi retelling where a criminal is permitted to delay their execution with storytelling cliffhangers... In this version the emperor is an alien and the storyteller is a contemptible human.
This has an aggressive message about conquerors and colonialism. It was pretty straightforward, with a few interesting spots. Overall I didn't really like it and it didn't work for me. It wasn't that I was squicked out about the alien / human romance, it just wasn't imaginative enough. It also kind of trailed off at the end.
THE WORM TURNS by Greg Benford
★☆☆☆☆ Can't give an overview because I DNF'd pretty quick.
Vulgar and annoying - she referred to herself as getting turned on / getting moist at least twice within the first 15 minutes. It was inelegant and unearned. And the rest of the story wasn't interesting enough to continue. In a short story, that was plenty of time to produce interest!
SEND THEM FLOWERS by Walter Jon Williams
★☆☆☆☆ Not worth even a mini synopsis.
This one wasn't interesting either. Less than 2 minutes in and we're already partying and looking for sex. I didn't like the tone or the setting. Sigh. Boring. Not for me.
ART OF WAR by Nancy Kress
★★★★☆ The story revolves around reclaiming stolen human art from an alien civilization. The title was darn clever, the Art Of War!
Clever in light of this alien society that has cycles of aggression, war, and acquisition, followed by a period of contemplation and artistic atonement. And the acquisition of their enemy's art is a critical component of their war strategy...
Our main character has some form of extreme anxiety that causes seizures. He has a fantastic marriage that is beautifully supportive. In contrast, he has an extremely contentious relationship with his mother who considers him a coward. Ended up not liking his interaction with his mom because she was so overwrought and closed-minded as to be unbelievable. Knocked a star off. Still a refreshing story in this collection
MUSE OF FIRE by Dan Simmons
★☆☆☆☆ In this story, space travel has a central intelligence running the operations of the ship, but it's not an AI. It's a person, in stasis, referred to as the Muse...
Cheese krispies! The obsession with women's bodies was so tedious. Continual descriptions of the Muse being naked, young with lots of details. There was all this sex to kick off the story, which I didn't have a problem with, but it wasn't interesting. Why wasn't this better? This story could have come close to three stars if it hadn't had so many annoying sexist tropes - the author just unthinkingly prioritized male thinking, male perspectives, men speaking for the entire crew etc. And the aforementioned male gaze.
What a shame that the penultimate book in this collection was such a disappointment. This is Dan Simmons. I expected so much better from this author! This really read like vintage sci-fi, which I was not expecting to show up in a contemporary collection. And it was utterly forgettable. Despite the text lovingly conveying the color of her nipples. *rolls eyes*
***
GR Personal Rating System:
★★★★★ 5 Stars ~ LOVED
★★★★☆ 4 Stars ~ ENJOYED
★★★☆☆ 3 Stars ~ LIKED
★★☆☆☆ 2 Stars ~ MEH
★☆☆☆☆ 1 Star ~ NOPE -
One of the best all sci-fi original anthology I have read.
Somehow it happened that Strahan & Dozois chose a large list of authors which I like and follow, and very strong stories from them: McAuley, Hamilton, Reynolds, Baxter, Silverberg, Simmons.
Remaining stories are above average as well, there are no fillers here. -
01 The New Space Opera (anthology)
Average Rating: 60/18 = 3.33 Stars
My favorite story was by Alastair Reynolds called Minla's Flowers - 4.5 Stars
My least favorite stories were by Gwyneth Jones called Saving Tiamaat AND James Patrick Kelly called Dividing the Sustain. BOTH were rated at 2.5 Stars.
Short stories are using rated lower for me, since I really do not enjoy this medium. I enjoy long form story telling...500 plus pages and long standing series...so that we can live in this world for a LONG time and truly get to know the characters...where they almost become family.
In short stories, you are dropped into a story in the middle and you only get a few scenes. It really is a frustrating experience for me.
The rating will obviously differ with each person. There are not ANY in this anthology that is horrible.
01: Gwyneth Jones: "Saving Tiamaat"
- 2.5 Stars - just wasn't that interested.
02: Ian McDonald: "Verthandi's Ring"
- 3 Stars - a little too loopy for me.
03: Robert Reed: "Hatch"
- 3.5 Stars
04: Paul J. McAuley: "Winning Peace"
- 3 Stars
05: Greg Egan: "Glory"
- 3.5 Stars
06: Kage Baker: "Maelstrom"
- 3.5 Stars
07: Peter F. Hamilton: "Blessed by an Angel"
- 3.5 Stars
08: Ken MacLeod: "Who's Afraid of Wolf 359?"
- 3.5 Stars
09: Tony Daniel: "The Valley of the Gardens"
- 3.5 Stars
10: James Patrick Kelly: "Dividing the Sustain"
- 2.5 Stars
11: Alastair Reynolds: "Minla's Flowers"
- 4.5 Stars 👆
12: Mary Rosenblum: "Splinters of Glass"
- 3 Stars
13: Stephen Baxter: "Remembrance"
- 3 Stars
14: Robert Silverberg: "The Emperor and the Maula"
- 3.5 Stars
15: Gregory Benford: "The Worm Turns"
- 3 Stars
16: Walter Jon Williams: "Send Them Flowers"
- 3.5 Stars
17: Nancy Kress: "Art of War"
- 4 Stars
18: Dan Simmons: "Muse of Fire"
- 3.5 Stars -
VERDICT: Average ~ 3.2 suns (mostly goodthink).
