Gothic Blue Book: The Haunted Edition by Cynthia Pelayo

Gothic Blue Book: The Haunted Edition Reviews

• 
  David Watson

  If you like horror stories that are short and sweet you should check out Gothic Blue Book The Haunted Edition from Burial Day books . This is a collection of 12 short horror stories and two poems edited by Cynthia and Gerardo Pelayo. This anthology honors the gothic story and includes old ghost stories and tales of misery, fear, despair, regret and dread. This collection would make Edgar Allan Poe proud. Don’t expect a lot of happy endings in this book.
  
  Gothic Blue Book: The Haunted Edition is a tribute to the Gothic blue Books that came out in the late 18th and 19th century. These books included several short stories and were between 36 and 72 pages long. They were very cheap and not well liked by literary critics; despite that they were very popular.
  
  When I started reading Gothic Blue Book, I didn’t think I would enjoy it as much as I did, but there were quite a few good stories in the book. The first story is a poem which sets the mood for the whole book. Its by Helena Marie Carnes Jeffries and called The Beach House. It describes the emotional state of a woman who has just found out her husband is cheating on her. The depressed woman is walking on a beach and sees a very familiar looking woman in an abandoned beach house. Thinking the woman needs help she decides to go inside but doesn’t like what she finds, but maybe it was what she was looking for. I loved how the woman’s thoughts we’re described in this poem and how well written it was.
  
  Another good story in this anthology was The Tapping by John Everson. This one was about three men who make a bet on who can be the first one to retrieve a skeleton’s hand from a graveyard so they can use it in a prank. This story was the kind of story I love to read as a horror fan. The way the graveyard is described and the main character’s fear as he starts to think he is not alone in the crypt are what horror is all about. Three men in an old graveyard digging up corpses on a windy cold Halloween night in an attempt to scare a co worker. What can be more fun than that and of course nothing can go wrong when you disturb the dead. right?
  
  Some other good stories in this collection include The Realtor, which tells the tale of a salesman trying to make a quota by creating a few urban legend. This one had me feeling sorry for the Realtor but also hoping his victim didn’t die. I also liked Where The Fault Lies by Greg Mollin and The Squatter by M.N. Hanson. Both are great ghost stories with very different moods and endings.
  
  My favorite story in Gothic Blue Book was The Gravedigger by Cynthia Pelayo. It tells the story of a woman named Madeline who just doesn’t fit into society but tries to make everyone around her happy. When she finds out that someone has been using her, she decides to get her revenge by reenacting a death scene which is a tribute to a very famous horror author. Madeline is a character that if you’ve ever felt like an outsider you will be able to relate to and I would like to see some longer stories with her in it. I highly recommend Gothic Blue Book The Haunted Edition
• 
  Barbie

  I like this collection of short stories.
• 
  K.R. Smith

  I would have given it 2.5 stars, if that were an option, but I gave them 3 to encourage any future publishing efforts they might make.
  
  There are a few good stories, most of the rest are just OK. In my opinion, you can skip "Attic". The stories by John Everson (The Tapping), Greg Mollin (Where The Fault Lies), and Courtney Sloan (Antidote For The Soul) were the best of the lot. Remember, Gerardo and Cina rated it 5 stars, and that bumps the rating up, but it's their book and they wrote a couple of the stories. I suppose I would probably rate my book 5 stars, too, but take the overall rating with a grain of salt.
  
  Is it worth the price? Yes, at $0.99, it's hard to go wrong, and if they came out with another book I might give it a try.
• 
  Nikki in Niagara

  A collection of haunted-themed short stories by indie authors, none of note. A couple of poems also. Very mediocre.
• 
  Mommacat

  Quite honestly, this little book surprised me by how good it was. I picked it up only because it had a story by John Everson, he's never let me down in the past and he didn't disappoint this time. But the other stories in the collection were, for the most part, of the 4 and 5 star variety. My main complaint was the poetry. Just not into the stuff and those got 1 star from and brought the book down . There always seems to be one story that doesn't fit with the rest, but I won't name names. The one I didnt like probably won't be yours.
  
  Odd though, the title "Gothic" I thought would reference the type of stories. No, not so much. Or, at all. Gothic stories are a time period and these had nothing to do with that. I have no idea what the title means. These are good, scary, creepy (in one case SCARY) stories.
  
  A recommended read.
• 
  R Allan

  Great collection of stories.