| Title | : | The Copper Beech |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | 0752876813 |
| ISBN-10 | : | 9780752876818 |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Paperback |
| Number of Pages | : | 407 |
| Publication | : | First published January 1, 1992 |
From the Hardcover edition.
The Copper Beech Reviews
-
There is something very special about Maeve Binchy’s writing. The first time I read one of her books it was 1990. In the 27 years since then she has continued to produce books that are in-depth explorations into people’s hearts and minds. She does not do this ruthlessly or clinically, like a surgeon making a deep cut. She does so with delicacy, sensitivity, and a garden of compassion.
Are her books all rainbows and unicorns? Not by any stretch of the imagination. The endings are always positive and affirming, but the pathway to the ending is layered with the grit and gravel of real life. Part of the specialness in her writing seems to me to be choice of language. For instance, there is a big difference between someone giving up on something out of disgust and giving up on something out of despair. One of them elicits far more empathy in this reader than the other.
This particular book was presented in a series of character spotlights with all of them tying together. As in real life, each individual experienced their life and the other people in the village from their own perspective, through their own lenses, tinted by their own conditioning and growth. It is very deftly done and highlights yet again how people can live in the same place and share a moment, a decade, a life and yet experience it so differently. Perception is such an amazing force and probably doesn’t receive the respect – nor the fear, perhaps – that it deserves.
The characters are all so well-done, and the story so satisfying, I couldn’t help but draw it out as long as I could. I really didn’t want it to end and I wouldn’t have minded being invited into even more of the villager’s homes, hearts, and minds.
Reading this book felt like being cuddled in a big old comfy armchair; safe, secure, and blissfully knowing that no matter the trials and challenges the characters in the book encounter, all will be well in the end. -
This is my favorite Maeve Binchy book that I've read to date. I've yet to find another person who feels the same way, so perhaps I'm the odd woman out, but I don't mind. I simply got immersed in the story and found it easy to relate to the characters especially Chris.
I loved the idea that everyone thought what they knew what was going in the other characters lives, but it wasn't until you got to their respective chapters that you learned the truth.... -
I have always loved Maeve Binchy's stories; she's such a marvelous storyteller. This book, set in a small Irish country village, follows a group of school children, from childhood through to parenthood. Their lives are entertwined, like many in small towns, but each of their stories hold secrets. The book was set from the 50's and ended in the 70's, and gives a good picture of life at that time in rural Ireland. The school that had seen generations of children walk through its doors, to carve their names on the giant beech it sat under, had stories to tell of its own, if it could only talk. Each chapter focused on one of the characters, and the tale was told from his/her perspective. This will be a reread for me.
-
'The Copper Beech' is a series of interwoven character studies, which tell different parts of a story of a small town community in Ireland, in the middle and late twentieth century. It opens with the description of a large beech tree, which gives shade in the grounds of a primary school. The school is being honoured with a visit from the Bishop, and we meet several characters from the town including some mischievous children.
There are then several sections, each written from the perspective of one of the people in the town. They usually start in the person's childhood, showing their upbringing and introducing some of their friends. There are ongoing threads too - who marries whom? Will Maura get her dream of a house of her own? What happens in Leo's family that makes her draw back from the rest of the community?
It's very well written, with excellent characterisations. Perhaps a bit slow-moving at times, and certainly no great excitement or intrigue, but for someone like me who enjoys reading about people, a very enjoyable book. -
Re-read June 27, 2022: I just needed a book taking place in a different time and place right now. Though this book starts off in the 1950s and ends around 1971 or so, it still brought me some comfort. Maybe because Binchy really does lay out how hard it was for women in Ireland in that time and place and even mentions a few times how the inhabitants of Shancarring were poor and how many women just had too many children they were just kind of done in. What's funny is that this book has several abortions being undertaken by some women in this book and I just honestly forget about it. Heck one of the stories ends on someone arranging an abortion for what would have been their grandchild. I still love all of the characters in this one that I did when I first reviewed it. Eddie, Nessa, Leo, and Dr. Jim's were great. Poor Maddy though. Her ending to me was the saddest. The main reason why I still didn't give this one 5 stars though is that I really do wish Binchy had given us Niall and Foxy's POV's too.
