| Title | : | Calibans War (The Expanse, #2) |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | 1841499900 |
| ISBN-10 | : | 9781841499901 |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Paperback |
| Number of Pages | : | 624 |
| Publication | : | First published June 7, 2012 |
| Awards | : | Locus Award Best Science Fiction (2013), Goodreads Choice Award Science Fiction (2012) |
In the vast wilderness of space, James Holden and the crew of the Rocinante have been keeping the peace for the Outer Planets Alliance. When they agree to help a scientist search war-torn Ganymede for a missing child, the future of humanity rests on whether a single ship can prevent an alien invasion that may have already begun . . .
Calibans War (The Expanse, #2) Reviews
-
Interconnection is everything
I´ve recently finished the ninth part and I must say that the immense coherency, precision in plotting, and meta context are so fine tuned that it is a joy to read. The effort to polish this until perfection without hardly any logic holes, lengths, and errors and to stay comprehensible must be immense and I must say that I´ve rarely ever seen something like that in Sci-Fi because it´s such a difficult task.
That´s how it often goes
Mostly, the novels of a series are closed in themselves and there are not so many retrospects and connections because it can get too complicated. Peter F Hamilton, Alastair Reynolds, Banks, and some others come close, but Hamilton is the only one with similar interconnections and great character development.
It´s not just that the events, fractions, and happenings of the previous parts are used for reminiscences, the whole power balance, allies, and economic motivations change and keep both the honest, direct war and the hidden, political messes and backstabbings evolving. In such cases I like to imagine the storyboard with context and lines in different colors, metaplots, subplots,… and how complex and interwoven it must be for the creators standing in front and, while writing, in their work and expanding it, pun intended.
All that makes sci fi great in one package
And there is everything, the war, supersoldiers, rebel fractions, big questions about the alien technology, mixed quantum fantasy elements, the highly recommended function of putting the name of the character whose POV is described in front of each chapter to get quicker and directer suspense without the need of explaining where we are, extreme attention on the detailed and realistic description of ship design, physics, life in space,... perfect balance of technobabble, harmless infodumps, tons of tropes, credible characters who are great for constructing inner and outer conflicts, unbelievable worldbuilding, sense of wonder en masse, just everything is done completely right to write one of the greatest space operas ever.
One doesn´t have to be a sci fi nerd to enjoy it
Even people who aren´t so in Sci-Fi can read it just because of the characters, like someone who reads Game of Thrones because of an interest in the protagonists and not because of medieval times, magic, and stuff. I think that sci-fi needed something like that, away from the, for an average audience, too complex hard sci-fi, the too slow and less explosive social sci-fi, too indodumpy and tech-focused cyberpunk, and the general very long and complex novels of many other authors.
Side by side together on the legendary shelve
One of the reasons why this series is so great may lie in the cooperation of the authors, that the weaknesses, if there are any, of the one can be compensated by the other and that everyone writes the stuff he is best at. This practice could get interesting in the future, not just with more and more collaborations to produce high-quality content, but with collaborative writing in a fictional social cataloging network, let´s call it goodbook. Whose inhabitants could, with the help of the book adaptability quote, become professional at escalating the whole thing very quickly, because the knowledge and experience of thousands of readers of specific genres are immense and the one or other might have already played with the thought of writing something, but has problems with the plot or the characters or the twists or… is just a lazy as heck procrastinating slacker. Ahem
Nom nom in space
Growing food in space is a tricky thing, even with advantages such as permanent solar energy and sunshine or someday taming and using the power of black holes, etc., but the side effect is the omnipresent danger of being a very attractive target in case of a war, of getting sabotaged or of errors, black swans, tiny imbalances that accumulate to a collapse of the food production. Personally, I would avoid direct sunlight, drill deep inside asteroids, dwarf planets, or planets and build underground farming complexes, avoiding most dangers this way and focusing on a mix of bioreactors and farming, to have 2 independent food production lines in case of catastrophes.
Necromanced vomit zombies. In space!
Zombies in space that vomit, what else could one´s heart wish for? But seriously, the average umbrella corporation zombie reason with out of control bioweapons can be greatly extended when one goes to space. Be it parasites, symbionts, programs converting all biological mass into something more useful for them, mind control,... it´s always great fun.
Tropes show how literature is conceptualized and created and which mixture of elements makes works and genres unique:
This series has some of the most amazing and massive tropeicaltiy t I´ve ever seen.
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.ph...
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.ph...
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.ph... -
4.5/5 stars
Avasarala is finally here!!!
Unlike Leviathan Wakes, I’m venturing into uncharted territory within the series for the first time here. By that, I meant that I haven’t watched any part of Caliban’s War, the second book in The Expanse series by James S. A. Corey duo, in the television series adaptation except for some episodes consisting of Avasarala and Bobbie. Caliban’s War is a superior book compared to Leviathan Wakes in every aspect. This is caused mostly by Corey’s decision to expand—pun intended, get used to this—the number of POV characters from two to four characters. This ended up being a terrific narrative decision. The distinction in character’s voices and personality allows the duo to display their strength as an author further as they tightened the pacing and the plot through several more different character’s perspectives rather than being constricted merely to Holden and Miller’s like before. Although I did love Holden and Miller, there were several chapters in the first book where their narrative felt like indistinguishable; it was like they’re the exact same character in a different situation. This kind of situation doesn’t happen at all in Caliban’s War.
The three completely new POV characters being introduced here were highly entertaining in their own way. Firstly, we have Prax, a scientist searching for his beloved daughter—Mei—in the war-torn Ganymede. Secondly, we have Bobbie, a Martian marine who watches her entire platoon slaughtered by an inexplicably monstrous supersoldier, and now she seeks revenge and revelations. Finally, we have Avasarala, a witty and foul-mouthed politician struggling to prevent an intergalactic war from reoccurring. Obviously, Holden and the crew of Rocinante are back again with their adventures, and they eventually find their fates being connected with all of the new character’s storylines. The increase in the number of POV characters brings balance in emotion and pacing to the narrative; the themes of responsibility, family, redemption, and love were dealt with care through the eyes of these characters.
“If life transcends death, then I will seek for you there. If not, then there too.”
