| Title | : | Seeds of Rebellion (Beyonders, #2) |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | 1416997946 |
| ISBN-10 | : | 9781416997948 |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Hardcover |
| Number of Pages | : | 483 |
| Publication | : | First published March 1, 2012 |
| Awards | : | Goodreads Choice Award Middle Grade & Children's (2012) |
After the cliffhanger ending of A World Without Heroes, Jason is back in the world he’s always known—yet for all his efforts to get home, he finds himself itching to return to Lyrian. Jason knows that the shocking truth he learned from Maldor is precious information that all of his friends in Lyrian, including Rachel, need if they have any hope of surviving and defeating the evil emperor.
Meanwhile, Rachel and the others have discovered new enemies—as well as new abilities that could turn the tide of the entire quest. And as soon as Jason succeeds in crossing over to Lyrian, he’s in more danger than ever. Once the group reunites, they strive to convince their most-needed ally to join the war and form a rebellion strong enough to triumph over Maldor. At the center of it all, Jason and Rachel realize what roles they’re meant to play—and the answers are as surprising as they are gripping.
Seeds of Rebellion (Beyonders, #2) Reviews
-
Seeds of Rebellion (Beyonders, #2), Brandon Mull
After Jason succeeds in finding a way back to Lyrian, he's immediately in more danger than ever. Meanwhile, Rachel and the others have made their own progress--as well as discovered new enemies. As the group ultimately rejoins, they strive to convince their most needed ally to join the war and form a rebellion strong enough to triumph against the emperor.
عنوانهای چاپ شده در ایران: «بذرهای شورش»؛ «بذرهای قیام»؛ نویسنده: براندون مول؛ تاریخ نخستین خوانش: روز چهارم ماه ژوئن سال2016میلادی
عنوان: سه گانه ماورایی ها - کتاب دوم - بذرهای شورش؛ نویسنده: براندون مول؛ مترجم: سمانه امین پور؛ تهران، آذرباد، سال1394، در624ص؛ شابک9786006225395؛ موضوع داستانهای نویسندگان ایالات متحده آمریکا - سده21م
عنوان: سه گانه ماورایی ها - کتاب دوم - بذرهای قیام؛ نویسنده: براندون مول؛ مترجم: فرناز حائری؛ تهران، بهنام، سال1394، در562ص؛ شابک9786007132128؛
داستان پر کششی است، ادامه ی کتاب «دنیای بدون قهرمان» است؛ «جیسون واکر» دوباره به «لیریان» برمیگردد، و ماجراهای پرهیجان سفر ادامه مییابد...؛
کتاب «بذرهای قیام» نوشته ی «براندون مول»، با حضور «گالوران»، آخرین امید «لیریانی» آغاز می‌شود؛ او برای دیدن زنی پیشگو، به معبدی دور افتاده سفر میکند؛ و برای رسیدن به آن معبد، بهای سنگینی میپردازد، «چوو» بسیاری از دوستانش را از دست میدهد؛ و پس از گذر از زنجیرهای حفاظتی، زن پیشگو را می‌بیند، او تنها صورت زن را می‌بیند، که در میان دو سنگ قرار گرفته است؛ زن پیشگوی به «گالوران» توصیه میکند، برای مبارزه و قیام، خود را آماده کند؛ او می‌گوید در صورت نبودن «گالوران»، «مالدور» پیروز می‌شود، که حکمرانی فاجعه آمیزی خواهد داشت؛ زن پیشگو، که نگهبان یکی از هجاهای کلمه ی کلیدی است، به «گالوران» نوید میدهد، که برای پیروزی باید، سایر هجاهای آن کلمه را پیدا کند؛ «گالوران» پس از آن دیدار، برای پیدا کردن سایر هجاها راهی می‌شود، و داستان کتاب «بذرهای قیام» نوشته ی «براندون مول» را شکل میدهد
نقل از متن آخرین صفحات کتاب دوم: (شاهزاده وارد اتاق شد؛ بخارهایی با بوی شیرین و تند، در فضا پراکنده بود؛ تلألؤ تک و توک شمع‌های روشن، بیشتر کنده کاری‌های کهن را، در سایه، پنهان کرده بود؛ برای رسیدن به این معبد، بهای گزافی پرداخته بود؛ دوستانی را از دست داده بود؛ خانواده اش معتقد بودند، که وظایفش را در قبال آنها و «ترنسیکورت»، نادیده گرفته است؛ ولی او می‌بایست سر درمی‌آورد؛ راهبان کلاه به سر، زنجیرها را بالا کشیدند، تا تخته سنگ از دریاچه ی معطر بیرون بیاد؛ بدن پیشگوی زن، پوشیده از گِل بود، و فقط صورتش پیدا بود؛ چشمانش بسته بود؛ شاهزاده صبر کرد؛ راهبان زنجیرها را بستند، و آنجا را ترک کردند؛ وقتی چک چک گلِ سرازیر از تخته سنگ تمام شد، فضا غرق در سکوت شد...)؛ پایان نقل
