| Title | : | The Sinner (Rizzoli Isles, #3) |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | - |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Paperback |
| Number of Pages | : | 419 |
| Publication | : | First published August 19, 2003 |
The Sinner (Rizzoli Isles, #3) Reviews
-
Najlepszy tom z dotychczasowych!
-
3.5 Stars. (Review contains slight spoilers for books 1 and 2 of the series).
Honestly, I didn't enjoy this as much as book 1 & 2. It was different to the others because instead of heavily relying on the surgeon (and the apprentice), it focused on Rizzoli & Isles solving a few cases and dealing with personal issues. I did find it weird that Rizzoli didn't really think of the Surgeon at all. He went from dominating the first two books, to disappearing and I know it might be because she doesn't see him as a threat anymore but I just found it odd. I did miss the Surgeon's perspective and I missed that dynamic they had because that is probably one of the best aspects of the series. So instead of getting the Surgeon's POV, we got Maura Isles' POV alongside Rizzoli's. Unfortunately I didn't really like her. I found her intriguing in book 1 & 2, but it turns out getting access to her internal monologue wasn't what I thought it would be. She's quite similar to Rizzoli but she lacks the likeability and I didn't find her interesting. I kind of wish that it was just Rizzoli's POV in this book because reading Isles' POV just made me like the book less.
I thought the story was interesting enough but I thought the story was hijacked by each woman's love/personal life. I did think that the second half of the book was better because that is when everything started to connect and really make sense. I did wish that the crime aspect was more prominent and more developed. It was quite predictable which was unfortunate but I thought Gerritsen had a really good idea. I also didn't find the writing as enjoyable (not sure if that had to do with me not enjoying Isles' POV or if it just wasn't as good). I read this book because I wanted something that was quite addictive but it didn't fully deliver. I still think this is a good series and I will keep reading on. Hopefully I just grow to like Isles as a character.
I know it sounds like I'm sort of bashing this book but I did give it 3.5 stars, which isn't bad and I did enjoy it. I guess I was just a little disappointed because I know how good Gerritsen can write and this just wasn't up there for me. I would recommend this series.
--------------------------------------
"There would be comfort in it, she thought. The ease of knowing, at each dawn, how the day will go. No surprises, no turmoil." -
It all starts with the murder of a nun within her abbey along with the assault on another. As Jane Rizzoli and Maura Isles investigate, it leads them toward some highly surprising and divergent paths, including connections to other circumstances.
This is the book where we learn more about Maura Isles, finally. Her voice is the strongest though Jane gets considerable space. Nicknamed the Queen of the Dead because of what she does and her gothic look, Maura had to be more complex than a caricature (she is) and that unfolds. And, her relationship with Jane Rizzoli develops beyond their roles of detective and medical examiner.
There were also personal elements for both that added texture to them as characters and the story. Both became more relatable here because of it and their work dynamics played out well. I really liked the story because of this and the complexity of the cases. I was a little blindsighted by the excellent twists at the end though the clues were there. I also listened to the story and Anna Fields did a great job but her pronunciation of Jane’s last name (Ritz-zoli) drove me nuts. Otherwise, this was a very good reading experience. -
“Bless me, Father, for I have sinned.” No one comes out and says those words in Tess Gerritsen’s
The Sinner. This is the third suspense novel in her Rizzoli and Isles series, and I confess, it’s a practically a sin that I haven’t gotten around to reading this book until now. It’s been three years since I read
The Apprentice, and as many avid thriller mystery readers know, there are so many amazing books out there just waiting to be read that it’s hard to get to even a small percentage of them. Now that I’ve returned to Gerritsen’s series, I won’t be waiting another three years to read the next one.
The first two books focused primarily on Detective Jane Rizzoli. This time around, we get to know Medical Examiner Dr. Maura Isles a lot better. Called "the Queen of the Dead" by medical students and some of the staff, Maura is a dedicated pathologist who believes that she has a duty to the deceased. She is calm in the face of the most gruesome crime scenes, a controlled, efficient professional. Rizzoli, on the other hand, is testy these days. She’s tired, cranky, and not feeling like herself. It’s days before Christmas, and the winter weather and holiday stress is getting to her. Must be the flu, she says.
When they are called to a crime scene at an abbey for a contemplative order of nuns, Rizzoli and Isles face challenges different from any they have faced before. These are women who do not venture out into the world except on rare occasions. Who would want to harm any of them, much less kill them? These are women of faith. Dr. Isles is a person of science. Detective Rizzoli, too, wants answers the sisters cannot give because their faith simply does not let them imagine the possibilities. Can there be a middle ground?
As a medical examiner in the Boston area, Dr. Isles has more than one case, naturally. What are the chances that she would have another death related to the murder at the convent? Little by little, Tess Gerritsen weaves her story. Along the way, she reveals some secrets. I was feeling proud of myself for figuring things out as I went along. I was putting two and two together and getting four. So far, so good. As for the main piece of the puzzle, however, I was waiting for that one big aha moment when I would have at least an inkling. I did, actually, and it was a good hunch, but I was slightly off the mark. Only slightly.