REVIEW: Not all tales within are "space opera," in my opinion. Not a keeper, but good enough to recommend.
BREAKDOWN: -
The whole thing gets just barely 3 stars out of 5. There were some great stories and some not so great ones; there were also some great narrators and some not so great ones. The following is more quick notes (some including spoilers) than actual reviews of most of the stories, so I'm putting it under a spoiler tag. I have rated each story on its own, and averaged those to get the book rating.
-
This is an original anthology. All the stories were published in 2007. As it says, this is THE NEW SPACE OPERA, not the old sort. The old sort being that which was published in the pulp magazines of the 1950s. It's unclear when the NEW began. In 2008, the next year, Jeff VanderMeer would publish The New Weird, and there are probably other NEW X that I'm aware of. I personally consider very little of this to agree with what I feel space opera to be, but that's fine. The editors say at one point that it's "wide-screen, high-bit-rate, action packed qualities typical of the form". I'm not sure what that means, but I don't think it applies to quite a few of the stories here either. Regardless of semantics and commonalities, there's still some enjoyable stories in here.
Saving Tiamaat - Gwyneth Jones [Buonaratti Transit]
The Interstellar Diaspora has discovered a new planet of sentient bipeds and now seeks to civilize them. Their planet has been ravaged by ethnic civil war, as the dominant ethnicity literally cannibalizes everyone else. Thus, The Interstellar Disapora sends representatives who believe that We Can Fix Them.
Meh
Verthandi's Ring - Ian McDonald
Two universal civilizations decide that there can only be one civilization to exist throughout the multiverse. The scale was too immense for me to take seriously. Any sense of wonder I may have had was obliterated by my constant eye rolling. Early on a single ship destroys 80k planets which kills 20 trillion sentients with a single brilliant strategic attack. Maybe some can read that and be utterly amazed, but when I read it I think, "oh, ok, that's a lot, huh."
Meh
Hatch - Robert Reed [The Great Ship Universe]
I've read at least a few of Reed's Great Ship short fiction, but I've never been interested enough to commit to the novels. Their scale is immense and the characters are functionally immortal superbeings, but it's never quite worked for me. In this one a raider seeks fortune by harvesting rare materials from a swarm of billions of insect-like biological robots, or something like that. There's a lot of speculation about the greater series and talk about plans that stretch into the millennia, to say the least.
Ok
Winning Peace - Paul J. McAuley [Jackaroo]
His side, the Alliance, lost the war against the Collective, and as a prisoner of war he's sold into slavery from one slaver to another. The current slaver sends him off on a suicide mission to a brown dwarf to retrieve what may be a elder culture artifact. It's also his chance to escape.
Ok
Glory - Greg Egan
Researchers travel to a relatively undeveloped planet to study the artifacts of an ancient civilization before the contemporary culture destroys everything because they revere only war and expansion.
Enjoyable
Maelstrom - Kage Baker [Mars]
An eccentric man living on Mars becomes extremely wealthy due to the generosity of his patron. He decides to devote his life and wealth to adapting old stories, especially Edgar Allen Poe, into theatrical plays. He assembles a motely crew, including two z-list actors from Earth and hopes for the best. One of those actors insists on doing Spongebob Squarepants impressions in a Poe story. Both popular culture and old classics are mocked. It's a far funnier story than I would have expected and by the end I was chuckling quite a bit.
Enjoyable
Blessed by an Angel - Peter F. Hamilton [Commonwealth Universe]
A pregnant woman is abducted to test whether she's been infected by a cultural parasite. Their foes work their ways by corrupting children. Most of the time is spent arguing about politics. I may not agree, but it was interesting to read about. It was moderately reminiscent of the relationship between Demarchists and Conjoiners in Alastair Reynold's Revelation Space series.
Ok
Who's Afraid of Wolf 359? - Ken Macleod
A man has committed adultery, which is illegal, with a member of the tycoon's harem. He's sentenced to a suicide mission of going to a planet where civilization has collapsed and report back his findings. The story seems to be a set-up for the punchline ending, which made me groan.
Blah
The Valley of the Gardens - Tony Daniel
The farm posts and fencing had stood for 50,000 years, their code preventing the spread of the desert into the pastures. All the soil and everything else was programmed. He was only 1,500 years old, still centuries away from truly being an adult. One day he meets a woman and falls in love, but she was of the desert and he of the pasture. They could neither cross over, but they had width of the fence to express their love. SUDDEN 50K YEARS FLASHBACK TO INTERGALATIC SPACE BATTLES AGAINST AN EXTRADIMENSIONAL LOVECRAFTIAN BEING WHOSE UNLIMTED TENTACLES CAN APPEAR ANYWHERE AT ANY TIME IN THE UNIVERSE. Return to the present and conclusion.
Ok
Dividing the Sustain - James Patrick Kelly
This story literally seems like it's almost all talking in a few different rooms, except for the sex, which I found nice in its own way. A courier has deceived his way onto a vessel filled with Consensualist heading to their homeworld. They don't make any decisions unless a consensus is reached. The courier feels like he's going to die if he has to stay with his pod so he schemes to leave them and and live with the pregnant ex-wife of the captain, with whom he's infatuated. I enjoyed the strange transgressive twist.
