Title | : | Making Roots: A Nation Captivated |
Author | : | |
Rating | : | |
ISBN | : | 0520291328 |
ISBN-10 | : | 9780520291324 |
Language | : | English |
Format Type | : | Hardcover |
Number of Pages | : | 280 |
Publication | : | Published August 2, 2016 |
Making Roots: A Nation Captivated Reviews
-
Seeing that Roots was being remade for summer 2016 broadcast sent me back to the original book, miniseries and a new biography of Alex Haley....and some startling disappointment. When I first encountered it on VHS in the mid-80s, I was probably still the audience of the late 1970s and it seemed striking, uncompromising and confrontational. Delmont examines how Haley, a moderate Republican and not a historian or genealogist, with the aid of the tourist-seeking new Gambian government, discovered incidents from his family tree and assembled them uncritically, then honed his narrative through years of lecture tours--judging precisely how much a white audience would accept, and the stable family, black history theme of rising importance to the African-American community in the wake of the Moynihan report. Taking it a step further, the TV network then tailored the story for the 90% white audience, casting familiar and beloved white actors for viewers to identify with, dramatizing the narrative arc and filling out the female characters in a way that didn't interest Haley. This is why the results were so perfectly fitted to 1977's state of race relations and historical memory. Delmont, who teaches the American history survey regularly, is quick to forgive the plagiarism and the carefully crafted "fact-ion" for its utility in offering Americans any knowledge of the Middle Passage at all in contrast to more historically sound films or books inaccessible to mainstream popular culture or written off as exaggerations. This is a provocative meditation on the power of middle-brow culture and the dangers (and opportunities) of historical memory.
-
Initial thoughts. More to come: Making roots by Matthew Delmont is an important accomplishment-- a painstakingly researched and engaging behind the scenes analysis of a pivotal piece of American history. It's also a great case study of the symbiotic, sometimes troubling relationship between art and commerce in American culture.