Do we find out what was bugging Jane Rizzoli those days leading up to Christmas? Read the book. And better yet, to find out if there is any passion and joy under that “Queen of the Dead” mask that Maura Isles wears, read the book. Who killed Sister Camille – and why? Read the book.
I’m glad I did, and I look forward to continuing this series very soon!
5 stars -
Another well-written entry in Gerritsen’s Rizzoli and Isles series... even though this is really the first time we get a chance to meet the ultra professional ME Maura Isles, I finally understand what folks like about their match up.
And even if the mystery was actually a bit cliched (I won’t give it away but you’ll know what I mean when you read it), it was still an interesting mix of characters — victims and villains alike.
I especially liked that Jane Rizzoli’s life is changing as Maura Isles is introduced to readers. This book was the start of both a professional and personal relationship which was spurred on by personal issues first. I look forward to continuing this series! -
The third book in the Rizzoli & Isles series and we get to know the characters better. Especially Maura Isles who until this book seemed to have more of a supporting role. The story opens with Isles performing an autopsy when she receives a call from detective Jane Rizzoli asking her to come to a crime scene.
The scene is the chapel of Our Lady of Divine Light, a cloistered convent. There two nuns were savagely attacked. 20 year old Sister Camille is dead. The other is critically injured. Who would attack nuns? And why? Sister Ursula is too badly injured to talk. Sister Camille is dead but maybe she can tell Maura Isles what happened. During the autopsy Dr. Isles makes a shocking discovery. Sister Camille had recently given birth. Who is the father? A suspect obviously.
With the exception of Sister Camille the sisters at Our Lady of Divine Light are all elderly and cannot help in the investigation but there is one person who no one really pays any attention to. Noni, the daughter of the cook / housekeeper, may be young but she is very observant and provides some invaluable clues. Then another body is found, mutilated beyond recognition. An attempt to hide the identity?
As Rizzoli and Isles continue their investigations into the deaths a link is discovered. A secret that someone is going to great lengths to make sure remains hidden. Things are not always what they seem at first. Maura Isles finds the crimes hit close to home. She is known as the "Queen of the Dead" because of her work and goth appearance but she had a life before she became a medical examiner in Boston. In this story we get to know more about that life and I found myself liking her more. The reader also learns about a change in Jane Rizzoli's life and a decision she will have to make.
I enjoyed this book very much and recommend it to anyone who enjoys the thriller / suspense genre. Especially those with strong female leads. -
Even though I have already read and reviewed The Surgeon and The Apprentice, Tess' previous books in the series, I still feel that it's such a perkiness of mine to review any book written by this genious (I emphasize: genious!). Gerritsen, one more time, now through The Sinner, made me hook into her writing until the end, NOT letting me to put it down, despite a few flaws I found that I dare myself to point again.
A crime envolving two nuns, in the circuntances presented by Jane and Maura therewith the investigation of the case, conduces us to initially match the name of the book to the probable "nickname" that could characterize one of the victims. However, two more crimes — a woman that can't be identified plus a massacre in a village in India years before — come to the surface and probably discard any previously settled teory by the readers about the ending of the story. Also, it's disclosed that the three crimes are, at last, all connected.
During several pages of the book, we're shown Maure Isles' life in and out of the morgue more throughly. It's soon noticed that the focus is aimed at introducing the patologist as a protagonist of the series — just like the policialwoman-detective Jane Rizzoli is in the previous book, The Apprentice.
This point of introducing one more protagonist into the series can turn it into a tiring reading at certain moments. Besides, can shadow the awesomeness the ending could have had — knowing the talent of Tess Gerritsen as a writer — and conduce the readers not to enjoy the book, but to even let them a little disappointed.
Nothing of this, though, mean that being acquainted more deeply with the character has turned The Sinner into a wearisome book. On the contrary: I've met a less cold and "self-loved" Jane Rizzoli, intimately braver to relieve everything, accepting her mistakes and wills, and to push off all the fear and weakness she denied to have. I've also met a new friend, Maura, who shows to be a better positive person, with a big heart, but not allowed to feel completely happy, considering her familiar, relationships problems. We get to, soon, relate ourselves to Maura and Jane, two protagonists that we, certainly, will miss once we have to say goodbye. -
If you haven't noticed, I'm obsessed with this series. Despite how different the books are from the tv show, reading them really makes me want to binge watch the show ( I need to see if its streaming anywhere).
The Sinner is about the death of a 20 year old nun and the nearly fatal assault of an elderly nun. While investigating Rizzoli and Isles discover the dead nun had recently given birth(not a spoiler, that's on the back cover).
I was happy to finally get more Maura Isles. The first two books contain very little Isles but in The Sinner we get a Isles center storyline involving her ex-husband. The murder mystery at the heart of this book wasn't as interesting as the first two books but the character development of Jane Rizzoli and Maura Isles more than made up for it. Jane's storyline is the B-story but could just as easily been the main storyline.
