| Title | : | Shaun of the Dead |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | 184576160X |
| ISBN-10 | : | 9781845761608 |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Paperback |
| Number of Pages | : | 96 |
| Publication | : | First published October 21, 2005 |
Shaun of the Dead Reviews
-
Update - I fancied something short to read - I guess a bit of a change in pace and I found it while sorting out one of my book cases. I love to film and the graphic novel is a close second, always raises a smile
Ok this is a short read - read in one night and its not the first time i had read it but from a fan of Spaced this is carrying on in the same vein. An excellent telling very reminiscent of some of the more modern 2000AD artwork and still carries the energy and fun of the film. A great quick read. -
More like 3.5 stars. I really like the artwork, and it retains the humour and style of the film. My only problem is that I know the film SO well that I noticed the changes in some of the dialogue, especially some of my favourite interactions between Shaun and Pete which I know word for word and was therefore disappointed when some was cut out or cut short. Inevitable for a graphic novel adaptation of a movie, I know, and I appreciate that you can only cram so much in. In fairness it did that very well. It's just the double edged sword of it being one of my favourite movies and knowing it TOO well.
-
As a huge fan of the Shaun of the Dead movie I was thrilled to find the graphic novel. This still has the feel and humor of the movie but cut down some to fit a graphic novel. It was enjoyable to read but I do think the art was a little too dark for this being a comedy. While it's fun to read nothing can hold a candle to the movie.
-
Awesome read based on a great film! Sums it up perfectly. Great graphics
-
Loved the movie, love even the graphic novel! :) Should probably rewatch the movie as people are saying that the comic book is a bit different (I watched it some time ago and do not remember all the details....so sue me!) :D
-
Firstly, to start off as a bad note, 'How's that for a slice of fried gold?' didn't appear in this novel. That genuinely hurt my feelings. Anyway...
This graphic novel is good for a collectible, for fans on the original film. However, for it to stand alone, I think it's a bit weak.
The artwork itself is very nice, and I can admire it, but the book misses some of the dialogue that makes Shaun and Ed's friendship what it is. The humour, wit and sarcasm of conversation doesn't transfer nicely to paper either, it was a story written for screen and should be kept as that medium.
This is not to say I didn't enjoy reading it, though I feel if you're not really a fan of the film, or haven't seen the film, it's maybe not worth the read. But I may be biased due to my love of the film.
To conclude, I did enjoy reading this one, just not as much as I had hoped. But, if you're as much as a Simon Pegg fan as I am, this is definitely something to add to your collection. -
3.5/5
as someone who has seen the movie nearly 400 times and has the dialogue memorized it left me rather surprised not having some of my favourite interactions between certain characters be in this. on the upside they made ed more likeable, and it was interesting to get more background information about yvonne, liz, dianne and david. i really enjoyed the art work as well, wished it was a bit longer! -
I really wanted to love this adaption more, but it doesn’t add anything to the story (short of showing Shaun jump in the dumpster to give the zombies the slip) and omits much of the humor and charm of the film.
Most of this comic is a direct pull from the script/film (I get it, it’s an adaption) but I’ve seen the film so many times I noticed when dialogue was taken out or changed in key scenes. Many scenes, particularly later on lost the emotional pull from the movie feeling rushed or totally skipped over. The art style was a bit dark, but did follow along with the spirit of the film.
Additionally, Ed’s racist terminology was never something I noticed in the film (this may 100% be my privilege so I ask for forgiveness). It wasn’t acceptable in 2010 when this was published, and I hope they edit or omit for future publications from the used copy I purchased.
For me - the movie was far better than the book. It feels sacrilegious as a reader, but seriously if you love zombies and witty humor, check out the movie instead. -
This is a pretty basic graphic novel of the movie of the same name. There's been little attempt to draw the character likenesses but it's easy to tell who's who. Fans of the film may miss certain lines of dialogue or visual gags that didn't make it into the book. Strangely, the encounter with the other group of survivors featuring more well-known actors did, which makes no sense as you can't tell who they're supposed to be. Apart from that, this was a fun whizz-through the movie, but if you have the time, just watch the movie.
-
Originalmente no iba a leerlo, parecía que solo iba a ser una adaptación de la película, como los cómics de Marvel que he leído este año. Pero, entre que leí el cómic de Bloddy Mary y que la sinopsis decía que incluía escenas eliminadas decidí darle una oportunidad.
Al final solo ha incluído una escena extra. La lectura no ha merecido mucho la pena, salvo por los dibujos de Zach Howard, que son muy buenos, mejores que lo que puedes ver en otras adaptaciones de películas a cómics, los personajes son de verdad reconocibles. -
Given the current global situation due to the spread of a deadly virus; it seemed the appropriate time to read the graphic novel adaptation of the much loved hit comedy Shaun of the Dead.
Faithful to the film and excellently illustrated; we find Shaun and a simple plan to survive the apocalypse.
