The United States Constitution: A Graphic Adaptation by Jonathan Hennessey

The United States Constitution: A Graphic Adaptation Reviews

• 
  Heidi

  As a constitutional scholar, I picked up this book with some trepidation about how it was going to portray the history and content of the Constitution, specifically the aspects that are currently the most politically charged (the Second Amendment, for instance). I was generally pleasantly surprised about the political neutrality and balance. I was also pleased about the fact that the author acknowledged the fact that neither the Civil War amendments nor Brown v. Board of Education immediately fixed the horrible situation in which blacks found themselves in the US. However, I found some of the descriptions of content or history surprisingly stunted. If a reader didn't already know the story of what happened leading up to the case of Marbury v. Madison, in which the Supreme Court seized the power of judicial review for itself, I have a hard time believing that she would really understand it after the stilted (and at one point inaccurate) version shown in this book. Nor do I think the author emphasized enough how radical John Marshall's decision was, or how crucial it has been to our mode of governing forever after. I had a similar feeling about the very brief and mostly accurate description of the case of Dred Scott v. Sandford.
  
  Furthermore, while I greatly appreciated that the author often reminded us that the Bill of Rights did not originally apply to the states, and that it took the 14th Amendment to create the mechanism by which nearly all of its provisions would eventually bind the states, I was surprised at how little coverage the 14th Amendment got in its turn. How and why does the 14th Amendment make the Bill of Rights apply to the states? You'll have to look elsewhere to find out! This book sure doesn't tell you.
  
  I have more...why were there no women included in the drawing of the Supreme Court justices? In fact, why were there really only portrayals of women in places that had specifically to do with issues of gender? Why is the author so frank about the fact that the 13th Amendment didn't do a whole lot to help out former slaves in practice, but so silent about how ineffective protections of the requirements for probable cause and reading of Miranda rights have been since the 1970s?
  
  So in the end, I would not put this book on my syllabus for any American Government class.
• 
  Jon Nakapalau

  A very good GA of all the stories behind the US Constitution - will help anyone trying to grasp the concepts behind this world changing document.
• 
  David

  4.5
  This is a great introduction to the remarkable document that is the U.S. Constitution. Some critics of this graphic novel claim it is way too long as a result of it being packed with too much information. Other critics claim it is way too brief and just brushes lightly on important Constitiutional issues. The fact that both arguments are frequently stated is evidence that this graphic novel is probably the perfect introduction to the U.S. Constitution.
• 
  Pam

  I haven't read any graphic novels so this was a great first experience, and really made the topic much more interesting than expected (honestly, I'd never pick up a book about the Constitution unless required for a class!). Each section of the document is explained, with a lot of background information as to what was happening at the time and why certain decisions were made. The illustrations aren't just from the time it was written but also include more modern depictions when appropriate. This would greatly contribute to students' understanding and appreciation of the process involved in creating the government of our country, and the format would certainly be appealing - it wouldn't be a bad choice for additional reading in history classes.
• 
  Alejandro

  It is a great way to teach a lot about the amendments and such, but the pages break to easily.
• 
  Becky

  Describes the Constitution in an historical framework. I thought it was really well done. I liked the metaphor in the artwork that made it easy to understand.
• 
  Lars Plougmann

  I am fascinated with the US Constitution, and this graphic explainer of the history and the mechanics of the Constitution is both a useful and vivid resource enabling a deeper understanding of it. The book describes the context in which the Constitution was drafted. It touches on what influenced the Constitution, and how each amendment came to be. It also goes into detail with the supreme court decisions that have created the interpretation of the Constitution that stands today.
  
  The illustrations are clever. Well-considered visual metaphors are developed and used consistently throughout.
  