I'm really enjoying this series and I really needed this book last night after watching All 4 hours of Leaving Neverland. This book served as a stress reliever.
If you're looking for a female centered crime series I think you'll love the Rizzoli & Isles series. -
A complex case for Jane Rizzoli and Maura Isles with some red herrings thrown in. The case kicks off in with the violent assault of two nuns in a convent, leaving one dead and one grievously injured. One has recently returned from India and one is new to the order and has a shameful secret - but is that the reason they were attacked? The gruesome find of a hideously mutilated body in an abandoned building also keeps Rizzoli and Isles busy. Both must also deal with their love lives as Maura's ex husband turns up wanting a second chance and Jane must confront her feelings about FBI agent Gabriel Dean. After some twists and turns and some top class investigative and forensic detective work a shocking international cover-up is discovered, but not before a thrilling ending.
-
4.5/5
First there was Detective Jane Rizzoli, then you were introduced to Maura Isles. Now you get to know her more as Tess Gerritsen tells you a part of the story through her point of view. You get to see where she lives and how she works beyond the operating table in the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner.
Two nuns were attacked in a Convent, one a young runaway from a family of skeptics and the other is an old-aged humanitarian. Each had a deep dark secret, but who was the reason for the attack?
In Maura's personal life, she is reunited with her ex, a philanthropist doctor, who just happens to be home for the holidays. While Jane, the investigating Detective on the case has been feeling sick for the last few days and the reason of her sickness is something she rather not have her colleagues know about. Especially not Agent Gabriel Dean, the FBI Agent who helped her in The Apprentice.
Lepers, a corporate scam, religion, love and family are some of the topics that come up in this excellent page-turner that surpasses the previous book.😍 -
Tess Gerritsen Fans Group Link - my second read
In Boston's snow filled December, Reverend Mother Mary Clement of Our Lady of Divine Light, needs help:
(1) Sister Ursula Rowland(68) - beaten into "comatose", a trained nurse back after a India mass slaughter in a abandoned Octogon Chemical plant.
(2) Sister Camille Maginnes(22) - murdered, was pregnant & baby found dead - consensual or rape? DNA tests needed to clear Father Daniel Brophy. They talk to Randell(her father) & Lauren(stepmother) to see if it was incest by someone at her grandmother's funeral that occurred 9 months ago.
(3) Next, a India woman found with hand & feet amputated, they name her, "Rat Lady".
Jane's FBI Agent friend, Gabriel Dean, & a Dr. Matthew Sutcliff, Univ of Vermont enter to help.
They need to determine the father of the Sister Camille's child? Effect of India's Octogon Chemical plant? Can the 3 murders be tied to one? Was it a Paid killer? -
A savage attack on two nuns within the cloistered walls of Our Lady of Divine Light prompts Detective Jane Rizzoli to call on the assistance of pathologist Dr Maura Isles. The attack has left one of the sisters dead and the other just barely clinging to life.
This is the 3rd book in the Rizzoli and Isles series but the first to primarily feature Maura Isles. A lot more emphasis is placed on the forensics around post mortems and autopsies and Tess Gerritsen goes into quite graphic detail with more than one corpse on Isles’ table (the squeamish should perhaps hesitate before reading). Not surprisingly, it’s through Isles’ forensic work that the major breaks in the case are found including one or two real doozies.
This book also serves to provide a deeper introduction into Maura helping to flesh out her character more fully. We learn a little about her past and the status of her somewhat complicated relationship with her ex-husband.
This proves to be a fascinating case which is not quite a locked-room mystery but, given the closed convent in which the nuns live, can almost be treated as one. It’s hardly surprising, then, that the case is taken into vastly unexpected directions with a series of well-timed twists that kept me slightly off-balance.
As already mentioned it’s the work performed by Maura that reveals the crucial tiny links in the case that are then taken over by Rizzoli and developed. It gives us a glimpse into the way in which the pair effectively team up to get the most out of a good medical examiner and a competent detective.
It augurs well for future books in the series which I am looking forward to reading soon. -
The Sinner is a macabre thriller. If you have a vivid imagination, this book will probably gross you out in parts. Besides, "the case" Rizzoli and Isles have some personal dilemmas to face. This is perhaps the best book of this series I have read so far.
This is a well written murder mystery featuring Rizzoli, the tough female detective, and her colleague and friend, Isles. Maura Isles is the Medical Examiner (ME) who "processes" the dead involved in violent crimes. In this story, a brutal murder occurs involving two nuns in a Catholic convent. Rizzoli and Isles are called to the crime scene.
The author takes the reader through the processing of clues. There are many twists and turns and a few a false leads that I was suckered into. In spite of the story time frame being set at Christmas, there is little cheer in the story until the very end. I found I could relate to this sentiment. I also found my mouth watering at the description of the Christmas dinner being prepared at the Jane Rizzoli's parents house.
Here's a story where I was totally absorbed in the mystery and its characters. -
Good, solid story with some interesting threads and twists.