I know I’m only two books into the series so far, and there are still seven more books for me to read before I’m done with it, but the characters are truly the heart of the narrative. The characterizations for all of the characters were wonderful. And I can’t emphasize how much I loved Chrisjen Avasarala. What a freaking badass grandma; we should all bow down to her. Avasarala has appeared in the TV series since the first season; I was disappointed to find that she didn’t appear yet in the first book. But wow, I didn’t expect that Avasarala in the book would cuss more fatally.
“I need not remind you all of the years I spent as a political prisoner.”
“Oh fuck me,” Avasarala said, clapping her hands in glee. “He’s using the outsider speech. That man’s asshole must be tight enough right now to bend space.”
It was incredibly entertaining to witness her cunning and cussing in actions; it reminded me of reading The Gentleman Bastards series by Scott Lynch. However, that’s not the only good part of her story. Avasarala is talented at politics but she’s not all-mighty, she does have a weakness in her, and I think this is what makes her a better character to root for; her greatness that she allowed the public to see is a part of her “mask”. I also loved Avasarala’s and Arjun’s relationship. It’s highly refreshing to read a mature relationship that’s not infuriating to read sometimes. Both Avasarala and Arjun has gone through years of marriage; they could perceive, understand, and comfort each other through facial expressions, gesture, or a few words. All of these praises doesn’t apply exclusively to Avasarala; Holden, Bobbie, Prax, and the side characters do have their own moments to shine. This kind of personalization and relationship building is what Corey does well as an author.
Caliban’s War is a worthy sequel to Leviathan Wakes; it’s better in every aspect. Although Corey’s prose isn’t particularly memorable per se, it truly gets the job of telling an accessibly entertaining story filled with great characters operating in an expansive universe done. I look forward to reading the third book in the series, Abaddon’s Gate, soon.
You can order the book from:
Book Depository (Free shipping)
You can find
this and the rest of my reviews at
Novel Notions
Special thanks to my Patrons on
Patreon for giving me extra support towards my passion for reading and reviewing!
My Patrons: Alfred, Devin, Hamad, Joie, Mike, Miracle, Nicholas. -
4.5
-
Things go very wrong in the colony on Ganymede.
”It grabbed an UN Marine in its huge hands and tore him in half like paper. Titanium-and-ceramic armor ripped as easily as the flesh inside, spilling broken bits of technology and wet human viscera indiscriminately onto the ice. The remaining five soldiers ran even harder, but the monster chasing them barely slowed as it killed.
‘Shoot it shoot it shoot it,’ Bobbie yelled, and opened fire.
The creature was a relatively slow-moving human-sized target, running a straight line. Her targeting computer could do ballistic corrections that would let her hit a softball-size object moving at supersonic speeds. Every bullet she fired at the monster hit.
It didn’t matter.”
Ganymede
In the first book in this series Leviathan Wakes, the universe is nearly destroyed by a protomolecule bomb/creature. After some heroics and more than a bit of dumb luck, the virus is plunged into Venus to burn up, right?
That would be a negatory.
Luckily, our plucky hero James Holden, a cross between James T. Kirk and Holden Caulfield, is still mucking up the universe along with his stalwart companions on the Martian ship Rocinante. They aren’t Martians, but they did... appropriate...one of their sleek fighters with a working coffee pot. It is the small things when the universe is on the verge of destruction...again.
Ganymede, the breadbasket of the universe, is under attack. The goo that destroyed Eros has been oozed into a section of the station. A young girl is kidnapped for nefarious biological purposes, and her father, Praxidike Meng, will do anything to get her back. He needs help, and as fate will have it, he runs into the one guy who is crazy enough to take on the search for his daughter while Mars, Earth, and The Belters (born in space) all square up for war.
Jim Holden is his guy.
Meanwhile, the politics behind the scenes are heating up, and Avasarala, the dignified but potty mouthed representative of Earth, finds herself right in the middle of a space standoff. She has hired Bobbie, the Martian Marine who survived the attack of the new protomolecule creatures on Ganymede, to be her liaison with the Martian government, doubling as a very capable bodyguard as well. When they intersect with Jim Holden and his crew on the Rocinante, sparks really start to fly. Bobbi is about 150% of the size of a normal woman. She is descended from Samoan warriors, and when she first meets Jim Holden, he is gobsmacked. He has conflicting urges.”Mate with it! Flee from it!”
Venus
When Venus starts shooting off protomolecule bombs at ships in space, regardless of their affiliations, these creatures explode right through the sides of the ships and turn the crew members into...yes, if you read the first book or watched the TV show The Expanse, you know what they become.
Vomit Zombies
Holden is suffering from Post Traumatic Miller Syndrome after Miller was killed. They both took a lethal dose of radiation poisoning on Eros. ”The radiation dose he’d received there meant he had to take constant medications to stop the cancers that kept blooming in his tissues. He’d still gotten off lighter than Miller.” Miller saved the world by diverting the protomolecule concoction into Venus instead of its intended target Earth, but he failed to save himself. Miller was Philip Marlowe, only more pissed off. He was more like a version of Marlowe with a swarm of wasps jabbing their stingers into his balls. Since Miller’s death, Holden has been more reckless, more aggressive, as almost a tribute to his dead friend, but that isn’t who Holden is supposed to be.
He is a crusader. A guy who shoots last. A guy who always tries to do the right thing. A guy who can’t help but make any situation much worse before he figures out how to make it better.
I have to say I’m really enjoying the humor, the politics, the grand scale of the world they are building, and the personalities of the characters. The TV series brings the concepts to life, and with the second season about to begin, I was up against the wall to get the second book read in time. I will not wait so long to read book three. So strap yourself in, let the drugs marinate your system so you can survive the g-forces, and for a few hours escape your life in an epic space adventure.
If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit
http://www.jeffreykeeten.com
I also have a Facebook blogger page at:
https://www.facebook.com/JeffreyKeeten -
**Reread update 5/17/17**
One big thing that stands out to me going back to this after reading all the available books in the series is that my complaint about distinct bad guys not getting introduced until very late in the stories was addressed. From this point on we almost always have a face of the threat through most of the action, and that’s an improvement that made a great series even better.
I also wanted to check this out again after seeing the second season of the TV series. The show has gotten so good that I’m now visualizing all the characters as the actors who play them while reading. There’s also an interesting dynamic in that that the two-headed writer who makes up the James SA Corey name also works on the show, and since they have the advantage of knowing what’s going to happen for the next several books it’s able to shade in lot of character nuance and motivations that were just a little thin and simplistic in the early going.