تاریخ بهنگام رسانی 12/02/1400هجری خورشیدی؛ 09/02/1401هجری خورشیدی؛ ا. شربیانی -
Review #1 - March 2012
By the end I was almost ready to give this book five stars. The concluding chapter packed a powerful emotional punch.
I think what I love most about Brandon Mull's books is that it's easily believable. There is no wasted space on boring histories of the world, Lyrian just...is. It exists, Jason and Rachel are there, displacers, manglers, Edomic....it all seems perfectly natural. I felt like I understood the world perfectly. Sometimes fantasy series spend so much time trying to explain the world, that the story is lost. Brandon Mull never has that problem.
Also, I honestly don't know how this series will end. I'm scared for the third book because I've grown to love so many of the characters that I don't want them to die. I'm hoping that Brandon Mull doesn't choose to make it needlessly tragic. From the way Fablehaven concluded, I don't think he will, but I'm still a little nervous.
I like the subtle lessons that we learn in this book. It's not dogmatic or lecturing at all, but it's a story of heroes, people who consistently put the welfare of all above their own. People who live for a higher purpose and sacrifice much for it. Jason and Rachel knew nothing of this world and yet chose to remain to help them. In a world that is full of entitlement and seeking personal satisfaction, it is a good reminder about what is most important.
I think Brandon Mull is a fantastic writer and I appreciate that his books appeal to boys and girls. I'm excited for the final installment in this series.
Review #2 - June 2020
I listened to the audio again. I enjoyed the second book a lot more than the first book. I think it's because the whole world is set up so we just jump right into the action. I love the places they visit too. -
This world is so rich, so fun, and Brandon Mull's imagination is so vast that I kept thinking, "This book should be better."
And when I was reminded of the language of this book as I read "The Magic Treehouse" to my 4 year old, I decided that what Brandon Mull really has is an editing problem.
His editor for Fablehaven is not the same as for this series, and I just can't help but think that this is the main problem. The sentence structures are inconsistent, with language ranging from cluttered and sloppy to just plain bad. And the pacing isn't as choppy as the first, but after an exciting battle, we grind to a screeching halt as we traipse through the jungle, and it's so boring that I skipped a few pages just to get to something that I could tolerate reading. Somebody should have caught that.
It's disappointing, because there is so much that is good in this book, and this series had the potential to be something amazing. But as I said before, when the language detracts from the storytelling, you know you have a problem.
In his notes, Brandon Mull said that he has been working on this idea for close to a decade, so I know this is something close to his heart. But the fact that it has taken him this long to churn it out makes me wonder if he couldn't quite wrap his brain around how to tell the story. And the way this series is filling out only confirms my suspicions--he doesn't know quite how to tell it, and so it doesn't gel as well as it should. And his editor didn't help. At. All. Seriously, there were some really cringe-worthy sentences in this book that don't belong in a book written by an author as talented as Brandon Mull.