Enjoyable
Minla's Flowers - Alastair Reynolds [Merlin]
A reluctant uplift/savior story where a planet's people must use science to escape from an upcoming calamity that will doom their planet. Knowledge without wisdom, let alone empathy, may create monsters.
Enjoyable
Splinters of Glass - Mary Rosenblum
A man leaves his lover's house and sees his ex-lover who believes that he's been dead for ten years. Memories rush back. There's a lot of motorized snowboarding scenes, including fight scenes, which were rather neat. It takes places on Europa, which is now livable, but still entirely ice. There's silly backstory stuff and I'm conflicted about it ended, but overall I enjoyed it.
Enjoyable
Rememberance - Stephen Baxter [Xelee]
Only one person, The Rememberer, still remembers the true past regarding the Squeem invasion and the atrocity they committed upon the Earth, but he slips up and is arrested. And so, he begins the tale that has been passed down for centuries.
Ok
The Emperor and the Maula - Robert Silverberg
This basis for this story's structure seems to be 1,001 Nights. A woman meets the emperor of the alien species who has conquered Earth and tells him stories and although she's meant to be executed, it keeps being delayed day after day, because the emperor must hear another story from her. It's fine, but I was never engaged with it.
Meh
The Worm Turns - Gregory Benford [Worm]
A woman is deeply in debt, but she's offered a suicide mission to clear all of it, which involves a wormhole. I didn't think the humor went well, especially the sex humor, and I thought it was an awkward story with a style that I disliked. I've read over a dozen short fiction stories from Benford, some of which I've quite enjoyed, and as far as I can remember this is the one I've liked the least by far. Disappointing.
Blah
Send Them Flowers - Walter Jon Williams
Two space drifters, one a relatively average guy, and the other an improbably successful seducer of women are on the run due to the latter's cuckoldry and theft. They travel through the multiverses until they run out of food and have to dock. They have a choice of spending their remaining money on food or partying. They choose the latter, getting drunk, high, and whoring. The average guy thinks he needs to turn his life around, but change is hard.
Enjoyable
Art of War - Nancy Kress
A captain is tasked with assessing and recovering the art looted by the Tali, with whom they are at war. There's one terrible problem though, the general is his mother, and they have a terrible relationship. So terrible that when he stresses out about her he goes hysterical, seizes, and passes out. More than anything else this story is about his relationship with her. The ending is atrocious and petty. I don't know why Kress wrote this story, let alone why it was accepted, but it's awful, annoying, and fixated. As with the Benford story, I've read more than a dozen stories from her, but this surely has to be the worst.
Blah
Muse of Fire - Dan Simmons
A spacefaring troupe of Shakespearean performers have to put upon plays for ever increasingly powerful beings, which have enslaved humanity, until at least they play for the one who may be the the most powerful of all. It's infused from start to finish with Shakespeare. There's some sexism, racism, and sex scenes, one with a girl who was "very young but old enough for me not to feel too guilty" which is stated to be the usual for the twenty year protagonist. I couldn't go along with the silliness this time.
Meh -
Rating for each story:
***** Saving Tiamaat • (2007) • shortstory by Gwyneth Jones
***** Verthandi's Ring • (2007) • shortstory by Ian McDonald
***** Hatch • [The Great Ship Universe] • (2007) • shortstory by Robert Reed
*** Winning Peace • (2007) • novelette by Paul J. McAuley
*** Glory • (2007) • novelette by Greg Egan
** Maelstrom • (2007) • novelette by Kage Baker
***** Blessed by an Angel • (2007) • shortstory by Peter F. Hamilton
*** Who's Afraid of Wolf 359? • shortstory by Ken MacLeod
**** * The Valley of the Gardens • (2007) • novelette by Tony Daniel
*** Dividing the Sustain • (2007) • novelette by James Patrick Kelly
**** Minla's Flowers • [Merlin [4] • 2] • (2007) • novella by Alastair Reynolds
FAVORITE STORY: ***** Splinters of Glass • (2007) • novelette by Mary Rosenblum
***** Remembrance • (2007) • shortstory by Stephen Baxter
*** The Emperor and the Maula • (2007) • novelette by Robert Silverberg
**** The Worm Turns • (2007) • shortstory by Gregory Benford
***** Send Them Flowers • (2007) • novelette by Walter Jon Williams
***** Art of War • shortstory by Nancy Kress
**** Muse of Fire • (2007) • novella by Dan Simmons -
Evidently the New space opera is not much to my taste, since it seemingly involves a lot more space than opera these days (notwithstanding the last story, by Dan Simmons, which is about half Shakespeare.) Galactic empires are only fun if you have Han and Luke, R2 and Chewy, an Ewok or two - heroes, that is, with something to fight for. Otherwise it's all Rosencrantz and Guildenstern waiting for Godot, pointless and not even tragic.
But I loved the Kage Baker story. -
There are good stories here, and there are great stories here.
My favorites:
The Muse of Fire by Dan Simmons - A Shakespearean acting troupe travels the galaxy.
Minla's Flowers by Alastair Reynolds - A man tries to save a planet, but they don't listen.
