| Title | : | A House at the Bottom of a Lake |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | - |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Kindle Edition |
| Number of Pages | : | 118 |
| Publication | : | First published October 31, 2016 |
It sounded like the perfect first date: canoeing across a chain of lakes, sandwiches and beer in the cooler. But teenagers Amelia and James discover something below the water’s surface that changes their lives forever.
It’s got two stories.
It’s got a garden.
And the front door is open.
It’s a house at the bottom of a lake.
For the teens, there is only one rule: no questions. And yet, how could a place so spectacular come with no price tag? While the duo plays house beneath the waves, one reality remains:
Just because a house is empty, doesn’t mean nobody’s home.
A House at the Bottom of a Lake Reviews
-
i...what...huh?? wtf was that ending? who decided to market this as horror? did i like it? wHAT???
-
(3.5) Two teenagers go on a date on a lake, find a house at the bottom of it and decide to explore it...
While I didn't care for the romance (or ending!), I was definitely uncomfortable from beginning to end.
Also: -
Well, I kind of enjoyed this? I'm not 100% sure what I just read, but I feel like it's been marketed unfairly. I wouldn't consider this horror; it might be stretching things to call it suspense. I was slightly bored throughout the entire novella but did find bits and pieces interesting, especially toward the end. If I had to narrow it down I feel as though this would fit well under a YA/Magical Realism. A quick read and I did feel the ending was strong, so I decided to bump the initial 2 up to a 3 Star rating.
-
Just because a house is empty, doesn’t mean nobody’s home.
this is the perfect tagline for a horror story. and between the ominous promise of that line and my having enjoyed malerman’s full-length books,
Bird Box and
Black Mad Wheel, well - it did not take me long to whip out eleven of my dollars for what i thought would be a sweet little nightmare.
and while i have a shelf for
“titles that lie,” i do not have a shelf for “publisher names who lie,” but i gotta say, if you are a publisher calling yourself “this is horror,” you’re setting up expectations in your readers. and while “this is mildly eerie” doesn’t have quite the same impact on the letterhead, it would at least diminish the disappointment of horror fans who will read this novella and think, “buh?” instead of “eek!”
it’s not terrible, but i kept waiting for the horror shoe to drop, and it doesn’t ever, really. there are moments when something really scary could happen, but it never blossoms into terror. i think this would make an excellent silent cartoon, though, where the horror is implicit, shadowed, like in a good japanese horror movie.
as it is, it’s kind of like a rom-com version of Channel Zero: No-End House. underwater. which isn’t the worst thing ever, but is not at all horrific. or horror-fic.
malerman has earned an off-day, but i want chills next time! CHILLS, i say!
come to my blog! -
Two and one half stars rounded up to three.
My thoughts on this novella are that “A House at the Bottom of a Lake” is incorrectly marketed. One is led to believe that this is a horror novella. Wrong. While marketed by “This Is Horror” there is no evidence that any essence of horror has been exposed to this work. Even if one hired the world’s best consulting detective, horror could not be discovered within these pages.
In the first sixty or seventy pages of the book, the author Josh Malerman, presents to the reader the dating habits of a couple of seventeen year olds We, the reader, are constantly reminded by both the narrator and the characters within the story to not ask How or Why certain events are occurring in the storyline. This may be due to the fact that events presented make little or no sense. The reoccurring narrative concerns itself how cleaver the male protagonist is in selecting a creative event to impress the female protagonist with their cleverness.
The remainder of the story revolves our teen couple determining when the “right” time is to consummate their relationship by inserting tab a in slot b. Then both characters suffer from guilt from what little story remains.
Certain portions of the plot lines are not even addressed, for example, the book deals with a certain amount of underwater diving, neither character has ay experience in this activity, yet is proficient in practice without drowning. Where do the two young lustful participants get their wet suites and diving equipment? Where does the air compressor come from and how is it powered In the middle of the lake. These are just a few minor quibbles.
A bigger quibble is the stilted dialog between the story participants. -
Sweet.
