Title | : | Doctor Who: A Time Lord For Change: in an Exciting Adventure with the Drabbles |
Author | : | |
Rating | : | |
ISBN | : | 1540336123 |
ISBN-10 | : | 9781540336125 |
Language | : | English |
Format Type | : | Paperback |
Number of Pages | : | 190 |
Publication | : | First published November 14, 2016 |
Doctor Who: A Time Lord For Change: in an Exciting Adventure with the Drabbles Reviews
-
100 words plus title for each televised Who story up to Capaldi's first good one (plus a few extras). Pro Who writers and stars of the show (including a Doctor and a Davros) rub shoulders with fans, no category having a noticeably better or worse hit rate than any other. The brevity of the form obviously tends to favour certain approaches – the poetic, the squib, the deleted scene – with those who nevertheless try to reprise the whole story in brief, or else review it directly, generally coming off worst. Often, the least promising stories can make for the best responses; ’The Beast Below’ by way of Samuel Beckett and Monty Python’s ‘Rings of Akhaten’ are both far better than the originals, and not just because they’re shorter.
-
Unfortunately, I didn’t love A Time Lord for Change as much as I expected to. My interest in Doctor Who is more in its characters than it’s stories; I’m a fanfiction person and while this anthology is definitely a transformative work created by fans I don’t know if it’s fanfiction as I’d define it!
The drabbles are concerned more with the narratives and themes of individual Doctor Who serials and that’s not especially interesting to me. However, they are for the most part very strong. And the big upside of a drabble anthology is that when you don’t enjoy a piece, it’s over very quickly.
It also does require a quite extensive knowledge of classic who – there’s one drabble for every serial and all of them will make sense only if you’ve seen the serial. Definitely a novella for the hardcore fans, which is a niche market. But if that’s you, definitely check it out – it’s an interesting read and for a good cause.