So now I’m counting the days until the new book publishes and the next season premieres.
(Original review.)
Essentially this is a mix of Game of Thrones and Firefly without all the rape and child burning and people talking like they’re in a western movie.
Humanity has expanded throughout our solar system, colonizing Mars and various moons and asteroids. Since people are always gonna be people, and will therefore suck, political tensions are high between Earth, Mars, and the Belters, and the events of the first book in the series have the threat of war seeming higher than ever. And just like in Westeros everyone is so consumed with their petty scheming and power plays that they’re ignoring the much larger threat that is growing under their noses. So it falls to a crew of misfits running their own ship for profit to step in when the shit hits the air recyclers.
This on-going space opera has sucked me in to its world...er… solar system completely with its spaceships, action, politics, and weird sci-fi elements mixed with just enough humor and emotional weight to give it some heft beyond its pew!-pew! appeal. The characters are well drawn even if they aren’t particularly deep, and their motivations are plainly spelled out in their dialogue. So this is all text, no subtext, but it is entertaining. I particularly liked the new character of Chrisjen Avasarala, a grandmother and UN official from Earth whose little old lady appearance is subverted by her foul mouth and political cunning.
However, the series so far has suffered a bit from not giving us any perspective from the vast conspiracy that is causing so much of the trouble. Granted, some of this has been played as a mystery to solve, but for two books now we’ve gotten no sense of who the bad guys are or what they're planning other than what’s been figured out by the heroes. Both books have finally revealed a kind of mid-level mastermind character near the end, and in both cases these have been full on mustache twirling villains so the threat they pose seems kind of vague and cartoonish.
Still, this one ends on a helluva twist that has me itching to roll right into the next one, and I couldn’t turn the pages fast enough when I was in the midst of this. I’ll be happily returning to the Expanse series as soon as possible.
Plus, this
trailer for the show coming to SyFy based on the series has got me even more excited. -
The Expanse - 2: The Expanse universe is further expanded with action on Ganymede, Io, Luna, and Earth! Venus looks like it's being alien-formed as the Solar System watches. Whilst the alien intent is self evident, mankind is intent in making the most out of the instability as the forces that started this all off, look to further their aims and goals with the alien Protomolecule. The quest for a five-year old emerges as the central cause that brings Holden, Naomi, Alex and Amos back into the spotlight, and deadlights of the Protomolecule. Earlier on Ganymede, Jupiter's moon, Martian marine Bobbi, had a really bad day...
Such a detailed and seemingly believable far-ish future has been built by the two voices that make up
James S.A. Corey, but for all the great reality building, plotting, dialogue and inherent jeopardy of being off-Earth, it's two of the female characterisations that blow me away - 1. There's UN big-wig Indian Avasarala, who loves drinking tea, cussing (and I mean cussing) and finds herself doing a fine job, because no one else appears capable, and 2. one of my fave female characters ever Bobbi Draper, a big brown-skinned girl, as in height, muscles and heart; such an unconventional protagonist and one that has to not only fight the 'baddies' but also come to terms with her own Martian authorities not being there for this super patriot.
I really wish that I hadn't watched the TV show first, as it has not only coloured my mind, but because it stayed so true to the book, it's hard to read it without picturing the show and or taking parts of the show unknowingly and making them part of the read? So I can't really differentiate from the show that I love, and the book, that I might love because I've watched the show... although I was on tenterhooks for the last 100 pages and fully invested. 8 out of 12.
-
OK, I liked this book but...
WHERE I HAD READ THIS BEFORE?
I think that at its core, this second book is was too much similar to the first one.
I mean, there is a search for a girl (different age but the same basic idea), a mystery about a threat, and the tensions between the policital powers.
The only difference is that while the first book, Leviathan Wakes can be read a stand-alone book if you wish, maybe since the authors weren't sure to get the chance of... expanding it (pun intended)... for a series.
However, here, in the second book, they already know that they have a series, so they leave it in a cliffhanger, to ensure the reading of the following books.
NEW GUESTS TO THE PARTY
I like two of the main new characters: Bobbie and Avarasala. Both different but both strong female characters and very different to the standard basic female leads in sci-fi books. That was certainly refreshing to read.
However, I couldn't stand Prax, he was so annoying, I understand that he was under many stress but still I felt a downside each time that I met with a chapter written from his point of view. Those were dragging episodes to read.
And something disappointing, in my personal case, while reading this second book, is that, between Holden and Miller, in the first book, I liked more (much much more!) Miller, while Holden was just okay, too naive fool to my taste. And here, this second book, I got only Holden but not Miller, GEEZ!!!, a real big downside for me.
There are some other things that I could comment, but I could spoil some stuff so I won't do it.
Still it's a very good book and the whole deal with details in each aspect of the society shown in this book (or this series) is way amazing and very distintive to call on its own.
So, it's not perfect, it's not awesome, but it's a pretty good reading for any interested about getting into a new sci-fi series, recently published. -
Leviathan Wakes was one of my great reads this year (review:
http://carols.booklikes.com/post/3263... ). It broke into my reading blahs and set off a trend of great reads. After finishing, I promptly placed a library request for Caliban’s War, out of general interest and just the tiniest bit of series OCD. When it arrived, I was in the middle of monthly reads for my book club, then all hell broke open over at Goodreads, resulting in a loss of reading mojo, quickly followed by reviewing mojo. Bridge of Birds brought me back to reading, but my reviewing despondency has lingered.
Caliban’s War fails to live up to the fun, plotting or consistency of Leviathan Wakes, though the writers tried their best by slapping a new cover on a heavily recycled version of the Leviathan. Narrative again begins with a point of view from a female character who won’t be heard from again, but will serve as the object/grail for obsessive male questors as they careen through space. Again, we have Jim Holden surrendering to his Tourette syndrome tendencies as he tilts at windmills and volunteers for suicide missions. Unsurprisingly, we also have the protomolecule, spaceships, and a Mars versus Earth versus Belters conflict.