Magical.
Eerie.
Beautiful.
This novella is an English teacher's dream! I wish I was 17 again and in Mr. Emmett's English class. The students could read this and discuss all the metaphors and symbolism while Mr. Emmett nods his head with approval and then blows all our minds with his thoughts on this book. He would LOVE this book!
James and Amelia go on a first date--but not your typical first date for two 17 year olds. They venture out on a lake in a canoe-James cursing the fact that he chose to sit in front and can't see Amelia, who is rowing behind him and Amelia giggling to herself because she can see a bit of James' crack peeking out from his swim trunks.
Man, I loved the way Malerman wrote this. It was authentic. Genuine. Painfully sincere and precious-- it immediately made all this nostalgia come flooding into my mind.
The day takes an interesting turn as they discover a hidden lake, accessible to them by squeezing the canoe through a tight tunnel partially hidden in some bushes.
As they explore their new, isolated surroundings they discover the roof line of what appears to be a house submerged underwater.
From this point on, Malerman begins to develop this impressive metaphor for young love. If I could, I'd stand up in my armchair on this foggy, MLK Monday, in my PJ's and slow clap for this sweet, sweet story.
Don't pick this up expecting to be scared-but first love is scary.
And don't think this is a horror novella...although a house underwater is horrifying.
Just enjoy this fairytale-like tale of two young lovers who discover, adventure, explore and dream in A HOUSE AT THE BOTTOM OF A LAKE, where the only one who sees them, is you. -
**3.5-stars**
During the summer they are seventeen, James and Amelia, go on their first date. They are both nervous, but decide to take the risk.
They canoe out on a local lake with some sandwiches and beer; planning to make a day of it. James knows the busy lake well.
He directs them towards a passageway to a connecting lake that sees less traffic; a place for them to be alone.
It's romantic, it's adventurous and the young pair really hit if off.
As they are exploring the second lake they come across another waterway; a tunnel actually, that the canoe will fit into. They're having so much fun, and not wanting to disappoint one another, they figure why not explore more.
Things get a little hairy for a bit, but ultimately they pop out in a third lake. It seems completely unoccupied. They paddle around marveling at their find and then they discover more.
Looking down into the water they spy the top of a house. A house actually submerged under the surface of the lake.
They take turns diving down and cannot believe what they find below the calm surface. A two-story house with an open door and multiple furnished rooms to explore.
It defies all logic. How can this be? The two are absolutely mesmerized by their discovery.
After that first date they begin to spend more and more time at the house. It's presence has altered their lives, but not all is well in their home below the waves.
This is an interesting novella. I have mixed feelings about it. Part of me loves the speculative side of it, that allows the Reader to imagine the outcome and essential meaning. But another equal sized part of me wants more explanation.
Even James and Amelia are confused by it all. How the heck am I supposed to know what is going on?
I did find the writing intriguing. I liked James and Amelia taking a chance on one another and finding and sharing this obsession together. I think they both felt like there was nothing special about themselves and finding this house, and each other, made them special. It gave them meaning.
To me, the house was ominous. It felt like a predator fish that lurks in the deepest parts of the ocean. The one that has a light on its head to attract all the little innocent fishes. By the time they realize they are in danger, it's too late.
You know the one...
Overall, A House at the Bottom of a Lake is a very interesting story. I think I got a good handle on Malerman's style from reading this. I'm definitely interested in picking up more of his work. Personally, I would love to see a continuation of this story.
Thank you so much to the publisher, Del Rey, for providing me with a copy of this to read and review. I appreciate you!
-
"We found a dangerously magic place. A place to fall in love."
Two adventurous teens on a first date happen across a dark tunnel just barely wide enough to squeeze through in "the green canoe with the brown trim."
And, beyond the tunnel, they are shocked to discover A HOUSE AT THE BOTTOM OF A LAKE.....a creepy house they must investigate, a mysterious house full of the bizarre, a house they must keep a secret as the presence begins to consume their every thought, a house where they must be careful and must not ask why...or how.