But I'll admit I was more invested in the characters than I was in the previous book, and Rachel's character is turning into something kinda cool. I was interested enough to keep reading (and seriously, how cool were Galloran's sword fights? Super cool, I tell you what), and I'll read the final installment when it comes out next year. I thought he delivered Fablehaven's conclusion in a very satisfying way, so I'll hold out hope that this things crystallizes and comes together in a way that is pleasing to both the author and the reader.
But, Brandon, for heaven's sake, get a better editor. -
Brandon has a very active, creative imagination. All kinds of strange things show up in these books. There’s lots of adventure and good characters, though it felt a little slow at times.
-
Brandon Mull has created an amazing world, and some amazing races. I think that as far as fantasy worlds go, this is one of the best laid out and most imaginative. The different people and food descriptions are so detailed, I feel like I am there meeting them, eating the food, and saving the world.
So, why only three stars? I have been having a difficult time connecting with the characters. Something I loved about the Fablehaven series that Brandon Mull wrote was that the characters and world were amazingly intertwined. I cared about the characters, got annoyed with Seth, and always appreciated a scene with the satyrs. I am struggling to make those connections with these characters.
Prehaps it's because the author has been trying to get this series out for ten years, we spent so much time building this amazing world, and then struggled to fit the main characters in.
I will read the next book, happily. I have a feeling that the characters will really rise up in the last book. It seems like Brandon Mull has been building the world in the first two, and the characters will shine in the third. I'm hoping. -
Final rating: 4.75/5 stars
Since i have no template for my reviews over here, i will have to do this without it.
I always went pass these books in my bookstore. Both in my language and in english. I decided I wanted to read the english version more. I do not regret my decision. I loved both first and second book. I hope the third book will prove to be a satisfying conclusion. Then i am sure i will buy the whole set on my language for sure.
This book does not suffer from bridge book effect. It was an essential addition to the story and fantastically done.
More and more i love the characters, but can I tell you all how much I love Ferrin, Tark, Aram, Drake and Rachel and Jason, and also Galloran? Basically I love all the main characters, and I feel like Galloran and Ferrin will always have a special place in my heart.
Also the covers are faithful to the scenes that happen. Which I love, since the first two covers are not nonsensical at all.
I love the plot, love the characters, love the ideas. And i really love the bad guy. He's a very interesting villain. Love the races idea (although displacers always make me laugh because Buggy from One Piece has the very similar ability hahahahah), and I love torivors and displacers, and dringlings etc etc.
These books are fun, exciting, emotional and dark. What more do you need? Loveable characters are here, plot is steady and fast paced, and it was over before I knew it. Sigh. I need the next book right now.► REVIEW(S) RELATED TO THIS BOOK:
◈
A World Without Heroes (Beyonders, #1)
◈
Seeds of Rebellion (Beyonders, #2)
◈
Chasing the Prophecy (Beyonders, #3) -
دنیای جادویی که نویسنده ساخته بود، جالب بود. موجودات جالب و جدید که توی کتابای دیگه مثل اونا رو ندیده بودم. مثل پیوندزن ها که اجزای بدن شون قابل جدا کردن بود، یا مردم دونه دار که با کاشته شدن دونه شون عمر مجدد میکردن و...
شخصیت ها هم جالب بودن. مخصوصا جیسون. نکته جالب اینه که جیسون هیچ نیروی جادویی یا خاصی نداره. (چیزی که توی داستان های فانتزی نوجوانانه خیلی پیش نمیاد.) اما میتونه مثل یک قهرمان رفتار کنه؛ دوستانش رو همراهی میکنه؛ بهش��ن انگیزه میده. جیسون وارد دنیای ماورایی شده که با میل خودش مجدد به اون وارد شده. درحالی که میتونست بی خیال مردم بیچاره ی سرزمین ماورایی و ظلم های امپراتورش بشه. چنین روحیه ای باعث میشه دیگرانی هم به قی��م علیه امپراتور بپیوندن.
شخصیت فرین هم جالب بود. کسی که خیانت و دورویی تو ذاتشه. اون خودش رو وفادار به قیام معرفی میکنه. اما اعتماد به خائن ممکنه یک خود فریبی باشه. تضادها و درگیری هایی که با خودش داره، شخصیتش رو کاملا واقعی کرده. فرین می خواد وفادار باشه؛ به جیسون و گالوران. اما میدونه که ممکنه هر سربزنگاه به اونا خیانت کنه.
