| Title | : | Sirena |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | 0590383892 |
| ISBN-10 | : | 9780590383899 |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Paperback |
| Number of Pages | : | 210 |
| Publication | : | First published October 1, 1998 |
That is why she hides when she finds an abandoned young soldier. He wants to know her, though she should not let him near her or allow him to hear her sing. But how can she fight a love she has been waiting for all her life -- a love that will make her live forever?
Sirena Reviews
-
The story is set in Ancient Greece during the time of the Trojan War, but it is not about the war. Sirena is a mermaid who, along with her numerous sisters, sings to attract the attention and love of mortal men. As soon as a mortal loves a mermaid the mermaid becomes immortal, and that is something all mermaids want. The mermaids’ singing does attract a ship but it runs aground on the rocks and many of the sailors drown (which was not the mermaids intention). Horrified by the unintended deaths, Sirena vows to never sing to a mortal man again, and she leaves her sisters to go live in isolation near an uninhabited island. Then one day a man is marooned on the island.
What I loved about this particular mermaid story is that it is not centered around the mermaid altering her appearance in order to gain love. She does not trade in her voice, or her fins for a pair of legs. Instead the questions are do you give up immortality in order to live your life with your lover? Or do you love more deeply because you know one day it will end? One of the things that always bothered me about Hans Christian Anderson’s “Little Mermaid” was that she wasn’t good enough as she was to be loved by the prince; she had to give up two big things (her voice and tail/fin). Plus she had to leave her world and live in his, and after all this he still didn’t love her (hope this isn’t a spoiler for anyone who hasn’t read the original fairy tale).
Sirena has no desire to be human; her desire is to be loved by a human. This is a young adult novel, but I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys a nice love story with a little bit of mythology thrown in. -
”We must make them love us.”
Such is the goal of a siren. With their seductive voices and ethereal appearance, these harmless looking mermaids cause more peril on the sea than joy. Their whole purpose in life lies in the sailors, warriors, and tradesmen who journey in the Mediterranean waters.”The smell of the ship is piney. The sweat of the men is sour. I smell their shoes and their dirty hair.”
Sirena and her forty-eight sisters spend days on the lookout for these giant ships, for they know with ships come men. In it lies the hope that once these battle and wanderlust weary men hear their voices and behold their striking beauty, they will fall in love with them, thus making the sirens immortal.
Until the day these beautiful voices cause the demise of an entire ship. The day that men turn against the sirens and curse their death-bringing songs.”We should have listened to the other men. They warned us of the dangers at sea. But no one told us of you. They must not have seen you. Of course not. Anyone who sees you dies. You. Wretches misshapen monsters of the deep. Seductresses of evil.”
After the death of her sister, Sirena ventures alone, vowing never to sing again and live out her days a mortal on a deserted cove. What she doesn’t expect is the arrival of a man, a mortal man. So tempting, yet so forbidden. She wants to love him, but can’t. And yet despite all odds, they do.
The queen of retellings strikes again! Usually, Donna Jo Napoli writes retellings based on European fairy tales, which have all been brilliant (my personal favorites are Zel, Beast, and The Magic Circle.) In this instance, Napoli takes us back to ancient Greece during the Trojan War in this dual retelling of the sirens myth and the myth of Philoctetes, the famous Greek warrior left stranded on a deserted island to die. And once again, she does a brilliant job. She alternately weaves in her own ‘What if?’ plot points to fill the gaping plot holes the myth has left out while still leaving enough of the original framework there so readers can recognize the tale their reading.
Sirena is the youngest of her sisters, and is very naïve in the beginning. Like all sirens, she wishes to be immortal and live forever. But when she sees the consequences of her wish, and the actions the sirens cause to the men they seduce, she is repulsed by it altogether.”If I knowingly killed a man, how could I want to go on living? I trade immortality for the right to want to live.”
She matures rather quickly, but as the novel progresses you get glimpses of the old Sirena through her new, more wizened state. She’s playful, vivacious, curious, intelligent, and has a clear sense of right and wrong in a sea of morally gray characters.