It's funny, I think I read this one eons ago (back in the mid-2000s) but I never got into it. At least I can say that nothing read as familiar to me when I started this. I thought that the way that Binchy balances all of the characters, and then we get to see them in the end, adults, married, with children was great. I always want to know what happens next in a story, so we get a little of that here.
Binchy divides up the book and focuses on certain characters in the village of Schancarrig. We start off with Father Gunn, then we move to Madeline Ross (known as Maddy) which also introduces Father Barry. We have other adults in this one, Dr. Jims and Nora Kelly but they are in the mix of when the school children are introduced. After them, we move to the children who go to Schancarrig school. First we have Maura, then Eddie, Nessa, and Leo. We also have another character who is not one that went to the school, Richard. He is related to one of the characters we hear about in this story, Niall. We don't get Niall's POV in this though.
I have to say that out of everyone I liked Nessa's and Leo's stories the most. Probably because Nessa gets to see a different side to her mother's relationship with her father, and she realizes that it's better for her to give her strength to someone who needs it/her instead of throwing herself away on someone who doesn't deserve her.
Leo's story was heart wrenching. Her family gets twisted upside down and she is forced to keep a secret that haunts her. I did love how the village reprobate Foxy made good and how he was hell-bent on marrying Leo. I thought it was odd though that Binchy didn't switch Foxy in for Richard's story. One of the main reason's why I gave it 4 stars.
Maddy's story was a hot mess. Dealing with an overbearing mother, she throws her all into being an assistant teacher, and then her friendship with Father Barry who is another mess. Her ending was not happy at all, and I liked how Binchy looped her back in the end.
I really liked the writing in this one. You really have to pay attention to what is going on while reading this since you get hints of thing to come in other people's stories. Also Binchy does a wonderful job of looping things back. For example, you don't know what caused Leo to suddenly change how she was personality wise. You just know that other characters remark upon it. Eventually you do find out while reading Leo's story.
The flow was good too, though some of the individual stories, I was a little bored with like Richard and Eddie. Eddie's story gets better by the end, but the beginning of his tale was slow. Richard I didn't like at all, and it was odd that was even included I though except it gave us insights into two other characters, Nessa and a woman we hear mentioned a lot, Mrs. Gloria Darcy.
The setting is Shancarrig in the 1960s. When the book ends we are in 1970 I think or at least 1971. The book focuses on the school (the old stone house) and the tree that the children wrote their initials on as they grew up (the copper beech).
The ending leaves things on a hopeful note for all of the characters except for Richard and Maddy. -
I had a Maeve Binchy phase, oh, about 20 years ago. She wrote these cosy books about an old fashioned Ireland, where people were quirky, knew everything about everyone, and were never nasty to each other. Bad things happened to good people, but they got past it. I outgrew Maeve, but from time to time I pick one up, for a pleasant re=read.
The Copper Beech is one of her ensemble cast stories. She takes a central theme and weaves the individual stories around the centrepost. It's a bit like reading interconnected short stories rather than a novel. Her style and plots are predictable, stereotypes abound, and there's an underlying order to things that her characters seldom deviate from. People pair off neatly, reproduce on cue (or suffer madly before finding a suitable alternative), agonize over their lives, become stronger, get over it. The bad guys get their low-key just desserts. But most of her stories are set in the 1950s or earlier and so she gets away with it. Overall, I think she does better with her earlier works "Light a Penny Candle" for example, which follows one storyline and fewer characters.
She's the macaroni cheese of Irish fiction and I love her for it. -
People Magazine said The Copper Beech by Maeve Binchy "is as soothing as a cup of tea."
Couldn't agree more.
You open the pages and you are transported to the little Irish town of Shancarring where you have the opportunity to meet all the various residents - chapter by chapter.