Because I continue my review with off-topic digressions about libraries and a mild speculation about author sexism, both of which violate GR's terms of service for on-topic, non-author-bashing reviews, the rest of this review will be continued at:
http://carols.booklikes.com/post/6532...
or
http://clsiewert.wordpress.com/2013/1... -
Awesome! A+
Mel 🖤🐶🐺🐾 -
Via The Obsessive Bookseller at
www.nikihawkes.com
I was a little hesitant to pick up Caliban’s War because the first book (Leviathan Wakes) was so amazing, how could the second book possibly compare? I was even worried I’d get bored because I thought I’d figured out which characters we’d be following and what direction the story was headed… Boy was I wrong! And happy to be so. It was definitely different from the first novel, and didn’t lack any of the adventure and excitement!
As I mentioned, I thought I knew which characters we’d hear from in Caliban’s War and was pleasantly surprised with the introduction of a handful of brand-new POVs who added fresh perspectives to the story without losing any momentum. Of course, it wouldn’t have been the same without Holden and his crew and I’m thrilled he seems to be the through-line for the series. Some of the new characters are among my favorite so far (specifically Avasarala, the feisty old politician – if I had half of her gusto, I’d be unstoppable!). As always, each character was interesting and well-rounded and I am eager to see who’s featured in the third novel.
The conflicts in this novel are a lot narrower, but by no means less exciting. It’s all working to build this brilliant momentum, and great momentum is what sets apart good books from great books in my opinion. Most of my favorite series have that in common. To that end, Caliban’s War gets an A+ for pacing. It’s that “holyshit-hold-your-breath-until-it-over” type of stuff that I love. I actually had to stop reading it before bed because it would get me too wound up to sleep.
Overall, if you like fast-paced adventure and excitement in your books, you’ll love these! I am certain I will be reading them again.
Recommended Reading: I would hand this series to sci-fi lovers, but it’s definitely a space opera (my new favorite genre). This is also an excellent series to hand someone wanting to try either genre. All I can say is, hold onto your seats – it’s going to be a wild ride! -
[5 Stars] That ending. Someone hold me. I wasn't ready for that.
-
When I read the first book of The Expanse series,
Leviathan Wakes I was not that impressed with it. It was, however, an instant hit with the majority of the sci-fi readership. My main problem was that I did not really care for the main characters. Consequently, I decided not to continue with the series. Then a few months ago Syfy started broadcasting
The Expanse Season 1 their adaptation of
Leviathan Wakes to practically universal acclaim. I wondered if I may have somehow misjudged the book so I binge-watched the TV show and—to cut a long story short—I thought it was great! However, I did not want to reread
Leviathan Wakes to reassess it, I want to know what happen next in the series so I went and bought a copy of Caliban's War and that’s the end of this dull intro!
Caliban's War continues the story of some Earth politician’s attempt to weaponize the weird alien life form called the Protomolecule and our heroes struggle to stop them and save the entire human race in the process. The heroes are mainly the crew of the spaceship Rocinante introduced in the previous book, plus three new—mostly excellent—characters. The most important of these is Chrisjen Avasarala, Assistant to the Undersecretary of Executive Administration, a lengthy job title which basically means she is an important figure in the Earth Government (yes, Earth has just the one Government in this future). More interestingly, she is an Indian lady in her seventies who is extremely intelligent, an expert at political machination, and cusses up a storm every time she opens her mouth.
Chrisjen Avasarala, looking younger than her description in the book.
This very lively creation makes me reflect on how unbelievable most of “strong women” in sci-fi are. They are mainly based on the
Ellen Ripley template of ass-kicking sci-fi women, and usually result in male characters who happen to be female. Chrisjen Avasarala is more like Margarette Thatcher than Ellen Ripley. Fortunately for mankind, she is on the side of the angels. There is also an Ellen Ripley-like female marine called Roberta Draper, a much less believable character but quite well developed and fun.
The great thing about reading Caliban's War soon after watching The Expanse TV show is that I now have an affinity for the main characters. If I had relied on my sieve-like memory of the previous book it just would not have worked. Now the bantering among the crew of “The Rocinante” has some resonance. Also, the vividness of their TV counterpart makes it easy to put names to faces, so they are almost as familiar to me as the crew of the USS Enterprise.
Beside the great character work Caliban's War also has a fast-paced, intriguing and exciting plot, with some nicely detailed world building. The strained relations between Earth, the Mars colony and the Belters (colonies on the minor planets of the Asteroid Belt) feel very real, and the main characters tremendous efforts to prevent all out warfare is quite gripping. The climax is really edge of the seat reading and far surpasses anything on
Leviathan Wakes (an additional pair of pants recommended while reading this book).
I also love the science and the minutiae of space-faring like:
“Gravity in the ship had shifted subtly. Instead of thrust from the drive creating the illusion of weight, it now came from the spin of the ring they were clamped to. Prax felt like he was tilting slightly to the side whenever he stood up straight”
Passages like this remind me of
Arthur C. Clarke at his best, they make the reading experience very immersive.
In my review of
Leviathan Wakes I complained about the labeling of each chapter with the character’s point of view (
Game of Thrones style) which I felt was unnecessary and distracting. The authors* use the same narrative format here but this time around it works much better because there are four points of view to switch around rather than just two. The several plot strands are also woven beautifully. I also enjoy the variety in the narrative, the bantering dialogue, the subtle political maneuvers, the romance, and especially the running, shooting, alien blasting derring-do's. The book is like one stop shopping for me.
So, bravo! Highly recommended for sci-fi fans, especially if you are into the subgenres of space opera and military sci-fi—with a touch of horror. I won’t retract my less favorable review of
Leviathan Wakes. If I were to reread it I will probably appreciate it more, but that is an honest review, as is this one. Definitely looking forward to book #3,
Abaddon's Gate.
_________________
* James S. A. Corey is a pseudonym of the two co-authors
Daniel Abraham and
Ty Franck.
World building quote:
“Ganymede Station was one of the first permanent human toeholds in the outer planets. It had been built with the long term in mind, not only in its own architecture, but also in how it would fit with the grand human expansion out into the darkness at the edge of the solar system. The possibility of catastrophe was in its DNA and had been from the beginning. It had been the safest station in the Jovian system. Just the name had once brought to mind images of newborn babies and domes filled with food crops. But the months since the mirrors fell had corroded it.”