Philocetetes is both the epitomeme and antithesis of a typical Greek hero. Left to die by his crew of men after a serpent bites him, Sirena saves his life by both tending to his wound and providing him food. He can be an arrogant, pompous know-it all, but his personality is never that of a full-fledged jerk like some of the heroes are portrayed to be. He willingly admits the flaws in the tales of the warriors that came before him that we all know and revere today, yet he can’t bring himself to fully hate them. And he’s Sirena’s perfect match in the sense he’s lively, jovial, and ready for adventure at a moment’s provocation.”What a strange thing human is, that he can be abandoned by his companions with a wound that resists healing, yet he’s ready to play at the first provocation.”
He’s basically a hot Henry Cavill from Immortals, if you had to picture the dude in your head (which you will often, I assure you). Their relationship is based on mutual understanding and a willingness to be open-minded about one another and their beliefs, and is very much a relationship of equals. Who would’ve thought that a relationship between a man and a mermaid in ancient Greece would be so progressive? Much appreciative, much wow!
One of the things I like so much about Napoli’s retellings is the fact that she never shies away from both the serious topics hinted upon in the original tale and the much darker aspects that would probably never make it into a family made film of the tale. They aren’t your mother or kid sister’s myths and fairy-tales, which make them so entirely appealing to me. The question of immortality, and how much does it really mean if everyone you love dies, is a key question that’s asked of both Sirena and the reader. Is it really worth sacrificing both your life over and the lives of others? The bodies of drowned men at the bottom of the sea? All so you could live forever? Readers will both be satisfied and melancholy at the results.
The ending isn’t one that I predict readers of the book will like. Especially since Sirena and Philoctetes are a couple to root for. However, there really is no alternative to their situation, and the author clearly explains that through the character’s actions. It doesn’t make it any less heartbreaking, however. Much like the original myth, this bittersweet yet hopeful retelling questions the price of immortality and gives us a couple that, although doomed from the start, are worth rooting for. -
I feel the stars. Each sparkle sets aflame the pain in my heart.
-Donna Jo Napoli Sirena
Once again, Donna Jo Napoli has captivated me with her style of writing and descriptions and characters.
Reading a book by her is always a treat (and I also recommend her other books-Zel, Spinners, etc...).
The story is lovely, but the ending is very very sad.
I recommend it to anyone of any age (well, okay, probably three year olds wouldn't be very interested, but still)
Okay so here's the story:
Sirena is a mermaid who lives with her sisters on an island. They lie in wait for any passing ships, to lure the men onto their island. But Sirena refuses to do the same again when her sisters relocate. Instead, she helps a man that has been newly stranded on the island.
Finally, they fall in love and live together for years and years. Sadly, the man is growing older while Sirena is still beautiful and young.
And even more sadly-they must break apart when a ship comes to pick the man (Philoctetes) up and get the bow Hercules gave to him.
It's so sad!!!!
but so good. -
Showing both the good and dark sides of mermaid folklore, this twist on Greek mythology is perfect for any folklore/mermaid/fantasy-romance fan. It inspired me to try and write my own mermaid story!!!!
-
What can I say about Sirena by Donna Napoli. Well, it's not what I expected. Her writing style was nothing I've ever encountered before, and the book was mainly a narrative from the first person of a mermaid, Sirena. I gave it three stars, because the writing was very fluid, and invoked the imagination which is worth mentioning. It's a fast read, and full of love, regret, and longing. While some parts of it are a little too *ahem* for the young adult section, it's not all that bad. I would tell anyone who likes mermaids, and wants a fast read to pick this up at the library. It teaches you a very important life lesson... love can happen at unexpected moments, and a true love, will live on, even if your love is no longer with you.