The story will make you laugh, cry and care in true Maeve Binchy style. -
a great collection of interlinked short stories by Maeve Binchy. possibly the best of hers in this format I've read 🙂
the weaving of the stories is skillfully and beautifully done imo, with each characters story adding perspectives on, and pieces to, the others, and you can feel a larger picture slowly taking shape. it's rather delicious.
the stories contain alot about class, gender, sexuality, choices, family, health, opportunity... and paint a particular picture of Ireland too... one that I feel balances an almost sense of nostalgia with times of change on a social and political level.
the collection moves with the initial characters from their childhood, through youth to adulthood, and towards the end often with their own children... and thus sets up at least three generations of inhabitants of the village. the different generational perspectives are then used to explore the different experiences, views, opportunities, and life choices, of both different individuals and different generations... creating overall a very full and rich story.
and the ending was perfect. maybe a little tidy 😉 but nice and secure, knowing the village of Shancarrig and it's inhabitants would continue... and with, what I thought was, the perfect closing line 😊
🍂🌳🍂
accessed as a local library audiobook, well read by Kate Binchy (she reads abit fast for me, but I found the function to slow the audio a fraction, and could relax into it).
the audiobook was a little marred by the transfer from CD not editing out 'end of disk X' repeatedly. pretty lazy on the part of the publisher. -
En realidad 3'5.
Me ha encantado este libro costumbrista. Es mu cozy. Sin duda volveré a leer a Maeve. -
3.5 stars
The Copper Beech is less a narrative story and more short stories about overlapping characters in a small town; the flow was too abrupt between perspectives, and each character had only one chapter to tell their story.
I liked these characters, and the amount of overlap within the chapters was enough to provide outside context without feeling like it was the same story repeatedly. Each chapter was long enough for most of the characters to win me over as they became complex and engaging people with unique views of the world. As to be expected, there were some duds, but every town has to have a few.
Maddy is a bit of a fruitcake. She's a little too sheltered: naive and oblivious to the world around her. Brian is the perfect foil to take advantage of these characteristics. Though his actions may not have malicious motives, his self-centred nature is ignorant of what effect these actions have on others, particularly Maddy. She doesn't show up in many of the other stories, but it's entirely unsurprising when she does as the .
Maura is one of my favourite characters with modest goals that made her endearing. She's self-possessed, takes everything in stride, and keeps working towards what she wants, dragging any obstacle along with her. Unconcerned about how others view her, Maura takes pride in what she does and lives her life in the way she pleases.
It took some time to warm up to Eddie. Actually, I think I warmed up to Christine and Eddie's mother more than him. He's a bit dull and passive for my taste, and while he improved slightly in the end, I wish there had been more Christine in this chapter.
Dr Jims was infuriating. He doesn't take his own medical advice, struggles to live with the consequences, and then basically neglects his child for decades. He seems like a good doctor, a good member of the community, but an absent and oblivious father.
Nora Kelly's story was heartbreaking and heartwarming in equal parts. Unfortunately, we don't see much of her outside of the perspective of motherhood, so it's difficult to see her as a complex character. But what we do get to know about her is incredibly touching.
Nessa is the underdog story you love to read. Self-conscious and unhappy her entire childhood, she manages to turn it around without realising it, gaining self-confidence and learning how to take her rightful place in the world almost overnight. I was worried Nessa was heading down the same path as Maura and many of the other female side characters in this book, but I should have had more faith in her. She seems to cross a line where she suddenly has the self-awareness to understand not only her own motives for her actions but those of everyone around her as well. It was refreshing and wonderful to read. Nessa isn't petty or vindictive; she acts in her own interest and doesn't let anyone else drag her down.
Richard doesn't deserve a paragraph. Selfish, disgusting pig.
Leo had the biggest buildup out of everyone but was a bit of a letdown. Sure, her mother is batshit crazy, but it's a pretty flimsy excuse for everything that happens. I think Foxy's perspective would've been more interesting. Leo doesn't really do anything; she floats from one situation to another, doing what is expected of her in a slightly nervous and anxious manner.
The last chapter, tying all the others together, was a little fairy story happy ending for me, but it was nice to get one last peek and where everyone ended up. Karma is alive and strong in this town, and everyone seems to get what they want - if they deserve it. This town is a lot less gossipy than most small towns, and while it's not unlikely that some secrets could be kept, many of the big, terrible secrets stay hidden for a lot longer than seems likely. Despite this, I enjoyed this collection of what I'm considering short stories. Each chapter was the perfect length, and most of these characters were worth reading about.
Review originally posted
here on Britt's Book Blurbs.
Blog |
Bookstagram |
Reddit |
Twitter -
Great storyteller !!!