Josh Malerman has given me one of my very favorite horror reads with BIRD BOX, (don't miss it) and has now given me a bewitching young adult novella of magical realism laced with horror with an ending that suited me just fine, albeit one I would love to discuss.
-
2.5 stars rounded up
What did I just read? I am not sure. Plus, the ending, I do not even know what to say about that.
Two teenagers go on a date, go to a lake, through a tunnel to another lake. What? Only to find a house at the bottom of the lake. I like to think that I am a good swimmer, but I don't think I could hold my breath that long or see so well under water......Nor, do I feel I would do so well with diving equipment with no experience using it. But I am not seventeen, on my first date, in a canoe, on a lake...
Jeepers. This was original. I cannot think of anything like it. But it was also strange yet compulsively readable. I was not quite sure what was going on and yet I had to keep reading to find out, only to have THAT ending and I am still not sure what I read. Especially the ending. I am not even going to mention that as I cannot form a coherent thought on that.
Bizarre, original, strange, interesting, slow. Ugh! I was all over the place reading this novella. One can read this in one sitting. It was a quick read for me. I still do not know what to make of this. I enjoy magical realism but cannot quite figure this one out...and yet.... I could not stop reading it. It's like driving past an car accident. You don't want to look, you know you should not but you can't help it and slow down, do some rubber necking to see the gruesome sight. That pretty much sums up how I feel about this book.
If you read reviews, they are at both sides of the spectrum. You will either really appreciate this one, not like it or be somewhere in the middle with me. You got to hand it to Malerman, he does have original ideas. What goes on in that mind of his? He's creative and has a big imagination.
I think fans of fantasy will enjoy this more, especially YA readers. I'm hit or miss with fantasy but I do appreciate his creativity. The descriptions of the house and their time exploring/experiencing it were my favorite parts of the book.
I received a copy of this book from Random House Publishing - Ballantine Del Rey and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own. -
4.5 stars
Holy crap I enjoyed this so much more than I thought I would. I was hesitant going in because of so many negative reviews on goodreads, but this book was everything. I buddy read this one with my friend Jacqueline and I feel like this was a perfect buddy read because there was so much discussion!
This is a very creepy and short novella about these two teenagers who go out canoeing on a lake for their first date and they discover a house at the bottom of the lake. I've only read
Bird Box from Josh Malerman so far and I freaking loved Bird Box so I've been wanting to read more form him and this book is so short it seemed like the perfect choice. This book works great as a short story and I'm not sure if I would've like this story if it were a full length novel, but it makes for a great short story. There are so many things I love about it, the main one being the atmosphere. This book is written in a way that creates this eerie, creepy feeling that I love experiencing when I read horror. I guess some people are claiming this book isn't horror but I definitely think it is because some scenes gave me fucking chills and I was genuinely creeped-out and terrified for the main characters. It is very atmospheric and disturbing the entire book, which I absolutely loved.
I also love the fact that these teenagers behave like teenagers. They're kind of shy but curious and naive and they just feel so real to me. They are kind of reckless and scared to fall in love and want to explore this scary place together but they don't want to ask any questions about it because they are afraid to know the answer.
I started theorizing what this book was about after 50 pages in, and I'm not sure if I was right or not in the end but I think I have a decent understanding of what this book is about, or what it's trying to say. I am someone who loves and appreciates a good ambiguous ending. I love books that don't spoon-feed me answers to every single question I have and make me think about it for hours afterwards and have good discussions about theories and things like that. It's my favorite type of shit to read, but I also get why a lot of people hate ambiguous endings which is probably why this book has such lo ratings. I felt the same way about this ending as I felt about
The Cabin at the End of the World where I absolutely loved the ending and I feel like a lot of people hated it, which is why that book also probably has a lot of bad reviews but I think it's fucking great. I have such a big fear of deep water and this book definitely played on that fear of mine. It also felt so claustrophobic at times and made me so anxious and just aksljdlajksda I love when horror novels actually make me feel creeped out because they are doing their job.