-
Sirena is a Siren, who, in Napoli's work, are mermaids; the offspring of the rape of a parrot-fish by Eros (no, really), they cannot be immortal unless they have a man fall in love with them. Yeah. So Sirena, unlike the rest of her sisters, doesn't want to trick a man into loving her by her singing (shades of the Little Mermaid, oh my), and runs off to Lemnos, where she meets Philoctetes. You could probably fill in the rest, too. Not a *bad* book, but it mostly was a supposed-to-be-titillating, I think, meditation on a young "girl" discovering sexuality, and really, YA books *can* be about something else! The constant discussions of sex, though not graphic, offended me a whole lot more than the graphic scenes in either An Arrow's Flight or Cook's Achilles. I think it's this sort of nonsense that ought to be kept out of the hands of teenagers, not to mention its ridiculous romanticism of Love. Bah!
-
Salted, saltish, very salty like a particular salt of memory. Reminiscent of fishy hopes and hearths lost between thighs.
-
This book is a great quick read that I really enjoyed.
I went into thsi book not knowing anything about it except that is is about a mermaid named Sirena. The synopsis gives no information about the time period or when it takes place. I was happy to find out that the book takes place in Ancient Greece at the time of the Trojan War. It is a re-telling of the myth of Philoctetes, who was abandoned on the island of Lemnos when he was bitten by a serpent on the way to Troy. The myth was changed to add a mermaid into it. The story takes place in the years that Philoctetes was stranded on the island.
I really liked Sirena. She was very innocent in the beginning. In this book, mermaids can gain immortality by mating with a male human. They use their singing to lure ships to their island where the ships will wreck and the survivors will have to stay on the island. Sirena is a very determined character who realizes that her singing can cause death which is why she promises that she will never sing again. She is very determined to keep that promise. Sirena has a sense of right and wrong, which her sisters don't have. Sirena wan't immortality but she doesn't want it at the price of a person's life.
Sirena is also very loyal, loving, caring, fun-loving and playful. She is also very nuturing which can be seen when she helps to heal Philotcetes. She is very amazed at small things such as mosaics and fire and rejoices when she is able to do some human skills (like make a fire). She becomes wiser throughout the book. She is also fiery and passionate especially in her beliefs.
I also liked Philoctetes. I admire him for staying on the island for so long without going crazy or trying to get off of it multiple times. He is a good man with unfortunate circumstances. He is a renowned archer and a Greek hero (after he gets off the island and goes to Troy). He is very brave and willing to try new things like learning to swim. He is very protective, loving, passionate and a wonderful story teller. He also had impressive friends~ Theseus, Heracles (Hercules) and Achilles were his friends. He gets used to life on Lemnos and with Sirena~ he begins to love it. He is very sweet and caring, surprising Sirena with surprises he thinks she will like and giving a lot of thought and hard work on his surprises. Of course being a human, Philoctetes, even though content with his life on Lemnos, dreams of going to war to be a hero and have people tell stories about him like he tells Sirena of Theseus, Achilles and Heracles. Honor is everything to him and he wants to go to war to win honor.
I love the romance in the story. The love between Sirena and Philoctetes is sweet. They both love each other completely and they fell in love on their own without her singing or anything interfering. They truly enjoy each other's company and have lively debates on some of the stories Philoctetes tells. While I loved this book I have to say I wasn't too happy with the ending. For me it was too sad and that sucks. I hate sad ending.
This review is also posted on
Spantalian's Book Reviews -
I thought this book was fantastic! I love Greek mythology and everything about Greek life, but this book wasn't necessarily about that stuff. It was a fun book about mermaids and caught my attention right from the first page. It was an easy read that is easy to relate to (at least I thought so), so the perfect thing to sneak in a day. It is the ideal book to read if you're in a book slump!
Originally Reviewed on May 4, 2017.
Updated with Grammarly on May 27, 2018. -
I have nice sentiments about this book, full of admiration. It was not a retelling of the Little Mermaid as I had thought but a new story. And it was really quite lovely. A bit sad too.