Remembrance by Stephen Baxter - Are there some things better left forgotten?
The Emperor and the Maula by Robert Silverberg - 1001 Nights in space.
Art of War by Nancy Kress - Someone has mommy issues.
I would listen to these again. -
THE NEW SPACE OPERA IS RATED 81%
18 STORIES : 2 GREAT / 9 GOOD / 7 AVERAGE / 0 POOR / 0 DNF
I was halfway through this anthology before I realized that it was an original anthology. Before that I’d assume that it was a themed anthology of modern Space Opera similar to The 2020 Look at Space Opera Book, edited by Allan Kaster (85% Positive.)
Gardner Dozois and Jonathan Strahan have certainly assembled a list of excellent writers, even if the stories in this collection are not their best work. The tales are full of wild galaxy-expanding baroque speculation and it is sometimes hard to find anything firm to ground yourself. Adventure abounds, as if the authors really wanted to make this into blockbuster movies.
At 81% Positive, with no Poor or DNF stories, it is worth reading. Two stories really stood out:
“Minla's Flowers” • (2007) • novella by Alastair Reynolds. An adventurer and his AI spaceship land on a planet at war, but needs to come together to evacuate. He befriends a young girl who’s life will be of great importance to the mission. In an out of cryogenic sleep, the protagonist sees the rapid transformation of the society as they try to get unified and able to escape. This is brilliant in its execution of its concept and full of power human characters. A superb novella.
“Muse of Fire” • (2007) • novella by Dan Simmons
A troupe of intergalactic Shakespearean actors performs for alien races that are progressively more awe-inspiring and strange. They may be performing for humanity’s very survival. This is a story that slowly expands from small conversations to the most majestic possible scale, while never losing the humanity of its characters. I loved this.
***
THE NEW SPACE OPERA IS RATED 81%
18 STORIES : 2 GREAT / 9 GOOD / 7 AVERAGE / 0 POOR / 0 DNF
Saving Tiamaat • short story by Gwyneth Jones
Good. A diplomat’s biases get in the way of negotiations between two factions on a primitive planet.
Verthandi's Ring • short story by Ian McDonald
Good. Wildly inventive story of war across galaxies with trillions dead and characters that basically live forever. Complicated to follow and maybe not entirely worth it.
Hatch • (2007) • short story by Robert Reed
Average. A dense baroque tale of people that live on the outside of a Jupiter-sized Great Ship.
Winning Peace • (2007) • novelette by Paul J. McAuley
Good. A fun adventure yarn about an indentured pilot and his owner/boss in a post-war world involving an artifact from a ancient culture.
Glory • (2007) novelette by Greg Egan
Good. Provincial squabbles get in the way of exploration of an ancient civilization’s mathematic remnants.
Maelstrom • (2007) • novelette by Kage Baker
Average. A quirk comedic story of a man who puts on a theater performance on Poe’s “Descent into the Maelstrom” for a rough planet.
Blessed by an Angel • (2007) • short story by Peter F. Hamilton
Average. Higher beings infiltrate a world and attempt to infiltrate it by seducing a couple. Over complex backstory for a very slight story.
Who's Afraid of Wolf 359? • (2007) short story by Ken MacLeod
Average. Man offends the Tychoon on a space station and is sent to investigate the problems on Wolf 359.
The Valley of the Gardens • (2007) • novelette by Tony Daniel
Good. Two parallel love stories combine with a brutal war fought against a collective consciousness. Good characters and great prose, but a ending that just keeps it out of greatness.
Dividing the Sustain • (2007) novelette by James Patrick Kelly
Average. On a large colony ship, individuals must ‘recast’ themselves to keep happy and sane. One man decides to recast as gay and finds himself drawn into intrigue around the Captain and his wife.
Minla's Flowers • (2007) • novella by Alastair Reynolds
Great. An adventurer and his AI spaceship land on a planet at war, but needs to come together to evacuate. He befriends a young girl who’s life will be of great importance to the mission. In an out of cryogenic sleep, the protagonist sees the rapid transformation of the society as they try to get unified and able to escape.
Splinters of Glass • (2007) novelette by Mary Rosenblum
Good. On the wild icy frontier of Europa, a man is hiding out from a large corporation. Then a former lover comes looking for them and they have to run.
Remembrance • (2007) • short story by Stephen Baxter
Good. A rememberer recounts the history of earth’s conquering and subjugation by an aquatic race.
The Emperor and the Maula • (2007) novelette by Robert Silverberg
Average. A Sci-Fi reworking of the story of Scheherazade.
The Worm Turns • (2007) • short story by Gregory Benford
Good. Wild adventure inside a wormhole with aliens. Dense science talk.
Send Them Flowers • (2007) • novelette by Walter Jon Williams
Good. A fun romp as a trader and a womanizer try to stay just ahead of the people they’ve cheated and husbands who’s wives they’ve seduced.
Art of War • (2007) short story by Nancy Kress
Good. A military art historian with seizures and painful family issues is sent to catalogue the human art stolen by an alien race in a war.
Muse of Fire • (2007) • novella by Dan Simmons
Great. A troupe of intergalactic Shakespearean actors performs for alien races that are progressively more awe-inspiring and strange. They may be performing for humanity’s very survival. -
An excellent collection of SF short stories. Not all of them are space opera in the classic sense of the term, but since they are all good that will trouble only the pedants among us. If you are looking for new authors to read (or more from authors you already know you like), this is a good resource.