I just have a lot of thoughts about this book and even though I know this book isn't perfect, I still fucking loved it and I love thought provoking shit and this book had plenty of that. -
WTF!?!??
A hauntingly beautiful, enchanting novella by Josh Malerman, who probably gets my author of 2016 award! His writing is just so good in this and in
Bird Box. Apologies, you've probably seen me mention Bird Box at every opportunity but it's just that good! And this story proves that Josh isn't a one hit wonder. It's a shame he hasn't got many books released as I'd dive straight in if he did.
My favourite thing about Malermans writing? It's quite old school. It's subtle and he lets you come to conclusions on your own instead of bashing you over the head with it which is today's trend.
As for describing the premise of this book...I can't, it just needs read. -
i think that this book is very dependent on the reader, this book works for me because i enjoyed the romance and i viewed the ending as a happy ending, i also think that they very clearly escaped something (who knows) in the end but without the romance i would not have the same feelings. Reading other reviews i saw some people didn’t care for the romance but enjoyed the atmosphere of the book.
I really enjoyed it and i highly recommend it for a summer read. it’s really quick and it keeps you guessing. I enjoyed the fact that the deeper they went into the house the more that they feel in love. it’s very clear they were delusional but it worked for them. whenever they thought about the house they thought about each other as well. the book is weird, yes but it honestly really worked for me. -
An exploration of a first and perhaps enduring love, conveyed in often microscopic detail. Malerman is a superb writer and his teen lovers are endearing creations. I was consistently impressed by their complete realism in terms of personality, inner monologue, affect, and dialogue. Surprisingly enough, I was reminded of a benevolent Robert Aickman when reading this surreal novella: like Aickman's many strange mansions and landscapes, the house at the bottom of a lake makes no rational sense; it could not exist in a natural or logical world, and is best approached as metaphor and inexplicable mystery. Indeed many of the actions of the thoroughly real couple are also inexplicable and unrealistic, except when looking at the story through a symbolic dream lens (and please forgive that pretentious phrase - but it fits). Sadly it appears that many reviewers have taken the wrong approach to the story, and became frustrated and confused by a work that contains little horror and even less that is recognizably rational. I think this is partly due to expectations created by the author's last major novel, as well as the publisher's name ("This Is Horror" - ugh). But it may also be due to a desire to approach A House as a linear and logical work, when it is anything but that, and so hopes of predictable horror thrills became frustrated...
-
2020
So this was a reread for me, which I don’t often do. But I remember really enjoying the creepiness of this one a lot. As for the second time around, I’m just as creeped out.
I feel like I would have taken one look at the roof and been like, NOPE!! Not going in there!! But I assume there’s a pull like moths to a flame, which freaks me out. As if there was no other choice than to go inside. To be scared and have to proceed anyway.
James and Amelia are almost sickeningly cute together. I guess when you’re experiencing that sort of thing together, it changes your relationship and brings you closer together, but damn... Hence the hell no!!!
I’m sure many people aren’t scared by this book and I wouldn’t say I was scared, but freaked out. I kept shaking my head and telling them not to go on. I do love a book that can give me chills and pull me in as much as Josh Malerman’s books can. I recommend this as suspense, not horror and I’m eager to read some more of Malerman’s works!!
2019
This book was intense, mysterious, sensual, and fantastic all in rapid succession. I wasn’t sure what to expect, but know from reading Bird Box that Josh Malerman can really draw a reader into a different world. Once again, Josh Malerman has written a great book, I could hardly put it down. -
3.5/5 stars!
A HOUSE AT THE BOTTOM OF A LAKE is a great story, but it's not a horror story.
These two teens awkwardly make their first date for a canoe ride. Both are nervous and shaky, but end up having a great time, especially after they decided to squeeze themselves through a narrow tunnel into a connected but smaller lake. As they paddle around, they can see the roof of a house from above. Each takes a turn diving down to take a closer look and they were right. It is a house. Under a lake. Of course they make plans to return and explore it more thoroughly and that's where I'll leave off. What will they find inside of the house? You'll have to read this novella to find out!