Greek mythology is woven into it or rather, a particular piece from Greek mythology is retold in the book. Since the part with Philoctetes was the same word to word from the mythology, I'm guessing the mermaid origins were taken from there too. There were certain gaps in Philoctetes' actual mythological story, how he survived on Lemnos, how he got his injury, etc. The author filled those gaps in her own way and I loved that.I found that out later. The trojan war and Paris and Heracles, I had known about before but I had never before heard of Philoctetes. I thought the author had made him up. When I finished the book I googled him and found his entire history on wikipedia. I was bummed a little, to be honest. But now I think it was amazing, how she put it all together.
This book is short by normal standards, barely 300 pages, so it can't be considered slow. But if you look at the plot, it's a slow-paced one. Years pass and it deals mostly with Sirena and Philoctetes' day-to-day lives. I was not bored by it at all. However, it's something to be aware of before reading the book.I also found the mermaids' physiological aspect interesting. They couldn't stay in the water indefinitely. They had to breathe above water and sleep on rocks. I've never heard that before either when it comes to mermaids.
I've definitely become intrigued by Donna Jo Napoli's work. I plan on reading all retellings written by her I can find. -
This book was beautifully written, as Napoli is a brilliant writer. I cried many times during my adventure reading it. The characters are surprisingly relatable, and the story is compelling. When we summarize it--"An immortal mermaid who falls in love with a human wishes she could return to mortality to live a full life with him"--it sounds very cliched. But in all reality, starting this book was like climbing up a hill, but when you reached the top, the view was meant for a great mountain. Climbing down the hill was a painful journey as the book was coming to its end, but it was satisfying--as if you stopped to cry at the sunset and feel proud that you'd gone through such an adventure. This book truly makes you think about life, and it's a spectacular read that I don't recommend finishing in a single sitting but in multiple sittings.
-
I did review this a little high, but I will be "thinking about this a lot" as I am writing my own mermaid novel. This mermaid novel is the first I've read with some research behind it. However, I'm not sure how I feel about it, because it takes place during the battle of Troy: its removed from time, place, culture, and she's a mermaid-- that's a lot of doors to get through.
I'm looking for information as to how to write an underwater world. So far, most books only have mermaids above the sea level. However, I did enjoy the mythic version here--of how mermaids were born, and how the mermen were lost at sea to an iceburg. Their life seems to be owed to a mystical goddess turtle.
After re-reading Hans Christian Andersen's original tale, I'm surprised to discover that his mermaids were not immortal and his heroine wanted to "share the joys of a heavenly world." The original "Little Mermaid" wanted to become married to later die and enjoy an eternal life-- as a human would. Her opinions about living for 300 years as a mermaid and then turning into foam were not very high. In essence her risk was to aim for eternity over a mere 300 years. It's funny that all the renditions of the mermaid's story I've seen are about how she is willing to bet her immortal fishy life for a few years of glorious human life, and who cares about the afterlife when there is a honeymoon, right? And although I bitterly scorned Andersen's ending when I was a child, I can see now in the rereading that she does get an immortal life, exactly what she asked for. Somehow she finds a loophole through good works and gets her wish. The princely husband was just one avenue to her destination, and she reaches it another way. Hmmmm. Only a truly innocent can love this ending, but I can see it's beauty in a "Water Babies" type of way. Anyone read "Water Bablies?" Marvelous.
As for Sirena, I think it's more YA, but it has its place in literature that educates the Greek myths. -
This was a very heartfelt historical fantasy romance. Dripping with the atmosphere of an abandoned Ancient Greek island, Sirena tells the tale of a mermaid’s and man’s love for each other when both are left abandoned. This discusses themes of loyalty, honor, morality and sacrifice. Weaving in Greek mythology and lovely nature writing, this novel went above my recollection and expectation. This would be better placed in YA or adult fiction as there are many discussions of sex, rather than the 12+ suggestion on the back of my book.
-
I read this twice on a plane and wow this is just wow ugh I don't know what to say this makes me cry every time i read it
-
First lines: I am waiting, impatient and excited.
A glimpse of orange in the damp sand above the waters edge catches my eye. It is a dried starfish. That makes the fourth one I have found this week. I lace my hair around it. My sister Cecilia will be jealous. She has covered herself with starfish. And Pontina has taken over the mussel shells, stringing them around her neck in layers. Leila collects pearls. Her hands are red and pink with scrapes from fighting oysters. We make ourselves beautiful.
