The Pirate by Harold Schechter


The Pirate
Title : The Pirate
Author :
Rating :
ISBN : -
Language : English
Format Type : Kindle Edition
Number of Pages : 67
Publication : First published June 28, 2018

In 1860, a sloop drifted into New York Harbor. Not a soul on board—just blood from cabin to deck. Looted coins led to Bowery thug Albert Hicks, the ax slayer who turned his shipmates into chum.

His crimes were absolutely fiendish. His execution was pure ballyhoo. It drew nearly ten thousand bloodthirsty sightseers to the city—including the enterprising showman P. T. Barnum. Refreshments were served as the most notorious and unrepentant mass murderer of the era made history as one of America’s first celebrity killers.

The Pirate is part of Bloodlands, a chilling collection of short page-turning historical narratives from bestselling true-crime master Harold Schechter. Spanning a century in our nation’s murderous past, Schechter resurrects nearly forgotten tales of madmen and thrill-killers that dominated the most sensational headlines of their day.


The Pirate Reviews


  • Jennifer Welsh

    Some fun facts about the intersection between piracy law and murder as profitable entertainment in 1800s New York City, but I felt that even an hour of this listen had too much filler. I was planning to finally crack open The Last Pirate of New York: A Ghost Ship, A Killer, and the Birth of a Gangster Nation, but now I'm wondering if I already know the key bits about P. T.Barnum and Hicks The Pirate. I'm still looking forward to reading Jewish Pirates of the Caribbean...

    Free with audible membership, well-narrated by Steven Weber, and part of a larger collection.

  • Fran (apologies...way behind)

    "all-you-can-eat-oysters raw on the half shell, for six cents"

    In 1763, the first oyster restaurant opened in New York. Oyster cellars, serving every social class, were becoming deplete of oysters necessitating the need for oyster merchants. The New York Harbor oyster beds were empty. A charter sloop, the E.A. Johnson, would sail down to the Chesapeake. The hired crew consisted of ship captain George Hanford Burr, brothers Oliver and Smith Watts, 24 and 19 years old, respectively, and ship mate William Johnson, a physically imposing, smart, knowledgeable sailor. On March 20, 1860, Captain Burr wrote a letter to his wife. On March 21, the abandoned sloop was found adrift. Upon inspection, blood soaked planks and blood splatter was everywhere. No signs of life, however, Captain Burr's silver, to be used to purchase Chesapeake oysters, was missing...so was the yawl hanging over the boat's stern.

    Through the use of newspaper clippings and court documents, American true crime writer Harold Schechter presents the story of Albert Hicks aka William Johnson, perhaps the last pirate in U.S. history to be executed for piracy. The populace was fascinated, including P.T. Barnum who was ready to add to his "curiosities".

    "The Pirate" by Harold Schechter is a true crime read by an author specializing in serial killers. The life and times of 1860 New York, as presented by Schechter, enabled this reader "to feel transported", to witness the unfolding events. An excellent true crime read!

  • Juli

    Grisly murders at sea. A crew hacked to death and thrown into the ocean. A sloop drifting unmanned into New York harbor with blood all over the decks. One man rowing to shore and walking away....

    In 1860, the killings by Albert Hicks drew a lot of attention. His execution was attended by thousands, including P.T. Barnum. Hicks had led a life of violence, killing and robbing all over the world as he worked on various ships. He was caught when he signed on as a mate on the E.A. Johnson to harvest oysters on the Chesapeake and killed the other 3 members of the crew for the money on board. Author Harold Schechter uses newspaper accounts and court records to piece together the story of Albert Hicks (aka William Johnson), a pirate who was executed in 1860 on Bledloe's Island (now Liberty Island).

    I'm a big fan of history and historic true crime tales.....I listen to many, many podcasts on the topic. So I knew I would enjoy listening to The Pirate, the first of six bloody tales in the Bloodlands Collection from Audible/Amazon Originals. I listened to the audiobook version of this story, narrated by Steven Weber. The audio is just under 1.5 hours, so it's an easy listening length. Weber reads at a nice, steady pace and his voice is easily understandable even with my hearing loss.

    I enjoyed this story. The author presents the facts about the crime, the life of the murderer and the aftermath of his arrest and conviction in an interesting manner. It is a lot like listening to a documentary....so if true crime or history isn't really your bag, you might want to pass this collection by.

    Listening to stories about crimes committed far in the past helps me put our present world in perspective. Today's society hasn't suddenly become a world of danger after peaceful times in the past.....the "good old days'' were just as violent and scary as what we face today. There just wasn't insta-news in those days....stories took awhile to get around. Investigations were completely low tech back then -- no DNA analysis, very little forensic knowledge above the very basic....and killers very often got away with their grisly crimes for quite some time before they were caught. Hicks led a life of horrific violence....until he made a mistake and got caught literally red handed. His execution was a public event with the atmosphere of a circus performance. That's almost as grisly as his crimes....

