Saint Valentine by Robert Sabuda

Saint Valentine Reviews

• 
  Manybooks

  As a story, and simply in and of itself, I guess one could say that with his 1992 Saint Valentine Robert Sabuda has penned a both heartwarming and heartbreaking account regarding the life and martyrdom of third century Roman priest and physician Saint Valentine (how he both healed and prayed for his patients and that before his execution Valentine was able to restore the sight of a little girl who had been blind since birth). However, considering that with regard to Saint Valentine, there are in fact multiple legends (as well as at least three separate martyred Saint Valentines), after doing a bit of online research, it certainly feels as though with Saint Valentine Robert Sabuda has simply taken all three Valentines and combined them into a pretty standard tale of an early Christian martyr (and with Robert Sabuda not even really textually showing the specific reasons for Valentine’s execution, for his being martyred, such as for example how in one of the stories surrounding him, Saint Valentine was supposedly secretly marrying young couples so that the men would not have to become soldiers in the Roman armies, and which is also one of the main reasons Valentine is considered and celebrated as the patron saint of love and of lovers), not to mention that in 1969, the Catholic Church actually removed Valentine from its list of approved saints, as the three Saint Valentines of late Roman antiquity might actually never have existed.
  
  And as such, and with Robert Sabuda’s narrative really quite lacking, I really and truly am not willing to recommend Saint Valentine either for Valentine’s Day reading or for introducing children to early Christian martyrs. Because Sabuda’s text feels pretty fantastical (and not even all that much mirroring the actual legends of the three Saint Valentines anyhow) that yes indeed, even the fact that his accompanying, that Robert Sabuda’s mosaic like artwork is visually stunning and gives a great visual sense of time and place will make me consider in any way a higher rating for Saint Valentine than two stars and to certainly not recommend this book except for academic purposes.
• 
  Cris

  If you are looking to tell the complete story of ST. Valentine to your children this book will be one beautifully illustrated disappointment, unless you are looking for a low-risk version. To its credit, the mosaic-inspired illustrations are very apropos AND its NOT inaccurate. It does show the generosity and intelligence of that Roman doctor. Its just not complete. In this version, St. Valentine is not married or in love with anyone himself. So it is more correct than other books. The story just stops short of explaining that St. Valentine was executed for performing weddings of soldiers against the King's orders. I don't understand why anyone would write a book leaving out the central thing that St. Valentine was known for..... I don't know why particular book sellers praise it so much, except they haven't read it or know the story. If the adult or child is interested, it could be followed up with a history book about how St.Valentine was actually acting to counteract what he saw as the abuse of women and children from The Children's book of Saints...... In the meantime, I'm looking for a more complete book.
• 
  Ebookwormy1

  I like to read this book on Valentine's Day alongside Cheryl Odden's The Story of Saint Valentine. The two authors take COMPLETELY different approaches to the life of Valentinus, and I think it helps kids understand both historical fiction and the discipline of the study of history.
  
  Odden's approach is so fact based as to be a bit wooden, Sabuda's characters are more fleshed out. Odden gives an introductionary overview of what we know for certain and what we suspect about Valentinus, Sabuda has brief notes at the end on the history that ties in with his text (but doesn't get into the mysteries created by lost historical record on Valentinus). The illustrations for Odden's book are colorful, but somehow bland. Sabuda's captivating mosaics are far more interesting, and give children a visual experience of an art form common in Valentinus' time. Each book has strengths and weaknesses, but I think discussing them together brings the brilliance out of both.
  
  More on Valentine's Day...
  The Story of Saint Valentine, Odden, 2007
  
  https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
• 
  Luisa Knight

  A brief story about Saint Valentine that focuses only on his friendship with the jailer's daughter.
  
  Ages: 5 - 9
  
  Cleanliness: nothing to note.
  
  **Like my reviews? Then you should follow me! Because I have hundreds more just like this one. With each review, I provide a Cleanliness Report, mentioning any objectionable content I come across so that parents and/or conscientious readers (like me) can determine beforehand whether they want to read a book or not. Content surprises are super annoying, especially when you’re 100+ pages in, so here’s my attempt to help you avoid that!
  
  So Follow or Friend me here on GoodReads! And be sure to check out my bio page to learn a little about me and the Picture Book/Chapter Book Calendars I sell
  on Etsy!
• 
  Margaret Chind

  I read this one aloud today. It wasn't the first time but apparently is the first time I've tracked it in Goodreads. Today is Valentine's Day of the year 2020. While I read my newborn (3m) slumbers nearby, my Kinder (5) and Toddler (2.5) snuggle up to me on the loveseat and the girls (10 and 8) sit at the counter making sibling valentine day cards. The mosaic art of this one is what I enjoy the most. In reading this, I loved how my oldest daughter was able to make the connections to Roman history and the persecution of Christians after the risen Christ. I do not find this to be an amazing book but I wouldn't hesitate to read it to them again.
  