Like many other people, I watched the Rizzoli and Isles TV show and quite liked it. Although it wasn't the TV show that made me start reading these books. I knew about this series before and read other books by this author. And even though I was aware that the show is very, very loosely based on the book series, it still surprised me a lot when I read
The Surgeon how many differences there are. This is my second book in this series and this time I was even more prepared. And yet I was surprised again. However this time at least the book was focused on the work of Rizzoli and Isles.
From reading the first book in this series, I remember that I didn't like Rizzoli very much and I generally had a problem with poor knowledge of the characters. And this problem is at least partially solved in this book. I'm not convinced that I like Rizzoli or Isles now, but at least I got to know them much better. And I can say with full conviction that they are interesting and complicated characters that add a lot to this story.
And the story is quite good, though maybe not as scandalous as a dead nun in a closed order would suggest. The full potential of this thread seems not to be fully used, but when I read the book, I had no problem with it. The solutions invented by the author are interesting and not obvious. There are a few things I didn't expect. And the whole story flows smoothly and without unnecessary lengthy fragments. Everything has its purpose. The action is swift and fast-paced with numerous twists and turns.
I am also satisfied with the ending, I mean solving the case, or actually a few cases. As for the events in the personal lives of Rizzoli and Isles, and especially Rizzoli, I have mixed feelings. But this is probably mainly due to the fact that I am surprised by this thread. I don't think I know Rizzoli well enough yet to be involved in her life. But it might be interesting in the next books. At the moment, I think I like Isles more, I find her more interesting.
This book has definitely encouraged me to read the others in this series. -
3.8
-
দ্য সিনার
কনভেন্টে হুট করেই নৃশংসভাবে খুন হল একজন সুন্দরী, তরুণী নান। আরেকজন বয়স্ক নানের অবস্থাও মৃতপ্রায়। এই খুনের তদন্তের দায়িত্ব গিয়ে পড়লো বোস্টন পিডির জেন রিজোলির কাঁধে। মৃত নানের অটোপসি করতে গিয়ে ডক্টর মৌরা আইয়েলস মুখোমুখি হল ভয়ঙ্কর এক রহস্য ও সত্যির। কে খুন করেছে নানকে? কোনো রিচ্যুয়াল মার্ডার নাকি উদ্দেশ্যজনক খুন এটা?
পরিত্যক্ত এক রেস্টুরেন্টের মধ্যে তরুণীর ভয়ানক বীভৎস এক লাশ পাওয়া গেল। খুনি তরুণীকে খুন করে তার হাত ও পায়ের পাতা কেটে নিয়ে গেছে। সেই সাথে খুবলে নিয়েছে মুখের একপাশ। কে এই সাইকোপ্যাথ খুনি? কি তার উদ্দেশ্য? নান হত্যা ও এই তরুণীর বীভৎস লাশের মধ্যে কোনো সম্পর্ক আছে নাকি দুটো ঘটনায় সম্পূর্ণ বিচ্ছিন্ন?
পাঠ প্রতিক্রিয়া:-
রিজোলি ও আইয়েলস সিরিজের তৃতীয় বই দ্য সিনার। টেস গেরিটসেনের আগের বইগুলো পড়ার অভিজ্ঞতা থেকেই জানতাম এই বইয়েও অনেক মেডিকেল টার্ম ও অটোপসি টার্ম থাকবে। আসলেই প্রচুর মেডিকেল টার্ম ছিল। মেডিকেল থ্রিলার হিসেবে ঠিকই আছে। খুনের বর্ণনা, অটোপসির বর্ণনা কয়েক জায়গায় বেশ ক্রিপি। যেটা ভালো লেগেছে। কাহিনীর বিল্ড আপ বেশ ভালো। গল্প যতই এগিয়েছে রহস্য ঘনীভূত হয়েছে। একসময় রহস্যের জাল ছিড়ে বেড়িয়েছেও আর সেটাও মেডিকেল সায়েন্সের ওপর ভিত্তি করেই। লেখক অনেক সুন্দর করে কাহিনী মিলিয়েছেন। উপমহাদেশের একটা বিরল রোগ সম্পর্কে ভালো জানতে পারবেন এই বইয়ে। উপন্যাসের প্রয়োজনেই রিজোলি ও মৌরা আইয়েলসের ব্যক্তিগত জীবনের ওপর একটু বেশি আলোকপাত করা ��য়েছে। এজন্য মাঝে একটু স্লো লেগেছে। সর্বশেষে, বইয়ের টুইস্ট নিয়ে কথা বলা যাক। দুটো টুইস্ট ছিল। একটা বেশ ভালোই, ধাক্কা দেয়ার মতো। আর শেষ টুইস্টটা ঠিক মাথা ঘুরানো না হলেও ধারণা করা প্রায় অসম্ভব। সান্তা রিকি আপুর অনুবাদ বুঝতে তেমন কোনো সমস্যা হয়নি। মেডিকেল, মিস্ট্রি, বীভৎস খুন সম্পর্কে আগ্রহী থাকলে বইটা পড়তে পারেন।
বইটির অসাধারণ কিছু প্রচ্ছদ করেছেন সজল চৌধুরী ভাইয়া।
দ্য সিনার
ভূমিপ্রকাশ
টেস গের��টসেন
অনুবাদ: সান্তা রিকি
প্রচ্ছদ: সজল চৌধুরী।
পৃষ্টা: ৩৩৫ -
Rare is the thriller that can scare me enough to leave the lights on at night, while bringing me to tears. The Sinner did both. Filled with more twists and turns than a labyrinth, The Sinner throws a curve at both Jane Rizzoli and ME Maura Isles. Jane must deal with a huge obstacle in her life as well as her relationship with Gabriel Dean, and Maura must face her own ghosts in the form of her ex-husband.