-
I have to admit that I sometimes get a sense of deja vu when starting any of Binchy's books. Her style is very much her own and taking any chapter from any of her books you can immediately tell it is a Bincky book. However, I think that that is one of the things that appeals to me about her as a writer. I read many modern novels that stretch the form and push the reader to re-evaluate our place on earth, etc., but when the world becomes just a tad to overbearing I always know I can open a Binchy book to chapter one and fall right into her world of comfortable deeply-imagined characters. Copper Beach is actually a series of interrelated chapters(almost novellas) that examine each character in a small town in Great Britain. I really enjoyed how she connected the characters yet gave each one a major focus for a long period of time in the story.
-
A great all around story; I love Maeve Binchy anyway, so it's hard for me to find a book of hers I don't like. I like the way she tells her stories; this one, like most, revolves almost entirely around different personalities, their secrets, actions, loves, hates, and how they all interact with each other. Complex, yet simple. The book spans almost 30 years, and you feel like you've been there all along as the characters grow and change. Nothing earth shattering, nothing overly gripping, just a well told story of a small town, its schoolhouse, and the faces that have passed through.
-
I always enjoy the cozy stories from Maeve Binchy. This one was not my favourite~ I found some of the stories dragged on a little too long.
-
Love Maeve Binchy! Another feel-good tale.
-
In the close-knit Irish community of Shancarrig, there stands an old copper beech overlooking the schoolhouse. For years, the imposing tree has been both a silent spectator and a staunch supporter of the generations of students who have gone to school in Shancarrig. Eight children once carved their names - and the names of those who they loved - into the bark of the tree, as part of an annual tradition that takes place on the final day of school. And so, the old copper beech has kept the secrets of these former pupils; bearing the etchings of their myriad ambitions and hopeful dreams for the future within its trunk.
These eight children have since become adults and are living their own lives. Yet the schoolhouse in Shancarrig still holds a special place in all of their hearts; as it is the schoolhouse that has shaped them and made them who they are. For each person, their hometown holds such special memories - some memories that are just too personal or private to ever be shared. However, the mighty copper beech has witnessed various declarations of love, hope, and identity - all the youthful dreams of the children who once played beneath its sheltering branches.
Although they live such vastly different lives, these eight dreamers can certainly agree on one thing about the bucolic and peaceful town of Shancarrig: life is dull; some might even say deadly dull. From Ryan's Hotel to Barna Woods, where the gypsies set up their campsites each year, from Nellie Dunn's bustling little sweet shop to Father Gunn's quiet parish church; the pace of life in tiny Shancarrig is placidly uneventful. And the community seems to prefer it that way.
However, for some more passionate souls - such as Nessa Ryan - there must be more to life in Shancarrig than running the family hotel. Yet if Nessa could just peel back the various layers of serenity - if she could see beyond the calm exterior of life in Shancarrig - she would see so much unexpected drama: the schoolhouse's headmistress, Maddy Ross has a secret love; Eddie Barton has developed a surprising friendship with someone through the mail; and Maura Brennan has discovered that she has a curious kinship with a glamorous couple - Mike and Gloria Darcy - recent newcomers to Shancarrig.
In this picturesque little town, where the river runs around the great rock for which the town is named, human life flows along in all its variety. Lives intertwine in much the same way as names crisscross on the trunk of that sturdy copper beech. Yet, from the cottages where Foxy Dunne and his family live in poverty; to the grand house where Leonora 'Leo' Murphy lives; and for the Kellys', who live near the school; as well as the town physician, Dr. Jims Blake, who lives on The Terrace - nothing is as it seems. For now, the secrets that have long been hidden deep in Shancarrig's shadows are being brought back into the light.
I must say that I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. As I know I have said before, I absolutely love Maeve Binchy as an author. In my opinion, she writes such poignant stories and develops such personable characters that I found myself truly connecting with as I read further along in the book.
I also appreciate that her plots are never just the 'chocolate box' variety - the 'feel good, happily ever after' type plots and stories. Ms. Binchy's stories aren't always wrapped up in a nice, neat little bow. I love her writing style precisely because I find it to be more realistic and true to life. I would definitely give this book an A+! -
A huge copper beech tree sits in the school yard in Shancarrig and everyone has weitten their names in the tree through out the years. From ryan's Hotel to Barna Woods, where the gypsies came each year, from Nellie Dunn's sweet shop to FatherGunn's church, the tenor of life in this small Irish village is outwardly placid and uneventful. Nessa Ryan would say it was deadly dull. But, behind the calm exterior, serenity fades into unexpected drama. Maddy Ross has a secret love; Eddie Barton a surprising friendship and the Darcys, the glamorous newcomers, find a curious partner in prro Marua Brennan. At the cottages,where the Dunnes live in poverty, the grand house of Leo Murphy, the Kellys near the school, Dr. Jim's on The Terrace...nothing is as it seems.