-
A través de este libro me he dado cuenta que mi subgénero favorito sigue vigente y vibrante, pero también he notado algo curioso, el ciberpunk, y la hard scifi, se han fundido con la Space Opera, quiero decir, en estas historias, los autores asumen que el lector ya entiende lo que es un mundo virtual, asumen que el lector ya comprende lo que son nanites (al punto de darles otro nombre y ni siquiera detenerse a explicarlos) y entonces utilizan esos elementos en los argumentos clásicos del viaje interestelar, la guerra a escala galáctica y la civilización Imperial antigua e inmensa...
El primer relato Saving Tiamaat de
Gwyneth Jones es una curiosa historia de diplomacia interestelar que resume muy bien lo que les comentaba más arriba; en esta historia la autora utiliza mundos virtuales, seudo máquinas del tiempo, poderes psíquicos, etc. y de paso agrega los elementos clásicos de la Space Opera, civilizaciones alienígenas, federaciones interestelares, etc.
Por supuesto es un relato asombroso, pero difícil. Me parece muy interesante de parte de los editores utilizar este relato para comenzar, es como una sacudida, por lo menos lo fue para mi, me sorprendió darme cuenta en lo que se ha convertido la Space Opera hoy en día. Y la autora hace un gran trabajo fusionando todos esos elementos; por otro lado también es apabullante, no me imagino cómo se sentiría alguien que esté comenzando a leer ciencia ficción con un relato como este, hay tantos conceptos aquí, que alguien que no esté acostumbrado simplemente pensara que la historia no tiene ni pies ni cabeza; para que la escritora se anime a narrar una historia tan compleja quiere decir que tiene una confianza enorme en la inteligencia de sus lectores, cosa que habla muy bien de estos.
Lo curioso es que no es la única historia con estas características.
Vertandi´s Ring de
Ian McDonald es una historia ligeramente más tradicional aunque no por ello menos desafiante para el lector, el autor nos cuenta una historia clásica de guerra intergaláctica, pero entonces toma cosas como por ejemplo las esferas de Dyson, los ascensores orbitales, y la física contemporánea y lo mezcla todo para crear una gran historia, sin embargo recordemos que años atrás, los conceptos de esferas de Dyson o ascensores orbitales daban para escribir novelas completas, pero parece que hoy en día el lector de ciencia ficción está tan acostumbrado a estos conceptos que el autor se puede dar el lujo de ponerlos todos juntos en un relato. Es decir que las ideas que hace unos años nos asombraban y nos dejaban maravillados, son utilizados ahora como moneda común.
The Hatch por
Robert Reed Es una historia que está contenida dentro de un universo literario más amplio, los protagonistas viajan en una nave espacial del tamaño de Júpiter, sin embargo gracias a la introducción de los editores y las buenas artes del escritor uno no necesita conocer todo el background de la historia para entenderla, pero imagino que se disfrutaría más. En la historia, el autor narra como tras una guerra en el interior de la nave algunos supervivientes consiguen formar una sociedad en el exterior de la misma, nuevamente nos encontramos con un argumento clásico, pero aumentado y detallado a niveles que no habíamos visto antes. Por ejemplo los habitantes de esta ciudad, son inmortales y no se preocupan mucho de sus salud, al menos en este caso el autor se detiene a explicar como y por que de esto aunque brevemente. Pero también lanza casi sin darse cuenta otro montón de conceptos como motores de fusión, bioquímica, mecánica del caos, IA, etc. Sin detenerse a explicar nada.
La historia es entretenida, aunque deja al lector como suspendido en el aire al final; pero ciertamente la historia no es recomendable para aquellos lectores que no tengan una enorme experiencia con la CF detrás de ellos.
Winning Peace por
Paul J. McAuley es de las pocas historias que podría ser entendidas por un novato, aunque el autor usa algunos conceptos dificiles, no es nada que no pueda entender una persona que se siente a ver el Discovery channel regularmente (como se nota que esta reseña es vieja). La historia narra de un futuro en donde la humanidad se ha dividido entre esclavistas y no esclavistas y las dificultades de un esclavo que intenta escapar de su situación, el autor cuenta la historia de forma interesante y con bastante acción.
Glory de
Greg Egan quien es un reconocido autor cuyo estilo conocemos muy bien; Egan como los autores de antes de la vieja Space Opera si se detiene a tomar al lector de la mano y detallar las ideas, la historia inicia con una larga perorata sobre materia, antimateria y relativismo, pero por lo menos el autor se detiene a explicarla, luego utiliza nuevos conceptos como nanomáquinas y nanoconstrucción, que son difíciles para un novato, pero también se detiene a explicarlos. Luego la historia va revelando los temas tradicionales de Egan, la conciencia, el honor, la búsqueda del conocimiento, etc.