    The Bloodlands Collection gathers six true crime stories from the past. Ranging from the 1860's up to 1949, the crimes are varied, but all grisly. Not for the faint of heart. Interesting tales for those who enjoy true crime stories. The kindle book versions use Kindle-In-Motion animation....some of the illustrations, photos and text moves or has slight animations. Kinda cool. I chose the audible version and listened to the story.

    I'm enjoying these collections of Amazon Original content. There are several different story collections...horror short stories, global warming tales, true crime, missing persons, etc. I haven't liked all of the selections, but I've had fun trying them. I like having a shorter story to listen to....something I can finish quickly rather than investing 10-15 hours in an entire novel-length audio book.

    All in all, so far Bloodlands is my favorite collection. I love the combo of history and true crime narrative!

  • ✨faith✨trust✨pixiedust✨

    Oh wow this was intense! And very informative!

    What is it about sociopathic murderers that's so fascinating? Why are we as a society so prone to exalt such people to celebrity status?

  • Cori

    Being the true account of Albert Hicks. Pirate. Serial killer. Possessed by a demon. Probably.

    I categorized this under "history" and "pirates," but also the unexpected category of "horror." As in, "Oh, the horror!" Because... oh, the horror.

    Super short listen on Audible. It wasn't what I expected, but I definitely felt entertained.

    Also, P.T. Barnum was a douche canoe. That is all.

    I'd rate this an R for the graphic descriptions of brutal murder, adult themes, and a disturbing hanging.

  • Montzalee Wittmann

    The Pirate is a history book with great information about this subject but especially on one particular act of piracy and murder. It tracks the rumors, known facts, and the gruesome story to the end! Very interesting!

  • Rachelle

    Who doesnt love a good tale of a seemingly ghost like ship drifting into harbor with not a soul on board!?!? This sad story tells of the murders aboard the A.E. Johnson, and how the fiendish Albert Hicks was brought to justice.

  • Isabelle reads a book a day because she has no friends

    3.5 stars. My favorite part of this book was the epilogue!

  • Brad

    The first in
    Harold Schechter's
    Bloodlands series, The Pirate is a strange piece of true crime in that the crime and its perpetrator are far less interesting than what orbits the supposedly important story.

    Albert W. Hicks attacked and killed the Captain and crew of the oyster sloop A.E. Johnson with an axe in order to steal the money aboard, which was meant to by oysters down in Virginia. It was a murder for money, it was brutal, and Hicks disposed of the bodies deep in the ocean. He also used that classic excuse of old timey (and some new timey) murderers: the devil made me do it. So the story has its attractions, but not enough to suck in most true crime aficionados.

    What is interesting, however, is that the prosecutors, who had no dead bodies but still wanted to get the death penalty for Hicks, decided to shift the case to maritime law -- since the killings took place on the ocean and Hicks had stolen money -- and try Hicks for piracy. Piracy was a crime that needed no bodies as evidence and a crime that meant Hicks would hang if convicted. These prosecutorial machinations are the most fascinating part of Schechter's book and are a nice reminder that loopholes often work as much for the state as they do for the defendant, perhaps even more for the former than the latter.

    And then there is the quirkiest of sideshows: the presence of P.T. Barnum. Barnum, you see, was always a man in search of getting bums in his tents, and how he uses Hicks, and how he makes Hicks almost immortal in the annals of Yankee true crime, are a hell of a lot of fun to read. But you'll get no more out of me. You'll have to read it or listen to it yourself.

  • Quentin Wallace

    This wasn't quite as interesting as Rampage, probably because it's not as timely. This dealt with Albert Hicks, a murderer who killed 3 men on an oyster ship back in the late 1800s in New York. He was convicted of piracy rather than murder since it was easier to prove and carried the same penalty. I wasn't familiar with Albert Hicks, but it turns out he was mentioned in an episode of the original Twilight Zone so I'm surprised I didn't remember him. He was also interesting because PT Barnum had several interactions with him.

    Overall this was interesting but nothing overly remarkable.

  • Martin,  I hate MTG

    Short story about a pirate A.W Hicks. He boarded a ship as an extra hand to catch oysters. One. Night he killed his two shipmates and the captain. Hicks stole everything worth value and boarded the ships small life boat. He rowed to shore with his ill gotten gain, but was soon caught and hanged.

    The book is only 78 pages long and it did manage to keep my attention. I would recommend this book for an exciting short read.