و گالوران. پیر خردمند داستان. آروم و پرصلابت. بچه تر که بودم معمولا عاشق پیرای خرمند داستان میشدم مثل دامبلدور و گندالف. اینجا هم تقریبا همین طور بود. گالوران شکست ناپذیر نیست. قبلا شکست خورده، تحقیر شده و سال ها زندانی بوده. اما می خواد دوباره تلاش کنه، ارتشی جمع کنه و علیه امپراتور مبارزه کنه. -
Full review found here:
Three Blank Pages ;)
Brandon Mull has done it again! Just when I thought things couldn't get better after reading the first book, Mr. Mull did a finer job with this one. It was really exciting and really hard to put down. While I was reading it, I was torn between the decision of finishing the book and to literally force myself to put it down, for the fear of having it to end. But of course, my curiosity got a better hold of me so I ended up finishing it. IT WAS WORTH IT. I did not regret anything aside from feeling a bit disappointed to have to wait a year for the final book.
The only question I have for the book is this, If Jason is supposedly the main character, then why is that Rachel seems stronger (in terms of ability) than him? Oh Dear Gracious, I wonder how the third book will be like. I CANT WAIT!! -
I’ve been waiting exactly a year for the second Beyonders book. I read A World Without Heroes at family camp last year. This year I checked out Seeds of Rebellion to read at camp once again. We leave today but, ahem, I finished the book last night. Drat! I did have a little trouble recalling details from the first book. People and places were mentioned that I couldn’t remember right away, but most of the time I figured them out through context. I fear I’ll have the same trouble next time; the final book of the trilogy releases in the spring of 2013.
This one felt a little nebulous. After the very definite quest of book one, I felt like Jason’s return to Lyrian didn’t really have much point. He was such a brave hero in the first go-round, but this time he’s more of a tag-along, a liability almost, dependent on others stronger than himself. They all seem stronger than him. Rachel discovers a powerful knack for the magical language; Aram, the half-giant, is a bastion of strength—at least half the time; Ned has tremendous cunning and knowledge of poisons; Tark turns out rather courageous; Ferrin the displacer is irreplaceable; and even old, blind Galloran finds unexpected strength and resolve. But no one seemed to have much of a plan about how to defeat Maldor.
Once the tiny group of rebels assembles, they journey to the land of the Seed People—they know they need all the allies they can gather—and they find plenty of adventure along the way. But when the Amar Kabal hesitate to join them and openly defy Maldor, a mixed company is formed to travel to the oracle and learn whether resistance against the evil wizard has even the slightest chance of success. They make it to the oracle, barely, and learn they have one chance in a million, which is more than they hoped for. But to succeed, they must split forces. Two tasks must be accomplished, one by Galloran and one by Jason, if they are to succeed. And I was rather glad to hear it. That means the little band with have a purpose once again in book three, and Jason will return to prominence.
Though I enjoyed book one more (once I got into it), this one did keep me reading. There are plenty of casualties, but the few squeamish moments of book one are absent. It’s a bit milder. In his Author’s Note, Mr. Mull mentions that he’s been working on this series ten years. That’s amazing, and I applaud his efforts. But I’m afraid the series will never place among my favorites. I do have to say he knows how to plug in excitement; the wandering band finds danger at every turn. And he’s endlessly creative. But the humor is just a bit bland, and the series never attains much depth. It does have purpose—defeat the Great Evil—and it has danger and magic, courage and honor, but those deep moments of reflection, of inner discovery, are few and far between. I must mention a very nicely written scene, however, in which Ferrin is examining his motives for betraying Maldor and joining the rebellion. He’s uncertain of himself and his loyalties. In my opinion, that is the most powerful, most emotional, most honest moment in the series. I wish there were more like it.