Spaceship life quote:
“He’d never actually walked with mag boots before, and it was a strange sensation. For most of the stride, his leg felt free and almost uncontrolled, and then, as he brought his foot toward the hull, there would be a moment, a critical point, when the force took hold and slammed him to the metal. He made his way floating and being snatched down, step by step.” -
5.0 Stars
Spoiler Discussion Video:
https://youtu.be/M7uqM82nhAc
I often struggle with sequels, because, in my personal experience, they rarely live up to the perfection of first novels. Therefore, I'm happy to pronounce that Caliban's War was a solid sequel to Leviathan Wakes. I would even go so far as to suggest that it might even be a better novel than the first in some ways.
This novel provides a lot of character development to the cast of misfits introduced in the first book, along with introducing a several new characters. I particularly appreciated the inclusion of two female leads who were both strong, kick-butt ladies, but for very different reasons. I personally am not a fan of the romance side plot that has developed between two of the characters, but that is more of a personal preference.
The story itself moved forward at a good pace, keeping me engaged the whole time. The authors managed a good balance of action, politics and personal development. As with the first book, the chapters cycle through a small cast of characters providing different perspectives on events and pushing the narrative forward..
One of my favourite aspects of the Expanse series is the world-building. I particularly loved reading the differences between the cultures of Earth, Mars & the Belt. I found the discussions of population control & unemployment polices to be just as fascinating as the horrific space monsters lurking in our solar system.
Needless to say, I am very excited to read the next book in the series. Bring on Abaddon's Gate! -
Re-Read 7/7/18
It's so great doing a re-read. I mean, I was somewhat hesitant at first but it's so rich with detail and the action is perfect. And by action, I don't just mean Bobby in her Goliath suit. I mean Avasarala on her com. :) Avasarala is a FORCE to behold. :)
All in all, though, this second book happens to kick major butt. Venus really stole the show by the end, but all the Powers butting heads was also fun as hell.
Did anyone else whoop when Avasarala and Bobby got on the Rocinante?
It was truly great both times I read it. :)
Original Review:
The Expanse series is rapidly becoming one of my favorite stories, and it's only partly due to the scope. Look: If I'm going to read a space-opera, I want huge, Huge, HUGE scope, right? Well, it's my own preferences here, so the answer is a definite YES! I know a little astronomy and scale and putting all of that in perspective with what the hell just happened at the end of this novel is right likely to blow my mind, if it hadn't already been blown when I read Stephen Baxter's The Ring. That's not really that important right now, though, because this novel isn't that novel. This is a much better novel in all the ways that count; in characters, in action, in complicated drama and fully believable, no... engrossing settings.
I think I've read some fantastic space-opera, before, and I think of Bujold as one of the best, but now I will be putting these two guys at the head of the class. Thank you, D.A. and T.F.! For the rest of you peeps sitting on the fence about reading these books, get off your asses and get some startle on. -
4 to 4.5 stars
The Space Opera continues and it ain't over until the fat lady sings . . . or, until you make your way through several oversized tomes!
I don't really have anything to add to this review that I didn't already already cover in my review of Leviathan Wakes. It is another epic in the middle of a bigger epic. The characters are dynamic and interesting. The action is intense. The horror is terrifyingly. All in all, a satisfying and exhausting experience.
When I read books and series like this, I am just so awed and impressed by the intricacies of the plot and it's development. It is so big, I have no idea how they keep up with everything they have created. Also, something will happen and the end of book two that it is obvious they were planning for at the beginning of book one. I picture a huge flowchart an the wall and a lot of double checking with each twist to make sure it still fits within the overall story. Again - impressive!
For sci-fi fans, I really don't think you can go wrong. And, another thing I keep thinking of as I work through this series is the show Firefly/movie Serenity. Anyone else feel that way? Maybe that is what they were going for here! -
Fantastic addition to the series!
Caliban's War was just as good as the first book in the series, Leviathan Wakes.
In fact, this addition adds three new points of view (characters) to the series and two are favorites now.
Gunnery Sergeant Bobby Draper of the Martian Marine Corps and Chrisjen Avasarala, the assistant to the undersecretary of the United Nations.
Both characters bring so much more to this series. They are both badass in their own specific ways and their working relationship with each other is rewarding and fun to follow.
The third new POV that's added to the plot is Praxidike Meng who's a botanist for the atmosphere and ecological system of Ganymede.
I enjoyed Prax for his sense of innocence with all things involving war, weapons and violence, along with his unconditional love for his missing daughter Mei.
I enjoyed the difference with him vs Amos who can be a brutal killer and enforcer for the Rocinante.
All the extra world building and politics with Mars, Earth and the Belters gives the series more depth and intrigue with dealing with the protomolecule.
And of course, the action is top notch like the first book and the level of danger in the galaxy just keeps leveling up.
I love everything about this series!
It should not have taken me this long to get to The Expanse with my love of sci-fi, fantastic characters and complex plots. I'm excited to get to the next book in the series! -
*** 4.25 ***
"...“That man’s asshole must be tight enough right now to bend space.”..."
It must be the right time for me and Sci-Fi, because I loved it! Caliban's War is the second installment in the "Expance" series and I actually enjoyed it better than the first one! No, nothing was wrong with the first one either, I even missed our pulp-noir drunken detective with nothing to lose, but fortunately the authors gave us to kick-ass female characters who more than made up for Miller's loss.
"...“Well, you’ve got a full load of torpedoes and bullets, three Martian warships trailing you, one angry old lady in tea withdrawal, and a Martian Marine who could probably kill you with your own teeth. What do you do?”..."
So, we already know the crew of the Martian ship Rocinante, both appropriated by the free agent Captain James Holden. Somehow, Holden ends up as the very well known face of the person who started the war between Mars, the Belt and Earth with his ideological stick up his ass, and the poster boy for speaking the truth no matter the consequences or the validity of what he believes is the truth. He has not changed much, although it seems that he has been getting a bit out of control and becoming very militant with it, which is upsetting those who know him best. He also gets called out on his self-righteous impulses and I love that I am not the only one who is obviously bugged by that:). Luckily for the very battered scientist of the Ganymede station which produces most vegetative edible forms in the System, Prax, Holden's popularity might help him find his lost 5 year old daughter, and the good captain and his crew take on the challenge.