  We originally added this book to our shelves because of the recommendation from Memoria Press Second Grade as a read-aloud. We own a paperback copy.
• 
  Set

  The tale of St. Valentine explaining why we associate love of all kinds with the Saint's day.
• 
  Judy

  The story isn't particularly inspiring, but the art is unusual and appropriate for the topic. I didn't know anything about Valentine, so found this interesting. I wouldn't read this to young children, but upper elementary kids who are interested in history or religion might enjoy this. I appreciated the additional information at the end of the book.
• 
  ♥♣Mary♦♠ If She So Pleases

  A very nice story time read.
• 
  Shaun Stevenson

  With Valentine's Day fast approaching, I wanted to take a look at the various books about the holiday as well as the Saint it's named for. Saint Valentine by Robert Sabuda was one of the first books I found on the Saint specifically, and didn't expect the emotional impact this beautifully illustrated picture book would have on me.
  
  Written as a sort of historical fiction of a snippet from the life of Saint Valentine, the book shares about the work Valentine did as a healer and a chance encounter one day with a jailer and her daughter who cannot see. While Valentine is sorry that he cannot do more for the jailer's daughter, he starts to pray for her. I won't spoil the ending here, but it definitely had the emotional punch that good storytelling will deliver.
  
  The story is light on Valentine's religious beliefs, and has a brief more historically accurate explanatory note at the end. The story implies the death of Valentine, but does not mention it specifically.
  
  The illustrations however are amazing. Sabuda takes a mosaic approach to each page, which create intricate details that weave together to form mesmerizing pictures that instantly draw your gaze. Kids will definitely enjoy searching the pictures for some time to see all the details and then to zoom out and see the larger illustration as a whole.
  
  While this isn't the most comprehensive book on Saint Valentine, it certainly tells a poignant story that illustrates the life of the saint.
• 
  Kathryn

  Summary. The life of St. Valentine. The fact that it is legend is not made clear.
  
  Why I Read This: With Valentine's day approaching, I wanted to read it.
  
  Review: I didn't love it because while it told a good story, it didn't make it clear that the story was legend and that not much is known about St. Valentine. Even in the postscript about St. Valentine, he doesn't mention that it is legend. The story and postscript are different from what I've heard about St. Valentine before, but that's ok because it's legend. He attributes the "love" aspect of St. Valentine to it's association with the Feb. 15 Roman Feast of Lupercalia and the love of St. Valentine for people.
• 
  Katy

  A beautiful retelling of the legend of Saint Valentine, the priest and physician in ancient Rome who was jailed and executed under the orders of Claudius II.
  
  The mosaics used to illustrate the story! WOW! These should be framed and displayed in a galley!
  
  
  (read with my 5th Grade students!)
• 
  Elizabeth

  AR 5.4
  
• 
  Two Hearts Homeschool

  The mosaic style illustrations just don’t hold my 5 year old’s attention and the story feels incomplete - it didn’t really convey the idea of St Valentine as a martyr.
• 
  Suzanne

  My family enjoyed this historical look at the origin of Valentines Day
• 
  Emmy

  A simple but charming book about the life of St. Valentine. I wish it would have been longer, though. The art was simply beautiful and all done in mosaic.
• 
  Shannon

  Not perfect but a simple account of the life of a St Valentine.
• 
  Jessica

  I had this is my fetus teacher/catholic school days. It is very interesting and the illustrations are mosaics but it is also very long which was tough for K kids.
• 
  Ivy

  This is a wonderful book for middle grades that tells the true story of St. Valentine. It is well written and led to great discussion about religious persecution. I didn't love the mosaic illustrations, but they are an interesting talking point.
• 
  Volkert

  I was just handed this attractive story about Saint Valentine by a 3rd & 4th grade teacher who is using it in her classroom as part of her Valentine's Day activities. I'm the librarian at a public elementary school, so I read through it quickly with great delight. Since we don't have it in our collection, it is one I hope we can acquire before Valentine's Day next year!
  
  While this story is about a saint of the Christian faith, the religious aspect of the story is toned down and not preachy. While Valentine's faith, and his role as a priest, are woven into the story, the text emphasizes his role as a physician and his relationship with the blind daughter of a Roman jailer who seeks healing. The "Notes on the text" at the end of the book explain Valentine's connection with the celebration of love.
  
  The warm colored mosaics, with their icon-like appearance, are a fitting complement to the text. This book is visually appealing, and both the size of text and word choice make it appropriate for primary and middle grade readers.
  
  It's my opinion that "Saint Valentine" would be a welcome addition to both school and church libraries, as well as in the collections of families who want to see historical, and saintly, figures like this come to life. (Written February 14, 2001.)
• 
  Teri

  This book is a little jem! We read it with our Roman history (just prior to Constantine, when the Christians were really being persecuted). All the illustrations are mosaics--perfect for an art project. My girls really connected with this book. What a tragic story.
• 
  Melanie

  Good story about the story behind St. Valentine. I though the mosaic illustrations were pretty neat!
• 
  Theresa

  a breif history and story about the saint and the mericles he preformed
  
• 
  Mckinley

  While I very much enjoyed the illustrations done in mosaic style, I thought the story wasn't very well developed.