A HOUSE AT THE BOTTOM OF A LAKE could be described as magical realism, and as that, it was fine. It's not horror, though, which is what I was expecting. As I proceeded with the story, a lot of things didn't really make sense. Can you become scuba divers in only a few days or weeks? Can you even fit, never mind run, an air compressor, with two people and diving gear in one canoe? Can two 17 year old teens spent nights sleeping on a raft together without their parents freaking out? I tried to put all of this out of my mind as the characters did. "Don't ask why. Don't ask how." It worked about as well for me as it did for them-meaning not that well!
Don't get me wrong, this was a nice little tale about two teenagers finding love, (and sex too), but it didn't make a lot of sense at times. Being by Josh Malerman, it was still good, but not great.
*Thanks to the publisher and to NetGalley for the e-ARC I was given, in exchange for my honest feedback. This is it!* -
interesting...
-
Copy furnished by Net Galley for the price of a review.
There's nothing like falling in love for the very first time. Unusual to discover a house under a lake on your first date. I cannot label this horror by any stretch of the imagination. One reviewer suggested it might fit better in a YA/magical realism slot, and I would agree with that assessment. Loved this author's Bird Box and Unbury Carol, but I wasn't able to wrap my arms around this one. -
3.5 Stars ⭐️
Mel 🖤🐶🐺🐾 -
Kitap benim için hayal kırıklığı oldu açıkçası. Neden bilmem beklentim çok farklıydı, çok yüksekti.
Kitap konu itibari ile aşırı merak uyandırıcı. Kano ile ilk randevularına çıkan 17 yaşında iki genç gölün dibinde bir ev keşfediyor. İki katlı, bahçesi var ve ön kapısı açık. Büyük bir heyecana kapılıp evi keşfetmek istiyorlar ve bunun için dalış dersi bile alıyorlar. Gölün dibinde imkansız bir ev var ve bu gençleri heyecanlandırıyor. Yerinden oynamayan tuzluklar, bozulmadan kalmış tablo ve kitaplar. Dayalı döşeli bir ev. Böyle bir şeyin olması imkansızdan onlar asla neden ve nasıl sorularını sormamayı kendilerine kural koyuyorlar.
Kitabı merakla okudum evin sırrının ne olduğunu çok merak ettim. Ama gerçekten okuduğum şeyler beni germek bir yana hayal kırıklığına uğrattı. Beklentimin çok altında kaldı.
Amelia ve James'in eve böylesine kapılması fazla sinir bozucuydu. Özellikle de Amelia'nın kafayı yediğini düşündüm kitap boyunca. Fazlasıyla takıntıya dönüştü çünkü ev ikisi içinde. Evi ilişkileri sayesinde değil de sanki ilişkilerini ev sayesinde edinmişler gibi davranmaları beni daha da sinir etti. Onlar birbirlerini aramaya korktukça ben çıldırdım burda.
Sonu için ise bir şey demek istemiyorum. Umduğumu bulamadığım yinede merakla okuduğum bir kitap oldu. -
Reading Vlog:
https://youtu.be/NQKqgu3NpIU
This is a horror novella. Short and spooky?! How could I possibly find it boring? Well...unfortunately...
There are things I liked about it. Josh Malerman's writing style in many ways is great. I liked the quick and thorough way he would describe things. For example, there was a moment that perfectly described the book and it was "Both seventeen. Both afraid. Both saying yes." I love that. Short, sweet. Gets the point across but also reels you in.
The problem for me is that nothing really happens. There is some eeriness of objects floating and maybe looking like a person. But it wasn't scary at all in my opinion and I kept waiting for there to be at least some sort of action.
This would REALLY work as a movie. I would absolutely watch this and probably love it. But as a book, I wasn't gripped and felt very meh about it overall.