Beautiful storytelling wraps around the mythological tale of Philotectes, the young friend of Hercules who is stranded on the island of Lemnos for ten years prior to the Trojan War. In this tale, Philotectes is saved by the mermaid Sirena, who both pines for humans and also avoids them, after she and her sisters caused the destruction of two sea-faring ships.
The story is really Sirena's, a mortal mermaid who must cause a mortal to fall in love with her in order to achieve her own immortality. Sirena, however, does not want to enchant mortals as her sisters do, she wants true love and refuses to sing her songs of enchantment. She tends to Philotectes' snake-bite wound daily and lives with him on Lemnos as a couple. She pines for children, knowing she cannot have any. And when a Greek ship finally pulls up to take Philotectes away to war, she must finally reconcile their love and differing natures.
I loved this story. -
I read this book a LONG time ago, before I even graduated High School, and didn't quite understand it. I happened to see it at A Half-Price Bookstore a few weeks ago, and picked it up. Re-reading it, I am amazed at how truly well-written and deep it is. My one regret is the ending, as it seemed fairly rushed. That doesn't change at all how much I enjoyed it. The mosaic scene was one of the most prominent in my mind, and Mrs. Napoli did such a fantastic job with descriptions that you really could FEEL like you were there. Really wish this could have been a movie, or even re-released now, as I know it would be a hit once more.
-
My good friend and fellow goodreads author Asghar Abbas recommended this book.
We had a discussion on a lack of credible literature involving the vision of mermaids. He produced this book and suggested I give it a go.
I thouroughly enjoyed this tale. It is an easy read and can appeal to all ages. The story doesn't read like a typical mythological tale, however, there is no mistake that is what it is.
Sirena is another story of coming of age.
Hunger, desire, struggles with maturing it is all there. -
I was going through some strange mental/emotional things when i read this and when i finished it, i had to throw the book across the floor. not that i hated it, just that i understood all of it too well.
-
I read this a long time ago, but I know I loved it! Must re-read...
-
Fantasy, fiction, romance, greek mythology. everything i could ask for in a book.
-
Such a pretty story. It leaves you happy
-
It was a good read... But sad ending..
-
Probably a 4.5. Super enjoyable, quick read.
-
I came in with no expectations at all, just to read a good ol'book about mermaids.
I'm a sucker for mythology (and mermaids' love stories in particular), so this was the book for me, but it was written like 20 years ago, so I was a bit skeptical about some, like, 90s vibe in an Ancient Greek setting, but boy was I wrong.
This little story is so bittersweet it will leave you laughing and crying and wanting for more, definitely.
The writer is a Professor and it shows in her knowledge about the Greek culture and mythology, so I enjoyed that as well.
Sirena will hold a special place in my heart for sure. -
I have mixed emotions.. I loved the book but the ending made me sad. I hope there is a book two or something
-
ATOS Book Level: 3.9
Interest Level: Upper Grades (UG 9-12)
AR Points: 5.0
Lexile: 540L
Word Count: 39264
This story is set during the time of the Trojan War. It's a story about mermaids, and one mermaid in particular, Sirena. Mermaids of course have the lower body of a fish and the upper body of a woman. The basis of the story is that in order to become immortal, the mermaid must entice a human man to love them (this being hard of course because of the fact that THEY'RE HALF FISH. While trying to accomplish this task a tragedy occurs when two ship loads of men, enticed by the mermaids song, crash on the shore of the island, and the men either drown or die of starvation.
Sirena is distraught, and leaves her island and her sister mermaids behind in an attempt to live life on her own, hoping to never see another human. The fates apparently have other plans in mind.
When Sirena arrives at an island that she believes no man will be on, she arrives in time to see a man (for now, we'll call him Phil) left upon the island by his companions to die.
This is a tale of ancient Greece, with Greek gods, and Greek mythology. It's also a story of two different people (beings really) who, given enough time, come to love and care for each other.