Maelstrom por
Kage Baker es una de dos curiosas historias sobre el Teatro, algo tan tradicional y tan humano como el teatro ¿que cabida tiene en una recopilación de relatos sobre la nueva Space Opera? ah pues que lo hacen en Marte. Es decir que la autora nos narra no de la exploración de Marte, ni de la terraformación del planeta, no, eso es historia vieja que ha sido narrado por miles de autores antes, la escritora en cambio elige narrarnos las dificultades de la primera compañía de teatro marciana y sus dificultades para poner ante el público su primera obra, nada más y nada menos que "A Descent in to the Maelstrom" por Edgar Alan Poe (me acordé de crónicas marcianas), genial, simplemente genial y es una demostración de lo mucho que ha cambiado el subgénero.
Blessed by an Angel de
Peter F. Hamilton no tiene ninguna relación con la conocida serie de televisión; es sin embargo otra de esas historias de las que les hablé antes en donde el autor combina los elementos clásicos y conocidos de la Space Opera y los mezcla (muy eficientemente) con otros elementos como por ejemplo cibernética, genética, mundos virtuales, nanotecnologías, etc. Sin embargo el autor no lanza todo aquello sobre el lector de una vez, por el contrario se toma su tiempo para explicar, pero teniendo tantos conceptos juntos me parece que tampoco sería una historia amistosa con el lector novato. Por la misma naturaleza de la historia creo que les dañaría la sorpresa si les cuento mucho del argumento, digamos simplemente que es fascinante.
Who's Afraido of Wolf 359? de
Ken MacLeod, es una muy buena historia que narra un muy curioso experimento social que nuestro protagonista altera radicalmente. Al igual que en muchas de las historias del libro, el autor asume que el lector conoce cómo funciona la nanotecnología y el
3D Printing excelente historia para los veteranos de la CF aunque difícil para los recién llegados.
The Valley of the Gardens por
Tony Daniel es una historia que siempre recordaré con cariño, me recordó al estilo de Sturgeon no sé por que, es narrada en dos tiempos.
En primer lugar un tiempo en donde el planeta es un hermoso jardín de imposibles habilidades y también un pasado en donde ese mismo planeta se libra una terrible batalla por el futuro de la humanidad. Bellamente contada la historia no es fácil, sin embargo pienso que es posible leerla y disfrutarla sin un enorme background en CF.
Dividing the Sustain de
James Patrick Kelley, si les digo que es una historia un tanto detectivesca que implica un divorcio y una pelea sobre los bienes de fortuna de la familia, podría parecer que la historia es bastante corriente, pero que tal si metemos en la ecuación, la inmortalidad, un viaje a velocidades relativistas, la clonación y la alteración de la conciencia? curiosamente el autor consigue que todo esto resulte hasta gracioso, pero muy real, por que efectivamente los humanos terminamos siendo hasta ridículos en los usos que le damos a nuestras tecnologías.
Minla's Flowers de
Alastair Reynolds, resultó ser lamentablemente la historia que me gustó menos; puedo decir que incluso odié a uno de los personajes, la historia está bien escrita, no me mal interpreten, y es muy interesante, posee una escala de dimensiones épicas. Sin embargo es en los personajes y en sus reacciones en donde falla la historia.
Me parece haber leído en alguna parte o quizá es tan solo idea mía, que cuando se trata de un historia corta, uno debe utilizar personajes fuertes, personajes de carácter, decididos, con un propósito, o, pienso yo, por lo menos personajes muy arquetípicos, de lo contrario el lector no será capaz de comprender en tan pocas páginas la complejidad de la mente del personaje.
Ese debe ser el problema aquí, el autor en esta ocasión se decide por un personaje indeciso ambivalente quien retrasa por décadas su búsqueda que podría salvar no a la humanidad si no la civilización galáctica para salvar a la gente de un planeta, no solo eso si no que entonces decide hacerlo de la peor manera posible y todo en medio de la peor indecisión que haya visto.
Splinters of Glass por
Mary Rosenblum, me recordó mucho ha aquellas viejas historias de Asimov en donde el Buen Doctor se empeñaba en describir las civilizaciones extraterrestres que podrían habitar el sistema solar, en aquella época nuestro conocimiento de nuestro propio sistema solar era escaso, sin embargo Asimov se las ingeniaba para inventarse sugerentes formas de vida adaptadas a las extrañas condiciones de los planetas, igualmente en esta historia la Rosenblum nos describe el futuro de Europa, no el viejo continente si no la luna de Jupiter, allí la autora nos narra, de como los humanos han traído su ciencia y su civilización y explotan los ricos recursos biológicos del satélite, mezclando a la vez una interesante historia llena de acción y romance.
Remembrance de
Stephen Baxter, se incluye cerca del principio de la serie de Xeelee sobre la que el autor ha escrito con frecuencia. En esta historia de esclavitud y de liberación, de actos terribles y dolorosos, de recuerdos y de olvidos, la historia lo deja pensando a uno si las acciones de los protagonistas son las correctas o no, pienso que tal vez se haga necesario conocer la serie mejor para llegar a una decisión.
The Emperor and the Maula por
Robert Silverberg, Me sorprendí bastante de encontrar a este Señor de la ciencia ficción en este volumen pues no pensé que siguiera escribiendo, con sus clásicos personajes fuertes y voluntariosos, este maestro de la ciencia ficción no nos falla en esta ocasión, tomemos por ejemplo:
"Meanwhile here I am- Earthborn woman, a mere barbaric maula, geting deeper into Imperial Space with each passing light second. I should be trembling with fear, I suppouse.