This is definitely an atmospheric read. If that's the horror you're into, this might very well be for you. -
I went into this not knowing what to expect. I know Josh, I know he's a fabulous writer, but this one sounded...different.
It is.
A HOUSE AT THE BOTTOM OF A LAKE is magical, mysterious, creepy, and...well, beautiful. I loved it. I especially loved the ending, which I didn't see coming at all.
Highly recommended. -
I love the concept of this one. This could have been a very good horror, but it wasn't.
-
Having read one of his recent psychological thrillers, I was eager to plunge into this novella by Josh Malerman. James has had his eye on Amelia for a while and has wanted to ask her out but lacked the courage. When the moment arises and they both agree to spend time together, their first date seems cemented. Wanting to try something different, James uses his uncle’s canoe and takes Amelia out on the lake. They paddle together, traversing through a tunnel and into a second connected body of water. This area is much quieter and away from the speedboat traffic. As they drift along, James notices something at the bottom of the lake, pointing it out to Amelia. Could it be a roof... atop an entire house? As they both take the time to peer into the water, James and Amelia learn that the house seems firmly grounded to the lakebed, but cannot fathom what might have brought it there. Taking turns diving down, James and Amelia soon discover that the house is fully furnished and everything is stuck in place—defying any forces of gravity— as if it were meant to be underwater. Planning future dates that focus around more exploration of the house, James and Amelia discover that a love affair is brewing, both between one another and with the house. Other mysteries await the curious reader in this well-developed novella that is distinctly Malerman. Recommended for those who like something a little supernatural and full of symbolism.
I thoroughly enjoyed the single novel I have read by Malerman, but have read some blurbs about others that may surely make their way onto my To Be Read list soon. In this novella, Malerman offers the reader some interesting insight into young love that soon turns into something supernatural. James and Amelia are inseparable throughout much of the piece, making their character development one in the same. Young and still uncertain about life, they share stories about dating and personal struggles before the house takes over all their conversations. Their connection, both physical and mental, gets stronger as the chapters pass, but there is also a struggle that seems to surface, which both pushes them apart and makes their bond even stronger. The house takes on its own persona, becoming more complex and alluring as the story moves forward. Its presence is the crux of the early narrative and soon becomes part of the psychological thrill of the entire novella. The story was decent enough, morphing from a teenage crush into something that envelopes them both and takes over their lives. Obsession, but not of the typical teenager variety. My father, who was an English teacher, would surely rage, as I choose not to delve into the many instances of symbolism throughout the piece. The attentive reader who enjoys finding these instances will be buoyed by the story’s strength on many levels. Malerman offers the reader with some spine tingles akin to some of the great psychological thriller writers of the time, proving that he is not an author to be dismissed. This shorter piece is easily digested in a single day, though the reader may want to take a break when things get a little intense. Perfect for vacation reading, though some may not want to take it to the beach.
Kudos, Mr. Malerman, for another wonderful piece that will keep me thinking. I needed something short, but the memory of the writing lingers!
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
A Book for All Seasons, a different sort of Book Challenge:
https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/... -
This is my second whirl on reading this novella so I’ve updated my review. I am a fan of Josh Malerman so was excited to read this novella. To be honest I went into it with an open mind and was glad I did as this was something quite different. You could not picture what’s coming at all.
We have a young couple, a first date, a lake, a boat and one hell of a discovery. That’s an understatement! The book gradually pulls you in until you are literally hanging to see what is going to happen next. It's haunting and special.
I will say the book wasn't as creepy or scary as I was expecting, so don't worry about being freaked out. It's got a powerful but subtle atmospheric fear element. Some scenes are so visually imaginative that I hope one day this is made for the big screen. It would be amazing.
The lives of these two characters will never be the same again after discovering what is in the lake. Recommended reading for any book lover but don't expect super scary horror, that's not what this book is about, nor is it intended to be. 4 stars from me!