"Take car. Go to Mum's. Kill Phil - "Sorry." - grab Liz, go to the Winchester, have a nice cold pint, and wait for all of this to blow over. How's that for a slice of fried gold?" -
Amazing simply funny just as good as the movie.
Pros
Funny, great humor throughout the comic, just like the movie
Not heaps of action but enough more humor then anything.
Great plot and creation, love the use of weapons like records xD.
Great story simply amazing.
Cons
To be honest none.
In conclusion a must read for all zombie fans 5/5 -
It was a direct novelization of the movie...and it works better as a movie. Some of the best lines or moments can't be properly captured through a single comic frame...unless you are Joe Hill and are able to brilliantly insert microscopic details that takes multiple readings to appreciate and catch.
But Zach Howard is no Joe Hill. -
It seems churlish to say it can't quite match the brilliance of the film itself, restricted as it is to static images, because it does its best with the format it has. How much of the charm, humour and horror of the original does it capture? Lots.
-
Funny, enjoyable read, but had to scrub out the N-word which featured twice.
-
If you are a lover of the film then you’ll love the graphic novel adaptation.
Quirky artwork and classic quotes from the film, a real enjoyable read to relive. -
Was okay, but not as enjoyable as the movie.
-
Pleasant but nothing new to add to the story.
-
Always nice to see more Shaun!
-
The movie will always be better.
-
Fun read.
Nice adaption of the film that I really like. -
Could’ve done more in the visuals to do iconic shots from the movie justice but still a great read regardless if you love the movie.
-
I was truly not expecting to see the white main character say the N slur in the first few pages
-
I got back int comic books last year so when I saw this on sale I picked up a copy for me and one for a friend.
If you've watched the film then you know everything there is to know about this book. A lot of the scenes from the film are condensed into just a couple of panes and obviously most of the dialogue has been stripped out, though there are enough of your favourite lines for this to feel completely familiar. If you know the film then all of the characters in the book take on the voices of the actors as you read along - unless that's just me!
I wasn't disappointed, but I probably expected too much from a comic that tries to condense one of my favourite films into a three-part story. Most of the artwork and direction comes straight from the film and there are a few panes that do a great job of illustrating some of the more complex action sequences. The dialogue is stripped down but *most* of the best lines from the film make it into the book. There's a lot missing, but if you were to cast your mind back to the film, everything you would probably remember is in this book.
My main criticism is that the book doesn't take enough chances. There are plenty of opportunities to flesh out some of the scenes from the film and the only one the book attempts is when Shaun tries to give the zombies (are we using that word?) the slip at the Winchester after David smashes the pub window. Even if they didn't fill in some of the plot holes it might have been nice to see some more scenes from the film in the book - they could have easily turned this three book run into a four book run.
Quicker than watching the film again, but not as enjoyable. -
Rating: 2.5 stars
Being a lover of zombies, graphic novels, and the movie this was based on; you can expect that I had quite high expectations.
Shaun has a boring life, and the movie & book reflects that quite well. Wake up, work, video games, bed; repeat. But when you throw some zombies in the mix- that's where it gets a bit interesting...
To be honest, this book was quite boring. I don't know if the reason I found this so boring is because I've already seen the movie, or whether that's just how it's meant to come across.
I feel like this book is meant to be okay. You're meant to snicker at the jokes, not laugh. Meant to be moderately scared, but not terrified. And upset, but not brought to tears. It's just the way the illustrator / author has designed this graphic novel. I feel like if that is how this was designed to be, a light, humorous (zom-rom-com), easy-to read book; then it was done very successfully.
Overall, an okay book and I was happy to have read this in 2016. Another zombie novel to be added to my "read" collection. -
Usually films are based on comic books and not the other way around - mainly, I don't see the point why someone would create a comic book based on a movie. And of course, it's a faithful carbon of the movie, a very accurate translation.
When I saw Shaun of the Dead some 6 odd years ago, I found it to be the best zombie movie ever. No, scratch that. Best British comedy ever. I've seen it a bunch of times ever since and it's just as great every other time.
The comic book didn't deliver enough in terms of humor. I didn't laugh reading the comic, and the characters weren't half as interesting as they were in the movie. And even though it was the exact same screenplay, the comic book felt hastened and incomplete. But I hope Ryall knew that his comic book would be compared to the movie, and I hope he recognized the former was no match for the latter. -
I dig graphic novels, I get the zombie fascination, and understand this actually is a close following of the film with the same name. I think I need to see the film, or not. But I just did not get into this, I truly thought the illustrations were great, Sean drives me crazy and looking at him I just want to say - "Dude! Your girlfriend - she is HOT - spend time with her!" and Ed I can only take so much, so the illustrations work, it is just the plot, pace, predictable and hard to hold my attention. Not a fan of this graphic novel. I am all for readers getting into any type of book not in their familiar zone, and maybe that is part of my inattention or disinterest. Though I read Wrenchies, another graphic novel and it had much much more depth.