Content is clean and so is the language. It is violent in a fantasy adventure sort of way but not inappropriate. I’d give this one a 10+ rating because of length, though there’s no reason to prevent younger readers from picking it up. -
I really, really wanted to love this, but... I didn't :(
I was a huge fan of Brandon Mull's Fablehaven and enjoyed his first Beyonders novel. I was excited to check out his next book, and freaked out when I received this in the mail, my very first ARC :) . Unfortunately, the problems that started with the first book persisted through the second, and I found it difficult to finish.
My main issue was the character development, or lack of, I should say. The author seemed to skip over his characters to focus on his plot, which I found irritating. Jason, our hero, is portrayed as an ordinary young teenager, to the point it's extremely boring. I'd rather read about an interesting character who was also relatable than a character who is basically so 'normal' he doesn't even feel real. The other characters aren't characterized enough either and it took away from the story since I simply didn't care about them. Unlike Fablehaven, where Seth and Kendra might have felt a little cliche at first, they really grew by the end of the series into likable, relatable heroes, Jason and Rachel simply didn't work for me.
The secondary characters had some interesting bits, but on the whole, were rather forgettable. Fablehaven is populated with a memorable supporting cast, while this book, set in a fantasy world, could have chose to use some really fascinating characters, but failed to. I don't know what I was expecting, a LOTR style ensemble perhaps, but that seems farfetched since this is a kids book. Overall, the characters weren't the kind who you would remember long after reading.
The plot; in times it was interesting, but in times felt slow and dragging. Brandon Mull certainly has an imagination and I found myself enjoying his creative world. It certainly feels similar to Narnia, Middle-Earth or any other medieval fantasy world, but it had it's own uniqueness too, including the beings who populate it. Speaking of unique and creative, the entire idea of 'the word' and the cliffhanger at the end of the first book, were a perfect set up for a sequel. Unfortunately for me, the sequel didn't deliver on the level I had hoped it would.
The writing style was so-so for me. It wasn't exactly riveting, but not badly written either. Honestly, I found I preferred the writing in his other books.
Overall, not a bad book, just not for me. I don't plan on reading the final book, but I will, however, check out any new series Brandon writes, especially if he continues with his Fablehaven books (since I'm dying to know what happens with Kendra&Bracken, Seth, Vanessa&Warren, the Sphinx, who the new Eternals are, and so much more!)
Thanks to GoodReads for providing me with a copy. xox -
Jason kembali ke rumah, setelah kembali dari petualangannya di Lyrian. Tetapi mengetahui Rachel masih di Lyrian dan kemungkinan bahaya bagi Rachel, Jason segera saja ingin menyelamatkan Rachel dan kembali lagi ke Lyrian, Jason berhasil menyeberang kembali ke Lyrian dengan cara yang sama seperti sebelumnya terakhir kali - melalui mulut hippo. Sementara itu, Rachel sedang mengembangkan bakat magis (sihir), dan jelas dia memiliki lebih banyak potensi dari siapa pun. Jason Walker juga harus bertemu dengan Raja Buta dan memulai pencarian untuk mempertemukan kerajaan simpatik untuk memberontak terhadap Maldor.
Kedua dalam trilogi Beyonders yang dimulai dengan Dunia Tanpa Pahlawan, Seeds of Rebellion membawa kembali banyak karakter baru. Dunia kreatif Mull tentang Lyrian memiliki susunan yang fantastis ras yang unik, dengan sentuhan baru. Karakter favorit adalah Ferrin, seorang pemindah yang dapat menghapus bagian-bagian tubuh tanpa membahayakan, yang benar-benar jujur tentang kecenderungan pengkhianat nya belum ingin setia kepada Jason Walker. juga Aram, Pemuda blasteran manusia-Raksasa bersedia mengawal Jason untuk meencari Rachel juga Raja buta. saya paling suka cerita petualangan Jason, Aram dan Ferrin di mana itu ada kejadian lucu, kocak,seru namun kompak. Aram n Ferrin jg saling mengejek satu sama lain yg membuatku tertawa ngakak.