This book serves as a pivotal point in the character development of both women, and is a must-read if you are a follower of the series.
The mystery itself is tantalizing and surprising. No plot spoilers here -- you must read it yourself to see how the death of two nuns in Boston relates to a terrorist attack on a colony of lepers in India. A true page-turner. -
Odusevljena cak sam i seriju pocela da gledam.
-
3.5
-
|| রিভিউ ||
বইঃ দ্য সিনার (রিজোলি অ্যান্ড আইয়েলস #৩)
মূলঃ টেস গেরিটসেন
অনুবাদঃ সান্তা রিকি
প্রকাশকঃ ভূমিপ্রকাশ
প্রকাশকালঃ সেপ্টেম্বর, ২০১৯
ঘরানাঃ মেডিক্যাল থ্রিলার/সাইকোলজিক্যাল থ্রিলার
প্রচ্ছদঃ সজল চৌধুরী
পৃষ্ঠাঃ ৩৩৬
মুদ্রিত মূল্যঃ ৪৪০ টাকা
ধরণঃ হার্ডকভার
কাহিনি সংক্ষেপঃ তুষারের চাদরে ঢাকা পড়েছে বোস্টন শহর। ক্রিসমাসের প্রস্তুতি নিচ্ছে শহরের অধিবাসীরা৷ এমন শান্তিপূর্ণ একটা সময়েই ঘটে গেলো একটা অশান্তিজনক ঘটনা। বোস্টনের এক কনভেন্টের পরিত্যক্ত চ্যাপেলে আবিস্কৃত হলো অল্পবয়সী এক নানের লাশ। সেই সাথে গুরুতর আহত অবস্থায় উদ্ধার করা হলো বয়স্ক আরেকজন নানকে। কেউ একজন ভয়াবহ আক্রোশ নিয়ে মাথায় আঘাত করেছে তাদের। দেয়ালে ঝোলানো ক্রুসিফিক্সের সামনে ও চ্যাপেলের পুরোটা জুড়ে শুধু নানদের রক্ত। ঈশ্বরের উপাসনালয়ে তাঁরই একান্ত দুই উপাসিকাকে এমন ভয়াবহভাবে কে আঘাত করতে পারে!
বোস্টন পুলিশ ডিপার্টমেন্টের চৌকস ডিটেকটিভ জেন রিজোলি ও মৃতদের রানী হিসেবে পরিচিত মেডিক্যাল এক্সামিনার মৌরা আইয়েলস কেসটার দায়িত্ব নিলো। মৌরার পোস্টমর্টেমে খুন হওয়া অল্পবয়সী নান ক্যামিলি ম্যাজাইনেসের ব্যাপারে ভয়াবহ এক গোপন সত্য সামনে চলে এলো। যে সত্য অবাক করে দিলো সবাইকে। আরো কয়েকজন মানুষকে সন্দেহের কাতারে ফেললো ডিটেকটিভ রিজোলি যাদের মধ্যে ফাদার ব্রফি সহ ক্যামিলির পরিবারের সদস্যরাও আছে।
এদিকে বহুদিন আগেই পরিত্যক্ত হয়ে যাওয়া এক রেস্টুরেন্ট থেকে ছোটখাটো গড়নের অভিবাসী এক মহিলার বিকৃত লাশ পাওয়া গেলো। খুনি তাকে শুধু খুন করেই ক্ষান্ত হয়নি, বরং ভয়াবহ পৈশাচিকতায় হতভাগ্য মহিলার মুখমণ্ডলের মাংস, হাতের কব্জিদ্বয় ও দুই পায়ের পাতাও কেটে নিয়ে গেছে। মেডিক্যাল এক্সামিনার মৌরার স্কালপেলের নিচে লাশটা যখন এলো, জানা গেলো আরো বিভ্রান্তিকর একটা তথ্য। খুন ��য়ে যাওয়া 'ইঁদুর মানবী' আক্রান্ত ছিলো কুষ্ঠ রোগে।
প্রায় এক মাস আগে ভারতের অন্ধ্রপ্রদেশে হায়দ্রাবাদ শহর থেকে বেশ অনেকটা দূরের এক প্রত্যন্ত ছোট্ট গ্রামে ঘটে গেছিলো ব্যাখ্যার অতীত এক ভয়ঙ্কর ঘটনা। বারা নামের মাত্র ১০০ জন অধিবাসীর এই গ্রামটাকে কারা যেন রাতের আঁধারে পুড়িয়ে খাক করে রেখে গেছিলো। রীতিমতো বড়সড় একটা জ্বলন্ত চিতায় পরিণত হয়েছিলো গ্রামটা। ডিটেকটিভ রিজোলির সামনে এই ব্যাপারটাও একটা কোয়েশ্চিন মার্ক হিসেবে দেখা দিলো একটা সময়। ততোক্ষণে অবশ্য এফবিআই এজেন্ট গ্যাব্রিয়েল ডিনও মাথা ঢুকিয়ে দিয়েছে তদন্তের মধ্যে।
বিখ্যাত অ্যাক্টিভিস্ট ও ওয়ান আর্থের গুরুত্বপূর্ণ ব্যক্তিত্ব ডা. ভিক্টর ব্যাঙ্কসের সাথে ডিভোর্স হয়ে গেছিলো মেডিক্যাল এক্সামিনার মৌরার। আজ তিন বছর পর ভিক্টর আবারো যেন ফিরে আসতে চাইছে ওর জীবনে। তাকে আবারো নিজের জীবনে গ্রহণ করার ব্যাপারে ভাববে, নাকি এতোগুলো লাশের ব্যাপারে - দ্বিধাদ্বন্দে পড়ে গেলো সে। আর অপরদিকে নিজের ভেতরে নতুন এক প্রাণের উপস্থিতি টের পাওয়া ডিটেকটিভ রিজোলি এফবিআই এজেন্ট ডিনের সাথে আবারো লিখনো সহজ হতে পারবে কিনা জানেনা। জেন রিজোলি ও মৌরা আইয়েলস, এই দুই নারীর পেশাজীবন ও ব্যক্তিগত জীবনের টানাপোড়েন যেন চলতে লাগলো একই সরলরেখায়।