  I find myself re-reading it every few years to refresh my understanding of the founding and workings of the United States.
• 
  Helen

  This remarkable non-fiction graphic novel style book about the U.S. Constitution manages to make what for most people might be a rather dry subject, quite exciting! Even for history buffs, or news junkies, or those who think they know all about the Constitution, this book will no doubt reveal many surprising and informative nuances. It's filled with background on how and why the various amendments were added to the founding document, and how the Constitution itself came to be. I didn't know much about the Articles of Confederation (although I must have studied it decades ago in elementary school or junior high school American history) this book explains why the embryonic country wasn't working out too well under the Articles, which is why a committee was set up initially to see if the Articles could be improved. Instead, the delegates decided to chuck the flawed Articles and start over again. Yet they had to produce a document that the States - which were more like sovereign countries under the Articles - could agree with, a system that would allow them to retain some power. The division of power not just horizontally among the 3 branches of the Federal gov, but also vertically, between the Federal and State gov (& even local/city/municipal government) is what is known as Federalism. The idea being that the more diffusely power is spread out, the less likely it is that someone will come along and try to grab all the power and become dictator. They also thought that the States could be laboratories of democracy if they were not too closely supervised, and that new ideas/laws that start in states could if they have merit find their way to the Federal level and eventually be adopted nationally.
  
  The text is clear - not ponderous - and the drawing excellent, as are the colors. Given our present circumstance with Trump challenging the limits to executive power, deriding judges, the press, etc., this book is particularly timely. Since it also discusses the philosophical trends that influenced the thinking of the Founders, it could also spark a reader's interest to learn more about the social and philosophical trends that led to the Revolution and what might result from it, as well as the thinking that went into the Constitution, and the effort to convince the States to ratify it. This book serves as an excellent all-around refresher civics course - with quite a bit of American history included since the Constitution and its amendments are in a way a record of the nation's history, since each came about in response to social crises or historic turning points. For a subject that some might consider dull, it is indeed refreshing that this non-fiction graphic novel is a real page-turner! Incredibly enough, it manages to make even ordinarily obscure Supreme Court decisions exciting!
• 
  Lizzie

  Informative and comprehensive outline of the United States Constitution. This graphic work guides readers point by point through the founding document of our federal government in way that provides historical background and relevant real world examples.
  
  That said, there is awful lot of to digest. The book contains an overwhelming amount of visual metaphors. Some, such as the depiction the federal government as eagle and the states as their respective state birds, are memorable and woven throughout the book. This would work very well in pieces injunction with any high school government, legal issues, civics or history class. The authors also point out some common misconceptions of rights protected by the Constitution and provide a fair and balanced review of around controversial subjects such as the 2nd amendment. The language is also not diluted or esoteric in any way.
  
  The authors are not afraid to play with genre, which is fun. For example once section contains a short noir fantasy to imagine what a country without such Constitution protections would look like. McConnell’s artwork uses muted watercolors that gives the book a almost dark tone.
• 
  Stephanie Linton

  I thought this graphic novel was well done. It meanders through the very document that the United States was founded upon and provides engaging visuals for readers. While it is jam-packed with information as well as history, I found that it was certainly quite wordy. There are many things happening in each panel sequence that might be challenging to follow if you are not paying attention. Still, this graphic novel is effective in presenting a different mode to learn about the Constitution.
  
  This would be a great one to use in any history class. However, due to the complexity of the visuals, panels, and text, I would recommend it for 8-12 grade levels. Also, it is not necessary to make students read the entire book. It's just as effective if you use the section on the preamble by itself. My favorite part about this book is the historical considerations it includes to tell the story of how the Constitution came about and its continued significance in our society.
  
  
• 
  Mary Cummings

  Ignorance is ultimately the worst enemy of a people who want to be free. (p. 141)

  Author Jonathan Hennessey's and artist Aaron McConnell's graphic adaption of the Constitution is an excellent choice for history buffs, those of us who just wanted a fun refresher, and Social Studies teachers looking for a resource to bring the historic document to life visually for their students.
• 
  J

  Great surprise. Found it very educational. Would definitely make it a suggested reading for any student. It's quite informative. I've read many of the cases used for various classes. It's a well done graphic novel.
• 
  Tim

  It is rather dry. I was going to read it cover to cover, but couldn't do it. I'll keep it as a reference if I ever want a quick visual/story on any particular parts of the Constitution, I think it will still be useful that way.
• 
  Matt Kelland

  Absolutely superb take on the constitution, what it means, and how it came about. Should be compulsory reading in schools.
• 
  Beth Honeycutt

  Whew - that took a while! There is so much information in this GN that I think it would be better read in chunks. I definitely could see the importance of it in a government or history classroom for students who are struggling to understand the Constitution.
  