No. Let the Emperor tremble. Laylah is here!"
La historia es una maravillosa modernización del mito de Sherezade.
The Worm Turns de
Gregory Benford, otra interesante historia de este grande de la Ciencia Ficción, el autor nos narra la historia del casi accidental primer viaje interestelar de la humanidad de forma muy interesante, en esta ocasión el autor nos ahorra los clásicos conflictos familiares que plagan sus historias y se decide por un personaje femenino que disfruta su sexualidad muy sanamente (cuando puede).
Send Them Flowers por
Walter Jon Williams, es una fantástica historia de un capitán y su amigo, un don Juan, quienes viajan por el multiverso metiendose en miles de problemas como por ejemplo enamorar a las hermosas herederas (unas preciosas ancianas de más de 200 años) de casas comerciales que controlan diferentes universos gracias a su perfecta genética.
Nuevamente una historia excelente para el aficionado pero mortal para el profano.
Art of War de
Nancy Kress es una historia muy femenina, aunque curiosamente el protagonista es masculino, sin embargo la fuerza de la historia esta puesta en los sentimientos, en la confianza, en el amor, en la criatura humana con sus debilidades y fortalezas. Y aunque la autora hace abundante uso de los elementos de la Ciencia Ficción y de la Space Opera, el peso de la historia no está allí si no en el carácter de los personajes.
Muse of Fire de
Dan Simmons, evidentemente Simmons es uno de los grandes de la Space Opera actual pero, evidentemente también, no es mi estilo y esta historia es la prueba. Si fue escrita antes de Hyperión, entonces evidentemente es una suerte de resumen, de preludio de los temas que veríamos desarrollados con mucho más detalle posteriormente en Hyerión, si fue escrito después entonces tendré que decir que es bastante monotemático, la historia narra las aventuras de otra compañía de teatro (con tal que no se convierta en otro subgénero) que viaja a través de las estrellas interpretando las obras de Shakespeare, y quienes súbitamente descubren que su arte es mucho más importante de lo que ellos pensaban, solo puedo decir que, me acordé tanto de John Lennon y los Beatles...
Será que la ficción de Simmons es así y el universo gira en torno a los sentimientos y acciones humanas, a mi simplemente no me cabe en la cabeza, será muy literario y será muy artístico y todo lo que quieran, pero no es mi estilo, no es lo que estoy buscando cuando me siento a leer una Space Opera.
Un detalle que me parece importante destacar es que a través de todo el conjunto de historias uno se da cuenta que los autores exponen diferentes puntos de vista, pero en su mayoría son positivos, por ejemplo encontré varias historias en donde los humanos se habían unido felizmente a una federación interestelar, o visitaban pacíficamente a otras especies, etc.
Pienso que esa visión positiva del futuro es clásica de la Space Opera y se ve que estos autores también lo sienten así.
Para finalizar debo decir que el libro es una joya, los cuentos, la elección de los autores, y hasta el orden en que los pusieron en el libro es toda una obra de arte que merece ser leída.
Como dije muchas veces, es un libro maravilloso para el conocedor, el fanático de la ciencia ficción y aún más el aficionado de la Space Opera se sentirá maravillado y feliz, sin embargo para alguien que está comenzando en el género sería mejor un Asimov o un Vance.
Vía:
La Cueva del Lobo -
You may look at this and wonder what is the "new space opera"?
Paul McAuley once did a great job of explaining it: "Like the old space opera of E.E. "Doc" Smith, Edmund Hamilton, and a host of unsung pulp writers, the New Space Opera sets its stories against vast backdrops of both time and space, and its characters are often engaged in superhuman efforts on which the fate of humanity is hung. But the new stuff is also closely engaged with hard science (from quantum physics and cosmology to evolutionary biology, bioengineering, and cybernetics) and asks tough questions (Who are we? Why are we here? Where are we going?) about humanity's place in a hostile universe. Its stories are informed by a sense of deep and often secret histories imperfectly understood and closely associated with cosmological mysteries, and are played out against a culturally rich patchwork of governments, economies, alliances, and alien species rather than the monolithic empires of old."
I've devoured hundreds and hundreds of books while on this rock and I've learned I clearly love one specific genre more than others. I love science fiction because it often takes me further than I'll probably ever go. More specifically, I love stories that often get labeled 'the new space opera' and typically fit the profile of what McAuley is talking about. Science fiction in its very essence is political and often presses some of the most progressive questions and ideas into our culture. That's why I loved this collection of short stories. The major standouts are Hatch by Reed, Glory by Egan, Minla's Flowers by Alastair Reynolds, Remembrance by Baxter, and Muse of Fire by Simmons. This is a great audiobook. It caused me to buy several books by the contributors!
1 • Introduction (The New Space Opera) • (2007) • essay by Gardner Dozois and Jonathan Strahan
Great introduction. I really enjoyed the history of this sub-genre of sci-fi.
6 • Saving Tiamaat • (2007) • shortstory by Gwyneth Jones
Saving Tiamaat - This was a fun story that’s definitely up my alley, alien cultures, galactic diplomacy, loved it. 3.5/5
24 • Verthandi's Ring • (2007) • shortstory by Ian McDonald
Verthandi’s Ring - I love Ian McDonald as a writer but this story was a little weird. Good but still weird. 2.5/5"
39 • Hatch • [The Great Ship Universe] • (2007) • shortstory by Robert Reed
Hatch by Robert Reed - was excellent. 5/5 stars. Definitely found a new author I like. I ordered 4 of his books! (I'm reading Marrow now.)