শীতল চ্যাপেলে খুন হওয়া একজন নান থেকে অজ্ঞাতপরিচয় এক মহিলার খুনের রহস্য, সবখানেই ক্রমান্বয়ে দৌড়ে বেড়াতে লাগলো ডিটেকটিভ রিজোলি ও মেডিক্যাল এক্সামিনার মৌরা। আর এভাবেই একটা সময় পর্দা সরে গেলো সত্যের ওপর থেকে, যে সত্যের মুখোমুখি হতে হলো সবাইকেই।
পাঠ প্রতিক্রিয়াঃ টেস গেরিটসেনের পাঠকপ্রিয় রিজোলি অ্যান্ড আইয়েলস সিরিজের তৃতীয় বই 'দ্য সিনার'। পূর্ববর্তী দুটো বই 'দ্য সার্জন' ও দি 'অ্যাপ্রেন্টিস'-এর পর লেখিকা তাঁর এই বইয়ে আবারো এক বিভীষিকার সাথে পরিচয় করিয়ে দিয়েছেন তাঁর পাঠকদের। 'দ্য সিনার'-এর পটভূমিও বোস্টন শহর। কাহিনির শুরুটাই কেমন যেন চমকে দেয়া। যখন দেখলাম ক্রিশ্চিয়ান কনভেন্টের চ্যাপেলের মতো পবিত্র জায়গায় দুজন নিরীহ নানের ওপর আক্রমণ হয়েছে, চমকে গেছি তখনই। এরপর আমাকে আরো চমকে দিয়েছে নৃশংসভাবে খুন হওয়া নানের ব্যাপারে লুকানো এক সত্য ও সেই সত্যের শেকড়।
ডিটেকটিভ জেন রিজোলির রাফ অ্যান্ড টাফ মনোভাবে কিছুটা চিড় ধরতে দেখা গেছে টেস গেরিটসেনের এই উপাখ্যানে। অবশ্য এর পেছনে যৌক্তিক ও মানবিক আবেগসৃষ্ট কারণও ছিলো। পক্ষান্তরে মেডিক্যাল এক্সামিনার মৌরা আইয়েলসের চাপা স্বভাবের বাইরেও যে একটা দিক আছে, সেটাও জানতে পেরেছি তার প্রাক্তন স্বামী ডা. ভিক্টর ব্যাঙ্কসের আগমনে। 'দ্য সার্জন' ও 'দি অ্যাপ্রেন্টিস'-এর মতো 'দ্য সিনার' অতোটা টানটান উত্তেজনাকর না হলেও প্রধান দুই চরিত্র রিজোলি ও মৌরার নিজেদের চিত্তাকর্ষক গল্পগুলো দিয়ে পুষিয়ে নিয়েছি।
যেহেতু এটা একটা মেডিক্যাল থ্রিলার তাই স্বাভাবিকভাবেই এতে প্রচুর পরিমাণে মেডিক্যাল রিলেটেড টার্ম এসেছে। বইটা পড়ে কুষ্ঠ রোগ সম্পর্কে অনেক অজানা ব্যাপারে যেমন জেনেছি, তেমন পোস্টমর্টেম সম্পর্কিত কিছু ব্যাপারেও ধারণা আরো স্পষ্ট হয়েছে। যদিও কাঠখোট্টা মেডিক্যাল রিলেটেড টার্মগুলোর বেশিরভাগই পড়ার প্রায় পরপরই ভুলে গেছি। আমার স্মৃতিশক্তি খুব একটা সুবিধার না।
সান্তা রিকির অনুবাদ ভালো ছিলো। বিশেষ করে তাঁর পূর্ববর্তী কাজগুলোর চেয়ে এটাকে সাবলীলতার দিক থেকে আমি এগিয়ে রাখবো। ভুল-ভ্রান্তির দেখা বলতে গেলে পাইনি। সজল চৌধুরীর করা প্রচ্ছদটা বেশ ভালো লেগেছে আমার কাছে। বইটার বাঁধাই ও কাগজের মানও ভালো ছিলো।
সংযুক্তিঃ আমার কাছে 'দ্য সিনার'-এর যে কপিটা আছে সেটার প্রচ্ছদ বর্তমানকালের কপিগুলোর চেয়ে আলাদা৷ কারণ, বইটার প্রি-অর্ডারের সময় একটা বিশেষ অফারে এই প্রচ্ছদটা পাওয়ার সুবিধা ছিলো। আমি সেটাই নিয়েছিলাম। তবে অন্য প্রচ্ছদটাও সুন্দর। ওটাও করেছেন সজল চৌধুরী। তাঁর করা প্রচ্ছদগুলো সত্যিই অনেক চমৎকার হয়। তাঁর জন্য শুভকামনা।
ব্যক্তিগত রেটিংঃ ৪/৫
গুডরিডস রেটিংঃ ৪.১৩/৫
© শুভাগত দীপ
(১০ নভেম্বর, ২০১৯, সন্ধ্যা ৬ টা ১৮ মিনিট; নিজ রুম, নাটোর) -
° if you never try, you'll never know
Omg, skaitai ir mėgaujiesi, tiesiog širdis džiaugiasi! Pagaliau šioje dalyje prasimušė jausmai, o visa įtampa perėjo į antrą planą. Klausimų kyla labai daug - kas, kodėl žiauriai? Ar patiko? Labai! -