  • Kathryn

    This book is the first in the Bloodlands series that tells old true crime mysteries from the past. This particular one is the story of Albert Hicks. He was one of the last people put to death for piracy. Over his lifetime he racked up many murders and stole from the masses. I read the "great on kindle" version which included some animated pictures in the beginning, along with a handful of pictures and documents to help give a more complete picture of what actually took place. I really enjoyed this short story and would love to read the rest in this series.

  • Melissa

    The story of pirate and mass murdered Albert Hicks, who murdered his 3 shipmates in 1860.
    This was my first Audible Audiobook and I found it quite entertaining. It’s a short story read by Steven Weber who did an excellent job keeping the listeners attention. The murders are described in vivid detail and I was surprised at the interest that P.T. Barnum had in it. Albert Hicks became America’s first celebrity killer due to the amazing turn out at his hanging.

  • Mark

    It's proof of the desensitized state of modern man that I found this boring.

  • Amy

    Grisly, gory murders on the sea. If the confession that Hicks gave to the reporter is even half true, this man was probably one of the worst serial killers in history. (I don't know if any of the things he said he did were ever investigated) It's probably a good thing he was caught and executed for the murders of the three sailors on the oyster boat. I found it interesting that they felt they didn't have enough evidence to convict him of murder, so they decided to try him for piracy, which also carried the death penalty.

    Creepy little story, and a reminder that there have always been monsters.

  • Elizabeth Edwards

    (rating is due to the fact of which books i prefer more than the others!!) I love it when Amazon groups these books all together, would enjoy seeing why and how they decide to do this?? all these are by: Harold Schechter? that is a 1st, right?? don't they usually have book by different authors? i made a list of my most favorite and in which order!! (I apparently did not read them in order, just jumped around and listen/read what i wanted to, that is how i roll!!!) 1. Rampage, 2. Brick Slayer, 3. Panic, 4. Pied Piper, 5. Little Slaughterhouse, & 6. Pirate (auto and books Kindle Unlimited, Bloodlines) I definitely think you have to have both the listen and read ...'cause there are so many awesome must see stuff. I love the narrator. "Steve Weber". then when you read the books .. u get like these amazing visuals. so cool! i will say these are not always pleasant stories ...they are pretty harsh ...but I would imagine that was well known before you starting reading?? right??! i mean these are not romances ... but i wonder ... i guess i could read some of the reviews (have yet to do that. some reviewers get kind of weird about certain things??!) I really enjoyed it ...and glad i found these. i know i wanna see more from Harold soon enough!! way cool! I do wonder ... can you really lump killers or folks who commit similar crimes into one box??! i recall when i was in college my teacher said we all have similar thoughts or feelings ...but the ones who go about carrying out the evilness ...that is what makes us different. it makes you wonder what sends them over the edge or make them so mean?? hateful?? have they been hurt in their past? treat wrong when raised ...what is it?? can you just narrow it all down to 1,2, and 3 ..and these reasons make you so to carry out evil ways??! i wonder??!

  • Christine Whittington

    "The Pirate" is another Audible book in the Bloodlands series by Harold Schechter. This one is about the pirate Albert Hicks, about whom I was blissfully unaware despite my love for maritime literature and tales of piracy. Albert Hicks was one nasty dude. "The Pirate" focuses on his final rampage, murdering the captain and crew of an oyster-seeking vessel on which he had assumed the position of mate. He also wreaked havoc, along with various compatriots, from California goldfields to Istanbul to the Congo River, pursuing gratification without remorse. The most interesting thing about this story to me was the hoopla surrounding his execution. It was held on Bledloe's Island (now Liberty Island) because he had been convicted of a federal crime and had to be executed on federal land. The execution was a carnival. Thousands of people paid for passage on boats to get a better view of the festivities. Hicks's final moments were witnessed by at least 10,000 people. A clairvoyant was present to attempt to communicate with Hicks's dying soul. There was a rumor that he had survived his hanging and was brought back to life. P. T. Barnum purchased his clothing in order to make a wax image of him for his museum.

    The story is fascinating and includes the historical and cultural background one would expect from Schechter, a professor of American Studies and literature at Queens college. Narrator Steven Weber as excellent, as with all the tales in this series.

  • Annie

    This was a quick read and is the first in the Bloodlands series by Harold Schechter. I had never heard this story before but it was fascinating how even in the 1860s they were able to track and find the killer fairly quickly. The legwork put in was absolutely outstanding.
    It is a mix of history, true crime and a bit on the macabre side.