Fantasi epik Kualitas ini dinikmati oleh pembaca dari segala usia. Sebuah fantasi berbasis pencarian, petualangan, tantangan, pengkhianatan dengan kompleks. Banyak misteri, ketegangan, sihir, dan humor membuat sekuel ini lebih menyenangkan daripada yang pertama. saya sgt menyukai setiap dari karakter yang berani, menakjubkan dan kualitas cerita menarik. serta membuat penasaran setiap halaman per halaman. -
{December 11th, 2014} FINALLY
“Do us all a favor and toss your mouth overboard.”
2.5 Starsnot really that sorry.
When I finally finished reading this I was wheezing, I hadn't noticed I had held my breath as I just blasted through these pages like mad because it was just that painful of a read. How is this STILL flat? Already had low expecations set by the first book but this just maintained and dragged it into the we're-gotta-need-a-goddamn-miracle-here-boys-and-gals kind of pinch for me. I just...I don't know where this has gone wrong. I mean it's written well as far as I can see (except for those few instances where I found editing mistakes, like how did you seriously miss those?!).
All in all, it builds on from the first book, but again--like many others before it--this book suffers from second-book syndrome. It's awful to get infected with. Honestly, I think this could have been basically a duology for most part. There's so many characters now that you just have to go back and reread after you noticed something vital happened to them--at that point I wasn't really caring and just sped-read to insanity, just trying to find a point I could care and liked. Unfortunately there weren't too many of those. x:
It's a shame, but I now embark on the final book--before I dive back into the Fablehaven books (I just noticed they arrived today).
“Sometimes the best offense was avoiding self-destruction.” -
Wow! I enjoyed this much more than I expected. I expected to enjoy it, but since it is the second (and middle book) in the trilogy, I didn't think it would be quite as exciting as it turned out to be.
Brandon Mull did a great job of reminding me about events from the first book without spending too much time rehashing the past. And I enjoyed the fact that the hippo was used again! :)
For those who have read book one in the series, you definitely need to read this! I look forward to book three. -
Alright. I take it back. I love this narrator. Most--if not all--of my complaints from the first book are nonexistent in Seeds of Rebellion! Yay! The writing improved a lot too. I feel like it wasn't as awkward or forced. I liked the story better too; It was so much more entertaining and kept me on the edge of my seat all day! Plus there's the fact that it seemed a little more believable (not that anything about this series is believable :p). I'm a little disgusted about some things in the book, like worm-infected zombies.....among other things. But it was great! And more cliff hangers. Thanks a lot, Mull. Thankfully I have the next audiobook available as well. Really the only complaint I have about Seeds of Rebellion is Rachel's character arc. It came out of absolutely nowhere and I don't think it matches her character very well. Oh well. I'm willing to forgive that :p
Overall, I enjoyed Seeds of Rebellion a million times better than A World Without Heroes and I can't wait to read Chasing the Prophesy!
I apologise for my scatter brained review but I've exhausted my reserves of long reviews (Yes, there was only long review). -
This is just as fun as book one of the series, with a large cast of characters that Mull manages to make distinctive and interesting. The story is also very much a quest, as was book one, with lots of peril and unusual creatures and races (including a unique take on zombies). Again, if you are a fan of the Fablehaven books, you'll definitely enjoy this series. And if you enjoyed the first book, you won't be disappointed with this one.
My Website
Find me on Facebook
My YA fantasy series:
book 1
book 2
book 3
-
Melanjutkan petualangan dari "A World Without Heroes" (review
di sini), Jason sekali lagi kembali ke Lyrian. Misinya kali ini adalah untuk membawa pesan tentang rahasia Maldor kepada sang Raja Buta, rahasia yang dapat mengubah seluruh alur pertentangan dengan Maldor.
Suka banget. Ceritanya masih tetap seru dan bikin betah untuk dibaca. Dalam 2 hari saja saya bisa menyelesaikan buku setebal 676 halaman ini.
Di buku ke-2 ini ada banyak perkembangan yang terjadi. Misi yang Jason dan Rachel jalani berkembang menjadi lebih besar. Semakin banyak dan beragam teman perjalanan yang muncul dengan satu tujuan yang sama: menumbangkan Maldor dan mengembalikan kedamaian Lyrian.