"...“Just do not pull that fucking trigger. Do you understand what I'm saying? Don't. You will be personally responsible for the deadliest screwup in the history of humankind, and I'm on a ship with Jim fucking Holden, so the bar's not low.”..."
Ganymede station had been attacked by monsters, who are nothing like anything known before and panic and death follows when as a result of the assault, the space mirrors which are used for light, are falling on the surface and destroying the closed ecosystem. During the pandemonium an unknown scientific croup takes Prax's daughter as well as several other children with a medical condition and disappear. On top of everything, some of the goo that made the vomit-zombies in the first book has been let loose in a section of the station and things get complicated when Earth government makes a connection with all of this and the viral station which ended up on Venice. It seems that the viral organisms are in a hive-like communication and not separate from each other.
"...“Point of clarification,” Alex said, raising his hand. “We have an apocalypse comin’? Was that a thing we knew about?” “Venus,” Avasarala said. “Oh. That apocalypse,” Alex said, lowering his hand. “Right.” ..."
The mistrust and fear between the different galactic governments makes the tension palpable and every entity thinks the other is trying to weaponize the virus in order to destroy the rest. However, one very smart, arrogant, plucky, and somewhat vulgar, yes, she curses like a sailor, Earth politician, Avasarala, who is a diminutive grandma with a tendency for wearing bright colored saris, has a real knack for what might be going on and is determined to prevent intergalactic war, which might lead to the destruction of billions of innocent lives. In order to do that, she recruits the biggest bad-ass Martian Marine, Bobbie, who survived the first attack of the alien monster on Ganymede and is now on Earth to testify as to its existence. Bobbie is being looked upon as a trader by her fellow Martians and hates it, but is also deep enough into the reality of things to understand that Avasarala is doing all she can in order to save all parties involved, Mars included.
"...“They’re all fucking men,” she said. “Excuse me?” Soren said. “The generals. They’re all fucking men.” “I thought Souther was the only—” “I don’t mean that they all fuck men. I mean they’re all men, the fuckers. How long has it been since a woman was in charge of the armed forces? Not since I came here. So instead, we wind up with another example of what happens to policy when there’s too much testosterone in the room.” ..."
I like Holden's crew, I am OK with Holden, but I love Bobbie and Avasarala!!! Particularly Avasarala, with her pain of loss, her ability to play the game on the big stage of politics without losing her soul and humanity, still hoping for the best and loving with all her heart her soulmate, who loves her back unconditionally, just the way she is!!! I am so in love with this character and her life, I can barely express it! I really hope I get to see more of both of them as we go on with the series! I can't wait!!!
Now I wish you all Happy Reading and many more wonderful books to come!!! -
3.5*
So similar to the first book in structure but I enjoyed it much more than the first one. -
In this second installment, we're still following events I already know (more or less) from the show.
After billions of years of being in the Solar system, unable to do what it came here to do, the protomolecule is working hard on finishing its job now, whatever that job is.
We meet a few new players in this second installment, most notably Avasarala and Bobbie. The former is a potty-mouthed deputy to the UN Secretary General, the latter a kick-ass Martian Marine.
These two allow us glimpses at Earth and the political crisis the events from book 1 have sparked throughout the Solar system. Avasarala, while being a politician, is actually a good person, swearing so much that any sailor would blush, but ultimately caring deeply about the future. Therefore, she wants to get the people behind Eros as much as Bobbie, who loses her entire platoon to a new version of a protomolecule-human hybrid and swears revenge.
Then, there is also Prax, a botanist and father of Mei - a child with a rare immune disease. While trying to get his daughter back and figuring out who took her and why, he meets Holden and his crew, and they agree to help him.
After some juggling of bureaucratic idiots, Avasarala and Bobbie team up and eventually also meet the crew of the Rocinante, bringing together all four POVs and giving the reader epic space battles and creepy space stations to explore and fight in.
But let's not forget the old players from book one, because they will factor into the events here as well.
Yes, my favourite characters were definitely "grandma" Avasarala and Bobbie, but also the entire environment of the book. I love the future the two authors are bringing to life here as well as the technology - most notably in this book the Martian Marine armor Bobbie wears.
I must say that I'm actually surprised at the number of events I liked better on the show such as . Both elements seem far better developed and thought through on the show.
However, there are also elements that are much more detailed here in the book, such as . Thus, one could say that the show and the books compliment and complete each other, which is actually quite nice.
Now, I've more or less reached the point where I don't know what's gonna happen (have to catch up on the show but there are also only 3 seasons of it and the book events are progressing farther) so it will be interesting to see how I think and feel about people and events from now on. Naturally, I'm most curious about the mystery behind the protomolecule (should we actually get answers) and . -
OMG!!!!!! WTF WTF WTF?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
-
Dying she could handle.
Dying without any answers seemed terribly cruel.
I read
Leviathan Wakes way back. While I enjoyed it well enough, I wasn’t compelled to rush off and start the next book immediately.
But, here we are. And given that this has now been adapted into a TV series (which I haven’t watched yet), the time has come to pick up where I left off…
“Ladies and gentlemen. This settlement is in security lockdown.”
…and I’m glad that I did! If this book is anything to go by the series is shaping up nicely, with the promise of good things to come.
This is a high-profile series, so there are already droves of (positive) reviews here; it makes little sense to add another. But let’s, anyway.
The story doesn’t take long to get going. There is a fair amount of excitement and drama right out of the gates, which sets the tone for the book’s pacing.
Also, I know comparisons aren’t necessarily good form, but I find that they help convey the feel of a story when my vocabulary lets me down:
-
The Quiet War: there is more than a passing resemblance to McAuley’s work, from the inner-system / outer-system politics down to the fact that a main character in The Quiet War is a Soil Biologist (Prax from Caliban’s War is a Botanist). The biggest difference, I suppose, is that The Expanse is more action driven.
- Firefly: obvious enough. Except: with more actual science.
To be clear, I don’t intend these comparisons to be taken as criticism, but it adds some context to what can be expected from this book. The general feel of this Universe, if you will.
It’s noteworthy that the authors can create a sense of Space Operatic grandiosity, while still keeping everything rooted in the kind of verisimilitude that near future Hard Science Fiction is normally known for. This marriage of style and substance does create something that is possibly slightly bigger than the sum of its parts.