    The story is about Albert Hicks, who murdered the crew of a oyster sloop and stole what money and belongings they had. The bodies were never found, as he dumped them at sea, but they were still able to get a conviction and sentence him to death, but not for the murders! He was sentenced to death due to piracy, and one of the last people executed for that in the United States. He was executed in front of a crowd of 10 thousand witnesses anchored in the waters off of Bedloe's Island (now Liberty Island, where the Statue of Liberty resides). It was an absolutely fascinating story.

    This is the first thing I have read by Schechter and I am looking forward to the rest of the Bloodlands series.

  • rose ✨

    “the outfit was a considerable improvement over the threadbare suit [hicks] had been arrested in and had worn throughout most of his imprisonment. that suit, however, was no longer in his possession. it had been purchased by p.t. barnum.”


    truly amazing how much serial killers/mass murderers haven’t changed throughout history. the excuses and explanations hicks offered are so similar to those given by contemporary killers.

    this was a well-researched piece, but the discussions taking place in the periphery were so much more interesting than hicks’ actual crimes—namely, the idea that hicks and men like him were a product of the supposedly idyllic rural america of the 1800s, and the media circus surrounding many true crime cases then and today (p.t. barnum’s involvement with true crime deserves its own piece).

    rating: 3/5 stars

  • Caitlin D.

    A quick and fairly interesting true crime read about a 19th century murderer. This wasn’t bad at all, but perhaps not quite as riveting as it could’ve been. I really enjoyed reading this as an ebook, as I could click on the endnotes and quickly jump back to the text. The way I could zoom in on the pictures and the little “title card” page with the quickly moving pictures was a nice touch. I’m looking forward to reading the rest in this Amazon series for a little taste of American true crime and history.

  • Teri

    This is a short story about the true-crime of Albert Hicks, a man who boarded a sloop in 1860 off the coast of New York and killed the captain and two mates before robbing them and sneaking via a lifeboat in the early morning. The story follows the gruesome discovery of the ship, the capturing and trial of Hicks and the outcome of his sentencing. Schechter is well known for his true crime stories.

    This is a quick read and is great to read as a "Kindle in Motion" that should be read via the Kindle app on an iPad or Kindle Fire to check out the fun moving graphics.

  • Miles Smith

    The first volume in a short but interesting series Amazon is doing. They're a mix of history, macabre, and true crime works so its hard to type them. I've included in one my fantasy/sci-fi shelf because there is a sort of brooding spiritual darkness that does with the Hicks case. I won't give away the details, but if you're looking for a well-written, fast-paced crime history with a splash of spookiness thrown in, this is your bag.

  • Cupcakes & Machetes

    I hope you're not tired of hearing me talk about Last Podcast on the Left because here I go again....

    I read this purely based on the fact that Marcus Parks of LPOTL, always highly recommends this author and frequently uses Schechter's works in his research.

    The Bloodlands Collection is also on Kindle Unlimited so I had nothing to lose by checking out this short story.

    Historical true crime fans, dig in. It's great.

  • Jen

    A very quick true crime read (under 100 pages) about Albert W. Hicks, one of the last in America to be executed for piracy. Reading more like a documentary, the author includes quotes, interesting photos, and an impressive bibliography noting the research and thought that went into this short novel. I found it very interesting. The first in a series of novellas of true crime, I may look into more of the "Bloodlands" series.

  • ✨ Anna ✨ |  ReadAllNight

    Had a promising beginning but went rather flat. The initial info about the all-out oyster craze in NYC for the last quarter of the 18th century is fascinating. Although, we never seem to learn about over-fishing, etc.

    It is a true crime story--the crime was in 1860.

    Text is better than the audio--the narrator was fair at best.

    Probably easier to read the entry.


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert_...

  • Ann-Marie "Cookie M."

    A true crime story about a 19th century triple murder committed on a shipping vessel in New England. A man hired on as free of an oyster shipping sloop and killed the captain and two other crew members for $150.
    A lot of research went into the writing of this short work, but I was left wondering why the author wrote it.

  • Andreas Porwanto

    First read of 2020! Whew! That was short yet I was on the edge of my seat at all times. It truly scares me how he seems to have no compunctions whatsoever regarding his killings but revisiting the story of these killers and have them written on these amazing original stories is mad cool! Can’t wait to finish the entire collection!

  • Paige Olsen

    I loved this. Super fast read… very well researched for such an old case. Some of it comes across as “filler”, but considering how old the case was, I enjoyed it because it was information about the time and how law worked back then… and direct quotes from people in the case that were so fun to hear!

  • Cindy Woods

    Ghoulish

    A true crime novel well written and based on newspaper reports, police reports and court documents of the " pirate Hicks" in 1860 New York.

    The author spared no detail of the bloodbath in board a sloop. And I have to say it is very intense and historically interesting.

    Although it made me shudder, I recommend to readers of historical crime fiction.