  Could be 3.5 stars!
• 
  Porter Broyles

  Meh. I couldn't get into the graphic novel presentation of the Constitution and I can't imagine kids would either.
  
  This is a novelty piece.
  
  An interesting approach to what many would consider a boring subject, but it failed to bring it to life.
• 
  Christy

  Informative, but rather dry.
• 
  Kennedy Miguez

  A great coffee-table or classroom addition!
• 
  Ryan Thomas

  Everyone should read it before they start spouting off about politics.
• 
  Kate O'Quinn

  This is a really easy to understand basic overview of the Constitution and amendments. I would recommend as a supplement to your civics or history class.
• 
  Susan

  A clever and unique look at the history of the U.S. Constitution shown in a graphic novel. The authors obviously know their history as evidenced by the combining of facts with great artwork depicting the points being made in each scene. My only complaint is that in a few places the words are cut off in the layout of the book. Perhaps it is only this copy? Otherwise this is a great resource of social studies teachers.
• 
  Barred Owl Books

  Our leaders swear to uphold it, our military to defend it. It is the blueprint for the shape and function of government itself and what defines Americans as Americans. But how many of us truly know our Constitution?
  
  The United States Constitution: A Graphic Adaptation uses the art of illustrated storytelling to breathe life into our nation's cornerstone principles. Simply put, it is the most enjoyable and groundbreaking way to read the governing document of the United States. Spirited and visually witty, it roves article by article, amendment by amendment, to get at the meaning, background, and enduring relevance of the law of the land.
  
  What revolutionary ideas made the Constitution's authors dare to cast off centuries of rule by kings and queens? Why do we have an electoral college rather than a popular vote for president and vice president? How did a document that once sanctioned slavery, denied voting rights to women, and turned a blind eye to state governments running roughshod over the liberties of minorities transform into a bulwark of protection for all?
  
  The United States Constitution answers all of these questions. Sure to surprise, challenge, and provoke, it is hands down the most memorable introduction to America's founding document.
• 
  Rachelle

  Not a challeng book. Read as an extra #2
  
  Not bad. Would be great for the younger population to learn about our Contitution in a way that it seem a lot of the younger population seem to grasp better.
• 
  Blake

  Knowledge: 5/5
  Pleasure: 5/5
  Ethics: 4/5
  Utility: 3/5
  
  
  Total Score: 4.25 / 5
  
  I don't normally read graphic novels, and I loved this book. It's the perfect primer for understanding the US Constitution, it's history, and it's 27 amendments. As far as I can tell, this book is straightforward and non-partisan. The commentary and images bring this document to life. I recommend taking time after each section to read the literal document.
  
  I'm going to reiterate a quote to end this short review:
  
  "We cannot defend and protect this dream if we are ignorant of the Constitution's history and how it works. Ignorance is ultimately the worst enemy of a people who want to be free."
• 
  Dakota Morgan

  The graphic adaptation of the Constitution is understandably text-heavy and the illustrations don't add a hell of a lot. But if you're looking for a quick, yet comprehensive introduction to the when's and why's of the Constitution, you won't find a better option. I found it all fascinating - others might find it extremely dry. Depends on whether you want "just the facts, please" or "give me the facts wrapped in a historical adventure ala Nathan Hale's Hazardous Tales." Folks in the former camp will be pleased here.
• 
  Erik

  Pretty good introduction to the US Constitution. It's naturally text heavy as it explains, analysis, and provides practical examples of each part of the document. The art is the really interesting part. I didn't know what to expect since it's something that can't literally be adapted to visuals, but I was surprised by how much I liked it. Many of the panels are based on historical people and events, while the rest are a mix of everyday events and some interesting metaphors.
• 
  Kathy Nealen

  Good introduction to the US Constitution and its amendments. It covers why our early leaders believed they needed to replace the Articles of Confederation and why the Bill of Rights (amendments 1 - 10) were promptly added. Good educational reading for students, voting citizens, and especially, the current POTUS.
• 
  Paul Sain

  I'm interested in the history of The United States of America, and i'm also interested in graphic novels. So I of course enjoyed reading it. I'd recommend it to anyone who enjoys reading graphic novels as well as history.