Thanks so much for reading my review! Join me as a friend or follower and feel free to browse my shelves for your next great book! Do share your comments on this book.
You will always get very honest reviews from me. Remember..a book a day keeps brain fog away.😻
-
“What was dark but the absence of light?”
― Josh Malerman, A House at the Bottom of a Lake
I am rating this a five even though there is so much about it that I do not understand. But it is soo readable. And just plain spell binding.
I have always been fascinated by the ocean. And what lies beneath the waves. I remember a dream I had where there was a whole world under water..with human beings living there. Not fish no r mermaids. People.
So this book..reading it..made the fantasy come true for a bit. I do not want to say to much nor give spoilers. But most of it does take place under the sea as two young adults..find.. a house at the bottom of a lake.
The imagery here is ethereal and hauntingly lovely. I could not put this book down while reading it. It is pretty short and is more a Novella then a novel but it is delicious.
SPOILERS; Just a few: But I will be speaking of the ending so stop reading this if you have not read the book:
I am as confused about the ending as anyone but looked it up and I think (think) I get it now. I think it was all symbolism to represent first love. That is one of the theories anyway and it fits. I really think though that each person can draw their own conclusion. And that is another thing that makes this book so special. Highly recommended. -
I swear at this point if you tell me it was all because of the sandwich they ate I will be onboard with it.
So a Mysterious house that is submerged inside water...
And a diving gear that also looks like an astronaut's suit..
Hmm where have I seen this.
Set in 90's this is the story of two teens who on their first date discover a house right at the bottom of their conoe. Because love makes people crazy they decide to dive right in and see if there's any treasure (?)...just kidding!
To well, Netflix and chill underwater.
Throughout the book we see them falling for each other and progressively behave delusional.
To me it felt like the author had this crazy shower thought but he didn't knew how to execute it. I mean if the books stresses on the fact that the reader as well as the characters involved can't ask HOW or WHY everything is happening. Then it kills the curiosity of the reader altogether.
In a wet environment everything starts feeling Dry xD
The idea of the ghost is totally based on their subconscious and how eerie can they make the setting look.
In this case the ghosts are also perverts. I guess those people don't go to hell but instead come to the house at bottom of the lake.
On top of that they are some weak ass ghosts all they can do is make cloths float in water, Maximize gravity, leave wet prints and make scratching noises.
I am dead serious the author could be into skin care routine. The amount of time soft skin is mentioned in the book is unbelievable.
This book can literally be sponsered by...
All in all it wasn't spooky! Just a wierd book filled with BS.
Buddy read with the
[Human] Sorting Hat. -
At 116 pages, it was pretty easy to get through this in one sitting. But as I'm sat here now, attempting a review, I'm not totally sure how I feel about it. It was definitely intriguing, no doubt about that. There was just something about the whole read that felt... unresolved? As if the story never really went anywhere?
-
This is how you write a novella! You come in, bang out some freaky and beautiful shit, and leave me wanting more. Damn you Malerman! Damn you.
There was no sense of being watched, not exactly, it was something much less focused than that. As if all that blackness was one dumb eye, pointed in his direction, capable of simply observing the small teenaged boy at the base of the house, with no brain to transmit the news to. Not watched. But seen.
Lakes are at the top of a list* of shit that freaks me out. Specifically, not being able to see underwater. I was okay snorkeling in Hawaii. I am not okay cliff diving in murky lakes.
*said list also includes (excluding existential fears) tropical birds, snakes, other people's feet, and mild claustrophobia
So A House at the Bottom of a Lake brings on the creepy when two seventeen year olds go canoeing for their first date.
Summer romance is a-bloomin' but they get more than they bargained for under the water. I mean, who goes to the lake thinking, "there sure might be a two story house down there!" They don't want to question a miracle, their miracle, but they do want to explore it.
But one dive down into this mystery isn't enough. Of course they want more, more of each other, and more of the house.
They’d agreed never to ask how or why. But neither had thought to ask who?...They were both afraid. For the first time. Afraid of the house.