66 • Winning Peace • (2007) • novelette by Paul J. McAuley
Winning Peace - Paul J. McAuley: 2/5 stars. Wasn’t my cup of tea. Maybe I just didn’t appreciate the ending?
88 • Glory • (2007) • novelette by Greg Egan
Glory - I love Greg Egan and enjoyed this story. 4/5 stars. Cool premise and ending
112 • Maelstrom • (2007) • novelette by Kage Baker
143 • Blessed by an Angel • (2007) • shortstory by Peter F. Hamilton
158 • Who's Afraid of Wolf 359? • shortstory by Ken MacLeod
170 • The Valley of the Gardens • (2007) • novelette by Tony Daniel
202 • Dividing the Sustain • (2007) • novelette by James Patrick Kelly
Just finished the Divide the Sustain novella and that was a weird one. I’d give it 3.5/5 though! Unlikeable characters always make stories weird for me...
234 • Minla's Flowers • [Merlin [4] • 2] • (2007) • novella by Alastair Reynolds
This story simply blew me away. I love Alastair Reynolds but my god this story was fun. Dark but still fun.
291 • Splinters of Glass • (2007) • novelette by Mary Rosenblum
316 • Remembrance • (2007) • shortstory by Stephen Baxter
Just finished Remembrance by Stephen Baxter. Wow, simply fantastic. An incredible invasion story. 5/5 stars on this one.
334 • The Emperor and the Maula • (2007) • novelette by Robert Silverberg
Just finished Robert Silverberg’s The Emperor and Maula... very good stuff. Another earth being conquered story.
379 • The Worm Turns • (2007) • shortstory by Gregory Benford
401 • Send Them Flowers • (2007) • novelette by Walter Jon Williams
This was a little hard to follow. I'd give it 2/5 but I may have just simply not been paying close enough attention to what was going on.
436 • Art of War • shortstory by Nancy Kress
454 • Muse of Fire • (2007) • novella by Dan Simmons
This story is excellent! Definitely didn't see the end coming! I've always held Hyperion in my top sci-fi stories ever. It was cool to see another Dan Simmons sci-fi story by such a strong author! 4/5. -
This was really a book full of hits and misses. The book grabbed my interest because there were a few authors names I recognized and I was very interested in short stories by them. Unfortunately the first several stories were severe disappointments, I seriously considered giving up on the book altogether a few times. But eventually the stories did start to run more to my liking. Minla's Flowers was an especially nice surprise.
However the stories that were unenjoyable tempered by the ones that left me wanting more lands the book in 3 star territory. If I only enjoy half the book, is it really worth it? The hallmark of a good anthology (in my opinion) is that I want to read more by that author, usually reading a collection of stories like this lets me add new books to my want-to-read list. I want to dive deeper into the universe that author has created. Too many of these stories left me wanting to get the first spaceship out of there. -
Saving Tiamaat GWYNETH JONES ***
Verthandi's Ring IAN MCDONALD ***
Hatch ROBERT REED **
Winning Peace PAUL J. MCAULEY ***
Glory GREG EGAN **
Maelstrom KAGE BAKER **
Blessed by an Angel PETER F. HAMILTON ****
Who's Afraid of Wolf 359? KEN MACLEOD **
The Valley of the Gardens TONY DANIEL ****
Dividing the Sustain JAMES PATRICK KELLY *
Minla's Flowers ALASTAIR REYNOLDS ****
Splinters of Glass MARY ROSENBLUM **
Remembrance STEPHEN BAXTER ****
The Emperor and the Maula ROBERT SILVERBERG **** [I read the complete, unabridged version]
The Worm Turns GREGORY BENFORD ***
Send Them Flowers WALTER JON WILLIAMS ***
Art of War NANCY KRESS ***
Muse of Fire DAN SIMMONS ***** -
Half space opera, half boring.
I had high hopes for this anthology of supposedly space opera stories, however, the vast majority of them focus on simple interstellar or planetary stories where the approach does not follow the same precepts you would expect from a space opera story. We have metaphysical stories, romantic stories, and a few adventures focused on scientific themes. A couple of the stories are space opera, and even then I wasn't satisfied.
Too bad, but this thick tome just bored me. -
3.5 stars. A good variety of Space Opera short stories and novellas. As with any collection, there were both hits and misses for me. I was fascinated that three of the stories dealt with art and two of those dealt with the profession of acting in outer space ("Maelstrom" by by Kage Baker and "Muse of Fire" By Dan Simmons, which gets extra points for combining Shakespeare and Gnostic theology in a futuristic and intergalactic setting). These last two were among my favorites.
-
First published in 2007, 'The New Space Opera' is a collection of 18 tales by some of the best SF writers. Story length varies from short to novella, but all were impressive. I particularly liked contributions by Robert Silverberg, Dan Simmons and Peter F Hamilton but it would be difficult and pointless to try to rank the stories. It seems to prove that talent at writing decent Space Opera is still out there, and I look forward to acquiring the follow-up volume.