The best scientific minds of the system were staring at the data with their jaws slack, and the reason no one was panicking yet was that no one could agree on what they should panic about.
And of course, theelephant in the roomprotomolecule. This obviously (still) makes for some scaryshits**t, and is the baited “hook” of the series. It’s a good one too. Horrorandin Science Fiction is a fantastic mix if done right. It’s utilized to fine effect here; the authors are wisely not bombarding the reader with zombie sequences all the time (something which would reduce their impact). They’re kept in reserve for just the right moment. I would have loved to learn more about the origin of the protomolecule, especially considering the closing sequences of the novel. Explanations had better be forthcoming in the next instalment.
When the battle began, it began all at once.
I have to say I found the action sequences pretty damn exciting. I can imagine that all of this would translate well to the visual medium.
Of course, no SF novel would be complete without some wonder:
Some part of [him] was disappointed that the transit was so dangerous. He’d never flown to Io before, and the view of the moon at the edge of his screens was spectacular. A massive volcano of molten silicate on the opposite side of the moon was throwing particles so high into space he could see the trail it left in the sky. The plume cooled into a spray of silicate crystals, which caught Jupiter’s glow and glittered like diamonds scattered across the black. Some of them would drift off to become part of Jupiter’s faint ring system, blown right out of Io’s gravity well. In any other circumstance, it would have been beautiful.
I’m not giving this book 5 stars though. Why? While I really enjoyed Caliban’s War it isn’t all rosy: for one thing, despite feeling like a better novel than its predecessor (as mentioned above), it also felt a bit “samey”. Like a repeat performance, if you will, albeit a better rehearsed one. Also, I didn’t care too much for a few of the characters. A chain is as strong as its weakest link; for example, I really liked Bobbie Draper but Prax annoyed me.
So, other than that there isn’t too much to add. This is the second book in (what appears to be) a nine-book series. As such it serves as a sequel as well as a set up for whatever comes next, which is a bit of an Achilles heel in itself, albeit an expected one. It does its job commendably; in the end everything comes together nicely. If Leviathan Wakes was a 3.5 rounded up, this one is a solid 4.0.
“We’re all traitors now.”
“Only if we lose.” -
2021 reread:
Avasarala is still the best. I love that woman. Felt somewhat lukewarm about Holden, to be honest. But his crew is still pretty cool. Overall, though, on this reread the novel was not as close to five stars for me as it was the first time around. But maybe this time I will actually continue with the rest of the series. I guess we'll find out.
*****
2018 review:
I liked this a little better than the first one, I think.
While it doesn't quite reach the highs of
Leviathan Wakes, it is more consistent in tone and feels like the overall more polished book.
We get more in-depth characterization of Holden, which was good, and two fantastic new characters in Bobbie and especially Avasarala (she's truly great) more than make up for the absence of Miller and the somewhat scarse appearances of Fred.
Still not quite five star material, in my opinion, but a very engaging space opera nonetheless.
I'd say 4.5 stars and recommended.
-
CALIBAN'S WAR is the second book in The Expanse series, and this is the one that made me a true fan and ensured my continuation of the series.
I want to make a special mention of the character Chrisjen Avasarala, the UN official-OMG her foul mouth had me laughing my ass off! She was a new character in this volume, as was Bobbi, (a Martian Marine), and Prax, a botanist on Ganymede. I loved them.
I also want to say that this narrator is fabulous!
Highly recommended! (But you must read this series in order to get everything you can out of it.)
I downloaded this book from my local library. Libraries RULE! -
Avasarala and Bobbi are great! They get to be a lot stronger than the show.
Love the firefly led into the next book. -
More like 4 and a half.
Yup, I drank the damn Kool-Aid and now I’m reading this series of inconveniently huge paperbacks. Sigh. What can I tell you: “The Expanse” is everything I could possibly want a space opera to be, both on the page and on the screen. It’s intricately plotted, furiously paced (I have screamed: “One more episode!” at my husband too many times to keep count), filled with awesome and diverse characters, and the world building is amazing. Now my struggle is figuring out how to free up shelf space for them…
“Caliban’s War” begins pretty much where “Leviathan Wakes” (
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...) left off: Earth has been saved by the skin of its teeth, thanks to James Holden and Joe Miller’s unlikely team work and sacrifice, but that doesn’t mean anyone in the Solar System has had much time to catch their breath. The Ganymede station is attacked and no one seems to know by whom (or what!), the governments of both Earth and Mars are simply itching to launch bombs at each other, and while crashing Eros on Venus was the best option available at the time, it turns out to have had serious consequences… Holden is still shaken up from saving Earth from the protomolecule, and seems to grieve by taking on some of Miller’s less recommendable traits, like extreme snarkiness and being a reckless wildcard who shoots first and asks questions never… He decides to help one of the survivors of the attack on Ganymede, a botanist named Prax Meng, who believes his daughter was kidnapped for nefarious purposes. On Earth, formidable political animal Chrisjen Avasarala works on preventing a System-wide war, and while her intentions are good, her methods can best be called questionable on certain occasions. She enlists the help of Martian Marine (ironic that they use the word "Marine" for soldiers from a desert planet...), Bobbie Draper, a rather intimidating woman who saw things the Martian military would like her not to talk about...
The Earth vs. Mars vs. the Belt conflict strikes me as depressingly realistic: the sign of excellent speculative fiction is that you read it and think to yourself “yup, that would totally happen”, which is absolutely the case with the complicated political mess that is this colonization of the Solar System. The SyFy adaptation is perfectly cast, so I now picture all the characters as they are portrayed on TV, but I must say that I am really pleased with the characterization as the series evolves: while the pacing doesn’t leave much room for deep dives into anyone’s back story, I find them all interesting and endearing in their own weird way. It’s also really lovely to have female characters in sci-fi who are not cookie-cutter stereotypes or defined by their sexuality: they have personalities, are competent at their jobs, flawed and layered.