The writing is lovely, as I've come to expect from Malerman. Since I will recommend it at every opportunity, read
Bird Box. He has such an effective talent for building suspense and tension, and slowing ratcheting up the stakes with the characters until you don't even notice a turning point, but your heart is beating faster. I could feel the stings on my nerves tightening, just a little bit, with each chapter. It doesn't bring the full-throttle scary, but it comes with a full arsenal of creepy tension.
I will happily read anything
Josh Malerman writes. (Edelweiss denied me for
Black Mad Wheel and it smashed a little bit of my heart.) He consistently has written amazingly creative, tension filled horror. (Check out
Ghastle and Yule as well.) Even when it's not blood and guts flying, hideous monsters, or in your face horror, there's always something churning beneath the surface.
Summary? A lovely little novella full of charm and horror, of summer love and (dangerous) discovery. It made for a perfect Sunday afternoon reading.
PS: Bonus gif I found when searching for canoeing gifs. I have no idea where or when, but this will be useful in my life.
-
Josh Malerman is quickly cementing his reputation as one of the best and most original horror writers on the scene. His first novel, Bird Box constructed almost literally a horror out of nothing and gave a new meaning to the term "see no evil" as its protagonists' fear of seeing created a haunting agoraphobia. In his new novella, A House at the Bottom of a Lake, we have a even quieter but still original horror tale that somehow serves as a setting for one of the most non-horror themes you can find. First love.
Shy and awkward teenagers Amelia and James are going on their first date. It's an inspired idea of James to take her canoeing on an secluded lake. While canoeing, they discover there is a path to another lake that is even more secluded. At the bottom of this lake is a intact two story house. What begins as a novelty to the two teens become an obsession but one that is welcomed as they swim down to the house to explore. Each visit bonds one to the other as well as to the eeriness of the house.
And that is what makes this tale so brilliant. This house at the bottom of a lake, at least the house as Malerman described it, is an impossible thing. We know that good rarely comes out of something so unusual and sudden. In other words, it is probably a lot like our first love. At the beginning our two protagonists, when they decide to return to explore the house via scuba gear, agree not to question the "why" and "how" of such a house lest it loses its wonder. Does that sound like a good rule for something else? The novella feels a bit like an analogy to me but what the analogy means is slightly elusive, the way I believe the author wants it to be. Perhaps the author also doesn't want us to question the hows and whys either and, when we inevitably do, he throws a twist at the end that makes us rethink it all.
So what is the house all about? What is the horror part of this novel? That is the part that needs to remain unsaid unless the readers loses the wonder of the reading before they even start. Malerman has a distinct poetic feel that works well in this story. The two teenagers are well rounded enough to feel familiar to us. The first love scenario is one of those baits that brings out the dreamer in us and maybe a bit of nostalgia. When the fear hits, we are already invested in the characters. Both Bird Box and this one works so well because they are character driven horrors. The real terror remains elusive but what it does to the imagination is where it is really at.
You are probably not surprised when I say I recommend this novella...highly. It is a fast and easy read but it deceptively complex and even hopeful perhaps. In fact, it would be a great horror book for those who claim they don't like horror. It is certainly destined for my list of top ten books of the year. -
I almost called on Grumpy Cat for another review appearance. But Grumps is for special occasions, so I’ll save him for another time. Here’s the thing with this book: It just wasn’t scary. I felt the hair on the back of my neck stand up at one point, but that may well have been the ceiling fan. Now, if you have fear of the water, especially being under the water – down where it’s dark and creepy, and something may be sidling up close, unbeknownst to you – then it may be a different experience. I don’t think so though. There were ample opportunities for scares while these two teen lovers found their way around the dark rooms of this house beneath the lake. And what’s that house doing down there? Beats me.
What Josh Malerman did with his other book, Bird Box, was phenomenal. It was unique concept and it worked. Here not so much. Unique, yes, but it doesn’t even feel like the same author. So skip this one. Read Bird Box instead.