-
"Pod crvenom bukvom", M. Binchy; Svako toliko otkrijem neku knjigu Maeve Binchy koju nisam čitala, pa je tako bilo i sa ovom. I nema tu iznenađenja, znam da će mi se svidjeti jer volim kako ona piše.. Opise malih irskih gradića u okolici Dublina i njihovih žitelja.. Tako je i ovdje.. Irsko mjestašce Shancarrig i osam ljudi i njihovih priča koje se, naravno, poprilično međusobno isprepliću. Toplo, životno, "opipljivi" ljudi sa svojim vrlinama, manama i strahovima.. I svi se na ovaj i ili onaj način mire sa životom.. Lagana knjiga koja se čita za zanimanjem i užitkom. :)
-
Maeve Binchy had a nice way of taking a lot of diverse characters and pulling them together to create a complete picture of a town or community. I found this interesting throughout. It struck me how much everyone thought they knew about one another, when in fact each person was deeper and different than believed. I think that is true of "real life" as well. We all have depths that few are able or take the time to plumb.
-
Not bad but I didn't enjoy it as much as I did with the other ones I have read from this author.
-
BOOK # 1000 on my 'read' list! Woot-woot.... a long time coming but a worthy celebration!
I really loved the way that this story wove in and around the characters! In some ways, it was like a collection of short stories in that the author would focus on one person and their particular situation and then move onto the next person. However, each and every character showed up in the stories of the other characters. Being set in a small Irish village, it was easy to have many of the villagers make appearances here and there--some significant and some insignificant--and the blending of their lives was seamless.
And, it had a very moving and happy ending! I love a surprise ending, but I really love a satisfying ending!
Well done and worth reading. -
Maeve binchy is a great writer and good storyteller. She really knows how to write honestly about ordinary Irish people and how to create atmosphere of suspense in her novels. In this novel the copper beech she take me to the small Irish town called shancarring to see how people live there simple life. The copper beech is a name of school built in shade of big old tree .I enjoyed reading very much this book. And I appreciate the way she writes passionately. She put together different characters and focuses on every details of their life .the common point between those persons that they had been in the same school: the copper beech .
-
Good study of a small town.
-
I cannot say that it was my favourite Binchy yet but I must say that it was quite interesting. I liked the way that the author broke down the novel according to the several characters who made the story what it was. I also liked the fact that when an event occured with one character, more details were provided in another chapter based on a supporting character. At times the novel was difficult to put down as the story was so appealing, despite the fact that there was no great particular event per se.
At times, I questioned what the purpose of the Copper Beech tree was to the story, but by book's end, I realised that it had had a significant impact on the lives of the people in Shancarrig at one point or another. I think it symbolised for them the secrets that many of them kept, or rather, it served as a backdrop to the interwoven relationships in the story.
I found it interesting that the school had been put up for sale in the end, and that so many of the main characters were willing to purchase it.However,I was very happy about the unanimous agreement about it in the end. -
I only recall the tree.. but I love Maeve and her characters so I’m sure I’ll go back there someday. That’s one author I can say that with ease.
-
I love all of Maeve Binchey's, including this one, The Copper Beech. Each chapter in this book is an expanded vignette of a character.
I loved all of them with the exception of Richard, a spolier fellow who almost got his way with any girls he picked but I like how his life disappointed him.
I loved the story of Eddie Barton who pressed flowers and was extremely sensitive and modest. The one of Maura Brenan who wanted to be like her school teacher, gets pregnant and abandoned after marriage and the birth of Down's syndrome boy. Maura never really had love until she had the baby and gave her son love which he returned to her and he loved the town too.
Most poignant was Leo or Lenora Murphy, her life crippled by mean mother and an ignoring father, was to endure horrible years haunted by her parents secret that she never wanted to a part of. The worst of it was that she could never tell the full story to anyone.
There are many more characters and the wonderful old beech tree near the school house where most carved their initials and hopes.