Entrei neste livro completamente envolvido e aterrei nas últimas linhas bastante satisfeito. Mais um policial muito bom!
Tudo começa com as duas freiras que foram atacadas com uma violência brutal no solo sagrado da Capela. Uma delas teve morte. A outra entrou num estado mortalmente critico. Quem as atacou e porquê? Fiz todas as deduções e falhei em tudo. A ligação deste crime com o outro crime vai dar a um desfecho surpreendente e chocante!
E, é neste livro que a detetive, Rizzoli, e a rainha dos mortos, Maura, duas mulheres possuidoras de carapaças duras, fisicamente frias e autoritárias, invenciveis de nariz firme, tornam-se vulneráveis e expostas... Dada a dureza das suas profissões e dos crimes ocorridos, esquecemos de que elas são mulheres. Por isto, deu-me bastante agrado de ver o lado apaixonante, doce e feminino destas duas heroínas.
Gostei bastante!! E que venham mais livros da Tess Gerritsen!
Foi perfeito ler este cartucho nesta altura, pois todo o enredo da história desenrola-se precisamente na época natalícia com a queda dos flocos de neve e o uivo do frio cortante. -
RATING: 4 STARS
(Review Not on Blog)
I really enjoyed the third book in the series - it continues to deliver on the gritty suspense! This novel has a new case and we get to know more about the elusive Maura Isles. This series is more case driven than about the characters but never fear as the books progress we do learn more about them. I am a fan of Jane's mom. -
Serinin her kitabı gibi bittiğinde bi sonraki kitabı fazlasıyla merak uyandırıyor. Ayrıca Rizzoli ve İsles hakkın da daha çok detaya girerek karakterlerin okuyucu tarafından daha ayrıntılı tanınmasını sağlamış.Aslında yapılacak çokta bi yorum yok çünkü eksik yorum yapıp kitaba haksızlık yapmak istemiyorum. Özet olarak serinin diğer kitapları okuyanlar mutlaka devam etmeyi seriye.
-
Ador stilul în care această autoare își constuiește cărțile, iar "Păcătoasa" este o altă carte care face parte din categoria cărților foarte bune. Te ține în suspans, de la început până la final. Nu poți anticipa ceea ce urmează. Te plimbă de la autopsia unui nou cadavru, la locul crimei, dar și în viața personală a celor două personaje principale: Jane Rizzoli și Maura Isles. Iar totul este relatat atât de bine, încât cartea te captivează și nu o poți lăsa din mână, până nu o termini.
-
I've read Tess Gerritsen's first two Rizzoli and Isles books before this one. I really love the way that the case progresses and keeps you hooked in those two. This one, while still very interesting, is a very abrupt change from the first two books. And while I read both of the first two in five days, this one took me almost six weeks because when I set it down, I didn't feel all that strong of a need to pick it back up.