Obviously, I missed Miller (#rememberthehat), who will always be sexy AF Thomas Jane in my (admittedly dirty) mind, but I was so excited to revisit the Rocinante’s crew (I simply adore Naomi!) and to finally meet Chrisjen Avasarala on the page! I am both fascinated and freaked out by this incredible lady, who makes Machiavelli sound like a garden-variety pencil pusher, and who rocks a million colourful saris. Of course, no Miller POV means the noir detective storyline and tone is gone, but the Firefly-type humor is still there (“If he hadn’t been the executive of the largest government body in the history of the human race, he’d have made a killing promoting health drinks.”), as is the plot’s constant hopping from fire to frying pan, which makes the book hard to put down. The addition of Prax is great, because it gives the reader a scientist’s perspective on the events unfolding, which makes the world building even more complex and interesting.
I don’t think any space opera series will ever top Becky Chambers’ “Wayfarer” series in my nerd-heart, but I’d say this is coming in at a close second. If you liked the first book, keep reading the series! And watch the show! -
Caliban's War (Expanse, #2), James S.A. Corey
Caliban's War is a 2012 science fiction novel by James S. A. Corey (pen name of Daniel Abraham and Ty Franck). It is about a conflict in the solar system that involves Earth, Mars, and the Asteroid Belt (colonies of people living on asteroids, referred to as "Belters"). It is the second book in The Expanse series.
On Ganymede, Mei Meng is kidnapped from her preschool by her doctor. Several hours later, Earth and Martian space marines are attacked and effortlessly killed by a super soldier, with Bobbie Draper, a Martian marine, the only survivor. Earth and Mars begin a shooting war which throws Ganymede into chaos. In the aftermath, Mei's father Praxidike Meng fruitlessly searches for his daughter in the midst of the societal breakdown in the Ganymede colony.
Several months later, the crew of the Rocinante are tasked with delivering emergency aid to Ganymede. Meng spots James Holden during a food riot and asks the crew to help find his daughter. They agree and are able to trace her kidnappers to unused tunnels on the moon. Holden, Meng, and ship mechanic Amos Burton discover a secret lab. In the midst of a shootout with lab security, they inadvertently release another super soldier who kills some of the lab personnel. In the wake of the battle, the crew find remnants of the protomolecule and the corpse of Mei's friend, who was being treated by Mei's doctor for immunodeficiency. The crew rush to escape the station as more chaos erupts around them, and are able to make it back aboard the Rocinante.
Draper is brought to the peace talks between Earth and Mars occurring on Earth, giving testimony regarding the super soldier attack on Ganymede. She violates diplomatic protocol and is dismissed by the Martian delegation, but is then hired by Chrisjen Avasarala, who is leading the UN negotiations. Draper discovers that Avasarala's assistant is betraying her, leading Avasarala to conclude that her UN superiors are trying to get rid of her, from which she deduces that a group within the UN is responsible for the super soldier attack. Avasarala allows Draper to be brought along as her bodyguard on a slow-moving yacht headed to Ganymede on an ostensible relief mission.
تاریخ نخستین خوانش: ماه ژانویه سال 2018 میلادی
عنوان: گستره: کتاب دوم: جنگ کالیبان؛ نویسنده: جیمز اس.ای. کوری؛
ا. شربیانی -
The second novel in The Expanse series finds Holden and the crew of the Rocinante trying to stop further attempts to weaponize the protomolecule, with a little help from a Martian marine, a belt-born botanist, and a UN power broker.
As exciting and action packed as the first book, and nearly as good. The ending, while spectacular, doesn't quite pack the emotional punch of its predecessor. -
I really want to like these books...and so I do. As I'm tidying up this review from notes I made ages ago, I've already finished the third book in the series and absolutely acknowledge that I could be reading these more critically. I'm finding as I read, though, that I am leaning into what I enjoy about them: they are fun, layered space adventures with a main cast that I enjoy to see bond and evolve. Right now, that's mostly enough for me.
I'm liking the expansion into a four-character POV, and mostly enjoying the new voices. Bobbie and Avasarala are kick-ass in very different ways (though I'll allow that the authors seem to commit too hard to a broadest stroke outline that winds up occasionally reductive). Prax has strengths that I love and quirks that I don't, and the latter got more page space than the former, unfortunately.
The first book in the series, Leviathan Wakes, was able to incorporate a number of genre nods into its structure, and I felt the lack of that in this second installment. Still, the alien protomolecule and what's happening on Venus contributes a fascinating menace while the politicking is amped up, kicking the whole space opera schtick into high gear.
If I had to pinpoint one complaint that almost pushed me into the sort of criticality that would genuinely eat at my enjoyment, it would be some anger at the way Naomi's character is presented in this book. She has all the potential for a strong individual, but for nearly three quarters of the book she seems only to exist for Holden's sake. And he is so bloody whiny about their romance.
Beyond that, and acknowledging that the tv series is better than the books, I'm going to dig in and say that I just like these books...and I'm happy enough to be to be liking much of anything right now. So I'm alright not thinking too deeply beyond that. -
2021 Re-read before publication of last book.
“Well, you’ve got a full load of torpedoes and bullets, three Martian warships trailing you, one angry old lady in tea withdrawal, and a Martian Marine who could probably kill you with your own teeth. What do you do?”
Always a bit worried with second volumes but Caliban's War is another amazing adventure, very cinematographic, which explains why the tv series is so popular. The plot carries on from the events of Leviathan Wakes and once again Holden is one of the narrators. His is a different voice however, shaded by his experiences, and one I enjoyed more, especially from the middle of the book onwards. We also have three new narrators, each compelling in their own right, with Avasarala being the most fascinating one in my opinion, reminding me a little of Foreigner's Ilisidi.
Although there are parallels in the structure of these two novels, the tone of this one felt different. Instead of the film noir aspect brought by Miller, we have the cut-throat world of politics of Avasarala, the military element of Bobbie, and the social aspect of feeding Belters. Of course this is ultimately a scifi opera, full of action scenes and thrilling moments. From the very beginning, the narrative grabs you and doesn't relent. And THAT ending!!!
Still loved it :O) -
Reread 2021 - 4 stars
I enjoyed this even more than the first time around. Bobbie and Avasarala are such great characters, and watching the way the Rocinante team comes together is a treat.
I'm finding it interesting to reread these after watching Seasons 1-5 of The Expanse show, and seeing the choices that are made not just with respect to storyline, but also how certain characters develop. I wouldn't say one is better than the other, they are just quite different. What they have in common is that they are both excellent in their own medium.
Read 2016 - 4 stars
Solid second entry in the series. That ending left me wanting to get to the next book as soon as possible!