Saya suka dengan karakter-karakter baru yang muncul di sini. Favorit saya adalah Aram, si setengah raksasa yang bertubuh besar dan berotot di malam hari, tapi ceking dan kecil di saat matahari tampak di langit.
Ceritanya mungkin tidak se-wah buku pertama, tapi tetap menghibur dan seru karena penuh dengan petualangan yang keren."Apa gunanya melawan musuh setangguh Maldor?" (Aram)
Moira menghadap putranya. "Karena kau mungkin akan menemukan bahwa dia tidak seperkasa yang kau bayangkan." (hal. 150)
Buku ini untuk tantangan baca:
-
2015 Read Big Reading Challenge
-
2015 Young Adult Reading Challenge
-
2015 Lucky No. 15 Reading Challenge -
Harus jujur kukatakan kalau buku ini lebih inferior daripada buku pertama. :(
Meskipun pada dasarnya buku ini tetaplah sebuah karya yang solid, ceritanya seru, dan secara keseluruhannya tetap menarik, namun Beyonders #2 ini seperti kejebak ke dalam kerangka standar buku kedua sebuah trilogi.
Kehilangan magis dari buku pertama dan fungsi utamanya hanya untuk build-up momentum buku terakhir. :|
Seeds of Rebellion berkisah seperti judulnya, yakni tentang benih-benih pemberontakan yang tumbuh di Lyrian selepas kembalinya Jason ke Lyrian (dengan terlampau mudah, eniwei) dan terkuaknya rahasia besar kata kunci yang dicari-cari orang di buku pertama.
Benih-benih pemberontakan untuk melawan penjahahan dan okupansi Maldor ditebar oleh lawan utamanya, pastinya, Galloran sang Blind King yang berlangsung ke seluruh penjuru Lyrian.
Karena masif-nya daratan yang dijangkau di buku kedua ini, maka isi dari buku ini lebih banyak tentang perjalanan dari satu tempat ke tempat lainnya yang dilakukan olehfellowship of the ringrombongan Galloran, tanpa adanya satu plot utama yang penting seperti di buku pertama.
Pengetahuan lebih dalam tentang bahasa sihir Edomic jelas merupakan salah satu poin menarik dari buku ini, namun tanpa adanya plot utama yang menciptakan klimaks yang dinanti-nanti, belum lagi dengan ending tentang ramalan yang berasa terlalu safe dan flat, serta sensasi humor yang berkurang, dan pemindahan channelsecara maksake show TV The Walking Dead, akhirnya buku ini menjadi berasa standar dan kurang memukau. (.__.)
It's still a good read, at least. ;) -
One thing I really like about Brandon Mull is that his writing is so inventive and it feels different. He's got a crazy good imagination, and it shines through in his writing, especially in this series. There are none of the typical elves, dwarves, and wizards. There are fantasy races in this book that are completely different, and if I'm honest, so different I can't even picture them. But that's not a bad thing. It's great to read something new and fresh.
The writing is solid and there's a lot of action here. The characters are dealing with one thing after another, and things very rarely slow down for them. There were so many different areas of Lyrian that we visited in the first book that you'd almost think there'd be nothing new to explore in the second. Not so, as we visit new and exciting places and get to experience new adventures right along with the characters. Okay, not literally, which is probably good cause I'd be scared out of my mind if I was living this story. Curled up in a ball hoping to wake up soon kind of scared. But of course, in books, characters are always braver and able to do things that normal people just don't do. That's why we all love these stories. We get to live adventure after adventure and travel the world and visit fantasy worlds and it's wonderful! And this is one of those books that makes me happy that I read. -
SERUUUUUUU!!!!!
-
FINALLY! I'm finished with this book! Not in a sense that it put me in a slump and was bad--absolutely not! This thing called 'Life' happened and is happening, still, and it drove me away from reading; I could barely concentrate or focus whenever I could or had time to read. Which sucks because I'm loving this series and I do enjoy Brandon Mull's writing and world building.