Between book two and this one, the setting moves from a blistering summer to an almost intolerably cold winter, which really suits moving from the point of view of the passionate Rizzoli to the cool and logical Isles. However, I feel like they didn't start making the connections in the case that I had made in the beginning of the book until after page 200 (of 342 for my version). The case itself moved much more slowly and there was a lot more of the personal lives of the characters.
This would be fine except... I don't really like the characters that much. Isles is okay, but a bit too poetically grand in her thoughts sometimes. And Rizzoli is just incredibly, annoyingly abrasive and whiny. Maybe it's just me, but the characters at this part of the story are just a bit too exaggerated.
In the end, this is a crime thriller where the crime is not nearly thrilling enough; a medical thriller with barely any medical aspect to it; and a practice in exploring characters that I didn't like. However, I liked the first two so much that I intend to read the next book as it sounds much more interesting. -
When Dr Maura Isles was called to the chapel of Our Lady of Divine Light by Detective Jane Rizzoli, she wasn’t sure what to expect. But it certainly wasn’t the horrific, savage attack on two nuns, one of whom is dead, the other clinging to life. And medical examiner Maura was further shocked when doing the autopsy, to discover that the young novice, 20 year old Sister Camille, had very recently given birth.
The race is on to find the child, and to find the father...obviously he is a suspect! But was it consensual or was it rape? With Jane talking to young Noni, daughter of the cook/housekeeper of Our Lady of Divine Light, she finds some surprising clues. Though Noni is a child, she is very observant, a silent watcher in the nunnery.
When another body is found, mutilated beyond recognition, little did they realize that the two murders were connected, that there was an ancient disaster that had lain hidden for decades, and suddenly, as these secrets begin to come to light, Maura finds herself in danger. The investigation starts to feel incredibly close to home. Will Jane and Maura be able to find the killer before they themselves are in deep trouble?
The incredible twists that Gerritsen can weave throughout her novels keeps the pages turning, the dark and frightening traits to human behaviour leaving you shocked to the core!
Another thoroughly enjoyable Gerritsen thriller! -
Bu sefer olaylar "Ölüler Kraliçesi" olarak bilenen adlı tıp doktoru Maura Isles'ın etrafında dönüyor.
Graytones Manastırı'nda bir cinayet işlenir: Genç bir Rahibe olan Camille vahşice öldürülmüş, daha yaşlı olan Rahibe Ursula ağır yaralanmıştır. Dr. Maura Isles, otopside Camille ile ilgili süpriz bir gerçeği ortaya çıkarır. Aynı zamanda bir kurban daha ortaya çıkmış, kurbanın kimliğinin ortaya çıkmaması için katilin uğraştığını polisler fark etmiştir.
Maura ve Rizzoli için acımasız katili bulmak için kovalamaca başlar.
▪️
Bu kitap ilk iki kitaba göre bana biraz sönük geldi. Ağır bir tempo havası vardı. Rizzoli'nin olduğu kısımları, onunla birlikte bir şeylerin peşine düşmeyi seviyorum. Aynı zamanda bu kitapta Maura'nın otopsi yaptığı yerleride sevdim. Yazarı tebrik etmek gerek; detayları atlamadan ve arada bilgiler de vererek bir otopsiyi baştan sona yazmış.
Kitap boyunca bazı tahminlerim tuttu ve bazı yerlerde yanıldım. Tabi gözüme kestirdiğim katil potansiyellerini yine affetmedim.😁 Baştan beri bir tahminim vardı. Bazı şüphelerim doğru çıktı. Katili bulunca çok seviniyorum.
Maura'nın bazı davranışlarını sevemedim maalesef.🙈 Biraz iradeli ve bazı yerlerde mantıklısı olmasını isterdim.
▪️
Kitapta üzücü mesajlar da vardı.🥺Okurken çok üzüldüm. Bazı insanlar bu dünyada olmamalı bence. Rahibe Camille ile ilgili gerçekler çok iç yaralıcıydı.
Tek mutlu olduğum yer Rizzoli ile ilgili bazı sürprizler var. 🙈 Dean ve Rizzoli bunun üstesinden bakalım nasıl gelecek? -
I liked this book a lot better than the 2nd book in the series. The plot was really engaging and I had a hard time putting my e-reader down and getting anything else done. I'm definitely continuing reading this series.
(My husband did talk me into going to the movies and we watched 3 Billboards. I'm a fan of Frances McDormand!) -
Possibly the pick of the series so far. Someone has killed a nun and left another corpse with no face, hands or feet. Pathologist Isles has a series of difficult autopsies to piece the puzzle together whilst her cheating ex-husband unexpectedly shows up. Detective Rizzoli tries to piece what turns into a major investigation together but is distracted by the return of FBI beau Gabriel. Very clever story of corporate greed and corruption with nice red herrings to throw you off the scent and a good unexpected conclusion. Turning into a fave series for me