Speaking of which, This second book does focus heavily on the world building. Only now, putting the book down and finished, I do see the formula more obviously. (first plot introducing the plot; second book focuses on characters and the word; so, the third will focus on finishing the plot.) But, so what if I notice this? It's still fun to read; it's fun to read how big the world of Lyrian is. Galloran was a badass in this book (Chapter 26 reminded me of The Order vs Death Eaters in HP5). -
3.5
-
4 1/2 stars. Ned is by far my favorite character. I am so glad he was shown more in the second book.
-
3rd time reading this series and I still love it!!
-
Though I loved the first installment in 'Beyonders' trilogy, 'Seeds of Rebellion' wasn't as great as I was expecting it to be; but still I enjoyed it a lot and look forward to read the last book.
Brandon Mull is a very talented writer and always has a very unique imagination in creating fantastic characters. His 'Fablehaven' series are my most favorite YA/children fantasy books and he hasn't disappointed me in 'Beyonders' so far. -
Honestly, this is hard for me to write because I really, really want to like this series.. but I was really disappointed in this book, and I've been very disappointed in this series.
I want to like it very much and I occasionally find myself liking some parts of it, but overall it just isn't grabbing me. Some aspects of the world that Mull has created I enjoy, and it is imaginative in some ways, but overall the story is missing something. I don't care about the protagonist(s) at all, I like a couple of the secondary characters much more. And, frankly, the Heroic boy who finds he's good at weapons and the female who is somehow gifted at magic is so gender/genre cliche that I literally rolled my eyes and shook my head when I reached that point of the book.
I have really enjoyed Brandon Mull's other books, as have my children, which is why I'm so torn over this one. His other stories have been incredibly imaginative, but what this story is lacking perplexes me. I think that maybe he's so concerned with world building a unique world that he's losing focus on his characters, and his characters were one of the things I enjoyed so much in his other stories. Possibly my expectations are too great, given how much I enjoyed his previous books.
Had the last 1/4 of the book not been a marked improvement over the first 3/4 I probably would have been forced to give it a 1-star review.
It honestly pains me to give a review like this. -
I think this book was very exciting and adventurous. Brandon Mull does a great job describing everything that is happening and keeping the action up so it seems like it is always the climax or rising action of the story. One of my favorite parts is when the heroes journey to Ebera, The Forgotten Kingdom. I like that part because it is really tense and full of action. Everytime I stopped reading this book, I wanted to keep reading again right away.
Brandon Mull also does a great job of writing it and including very descriptive word choice like "pantomimed" and "dismantle". He also includes many pieces of humor like when Jason, the main character throws a fruit to a torivor, or shadow creature, and it chucks it back at his face. The first book of the trilogy, A World Without Heroes, is also very good. I liked the cliffhanger ending and how it just made me want to read this book even more. The style of the story is really adventurous and includes much excitement. Overall, I think it is a great book and I can't wait until the next book comes out. -
Reread February 2019: I still very much enjoyed this second volume. I'm going to leave my original 5 star rating, but I think this go 'round would be a 4 star rating from me. I love Aram in the first half of the book a lot. I don't know how I'd forgotten about him since I read this the first time.
The second half of the book is following a lot of characters all together, so you don't get to spend much time with any one of them. But I still had a fun adventure alongside the characters. I still love all the different types of beings in this world, and I like that it uses them to somewhat address ethnocentrism. A lot of this book is moving characters to gear up for the final book though, so there isn't much/anything wrapped up at the end. It's actually more of a "dun dun duuuun" ending. Galloran is a total boss, and I'm excited to reread the final book in this trilogy when I get the chance. -
Brandon Mull has really taken his writing to the next level with Seeds of Rebellion. I only wish someday he would write adult science fiction and not just kid's books. He is a fantastic world and species builder. I love the cast of characters in this series. They are an amazingly diverse group. My only critique is too many internal conversations and not enough relationship building between the group. There is just not enough talk between the two main characters, Jason and Rachel. Galloran is by far my favorite as well as the unlikeable Ferrin. I must say that this author's imagination is superior!!!!! I will be reading book 3.
